The Bush Resume

dwb said:
I still think that Bush did a good job as governor, and you can Google to your heart's content to find web sites that support that notion, specifically on his education policy.
Bush's pearl, the education system in Texas, was mostly put in place by his predecessor. To his credit, he did not weaken the programs. He did, however, put a lot more emphasis on testing, which is a double-edged sword. It is questionable whether "teaching the test" is the best way to improve education, even if it does improve test scores.

Recently, there have been scandals with school administrators, under pressure to keep their schools funding in place, hiding and even changing test scores.

But it is true that Bush did a reasonably good job on education in Texas, with the exception being Charter schools. Sadly, he has not put any of the reforms he made in Texas into his US policy, as this article on a conservative website suggests.
"As soon as he signed the No Child Left Behind Act, President Bush walked away from his job of improving our schools," charged Sen. Tom Harkin of Iowa, echoing the sentiments of his colleagues and of liberal interest groups like the National Education Association, the American Federation of Teachers and the National School Boards Association.

"His budget for this fiscal year had the smallest increase for education since 1996," said Harkin. "It eliminated funding for rural schools, school counselors and dropout prevention ... cut funding for the No Child Left Behind Act by $90 million; and you can bet his budget for next fiscal year won't do any better."
 
RandFan said:
Rhetoric.

It's funny how the facts are tossed aside to suit ones world view. I admire people like Steven Brill who look at the facts objectively. He doesn't share your view. And there are other Democrats who are endowed with critical thinking and don't simply dismiss Bush and make such silly and unsupported claims.

I am proud of Bush for the very reasons Brill outlines in his book After : Rebuilding and Defending America in the September 12 Era.

If you precious world view is as important to you as I think it is then I wouldn't read the book. Facts can be a dangerous thing.

It's odd how you can be proud of a president who has generated a 650 Billion Dollar Annual Deficit, has cost of the good will and trust of nearly every nation in the world, has galvanised even further the Muslim hatred of the US (while accomplishing nothing), has relaxed environmental standards to the point where his own people keep resigning, has been one of the least communicative presidents in all US history.

You obviously have different standards from mine.

And I'll mention again, since you don't seem to pay attention to it: I am NOT a Democrat. I don't make excuses for them, either.
 
Mark said:
It's odd how you can be proud of a president who has generated a 650 Billion Dollar Annual Deficit...
The deficit is a valid concern. I have stated on numerous occasions my disagreement with the Republicans for not reigning in spending. No claims were made that the tax cuts would solve the problems in short order. Having excoriated Gray Davis for his supreme bungling of California's budget it would be inconsistent to simply say the deficit is no big deal. There are significant differences though. And unlike Davis Bush has proven to be a very good leader. Making important and tough decisions in difficult time. YES! I do very much like and respect him. As I have said in the past. No leader can please everyone and those who are pleased by your performance are unlikely to be pleased with everything that you do.

...has cost of the good will and trust of nearly every nation in the world
1.) Arguable.

2.) I don't want any good will of those who don't have our best interests at heart. I'm sick of the arrogant and pompous attitude of others who tell us we must do things their way or else.

...has galvanised even further the Muslim hatred of the US (while accomplishing nothing)
Oh christ, people are getting into planes and blowing us up. The notion that we have to tread lightly with Muslims for fear of making them mad at us is stupid. The religious leaders have been spewing their hatred towards us for decades. Appeasement and weakness is poor diplomacy with Muslims. We absolutely did the right thing.

...has relaxed environmental standards to the point where his own people keep resigning...
Don't know enough to comment. I believe in balancing environmental needs with human ones. And no they are not always the same. I have asked before of others, a link would be helpful.

...has been one of the least communicative presidents in all US history.
I want a president to get a job done not blow smoke up my a**

You obviously have different standards from mine.
Quite

And I'll mention again, since you don't seem to pay attention to it: I am NOT a Democrat. I don't make excuses for them, either.
If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck...

One need not be a democrat to be aligned against the right. I have not seen anything from you that would suggest anything but a strong left of center ideology. I of course could be wrong, it wouldn't be the first time on this forum. It is just that I figured that by now you would have outlined any right of center thinking rather than disassociate yourself from democrats. Look, make this easy, elucidate for me any right of center ideology that you identify with?

Can you name any current Republican or Conservative leaders that you admire?

Which specific right of center policies do you endorse and what right of center laws would you like to see passed by the Republican congress?

Thanks,

RandFan
 
RandFan:
Oh christ, people are getting into planes and blowing us up. The notion that we have to tread lightly with Muslims for fear of making them mad at us is stupid. The religious leaders have been spewing their hatred towards us for decades. Appeasement and weakness is poor diplomacy with Muslims. We absolutely did the right thing.

Who said anything about appeasment? But making the same mistakes that we did in the past is NOT the mark of a good leader, and we don't have one. The Taliban is once again taking hold in Afghanistan. Osama is still on the loose.

Invading a country that had very little to do with terrorism against the US didn't accomplish anything except make us look stupid. Yeah, great "leader" we've got. He could knock over a liquor store and you'd be telling us how brave he was to make such a bold move.

I want a president to get a job done not blow smoke up my a**

I honestly can't believe you even said this. Bush's lies are costing the lives of our soldiers and bankrupting our nation. But I guess lying about sex is worse to you? Yikes. We DO have different standards.


B]Can you name any current Republican or Conservative leaders that you admire?[/B]

OK, but I wonder if you will name any Democrats you admire, since you claim to be objective (I have seen little evidence of that).

William F. Buckley
Gerald Ford
John Mcaine
Sherwood Boehlert
Mike Castle
Christopher Shays
Jim Leach
Nancy Johnson
Wayne Gilchrest
Chris Smith
Sue Kelly
Chrsitine Todd Whitman

OK, Rand Fan, your turn...
 
Mark said:
Who said anything about appeasment?
I did. Aside from what Bush did there are few other options.

But making the same mistakes that we did in the past is NOT the mark of a good leader, and we don't have one.
We are not making the same mistakes.

The Taliban is once again taking hold in Afghanistan. Osama is still on the loose.
Again, arguable. According to Steven Brill (a democrat who did not vote for Bush and is respected for his objectivity) we have made great strides.

Invading a country that had very little to do with terrorism against the US didn't accomplish anything except make us look stupid.
That is your opinion. For 12 years Saddam mocked the international community and flaunted his contempt. That mockery and contempt are over. He was ordered to disarm and we have ensured that he has. We also ended his reign of terror on the innocent people of Iraq. "didn't accomplish anything"? It is claims like this that really make me question your objectivity.

Yeah, great "leader" we've got. He could knock over a liquor store and you'd be telling us how brave he was to make such a bold move.
Yes he is a great leader and putting words in mouth does not advance your argument. Saddam was a tyrant who invaded his neighbor, gassed his own people and launched scuds at Israel. He refused to comply and disarm and we disarmed him.

I honestly can't believe you even said this. Bush's lies are costing the lives of our soldiers and bankrupting our nation.
What lies? Bush is not bankrupting our nation. You are entitled to your opinion but this is not true.

But I guess lying about sex is worse to you?
You obviously haven't been following close attention have you. I was against the impeachment and do not think lying about sex is important. Bombing a milk factory and dropping ton's of bombs during the investigation is another thing entirely.

OK, but I wonder if you will name any Democrats you admire, since you claim to be objective (I have seen little evidence of that).
You failed to name any policies or laws.

Thanks for giving me the opportunity to opine about those from the left I admire.

First I would have to say Pat Cadell. Intellectually brilliant, independent in that he never follows the pack (he says he is a liberal democrat) and the most intellectually honest pundit bar none. It would be a huge honor for me to some day meet him.

When I think of liberals that I like I always think of Mario Cuomo. He has been out of the lime light for awhile but I hope you will indulge me none-the-less. Again, smart, eloquent and firm in his convictions. I never once got the impression that Mario was a Liberal for any other reason than sincere belief in core principles. His ability to debate and his fearlessness towards critics was, to use a tired cliche, an inspiration.

For purely political reasons I have to say Bill Clinton. After the 1984 take over by Republicans Bill went on the offensive and kicked Republican ass like there were no tomorrow. He defeated Newt Gengrich soundly. He took the fight to the front lines and to the people and without fear set his agenda and won every battle time and time again. I don't know what legacy Clinton will enjoy but his ability as a politician will absolutely go down in history as one of the deftest of all time. And I say that with all sincerity.

Would you let me go back in time just a bit. Sorry. Ed Koch. I think Ed could have done more for New York the way Guiliani did. But as a politician and as a human being Ed is truly one of the great ones. Zero sleaze factor IMO. Ed balanced politics and the needs of people in a way that put the needs of people first.

Ed proved that one can be a politician without being a politican He is in my estimation a rare individual.

William Bratton, Democrat. It was Bratton who was behind much of the crime reduction in New York. Bratton is fiercely pro-law and pro-civil liberties. He believes that the two are not mutually exclusive. Bratton has contempt for those who feel that there should be different standards for law enforcement and everyone else. Bratton also believes in personal responsibility and that the punishment should fit the crime. We need a lot more William Brattons.

I admire Loretta Sanchez from California. She defeated the pompous B-1 Bob and did so with style. She has been a great asset for her constituents and has risen through the ranks in spite of her lack of experience.

Morris Dees. I would hope his accomplishments go with out saying but Morris has worked tirelessly for civil rights and has scored a number of very significant victories over the hate groups here in America. Please see Southern Poverty Law Center for additional information.

I am out of time but would be happy to supply more if you require.

Again, are there any policies that identify with or laws from the right that you would like to see passed?
 
RandFan said:
I did. Aside from what Bush did there are few other options.

We are not making the same mistakes.

Again, arguable. According to Steven Brill (a democrat who did not vote for Bush and is respected for his objectivity) we have made great strides.

That is your opinion. For 12 years Saddam mocked the international community and flaunted his contempt. That mockery and contempt are over. He was ordered to disarm and we have ensured that he has. We also ended his reign of terror on the innocent people of Iraq. "didn't accomplish anything"? It is claims like this that really make me question your objectivity.

Yes he is a great leader and putting words in mouth does not advance your argument. Saddam was a tyrant who invaded his neighbor, gassed his own people and launched scuds at Israel. He refused to comply and disarm and we disarmed him.

What lies? Bush is not bankrupting our nation. You are entitled to your opinion but this is not true.

You obviously haven't been following close attention have you. I was against the impeachment and do not think lying about sex is important. Bombing a milk factory and dropping ton's of bombs during the investigation is another thing entirely.

You failed to name any policies or laws.

Thanks for giving me the opportunity to opine about those from the left I admire.

First I would have to say Pat Cadell. Intellectually brilliant, independent in that he never follows the pack (he says he is a liberal democrat) and the most intellectually honest pundit bar none. It would be a huge honor for me to some day meet him.

When I think of liberals that I like I always think of Mario Cuomo. He has been out of the lime light for awhile but I hope you will indulge me none-the-less. Again, smart, eloquent and firm in his convictions. I never once got the impression that Mario was a Liberal for any other reason than sincere belief in core principles. His ability to debate and his fearlessness towards critics was, to use a tired cliche, an inspiration.

For purely political reasons I have to say Bill Clinton. After the 1984 take over by Republicans Bill went on the offensive and kicked Republican ass like there were no tomorrow. He defeated Newt Gengrich soundly. He took the fight to the front lines and to the people and without fear set his agenda and won every battle time and time again. I don't know what legacy Clinton will enjoy but his ability as a politician will absolutely go down in history as one of the deftest of all time. And I say that with all sincerity.

Would you let me go back in time just a bit. Sorry. Ed Koch. I think Ed could have done more for New York the way Guiliani did. But as a politician and as a human being Ed is truly one of the great ones. Zero sleaze factor IMO. Ed balanced politics and the needs of people in a way that put the needs of people first.

Ed proved that one can be a politician without being a politican He is in my estimation a rare individual.

William Bratton, Democrat. It was Bratton who was behind much of the crime reduction in New York. Bratton is fiercely pro-law and pro-civil liberties. He believes that the two are not mutually exclusive. Bratton has contempt for those who feel that there should be different standards for law enforcement and everyone else. Bratton also believes in personal responsibility and that the punishment should fit the crime. We need a lot more William Brattons.

I admire Loretta Sanchez from California. She defeated the pompous B-1 Bob and did so with style. She has been a great asset for her constituents and has risen through the ranks in spite of her lack of experience.

Morris Dees. I would hope his accomplishments go with out saying but Morris has worked tirelessly for civil rights and has scored a number of very significant victories over the hate groups here in America. Please see Southern Poverty Law Center for additional information.

I am out of time but would be happy to supply more if you require.

Again, are there any policies that identify with or laws from the right that you would like to see passed?

Since we are starting go in circles, I will close by saying I genuinely admire your willingness to list lefties you admire, as much as your continuing defense of Bush genuinely mystifies me. Oh, well;let's just agree to disagree about Bush, OK?
 
Mark said:
Since we are starting go in circles, I will close by saying I genuinely admire your willingness to list lefties you admire, as much as your continuing defense of Bush genuinely mystifies me. Oh, well;let's just agree to disagree about Bush, OK?
That is cool,

Thanks Mark

RandFan
 
dwb:
"I can go out and find more"

I Googled til my eyes rolled back.

You can't find any more. Its easy to say there's more. There ain't.
I did the heavy lifting that no one else would bother to do.
I'm talking measurable objective standards not opinion as to whether he did a "good job."
Even the ones I found have another side to them.
You are invited to Google to your hearts content.
Glad to see you had a soft landing.
 
subgenius said:
dwb:
"I can go out and find more"

I Googled til my eyes rolled back.

You can't find any more. Its easy to say there's more. There ain't.
I did the heavy lifting that no one else would bother to do.
I'm talking measurable objective standards not opinion as to whether he did a "good job."
Even the ones I found have another side to them.
You are invited to Google to your hearts content.
Glad to see you had a soft landing.
So, is there a point? Is there an "acomplishment index" that we can compare Carter, Reagan, Bush Sr., Bush Jr. and Clinton with?
 
"For 12 years Saddam mocked the international community and flaunted his contempt."

I think this goes a long way in understanding Bush's passion and apparent unwavering desire to get rid of Saddam. I think a more accurate phrase might be "For 12 years Saddam mocked George Bush Sr and flaunted his contempt. I think Bush Jr was avenging Bush Sr.

"Bombing a milk factory and dropping ton's of bombs during the investigation is another thing entirely."

Are you suggesting Clinton knew it was a milk factory and bombed it anyway?

Interesting how much this parallels current detractors of the Iraq war claims that Bush knew that no evidence of WMD's existed, no chemicals, no bombs, etc. and yet bombed anyway.
 
Barry Goldwater
Everett Dirksen
Nelson Rockefeller
Bob Dole
John McCain
William Milliken
Dwight Eisenhower
William F. Buckley
Arlen Spector
John Warner
Howard Baker

A short list of Republicans I respect.....in case you were wondering...
 
DavidJames said:
"For 12 years Saddam mocked the international community and flaunted his contempt."

I think this goes a long way in understanding Bush's passion and apparent unwavering desire to get rid of Saddam. I think a more accurate phrase might be "For 12 years Saddam mocked George Bush Sr and flaunted his contempt. I think Bush Jr was avenging Bush Sr.

"Bombing a milk factory and dropping ton's of bombs during the investigation is another thing entirely."

Are you suggesting Clinton knew it was a milk factory and bombed it anyway?

Interesting how much this parallels current detractors of the Iraq war claims that Bush knew that no evidence of WMD's existed, no chemicals, no bombs, etc. and yet bombed anyway.
Thank you,

Exactly my point. I DON'T know Clinton's motivations, *intelligence, thoughts, advice, etc., etc. I don't claim to know them. But many on this forum, skeptics and fanatics alike seem to KNOW Bush's motivations his knowledge of the exact capabilities of Iraq. My only purpose in bringing up Clinton is to highlight the glaring inconsistency of applying judgment differently based solely on ideology.

It should be noted however that there were claims made by Bush and his administration about WMD and where they were being kept. You can be assured that that fact will be brought up.

Bush did not know where or if there were WMD. It seems very likely that he used an assurance of WMD to secure public support for the war.

He did NOT know that there was no WMD and there was good reason to beleive that there were.

My thanks again,

RandFan.

(*Secret information, especially about an actual or potential enemy.)
 
RandFan said:
So, is there a point? Is there an "acomplishment index" that we can compare Carter, Reagan, Bush Sr., Bush Jr. and Clinton with?
You're like so into comparing and bringing up other names....I'm talking about his qualifications to be pres.............take any measurable thing.......take that number before Bush took the job, say governor, and see how he improved on it.....seems to be a lot of quibbling rather than googling....
....."accomplishment index": improvement in something in any measurable way.......not clear? ....something, anything......
 
subgenius said:

You're like so into comparing and bringing up other names....I'm talking about his qualifications to be pres.............take any measurable thing.......take that number before Bush took the job, say governor, and see how he improved on it.....seems to be a lot of quibbling rather than googling....
....."accomplishment index": improvement in something in any measurable way.......not clear? ....something, anything......
Sub, to be honest I really do not know where you are going? I don't know why I need to google anything? What is your point?
 
Come on, stupid U.S. redneck:
RandFan said:
Sub, to be honest I really do not know where you are going?
...
Do you know of any undisputable Bush achievement that makes Bush deserving to become the U.S. President?
 
RandFan said:
Sub, to be honest I really do not know where you are going? I don't know why I need to google anything? What is your point?
This thread is about his resume. Some said it wasn't fair and we're giving people a chance to put good things in there, much as you or I would put on our resumes.
 
subgenius said:

This thread is about his resume. Some said it wasn't fair and we're giving people a chance to put good things in there, much as you or I would put on our resumes.
Well, there was the Patient's Bill of Rights

Also, you may have heard President Bush has announced he could not support a patient's bill of rights that allowed patients to sue HMOs. President Bush indicated he could only support a patient's bill of rights that would allow people only a limited remedy with caps on damages and only in federal court after external reviews. This is in sharp contrast to President Bush's position as a candidate. While running for the presidency, he claimed credit for a patient's bill of rights in Texas he vetoed but ultimately allowed to become law without his signature because the legislature was poised to override a second veto. It is clear the President only wants to protect HMOs and other managed care insurers rather than patients, who, all to often, are killed or injured because insurers delay or deny the care they need.
 
Also, you may have heard President Bush has announced he could not support a patient's bill of rights that allowed patients to sue HMOs. President Bush indicated he could only support a patient's bill of rights that would allow people only a limited remedy with caps on damages and only in federal court after external reviews. This is in sharp contrast to President Bush's position as a candidate. While running for the presidency, he claimed credit for a patient's bill of rights in Texas he vetoed but ultimately allowed to become law without his signature because the legislature was poised to override a second veto. It is clear the President only wants to protect HMOs and other managed care insurers rather than patients, who, all to often, are killed or injured because insurers delay or deny the care they need.
I am no fan of HMOs that is why I have a PPO.

There are legitimate reasons to cap damages. Run away workers comp costs in California are an excellent example of what happens when health care providers can charge anything they want, as much as they want, whenever they want.
 
subgenius said:
This thread is about his resume. Some said it wasn't fair and we're giving people a chance to put good things in there, much as you or I would put on our resumes.
Oh, right, sure, whatever.

Having witnessed first hand 7 presidencies I can honestly say that I see little purpose to the exercise. Nixon had an enormous amount of experience and qualifications as did Ford. Nixon left in disgrace and Ford was voted out of office. Carter had little to no experience that would qualify him for office but was a very decent man. He had some significant success at peace between Egypt and Israel but did little else and nothing for the economy and was soundly voted out of office after one term. Reagan was a governor prior to being president. Depending on whom you talk to he was a hugely successful president or the scourge of America. He did enjoy broad support from a wide range of citizens. Bush Sr. was imminently qualified having served his country for half a century in various areas of government. He prosecuted a successful war but did nothing for the economy and was booted out of office. Clinton was the governor of a state that by any measure ranks as one of the lowest of any in the union. Under his direction the state got worse. Like Reagan he enjoyed broad approval and also like Reagan won a landslide re-election.

What I don't understand is what the "resume" has anything to do with anything? I have been asking for sometime now and it is becoming painfully clear that there is no answer to be had.

Please enjoy yourself. I have other things to do.

I will see you in some other threads.
 
The office of President has changed a lot. Reagan and Bush II have shown that the US President need not be saddled with a lot of baggage about policy and decisions and stuff like that. Bush II has shown that he need not even be partcularly articulate. But Dubya has excelled in the resumé point that has recently been shown to be the most important for presidential candidates. Fundraising. Bush has excelled at this at every level, from the trivial posting of bail to the funding of businesses (and the bailing out of same), to gigantic taxpayer-supported sports complexes. He has the remarkable ability to extract dollars from businessmen in heretofore unheard of amounts.

There is little doubt that this skill is absolutely crucial to the hopeful candidate these days. Some, like Clinton, were clumsy about it and took meager amounts of money for silly things like a night in the Lincoln Bedroom. Bush has refined that to the much more subtle and profitable skill of selling off cabinet posts, chairmanships and secret meetings with the policy makers.

How has Bush managed to perfect the art of fundraising? The answer is simple. Delivery. Once you leave your overstuffed briefcase with GWB, you can be assured of favorable policies, whether you be a polluter, an HMO, an energy trader, a defense contractor, or an oilfield service provider. George W. Bush is a man you can trust. Once he is bought, he stays bought.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom