The certainty of God's existence.

I use biblical archeological evidence.
Such as?

We're still waiting for you to present this evidence.

Fulfilled prophesy is a good evidence for supernatural evidence
So what is this fulfilled prophesy?

Its impossible to provide empirical evidence for some things of science
Such as?

and religion.
Well, that I'll grant you.

However with enough circumstantial evidence you can be executed in this country or jailed for life in other countries.
Which is in no way relevant, since not only is this not a court of law, but you have failed to present even circumstantial evidence to support your claims.

As far as religion being a con-man show the proof 'he lies' I named some very well known frauds of science.
Well known because they were uncovered and rejected by science.

Christianity has little proven fraud, nothing like science has.
Science actually tests claims and rejects those that aren't true. So fraud, when it happens, is uncovered.

Religion just asserts things. Fraud, honest mistake, translation error, it all goes into the mix to be explained away later by a stream of logical fallacies.
 
You ought to know full well how and why I found my way (blundered) to faith VIA science. Why? Because I have told the sordid story here so many times before, nevertheless, I will give a brief abstract ; During the late 70’s 80’s and 90’s science was having a something of a renaissance fueled by new discoveries, and I was having a personal renaissance fueled by what these new discoveries meant to my religious paradigm.

The Big Bang was practically verified by the discovery of the CBR, which lent overwhelming evidence for a universe that began to exist just as the bible said it did, and contrary to what science had told us for over a thousand years.

What scientific theories were there for the universe having always existed? I've never heard any. Legitimate question - please provide links, I'd really like to read it!
But I'm afraid that the universe having a beginning is not a confirmation of all Biblical fact. You are pulling a fast one here, plain and simple; you say, "Look. The Bible says the universe began. So does science! The Bible is entirely correct!"
:/
No. You're leaving out the most important part. The Bible not only says that the universe began, it specifies the exact way in which it began. The way that it claims the universe came into being is self-evident nonsense, I'm afraid.

Today atheists are attempting to sweep that little fact with its supremely profound implications under the rug with industrial sized brooms all the while hoping no one notices...I noticed.

No, you didn't. You think you did. There's nothing to notice. The fact that the universe had a beginning does not support your idea of a creator god. Admittedly, the universe not having a beginning would have a been a serious blow against an idea of a creator god, but merely having a beginning does not equal having a creator.

…………………….. Oh No! Its time for another Rev Spoof …………………………..

Another Rev Flame, you mean. So I will ignore this part of the post. In any case, my argument against it is presented above.

No, to the dismay of all atheists, the theistic dust (the same kind that made Adam) clings to the lab floor resisting the attempts of the atheists actions to hide it by the fifth force i.e. ‘the strong-electro-God-cling force’. This fifth force was recently discovered by …..me.

Except this part. It begs to be addressed. And the question it wishes to be asked is... What the hell are you going on about?

Religion one science zero, and it was a BIG zero!

Again, this argument was debunked above. It is nonsense.

Then as the years progressed there was many science ‘breakthroughs’ that confirmed the bible and biblical truths, as well as the philosophical Gods existence! So yes I was an atheist and as science kicked down door after door metaphysical beliefs got stronger with each passing year, until finally one day I asked myself why was I denying God? It was because I had become comfortable with an atheistic world view or paradigm.

Once again, please give us links to the evidence you claim verifies the Bible. Until that point in time, I'm afraid you must stop talking.

I think science may not mention religious beliefs per se but they are all over God as a concept, at least the brave scientists are. The cowardly scientists go around with their head in the collective academia sand hoping that the goblin will go away if they ignore it long enough. Trust me it wont go away this time two billion Christians will make sure of it. Personally I think we will all be better off for it, at least in this country.

Argument ad hominem, argument ad populum, bare assertion fallacy.
Show us what scientists or scientific fields are "all over God as a concept". And show us their evidence for your god's existence.

I don’t to be rude either, but I think you must have had some horrendous teachers if you really examined all the information and evidences for the existence of God and still rejected religion. I along with well meaning but bad teachers you didn’t get all the information that was needed to make a decision, of course I can’t know one way or the other until I know your lifes history.

Whereas the majority of the people in this forum believe that you must have had some horrendous teachers if you really examined all the information and evidence for the existence of god and still accepted religion.

BTW Do you claim or ID with strong atheism? Again I am not trying to be rude but I don’t know how one can be an agnostic atheist. I feel that you can be either or (an atheist or an agnostic)

There's no "weak" or "strong" atheism. You are simply atheistic. There is no doctrine that you can partially accept, so it is impossible to be a "weak" atheist. The only tenet of atheism is that there is no god. Or gods, as the case may be.

I would say that its our perception of what is nearest to truth is why we believe as we do. I know a few atheists that Go to church for their friends, I see nothing wrong with that.

And you shouldn't. But your perception of "what is nearest to truth" works for you, and only you. We don't object to you holding these beliefs. We do, however, object to you trying to force your paradigm on us.

Well all I can say is that I searched for truth as well. And was cautious in every move I made. As for McDowell, most of his stuff is good solid research. Of course some is suspect. In his book evidence of Christianity I find about 20% of it as needing more verification. However the last (atheist apologists) review I read was about 50% fiction. If I were McDowell I would of sued the site that published the review.

If the book is 20% wrong to his supporters, I'm afraid that I cannot accept McDowell's work as legitimate. Even the people who are supposed to share his viewpoint find major faults in his work.

I can not help but be (beyond) saddened that you have rejected God, because as a ex Christian you know what that means (to a believer). However if you are now happy with your new lifestyle I am happy for you.

Good. Now all you have to do is take another step back and ask yourself, "If he is happy as an atheist, why am I trying to convince him of the truth of Chrisitianity? He doesn't need it."

Yes they are called truth. They were truth while science ridiculed them and they are truth after science discovered they are correct.

No, they aren't truth. And science has not discovered that they are correct. Quite the opposite.

If you had half the people to respond to as I do I would say that your response would be as slow or slower than mine. BTW you may have to refresh my memory and keep in mind that I am going to begin to not respond to material already covered or replies with insults etc.

So, in other words, you are not going to respond to anyone who does not share your viewpoints.
I would ask, though, that since you are so keen as to avoid being insulted, that you take just as much care in avoiding insulting us as you would like us to take in avoiding insulting you.

Your replies for the most part are not insulting and they usually are valid.

Your previous replies have been quite to the contrary. You have accused most - if not all - of the members of this forum of lying, insulting you and making invalid arguments.

; {>

Oh this is a reminder, In addition to not replying to insulting posts, or replies with unsavory, or off color personal content my recreational computer time has been severally restricted due to domestic and other personal issues (illness in the intimidate family) and getting the new non profit up and running etc. Thanks for all the good posts (the majority unless we are :catfight: ing)......

Sorry to hear that you're going to have connection problems. I had that for a long time... not fun. Especially because it means that, when you do come back, there's two pages of material to read through just to catch up.

I have been telling that sweet fairy tale for long before I landed here. I still say that the OUOT theory is the only supported theory so I don't know why you think I would abandon the most popular scientific theory ever. Certainly not because a few atheist apologists here tried to teach me highly tainetd basic cosmology and astronomy.

Argument and hominem, argument ad populum, bare assertion. Where does it say that OUOT is the most popular scientific theory of all time? And what evidence does OUOT have to support it?

Sorry I learned that in the 70's then was refreshed in the 80's 90's and almost every day I crack open a book or slew a telescope to the heavens. And, lastly, I don't relegate God to an unnecessary being. You are either gone mad or have grossly misunderstood me.

Maybe you have worded your posts incorrectly, then. I also have received the impression that you are putting God on the back burner. You say that he is only omnipotent in his own realm, that he cannot interact with our own world because he is a spirit, and other arguments that, in the end, are just variations on the theme of special pleading.

Look around God doesn't hide, he is here for everyone to see, (just as the bible tells us). However those that are blinded by their own bitterness and inability to think with a critical mind, or can not bear to change instead clinging to old tired theories, it is they that are suffering in their sad paradigm built on falsehoods and fear.

Argument ad hominem, argument from authority, circular logic, bare assertion.
If God really were here for everyone to see, do you think that anyone would doubt his existence?
The Bible is only correct if God does, indeed, exist. It assumes that he does. It is not valid evidence for his existence.
Insulting us gets you nowhere.

Well put up the evidence or just keep on speculating away ? I would like to see your archeological evidence for the Greek gods.

We would like to see your archaeological evidence for the Christian god.

Science is the ultimate con man. He lies to us for decades and we still believe him. We have to because of the technology that we now depend on...

Yet you use science to support your claims. :dig:

You will have to be more specific than that.
; {>

It seems to me like you are the one that must be more specific.

We agree on more than that. I wish we could merge. Now that would be something! A four billion man force! Yeah baby!

; {>

Argument ad populum.

I believe in very few biblical evidences such as the shroud, too much temptation to fake them, kinda' like the Piltdown man or more recently the glued and construed Archaeoraptor, or even the knuckle walking Lucy, the ongoing fraud that many Darwin apologists consider valid. :jaw-dropp !!!WAIT !!! that ain't religion that is fraudulent science!!

Lucy was never debunked. That is a blatant lie perpetuated by proponents of creationism to support their "theory".
The Piltdown Man, on the other hand, was debunked. By scientists, I might add, in the name of science. Not creationism. In any case, the Piltdown Man is completely irrelevant. Likewise with the Archaeoraptor.
The thing about science is, when it's wrong, it doesn't hide it. It reveals the fact that it was wrong, then goes about trying to find the right answer. And if you are a hoaxer, then the rest of the scientific community comes down on you like a ton of bricks.

:rolleyes:So yes, may all the religion bashing history channel arm chair archeologists beware, religion is riddled with fraud. :rolleyes:

Yes. Yes it is.

I use biblical archeological evidence.

Which you have yet to show us.

Fulfilled prophesy is a good evidence for supernatural evidence

Not if the prophecy fulfilled is fulfilled in the text that predicted it. Circular logic again.

Its impossible to provide empirical evidence for some things of science and religion. However with enough circumstantial evidence you can be executed in this country or jailed for life in other countries.

That doesn't make it right. Circumstantial evidence should be disregarded. And if you can't provide solid evidence for something, then you should operate under the strong suspicion that it is false.
Please show us some CURRENT scientific theories that have no evidence backing them.

As far as religion being a con-man show the proof 'he lies' I named some very well known frauds of science. Christianity has little proven fraud, nothing like science has.

...
No.
Shroud of Turin.
Ark of the Covenant.
Noah's Ark.
And, as for scientific fraud, see the argument I presented above.

Its sad that you have a habit of taking my replies out of context and putting words in my mouth. You may have to detox cold turkey soon. Really you should focus less on the personal and more on the subject at hand, which isn't me. I will say its flattering in a weird way.

No one here is getting personal. We are attacking your arguments, not you. Whereas you regularly emply argument ad hominem against atheism.

What do you mean clear evidence? Until you prove the bible is inaccurate (where its used as evidence of a prophesy fulfilled etc or in specific areas) It can be used as said evidence.

a) No it can't. You can't just say, "Well, no one's proven it wrong, so it must be right." You have to have proof that it is, in actuality, correct.
b) It has been proven inaccurate. Several thousand times, many of them in this thread.

We wouldn't have much history if no one allowed the victor to write an account of the event, or to accept the account as true simply because the victor was hostile to the defeated. A good example would be holocaust deniers rejecting the evidence written by the American press attachment.

That's a horrible example. There is so much evidence for the Holocaust that denying it is nothing short of ludicrous idiocy.
As is your first statement about history being written by the winners. In the short term, yes, it is. But in the long term, archaeologists find out what really happened.

Yes it is really ! The irony is if atheist apologists can't win a debate by facts, they make it personal. If you can't see that you are blind! ....Hey over here (jumping up and down waving hands) ...yep blind as a bat.

Cross out "atheist" and write "theist" and you're 100% correct.

I suggest everyone get on topic.

We are on-topic. You're stalling.

No you are wrong as usual. You said that my God had the same amount of evidence as the Greek gods etc did. I said I provided e evidence for my god in earlier posts and would like to see your evidence for your examples. You having no evidence for your examples renders your argument invalid.

You say that you gave evidence for your god's existence earlier. We are unable to find where you gave us this evidence. Please repost the links. Until that time, you have no evidence.

Why you are so angry? Or is angry just a default position of whatever you ID with?

Argument ad hominem.

Even con men have useful information.

False analogy.

I stated long ago the rules of engagement and did not enforce them. See where that got me? So no more personal BS etc. I will do the same unless provoked or taunted or insulted etc...:boggled:

; {>

You do it all the time, whether provoked or not. Have you ever actually looked at any of your own posts?

Even in the very best of situations it would be difficult for one person to answer five or six students ahhh'...I mean members. When the subject is a complex one I would say its nearly impossible for one person to debate more than two in a forum sitting.

Agreed. It has taken me an hour to go through this thread alone.

That's the reason these things usually degenerate into a personal fight, frustration etc.

No. They devolve into these things because you attack us baselessly.

If there were more christian types that would debate I think it would make a better forum. Frankly many of these kind of sites (atheist friendly or apologist) run off the christian or religious posters by several tactics. I am happy to say that in the last 10 to 15 days the administrative issues have become more fair. Of course I haven't checked my PM's for a week and might feel differently after I do that!

See? This supports my previous statement.

All in all even with the usually mild insults and the what I thought was a double standard by a staff member this site is far and away more fair than most of the others I have visited. And the members are better qualified to speak on complex and difficult subjects.

Yeah. This is a good place to hang out - provided that you are actually seeking debate. You don't seem to be.
 
I missed where you provided some archaeological evidence to support the existence of YHWH.

Standard modus operandi of some of the faithful cornered into being asked to give evidence. In case you did not remark he shifted the goalpost from "[revdista] giving evidence of YHWH" to "[everybody else]Until you prove the bible is inaccurate... ". Naturally he will explain away all the inaccuracy of the bible with some apologetic mumbo jumbo, but in the mean time he escaped giving evidence, and he probably hopes we forget he gave no evidence whatsoever.

IMHO discussing logic with irrational person is useless. But it is certainly fun to read :).
 
Even in the very best of situations it would be difficult for one person to answer five or six students ahhh'...I mean members.

I thought you were done with the "personal BS".

Anyway, about that biblical archeological evidence you mentioned...

Do you have any? Like an ancient wall with "Yahwe was here! 527 BC" scribbled on it?
 
The Big Bang was practically verified by the discovery of the CBR, which lent overwhelming evidence for a universe that began to exist just as the bible said it did...
There is no overwhelming evidence. You are in essense applying confirmation bias to a bronze age mythology. You ignore every notion and concept that doesn't fit (geocentrism, etc.) and go after a single positive "hit" and think it proves something. There was no firmament, no separating of the waters. But even if the Bible had stated that there was simply a beginning and the Big bang confirmed this it would be spurious to suppose that such a thing confirms the Bible. That takes post hoc rationalization.

Religion one science zero, and it was a BIG zero!
Assuming for the sake of argument this is true. What about all of the other "zeros" on the side of religion? There are one hell of a lot of them. Geocentrism, firmament, parting of waters, day before there is light, etc., etc.?

Then as the years progressed there was many science ‘breakthroughs’ that confirmed the bible and biblical truths, as well as the philosophical Gods existence!
Nonsense, objectively the Bible is mythology and alegory. It gets much wrong and requires holding it up to a faint light, tilting one's head and squinting to tease out any possible scientific truth.

Your replies for the most part are not insulting and they usually are valid.
I appreciate that.

Before I was an atheist I had a lot of dissonance. Whenever I gave up a superstitiouis or spurious belief the dissonance would dissipate (sorry for the illiteration).

When I let go of god the dissonance disapared alltogether. I experience it from time to time but by and large I've come to the acceptance that I can't answer every question and positing god to fill in gaps doesn't help.

I don't know that there is no god. I do know that religion is, by and large, obviously man made and contradictory. I know it reflects the sentiments of the times it was invented.

I honestly couldn't give religion any points as far as there being any truth that demonstrated the validity of the religion. There is no there there. I think you are falling victim to the oldes trick in the book. Self delusion. Seeing what you want to see post hoc.

I can't read your mind but if you are anything like me you have a good deal of dissonance. You often run smack into some fact that causes you concern and your world view is threatened. So you go to appologetics web sites and find some explanation to smooth over the unease.

I have no unease. There is only the natural world and human ignorance. We know only so much and only to a certain degree of certainty. The only thing that gives me confidence is skepticism, critical thinking and an open mind. "I could be wrong." That realization is the most liberating (and scientificly minded) position I've ever held.


Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by RevDisturba
... Please show your sources where the archeological evidence of biblical events etc has been debunked. And there is too much to list in this page. ...

Could you shout me a link to this archeological evidence, please?

I asked this back on p46 and I see I'm but a voice in the chorus.
I'm curious about someone who claims to have archeological evidence of the bible's events in a post on a skeptics' forum, yet can bear to delay savouring the angst, general alarm and psychological disarray this evidence will cause.

I have a feeling it won't be the Shroud of Turin.
 
RevDisturba,

I find the little devil image you include at the end of every post you make offensive. Please stop posting it.

Regards,
Rosencrantz
 
It's strange. Rev keeps claiming he wants to debate, but when given counter arguments, he chooses to ignore those and instead harps on derails. One wonders if that's intentional or not.

I don't wonder.

I asked this back on p46 and I see I'm but a voice in the chorus.
I'm curious about someone who claims to have archeological evidence of the bible's events in a post on a skeptics' forum, yet can bear to delay savouring the angst, general alarm and psychological disarray this evidence will cause.

I have a feeling it won't be the Shroud of Turin.

I would love to see an example of a fulfilled prophecy.

I shall Add my voice to the register to create a needed triad.


"I would love to see an example of a fullfilled prophecy."


Make that another vote from me.
 
You mean like the conflicting genealogies for Joseph in Matthew and Luke?

First before I go to lengths to explain the genealogies, which I can do but its a long process, I am hoping your doing this in good faith. I don't want to spend a lot of my and the forums time answering a difficult question just to have it fall on deaf ears


In history, we do allow such accounts.

No we don’t not in the capacity I was alluding to. I have a request please use quote tags especially if you are responding to a reply I had made to someone else. BTW for the above, I assume your referring to post #1897 where I was replying to Mr zooterkin ? Its not too difficult for you and the other members because you are usually responding to me.

What we don't do is accept those accounts as factual without further investigation.

Nor do biblical scholars and other ‘agencies’ blindly accept as fact that all biblical accounts are true. Many biblical accounts have more than one type of verification before it could be included in the bible. ‘If we were to look at a chart that compared the biblical documents with other ancient documents, we would see that the Bible is in a class by itself regarding the number of ancient copies and their reliability‘.

We also make a distinction between recorded contemporary or eyewitness testimony and cultural legends and traditions that have been shaped by generations of embellishment.

Please show proof where biblical text is “shaped by generations of embellishment”. I can show proof where biblical text separated by hundreds of years are nearly identical. Ie one copy is accurate when compared to another discovered at a later time to an astonishing degree of accuracy. I am going to begin making notes to make sure you answer these questions. Many, I would guess that 50% of my questions go unanswered.

Care to guess what category the vast majority of the Bible falls into?

Sure in the category of the most accurate copies we have of any ancient manuscript. http://home.earthlink.net/~ronrhodes/Manuscript.html

For example: the stories about the Hebrew invasion of Canaan are not supported by archaeological evidence. They are an example of cultural legend and mythos handed down in oral tradition for centuries prior to being recorded textually.

“Archaeological research has provided only limited assistance for the reconstruction of the invasion history. Excavation at Jericho produced no evidence for the period of the Hebrew attack because erosion had washed away all remains7 but there is no reason to doubt the tradition that Jericho fell to the Hebrews. “

I will get back to you on this.

The Bible is an ancient work of hearsay recorded generations after the events they describe and with little to no verification by external sources

Well again you outdo yourself by making unsupported statements. Evidence abounds both internal as well as external sources, hearsay isn't in the new testament as per rules of admissibility. What you say? Here is an interesting argument that demonstrating why the New Testament for example is not hearsay.

excerpt ; Thus, as we can see, many of the most controversial parts of the NT are admissible under exceptions to the hearsay rule. Someone challenging the Bible could attack these statements on other grounds, grounds which are more than adequately covered by other material on this site, but they could not be preliminarily excluded on the basis of hearsay.

Read more at >

http://www.tektonics.org/gk/hearsay.html

; {>
 
Last edited:
Well again you outdo yourself by making unsupported statements. Evidence abounds both internal as well as external sources, hearsay isn't in the new testament as per rules of admissibility. What you say? Here is an interesting argument that demonstrating why the New Testament for example is not hearsay.

excerpt ; Thus, as we can see, many of the most controversial parts of the NT are admissible under exceptions to the hearsay rule. Someone challenging the Bible could attack these statements on other grounds, grounds which are more than adequately covered by other material on this site, but they could not be preliminarily excluded on the basis of hearsay.


Testimony that was audio taped in front of officers with corroborating evidence is the same as the biblical hearsay?

Hmmm, let's look at the article cited here:

article said:
Contrary to the misconception held by many lay-people, the legal definition of "hearsay" is not "secondhand information." Hearsay, when used to exclude evidence, is defined as "a statement, other than one made by the declarant while testifying at the trial or hearing, offered in evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted."[Fed.R.Ev. 801(c)]. Every out of court statement offered to prove its truth is hearsay. Statements made during debates between atheists and Christians are hearsay. Your local DJ's listing of songs he or she just played is hearsay. The lecture where I learned this is hearsay. Such statements are generally inadmissible in court, although there are exceptions. The reason for this is that the law assumes that in-court statements have certain safeguards that out-of-court statements lack. These safeguards are: 1) cross-examination; 2) the oath; and 3) the opportunity to observe the declarant's demeanor.[Weissenberger's Federal Evidence 400-401]. (As an interesting aside, atheists were once incompetent to testify at trial, since the oath would have been meaningless to them!) Now, this should adequately show the silliness of using legal evidence standards in this context, because I doubt if skeptics and critics are willing to only use statements made in court, under oath, and subject to cross-examination in this debate.


Strawmen galore! Poisoning the well! Argument from incredulity!

Holy logical fallacies, Batman!
 
We also make a distinction between recorded contemporary or eyewitness testimony and cultural legends and traditions that have been shaped by generations of embellishment.
Please show proof where biblical text is “shaped by generations of embellishment”. I can show proof where biblical text separated by hundreds of years are nearly identical. Ie one copy is accurate when compared to another discovered at a later time to an astonishing degree of accuracy. I am going to begin making notes to make sure you answer these questions. Many, I would guess that 50% of my questions go unanswered.

This one is fairly simple actually. The Bible was written before the Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered. It was The Book of Laws and the history of the tribes. One does not "edit" such a thing.

Of course there will be some small variations over time as different copies are made and these variation were found.

How it was shaped at the beginning can be proved by how it was copied later.
 
Imagine two arenas. Place youself into one with me,
and other responders from this thread, and yrreg into the other.

Now we should find a way to defeat him
in a different arena, a different set of rules,
without hearing one another.

Is there anyone who could make this scenario a
bit more possible for one another,
to find some common ground on which to stand on?

There's no mixing oil and water, nor crazy and sane.
They are not playing by the same rules.
But is there any sanity in which yrreg lays upon?
And is there any room for belief in us?
And I mean anykind of belief, superstition,
that you sanely deny, but still take it into concideration in you life.
Just an example though.
Is there any common ground between sanity,
and examining religion?
 
Sure in the category of the most accurate copies we have of any ancient manuscript. http://home.earthlink.net/~ronrhodes/Manuscript.html

First two paragraphs:
There are more than 24,000 partial and complete manuscript copies of the New Testament.

These manuscript copies are very ancient and they are available for inspection now.​

*facepalm*

The vast bulk of those manuscripts (the 24.000) cannot by any stretch of the imagination be called "ancient" let alone "very ancient." And what there is in terms of "very ancient" copies - included in those marvellous 24K - tends to be fragmentary.

See a list for Greek manuscripts here
http://www.earlham.edu/~seidti/iam/table_gkmss.html
Or a wiki page on Greek manuscripts:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catego..._of_Greek_manuscripts_by_century_and_category

The first link gives date and content of each manuscript. The Wikipage gives the date but not what the manuscripts contain; you may try your luck and see if there is a page for individual manuscript though (there is a decent page of P52 for instance).

For Latin manuscripts it is no different. The bulk is late:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_New_Testament_Latin_manuscripts


And on top of that, those are not necessarily copies of the New Testament. Sometimes they are just fragments of a single book of what became later known as the New Testament. P52, the oldest fragment, contains 112 letters from a copy of GJohn.
 
First before I go to lengths to explain the genealogies, which I can do but its a long process, I am hoping your doing this in good faith. I don't want to spend a lot of my and the forums time answering a difficult question just to have it fall on deaf ears
Oh, I'm earnest enough.

I'm guessing that this will be some apologetic along the lines of one genealogy representing the ancestry of Joseph while the other represents the ancestry of Mary.

No we don’t not in the capacity I was alluding to.
What capacity was that? The capacity of accepting an account without consideration of the likely biases of its author or authors?

Nor do biblical scholars and other ‘agencies’ blindly accept as fact that all biblical accounts are true. Many biblical accounts have more than one type of verification before it could be included in the bible. ‘If we were to look at a chart that compared the biblical documents with other ancient documents, we would see that the Bible is in a class by itself regarding the number of ancient copies and their reliability‘.
Please provide evidence of this assertion. Give an example of a Biblical account and the multiple verifications required of it prior to inclusion in the Bible. please provide or direct us to a chart contrasting the reliability of the Bible compared to other ancient documents.

Please show proof where biblical text is “shaped by generations of embellishment”. I can show proof where biblical text separated by hundreds of years are nearly identical. Ie one copy is accurate when compared to another discovered at a later time to an astonishing degree of accuracy.
How about the fact that archaeological evidence does not support the Biblical narrative regarding the Hebrew invasion of Canaan? How about the fact that the Bible simply repeats the Epic of Gilgamesh when it describes a great flood? (A flood for which there is no geological evidence.) How about the fact that the canonical gospels' narratives show signs of differing interpretation over the years, with Jesus going from a prophet to the son of God. How about the fact that the earliest known gospel, the one attributed to Mark, indicates that the author was unfamiliar with the geography of Palestine. How about the last twelve verses of Mark being added much later?

I am going to begin making notes to make sure you answer these questions. Many, I would guess that 50% of my questions go unanswered.
Are you sure you want to do that? Others might be inspired to compile a similar list regarding questions that you fail to answer.

Sure in the category of the most accurate copies we have of any ancient manuscript. http://home.earthlink.net/~ronrhodes/Manuscript.html
Too bad Mr. Rhodes doesn't mention that most of those many manuscripts were copied centuries after the origins of Christianity and that we only have but a few fragments of text from the early centuries of Christianity. Too bad he doesn't mention the many, many early Christian texts that show that early Christianity was so diverse in beliefs that many of the sects bear little to no resemblance to the eventually established canon.

But that isn't the issue. The issue is: is the Bible reliable historical testimony? The answer is "no".

“Archaeological research has provided only limited assistance for the reconstruction of the invasion history. Excavation at Jericho produced no evidence for the period of the Hebrew attack because erosion had washed away all remains7 but there is no reason to doubt the tradition that Jericho fell to the Hebrews. “

I will get back to you on this.
Yes, please provide a source for the quote.

Well again you outdo yourself by making unsupported statements. Evidence abounds both internal as well as external sources,...
Then provide it. All you do is claim that evidence supports your position. Where is it?

...hearsay isn't in the new testament as per rules of admissibility.
What "rules of admissibility"?

What you say? Here is an interesting argument that demonstrating why the New Testament for example is not hearsay.

excerpt ; Thus, as we can see, many of the most controversial parts of the NT are admissible under exceptions to the hearsay rule. Someone challenging the Bible could attack these statements on other grounds, grounds which are more than adequately covered by other material on this site, but they could not be preliminarily excluded on the basis of hearsay.

Read more at >

http://www.tektonics.org/gk/hearsay.html
Interesting? More like silly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom