The certainty of God's existence.

Haven't I already posted a few links? Here are a couple of links to specific examples that provide evidence where biblical stories are substantiated by archeological evidence confirmed by archeological evidence. I can cut and paste these or simply provide the link.
I don't recall any previous links pertaining to this point, but I may have missed them.

There is no use for me to reword these and post them.
If the material is online, a link is best, though a quick summary (just a sentence or two) can be helpful.

Archaeology reveals evidence of Paul's travels through Cyprus (Acts 13:4-12).

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/bible/evidence.html

http://www.christiananswers.net/q-abr/abr-a020.html
Okay, I haven't checked through all the items in the first, but the latter link offers no evidence whatsoever to support Paul's travels through Cyprus.

The fact that Cyprus exists does not constitute evidence that Paul existed or went there, much less that the Biblical account of his journey is correct in whole or in part, much less that the Bible is more broadly correct.

We all agree that Jericho existed - after all, it's still there today. That doesn't mean that the Biblical story of Jericho is actually true. It merely tells us that one of the points of the story was not necessarily invented.
 
Last edited:
Off topic* no reply forthcoming. I will answer. (to be nice) and will say that the tone is seething .
Well, you're wrong.

Any outsider that does not have a vested interest in this site personal or otherwise would tell you the anger is so obvious its thick enough to cut with a knife.
Not even remotely.

The great bulk of the discussion - except for your posts and Yrreg's and a scattered handful of individual items - has been calm, polite, and on-topic.

As far as I can see, you simply take having your ideas challenged as a personal insult.

It's not.

As I said I am doing this because its impossible to reply to four or more people intent on making their point.
No, this is not true either.

Yes, you are finding it impossible to support your position. The problem lies with the position you are trying to support.

Maybe with a one on one thing the answers will make more sense and there will be less frustration. (on both sides).
That seems unlikely.

Who knows we might actually change some minds!
That also seems unlikely.
 
Haven't I already posted a few links? Here are a couple of links to specific examples that provide evidence where biblical stories are substantiated by archeological evidence confirmed by archeological evidence. I can cut and paste these or simply provide the link.

There is no use for me to reword these and post them. I also have several functional file (cabinets) of older information that are still relevant today, and some newer material on hard drive and removable storage. AGAIN as with father z. There is no use to post this information if its to fall on deaf ears or minds already made up.

However I if you are approaching this in good faith (don't get all huffy considering our history that was an appro statement) I would be happy to debate this with you as long as you keep up the civil posting…

Archaeology reveals evidence of Paul's travels through Cyprus (Acts 13:4-12).

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/bible/evidence.html

http://www.christiananswers.net/q-abr/abr-a020.html

; {>

This evidence does, indeed, support the fact that these cities did exist. However, it puts forth no evidence for the fact that Paul actually traveled between them.
I can say that Bob traveled from Memphis to New York. This doesn't make it true, though the cities certainly exist.
As for the NOVA link, it says that, yes, the Israelites did exist. Which is no surprise. It does not, however, support any of the religious claims that the Bible makes, which is what this debate is about. It does corroborate a few - a few - of the historical claims in the Bible. But these historical facts do not make the religious claims true.

You just are a sore loser.

; }>

You just don't know when you're beaten.

Ok, I will debate one of you, attempting to answer five or six angry atheists can't be done by a normal human even a Christian! Its patently ridiculous to attempt to. :shocked::shocked: So get you best guy, or if you don't have one, draw straws or whatever. My mail box had about one hundred hits in three days from this lovely site. I will debate one at a time in serious debate.

And the subject etc will be decided on by some method. Its impossible to answer all the replies even cutting the personal issues out.

So Get your PhD or better yet do a random drawing. Or I could just do a hit here and a miss there, the same as usual but that isn't fair to anyone, especially me.

:shocked::shocked: Yeeeeeaaaahhhh ...:shocked::shocked:

; {>

Okay, this is just ridiculous. This is a forum, for Cthulhu's sake. It is a website meant for open debate between many different people at once. You can't say "Well, I don't want to listen to multiple arguments so only one person at a time."

Off topic* no reply forthcoming. I will answer. (to be nice) and will say that the tone is seething . Any outsider that does not have a vested interest in this site personal or otherwise would tell you the anger is so obvious its thick enough to cut with a knife. As I said I am doing this because its impossible to reply to four or more people intent on making their point.

Maybe with a one on one thing the answers will make more sense and there will be less frustration. (on both sides). Who knows we might actually change some minds! This won't apply to other subjects unless the same problem occurs.

; {>

* The certainty of God's existence.

Any outsider without so much invested in this conversation will tell you that the tone of this conversation is not angry. In fact, I would say that it is extremely subdued compared to some of the Yrreg threads we get here. The only angry one here is you.

Its up to you guys not me. No wait I might have to fight Reggg ...

; {>

If you are unable to see that Yrreg is quite possibly the least-skilled philosopher on this site, then there is no hope for you. Of course, you will never admit that Yrreg is a horrible apologist for the Christian faith, since he shares your belief.

Maybe its one angry christian against a whole dang batch of nice atheists?

Certainly seems to be the case. And, unlike you, I'm not being sarcastic.

That's the problem, there is no fine line where one begins and the other ends. It's wrong in debate as well as in life to think that somehow we can compartmentalize them into neat title boxes, when in reality they are all interwoven, and blended in the most intricate of details and flavors.

; {>>

LOGIC FAIL.
There is very definitely a line between religion and science. The line is considerably less thick between science and metaphysics, but it's still there.
 
How about nice bunch of theists and atheists having an occasionally rancorous difference of opinion?
 
Steven Jay Gould's notion of science and religion as being nonoverlapping magisteria comes to mind here. They don't deal with the same classes of phenomena, they use completely different methods to ask and answer completely different sorts of questions and the people involved in each kind of activity have no need to interact whatsoever.
 
Archaeology reveals evidence of Paul's travels through Cyprus (Acts 13:4-12).
I don't think it does. It could conceivably support the claim that he did make those journeys by confirming details in the accounts. However, even if it did, I don't think that proving that Paul made the journey adds any evidence for the existence of god.

My mail box had about one hundred hits in three days from this lovely site.

I would suggest turning off email notification, so you don't feel under pressure. Just come to the site when you have time, and respond to the posts you want to.
 
Haven't I already posted a few links? Here are a couple of links to specific examples that provide evidence where biblical stories are substantiated by archeological evidence confirmed by archeological evidence. I can cut and paste these or simply provide the link.

There is no use for me to reword these and post them. I also have several functional file (cabinets) of older information that are still relevant today, and some newer material on hard drive and removable storage. AGAIN as with father z. There is no use to post this information if its to fall on deaf ears or minds already made up.

However I if you are approaching this in good faith (don't get all huffy considering our history that was an appro statement) I would be happy to debate this with you as long as you keep up the civil posting…

Archaeology reveals evidence of Paul's travels through Cyprus (Acts 13:4-12).

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/bible/evidence.html

http://www.christiananswers.net/q-abr/abr-a020.html

; {>

As other posters have pointed out, these links have nothing to do with the author's claims.
Confirmation of the existence of places/routes mentioned in the bible doesn't confirm the events, which is what RevDisturba has claimed here.

Try again, RevDisturba.
So far this 'evidence' posted up doesn't support his/her claims in the least. In fact, I can't help wondering why they were posted in the first place, unless RevDisturba really believes these links provide archeological evidence that support his/her claims?
Either way, I'm definitely willing to follow up any other links he/she provides.
It would be nice if they provided archeological evidence to support his/her claims.
 
I am disappointed. We were told there was loads of evidence; we were told it had been posted and I thought I had missed it; we were told that those links were part of it; and there was no evidence in them.

Is that the best there is? Surely it is not? Can we have some proper evidence, please
 
Sounds like a justification for vagueness to me.

They may be interwoven but the purpose of philosophy is examine the weaving and sort out weft from warp.

It is OK to bring science into a metaphysical argument just so long as it is possible to demonstrate precisely how it fits into the argument, otherwise it is just muddying the water.

It is even OK to bring metaphysics into a scientific argument just so long as it is understood that the final arbitrer of the science is still experimental confirmation.

The point is that if any of us make a statement and claim reasonable confidence that this statement is true we must be clear on what basis we are making that claim.

It is the basis on which I operate, it would be purposeless to debate someone who did not operate on the same basis.

The atheist who says "religion is a virus" and the theist who says "atheism is a tumour" are birds of a feather and I will not neglect to point out that their argument is specious in each case.
Hmmm... What a dick I sound like here!

Please ignore.
 
I am disappointed. We were told there was loads of evidence; we were told it had been posted and I thought I had missed it; we were told that those links were part of it; and there was no evidence in them.

Is that the best there is? Surely it is not? Can we have some proper evidence, please
I would certainly like to see it.
 
Off topic* no reply forthcoming. I will answer. (to be nice) and will say that the tone is seething .

Of course you'd think so, since it would allow you to take the moral high ground. Of course this is a skeptical discussion about evidence, so I don't see how that would count, but then we're having a conversation with a theist, so logic be damned!
 
We agree on more than that. I wish we could merge. Now that would be something! A four billion man force! Yeah baby!
That would be a four billion person force.

But as I understand it your wish is coming true day by day, why don't you give Yusuf Estes a call and help the process along?
 
I prefer...

I am Grey.
I stand between the candle and the star.
We are Grey.
We stand between the darkness and the light.


But what do I know? :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom