RandFan said:
Regnad Kcin,
Thank you for your response and reasoned tone.
My pleasure. The same to you.
It need not be perplexing at all. I don't view Bush through an ideological filter. If I were a Democrat and devoid of objectivity I suppose I wouldn't like him. I don't like everything he does but I don't condemn him for any mistakes he has made so far.
I don't want to parse every one of your statements, either those in response to me, or others in this thread. But I also hesitate to let things go by without comment.
That being said, it's possible to not like the man and his policies regardless of one's political affiliation. Yes, you would be right to suspect that a particular Ford salesman doesn't like the Chevy huckster from across the street because they're competitors. But it's possible that Mr. Chevrolet is of questionable virtue irrespective of who's doing the scrutinizing.
Which president do you like or respect?
A fine question, though you'll forgive me for smelling a trap. Nevertheless, I'll answer. Among modern presidents, I'm more fond of Harry Truman than not. Jimmy Carter comes in second. (I wonder if this is because of the casual nature of their first names.)
The day I find a simple way to point out the hypocrisy and inconsistency of many of those who attack Bush is the day I'll leave the ghost of Clinton's presidency in the grave. If you can provide for me a better way I will use it.
I agree, to a point. It is certainly frustrating to deal with anyone who is not able to manage the basic tools of debate, let alone those which are more sophistcated. However, we should try. An argument should stand on its own strength or fall because of its weakness.
The politics of Bush et all is no more slimier than Clinton and friends.
This is just the kind of statement you should guard against, if you don't mind my saying. For one thing, it's impossible to measure such things. Furthermore, it all depends on who's making the call.
That being said, in my opinion the far right (both politicians and punditry) has much to answer for due to their behavior over the last decade or so.
As I said, if you were as critical of Clinton as you are of Bush then I respect your opinion.
Again, forgive the parsing, but I would hope you respect my opinion based on the strength of my arguments; being equally critical of another is irrelevant.
You discover that there is a newly-taken photo of your girlfriend kissing another guy floating around. Does it matter if a criminal took the shot? (Goodness, I hope that's clear.)
Hence my going back to the Clintons. What reason would anyone have to like or respect any president? They have all held beliefs and done things that are contemptible. It is sadly the nature of politics and particularly presidential politics. I judge Clinton, Bush, Bush Sr., Reagan in the context of a president.
I agree, it isn't easy. And the citizenry asks entirely too much more of the executive than he can possibly give. Plus, our popular culture has created a mythic sensibility surrounding the office that serves to elevate its holder regardless of whether or not he has earned the honor. So we judge him on that. And of course he'll come up short.
Then there's the nature of adversarial politics. I tend to chuckle when people moan and groan about how Congress or some deliberative body is "not gettin' anything done" or how they're "always bickering." Folks, that's the way it's
supposed to be! The system promotes gradual change through compromise as the best method for reaching goals that benifit the most while hurting the least. But I digress.
I find most people only consider context when there is shared ideology.
A safe bet, but not a sure one.
I'm glad you brought this up. And sorry but I am going to go back to Bill Clinton. According to Dick Morris Clinton never made a single decision that he didn't first check the polls over. Bill Clinton was famous for pandering. After the Republican takeover of 1984 Bill Clinton moved sharply to the right. George Stephanopoulos talks about this in his book All Too Human. He regret that Clinton followed Morriss' advice but Bill credits this move for giving him a landslide victory in the next election.
This raises the question, do you think Bill Clinton was a coward and do you think that he was disrespectful to you and the constitution?
Y'know I haven't done my Ronald Reagan imitation in a while. Let's give it a try...
There you go again.
Hey, that was pretty good, if I do say so myself! The point being, I'm not participating in this thread to discuss Bill Clinton. If Bill Clinton jumped off a bridge (or jumped on an intern) would you do it too?
Originally posted by Regnad Kcin
Please name three difficult and courageous decisions that George W. Bush has made.
Originally posted by RandFan
To send troops into harms way in Afghanistan.
To stand up to those who did not have our best interests at heart (French, Germans, etc.) and fight for a referendum against Iraq.
To send troops into harms way in Iraq.
Thank you. However, I believe your list is highly debatable.
Regarding the first item: I must say that the decision was a no-brainer. Following the attacks of 9/11 people far and wide were champing at the bit to go after Osama bin Laden and his goons. Frankly, if the US had spent a fraction of current $1 billion per week expenditure in Iraq on thoroughly rooting out al-Qaeda, few would argue, and the world would be a much nicer place.
Item number two: George W. Bush did not stand up to anyone. He and his team had a particular game plan in mind and ignored those governments and peoples who begged to differ. International diplomacy is extravagently complex. But is what Mr. Bush did courageous? I prefer short-sighted, but I'll allow for a maybe, so I'll reluctantly give you this, though with the caveat that it's open to interpretation.
Your third item is related to your second. And since I've adressed it, let me take issue with the meaning behind your choice of phrase. Troops are, by nature, supposed to go in harm's way. That's what they're for. I hope that we try to avoid any situations that would require the decision to use them. A circus manager is not courageous for instructing his wild animal trainer to enter the lion's cage each performance. Even with the very real possibility that the whip snapper may not come out alive.
There are a plethora of books about Bill Clinton (bear with me) written by prominent individuals. I have not read all of them. I did read Stephanopolus' book and Barbara Olson's book The Final Days and others.
I have not read Miller's book. Have you read Olson's book?
I have not. (I hasten to add my regrets that she lost her life on 9/11.) That being said, an analysis of the Clinton administration at this point can only serve a scholarly purpose; it is history. Discussing the present president and the possibility of his gaining a second term is quite a bit more relevant.
When I said tripe I was referring to the anti-(whoever is president) propaganda that is written about every president. I have read enough conspiracy theories and attack pieces to know that people can make Charley Manson look like Mother Theresa and vice versa. I haven't read the book but I don't need to read every book that comes along any more than you need to read every book that comes out against those in your ideological camp.
I think your point is valid, though there is a difference between propaganda and scholarship. While Professor Miller's book is quite scathing in its judgement, it is less a personal attack than an indictment directed towards our largely content-free modern system of selecting and promoting candidates for office. (He is, as I mentioned, a teacher of media studies.) In addition, Miller has little patience for a citizenry that is so cavalier in its disregard for what are today perhaps the most important issues of civilization.
BTW, if you feel Ms. Olsen's book is worth my time, I'll look for it.
I find so much hypocrisy and inconsistency in threads like this. It is the only way I know of to puncture the pompousness of those who get on and make a laundry list of reasons they dislike or even hate Bush. I dealt with it for 8 years when Clinton was president and I often turned the tables on my friends and family when the attacked Clinton.
I hate hypocracy.
Agreed.
Are you saying that the attacks made against Bush in this thread have all been "honest analysis"?
Not at all. If I presented that impression, I apologize.
While there have been a number of serious and objective posts most have not. If they had I wouldn't have even bothered posting. I have no problem with "honest analysis". I am no Bush sycophant. I have said on a number of occasions that I am concerned with his judicial appointments and I have also made known my concerns with the patriot act and other issues. I have admitted that his statements about religion and atheists were wrong.
It is the blanket statements and indictments of others on this thread that I take issue with. One poster says that he wants to physically harm Bush. Is this what you call "honest analysis"?
You keep placing the words honest analysis in quotes. I can't find where I used the phrase, but no matter.
As I stated earlier, many of the items in the "resume" at the top of this thread do not stand up to scrutiny. Quite a bit of the discussion that has followed has been, as with any forum, out of line and warrants only my disregard.
I have no problem with "honest analysis" and the purpose of my "argument" was an attack on those individuals who would condemn Bush for the very actions they would excuse Clinton for.
It seems to me you're making a generalization, in part born of your frustration at those who do not share your sense of fair play.
I appreciate your willingness to engage me they way you are. It seems quite obvious that you are willing to consider my point of view. It is all that I want. I can honestly say that some of the posters that I respect the most I disagree with. Tricky and Subgenius, Wayne Grabert, Roadtoad and others. Of course there are areas of agreement and that helps ... I think you are objective as are many others on this forum. I am hardly unique I just feel the need to toot my own self righteous horn more than anyone else.
I'll have to see a therapist about that someday.
Thank you once again for your compliments. Consideration for others is a skill that should be practiced often.