The economy, technology and the future of work

Orphia Nay

Penguilicious Spodmaster
Tagger
Joined
May 2, 2005
Messages
54,618
Location
Australia
I was discussing the economy with The Atheist and asked how how it was actually measured. He said:

The official measures are GDP and unemployment, and they're both going to get a lot worse before they get better.


I was wondering because I think the measurement for the economy needs to change and be more based on how we're all doing, not just rich people playing the share market.

This is all partly related to another thread on funding Universal Basic Income:
"UBI - If robots are taking jobs, their wages can be given to us"

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=345683

I replied to The Atheist:

I'd like to know how automated production of goods and services affects "the economy", and if "the economy" is ever going to change its definition because of technology making human employees less necessary.

That's probably a subject for a new thread, and I have plenty to say on the subject, so fire away!

And so, this thread.

Has the measurement for the economy changed in history, and will it change for the greater good?
 
I was discussing the economy with The Atheist and asked how how it was actually measured. He said:




I was wondering because I think the measurement for the economy needs to change and be more based on how we're all doing, not just rich people playing the share market.

This is all partly related to another thread on funding Universal Basic Income:
"UBI - If robots are taking jobs, their wages can be given to us"

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=345683

I replied to The Atheist:





And so, this thread.

Has the measurement for the economy changed in history, and will it change for the greater good?

The automated production of goods and services tends to result in more goods and services, so GDP goes up. That's not guaranteed to happen, but it's a tendency. GDP goes up because there is more stuff, so that means, on average, people have more stuff. This is the "a rising tide lifts all boats" phenomenon.

On the other hand, fewer people are are being paid to produce, so the unemployment rate tends to rise, and people tend to get relatively lower paying jobs, so the gap between rich and poor increases. The people on the low side of the divide sometimes even go backwards. This is the "A rising tide lifts all those who can afford a boat" phenomenon.

The use of automation isn't specifically measured in commonly used economic statistics, but it does make an appearance in "worker productivity", which is something measured by economists.
 
The automated production of goods and services tends to result in more goods and services, so GDP goes up. That's not guaranteed to happen, but it's a tendency. GDP goes up because there is more stuff, so that means, on average, people have more stuff. This is the "a rising tide lifts all boats" phenomenon.

On the other hand, fewer people are are being paid to produce, so the unemployment rate tends to rise, and people tend to get relatively lower paying jobs, so the gap between rich and poor increases. The people on the low side of the divide sometimes even go backwards. This is the "A rising tide lifts all those who can afford a boat" phenomenon.

Thank you, Meadmaker. That's clearly explained.

The use of automation isn't specifically measured in commonly used economic statistics, but it does make an appearance in "worker productivity", which is something measured by economists.

Tangent to the UBI/robots/wages thread, I wonder how "work" or "employment" is going to be a measure of the economy if unemployment continues to rise and UBI is implemented.
 
My economics, absolutely elementary to begin with (a few non-major credits some years back), is rusty, but if I remember correctly, you can get a snapshot of the economy as a whole by looking at measures like GDP, and GNP, and delta these two, and per capita these two, and delta that per capita, and measures of inequality (there are few, but the only one that I can recall without checking is the Gini coefficient).

Employment per se isn't necessarily a necessary measure, income is.

And as for the future of work I can see no sustainable solution that does not incorporate UBI.
 
The use of automation isn't specifically measured in commonly used economic statistics, but it does make an appearance in "worker productivity", which is something measured by economists.
Economists still tend to have a "technology creates more and better jobs for horses" mentality.
 
There are other measures such as
- Distribution of income. What % of total income does the top #% earn?
- Underemployment. Maybe many people work a few hours a week when they want to work more.
- Source of income. What % of income is from wages? Share income?
- environment. Hardly economic, but a country could earn its wealth by destroying its environment.
- Balance of payments. This is to do with imports and exports of goods and services. Plus investments.
- The value of the currency.
- Value of the stock market.

These are just a few. There are plenty more economic indicators.
 
And as for the future of work I can see no sustainable solution that does not incorporate UBI.

Indeed.


Economists still tend to have a "technology creates more and better jobs for horses" mentality.

I hadn't heard that saying but I think it's great.

I found this:

"We moved from backbreaking subsistence farming, to the arduous toil of factory work to the ******** jobs of office work, where employees spend five hours of a 40 hour week doing actual work (itself ridiculously easy in comparison to the hard labour of yore) and the other 35 attending ‘motivational seminars’ or playing around on Facebook. Just as horses had the advantage of millions of years of natural selection fine-tuning them for the job of trotting and galloping around fields, meadows and marshes, humans had the advantage of millions of years of natural selection fine-tuning them for the job of doing tasks which require common sense, language ability, and creative thinking."
https://extropiadasilva.wordpress.com/2017/01/10/technological-unemployment-the-horse-analogy/


There are other measures such as
- Distribution of income. What % of total income does the top #% earn?
- Underemployment. Maybe many people work a few hours a week when they want to work more.
- Source of income. What % of income is from wages? Share income?
- environment. Hardly economic, but a country could earn its wealth by destroying its environment.
- Balance of payments. This is to do with imports and exports of goods and services. Plus investments.
- The value of the currency.
- Value of the stock market.

These are just a few. There are plenty more economic indicators.

Indeed, which is why I think GDP and unemployment are ridiculous measures.
 
Perhaps the question isn't how will the future, rife with its magiclike technology, handle money but whether money will even be necessary past a certain stage of development? We only use money now because exchanging tokens of worth is easier for a large, sophisticated, and widely-distributed population to handle than straight bartering would be...but if our technology advances to the point where we can produce and allot goods by means not requiring exchanging tokens of worth then there will be no purpose for them. Money is really just the way of keeping score, isn't it, making sure that Joe Bloggs deserves to get X, Y, and Z goods/services because at a point in the past he supplied something of equal value to those things to other people?
 
<snip>

Indeed, which is why I think GDP and unemployment are ridiculous measures.

No. You need to know what all these numbers are and more in order to understand a country's state of the economy.

More includes what are its main imports and exports? For example, in 1900 Australia was the wealthiest country as measured by GDP in the world. A few years either side of that year, it was nowhere near that level. The reason is that its main export was wool and that was fetching very high prices.
 
Perhaps the question isn't how will the future, rife with its magiclike technology, handle money but whether money will even be necessary past a certain stage of development? We only use money now because exchanging tokens of worth is easier for a large, sophisticated, and widely-distributed population to handle than straight bartering would be...but if our technology advances to the point where we can produce and allot goods by means not requiring exchanging tokens of worth then there will be no purpose for them. Money is really just the way of keeping score, isn't it, making sure that Joe Bloggs deserves to get X, Y, and Z goods/services because at a point in the past he supplied something of equal value to those things to other people?

Yes, I don't know of any other way anyone's found of keeping score. How did the Babylonians and Egyptians do it?


No. You need to know what all these numbers are and more in order to understand a country's state of the economy.

More includes what are its main imports and exports? For example, in 1900 Australia was the wealthiest country as measured by GDP in the world. A few years either side of that year, it was nowhere near that level. The reason is that its main export was wool and that was fetching very high prices.

Yes, I guess "GDP and unemployment" are terms that include calculations that include the things you listed.
 
Perhaps the question isn't how will the future, rife with its magiclike technology, handle money but whether money will even be necessary past a certain stage of development?
Yes. There will always be things that are less abundant than oxygen. There will always be people who have something that somebody else wants and therefore have an opportunity to make a profit.

Yes, I don't know of any other way anyone's found of keeping score. How did the Babylonians and Egyptians do it?
Gold has been around for thousands of years.

An interesting piece of ancient Egyptian history is that when farmers delivered their grain to the Egyptian silos, they were given receipts written on shards of pottery. Since these receipts could be exchanged for grain, farmers could spend them on other things just like any other currency.
 
Has the measurement for the economy changed in history, and will it change for the greater good?

The measurement has always been subjective, and politically biased. One side will point to GDP while another points to standard of living.

To me, the measure we should be using is inequality. If it's increasing, we're losing.

I believe automation isn't even an issue.

We were led to believe in the 1970s, then '80s, then '90s, then all the 21st century so far, that automation would decimate workforces, yet we still have a glut of jobs and very low unemployment worldwide - pre Covid, and it will return to those levels.

Automated tasks are the repetitive ones that people don't want to do, and new jobs open as others close.

Who the hell would have thought e-gamer or Insta influencer would be viable career options in the year 2000?

A single occupation that needs a massive influx of workers is age care. You can have robots to do some tasks and that might just enable us to find sufficient people to do the jobs the residents will want people to do.

And in the end, any savings made by automation go into the hands of shareholders, and when we're welded to the ******* Friedman Doctrine, I don't imagine they're about to share the wealth.
 
Automated tasks are the repetitive ones that people don't want to do, .

That's not strictly true, though i agree with your general point. Automated tasks are the ones where it is economically advantageous to invest huge sums in a fixed asset to replace humans. As a general rule robots are used in 2 situations:

1. Where the required task cannot be done by humans
2. Where it makes economic sense

While it might be nice to think that robots will take over all the drudge work and everyone will be poets and thinkers the reality is that robotics are going to have to reduce in cost by one hell of a lot before it's economically viable to employ robot toilet cleaners or robot busboys.

As for the OP, there is some movement to include a measure like Gross National Happiness.

The link between GDP and automation is also complicated. In reality what it should do is increase production efficiency which doesn't of itself mean you produce more unless there is demand for more. It could equally mean a reduction in prices and a drop in GDP.

Since automation only tends to be economically viable when it's run on a fairly high utilisation there is always pressure to keep it running, which can lead to oversupply issues in a market as well.

I don't see any reason to think that increasing automation is going to lead to increasing GDP. We should also consider that a non-trivial amount of GDP is generated by the whole rat-race of keeping people going to work in the morning to build widgets.

As a thought experiment ... what happens to the output and impact on GDP of motor manufacturing if automation means they can produce 10* as many cars in a year, but that nobody needs one to get to the car factories in the morning any more?
 
We were led to believe in the 1970s, then '80s, then '90s, then all the 21st century so far, that automation would decimate workforces, yet we still have a glut of jobs and very low unemployment worldwide - pre Covid, and it will return to those levels.
More of this "more better jobs for horses" mentality.

Although jobs are still keeping pace with technology (even though many of them are minimum wage jobs) the signs have been there since the 80's. Entry level jobs have been drying up and youth unemployment is higher than average. It would be even worse if young people weren't forced to stay in school longer and seek post secondary education afterwards (often at their own expense).

It is only a matter of time before technology stops creating jobs that it destroys - or creates jobs for machines instead.
 
... I think GDP and unemployment are ridiculous measures.


Like I said, I'm no economist, just someone who knows a few -- not all! -- of the letters of the (economics) alphabet, but I'm afraid I think you're mistaken in thinking that.

I personally believe a GDP-obsessed economy is unhealthy; but, that said, if you want to name one single measure to, well, measure the economy, that would have to be GDP, there's no getting away from that. You'll need other measures to make your assessment broader, but I don't see how GDP can be left out of any such list of measures.

And as for (un)employment, again it is my personal belief that an emphasis on employment numbers is essentially ideology creeping up on us unexamined (or perhaps, in some cases, deliberately), because what we want to be looking at is income; but again, all of that said, in the real world, where UBI is still a fanciful pipe dream (which in any case most countries in the world, bar a few, cannot afford at all), the one is so closely correlated with the other as to be practically synonymous.

So if you ask me to pick three de facto indicators of the state of the economy (in the real world, not Utopia), then I'd pick GDP (along with its cousin, GNP) -- as well as per capita measures, and trends -- and some measure of (un)employment; and some measure of inequality or income dispersion.

-------

You've introduced a great discussion topic here, and it will be a fun read if people better versed in this than either you or I, including the posters here already, start weighing in with some details. I personally think -- now that I've thought about it, thanks to your thread -- that we're actually in a good place, a great place. If only we can get rid of ideological baggage as well as blindly self-serving and short-sighted greed, and look at ways to redistribute somewhat what we already have, and focus further research on more egalitarian and inclusive lines, a far better world is already within reach. Or at least far far closer than we'd ever been.

But then you look at ogres like Trump, and imbeciles and idiots that for some reason worship said ogre-deity, and you realize that the only place we as a species are likely to go is down. Even though there's absolutely no need to, the only thing we'll do with our science and our tech is make guns to shoot ourselves in the foot with.
 
...A single occupation that needs a massive influx of workers is age care. ...


Very true. That's probably one bumper growth area, as far both research/tech as well as employment, and what is more one of those few areas where actual trends more or less converge with what most would think they should be.
 
Entry level jobs have been drying up and youth unemployment is higher than average.

On what grounds do you blame technology for that?

I'm certain the reason youth unemployment is high has 100% to do with piss-weak government action on the subject and zero to do with automation.

Cases in point, where the lack of apprentices is hurting long-term trade shortages:

Australia

UK

USA

Best of all, the example of a highly automated workforce, where positive government action has been shown to reduce youth unemployment: Germany.
 
While it might be nice to think that robots will take over all the drudge work and everyone will be poets and thinkers the reality is that robotics are going to have to reduce in cost by one hell of a lot before it's economically viable to employ robot toilet cleaners or robot busboys./QUOTE]

That's a point I've been making in these discussions forever, and not only the initial cost - every time a job duty changes, someone has to program it, and given the lack of programmers worldwide, it's not going to be easy - you can't train that in 5 minutes.
 
The main problem with GDP is the word 'Gross'.

Gross domestic product
Gross domestic product (GDP) is a monetary measure of the market value of all the final goods and services produced in a specific time period. GDP (nominal) per capita does not, however, reflect differences in the cost of living and the inflation rates of the countries...

GDP does not account for the distribution of income among the residents of a country, because GDP is merely an aggregate measure. An economy may be highly developed or growing rapidly, but also contain a wide gap between the rich and the poor in a society. These inequalities often occur on the lines of race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or other minority status within countries. This can lead to misleading characterizations of economic well-being if the income distribution is heavily skewed toward the high end, as the poorer residents will not directly benefit from the overall level of wealth and income generated in their country.


Another problem is it equates monetary transactions to 'Domestic Product'. But the price paid for a 'good' or 'service' does not necessarily match its real value.

GDP does not take into account the value of household and other unpaid work. Some, including Martha Nussbaum, argue that this value should be included in measuring GDP, as household labor is largely a substitute for goods and services that would otherwise be purchased for value. Even under conservative estimates, the value of unpaid labor in Australia has been calculated to be over 50% of the country's GDP


Finally, it does not take into account the persistent value of assets...

The UK's Natural Capital Committee highlighted the shortcomings of GDP in its advice to the UK Government in 2013, pointing out that GDP "focuses on flows, not stocks. As a result, an economy can run down its assets yet, at the same time, record high levels of GDP growth, until a point is reached where the depleted assets act as a check on future growth". They then went on to say that "it is apparent that the recorded GDP growth rate overstates the sustainable growth rate. Broader measures of wellbeing and wealth are needed for this and there is a danger that short-term decisions based solely on what is currently measured by national accounts may prove to be costly in the long-term".


But even we did take assets into account, how can we determine their true worth? Is a rich man's mega-yacht or private jet worth more just because it cost more to manufacture and operate? Or is it actually a drag on the economy because it wastes precious resources? Is a high obesity rate good because the population can survive longer in a famine, or...

Just combining all the so-called 'goods' and 'services' into a single number is not a good way to measure the true value of an economy. For example, some of the GDP 'recovery' in countries affected by Covid-19 is due to increased activity in the health, PPE, and remote working industries, which is a broken window fallacy. OTOH, countries which did a good job of dispatching the virus may suffer a GDP 'loss' due to better hygiene reducing visits to the doctor.

Much of what we produce and consume in 'healthy' economies is not actually healthy. Take food for example. We produce too much unhealthy food which people consume too much of, which affects their health and props up the medical industry as well as forcing them to work harder to pay medical bills etc. Sure it increases GDP, but that is not reflected in personal wellbeing.

Ultimately the reason we want the economy to do better is so we can feel better. But even if we don't realize it - overconsuming generally makes us feel worse. The economy is largely driven by people who overconsume, and they consider GDP to be a measure of their 'success'. This skews economic activity towards even more overconsumption, which hurts us even more. At no time has this been more obvious than right now, as we focus on 'opening up' our economies to protect precious GDP numbers rather than protecting people, who are becoming sick and dying prematurely in unprecedented numbers.
 
Last edited:
I was discussing the economy with The Atheist and asked how how it was actually measured. He said:




I was wondering because I think the measurement for the economy needs to change and be more based on how we're all doing, not just rich people playing the share market.

This is all partly related to another thread on funding Universal Basic Income:
"UBI - If robots are taking jobs, their wages can be given to us"

Um, what wages? Robots don't work for pay, basically they work for oil and maintenance expenses. What's that? Oh, if your job is replaced by a robot, you should still get paid? Exactly how many robots do you think the bosses will purchase under those terms? My guess is 0, because then there is no return on the investment. If your goal is to keep everyone employed it might work, but if your goal is a life of ease, this scheme isn't going to do the trick.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom