The big list of things Science can do.

Science kicks ass because it let me still have a wife and son instead of neither.

Science kicks ass because it doesn't mind being scrutinized and actually encourages it.
 
Science kicks ass because it let me still have a wife and son instead of neither.

Science kicks ass because it doesn't mind being scrutinized and actually encourages it.
Awesome!!!

"What PatKelley said!" (to both points)
 
Science is so ass-kickingly cool that it has its own fiction genre.

Science can use DNA evidence and determine who was at a crime scence about 100,000,000,000 times better than psychics can.
 
Science kicks ass because it stopped my dog's seizures with a small daily dose of phenobarbital.

Science kicks ass because it helped me carry my second child nearly to term, instead of miscarrying him at 14 weeks.

Science kicks ass because it successfully reattached that child's finger when he severed it in an accident.

Science kicks ass because it detected and then completely removed the 90% blockages in my husband's carotid arteries!

Science frikkin rocks, dudes!!!
 
Science forcefully applies the metatarsals to the gluteus maximus because it permits a consulting surgeon in Tel Aviv to oversee in real time a lifesaving operation on a patient in St. Louis through precision instruments under the remote control of a surgeon in New York.

Science abuts foot to butt with vigor because it allowed us to send Gene Roddenberry's ashes into the Great Beyond.

Science whups the dorsal nether region because it enabled the develoment of automated equipment that produces the perfect thick-crust pan pizza every time (thuis enabling the efficient, continued expansion of said nether region).
 
Science is so ass-kickingly cool that it has its own fiction genre.

Science can use DNA evidence and determine who was at a crime scence about 100,000,000,000 times better than psychics can.

Just Today:

(Associated Press)New York-A jury took less than two hours yesterday to convict a man of raping a woman 32 years ago at knifepoint-a verdict made
possible by DNA technology that did not exist when the suspect escaped conviction in the 1970s...
 
Format it like so:

Science kicks ass because......

I don't want to be the party pooper, but there are two things I'd like to add

1.) I don't think science "kicks a***" because it can't. I think science is a more educated form of curiosity and therefore rather neutral. Like a rock: It can be used to do different things (good and bad) but that doesn't make the rock good/bad.
And science can't "do" things either. The use of science might lead to pleasant inventions and also not so pleasant ones. (It's easier than ever to kill large amounts of people by the use of "great" inventions...)

2.) The "worst thing science does" (to stick with this terminology) is to turn people who concern themselves with it into believers. If somebody says "God is great, because I always have somebody who listens / because he made the earth / etc.", I find it strange enough.
But if somebody on a sceptics board says "Science is great because it brought me the internet / the cure for a sickness" I find it rather ironic, yet it proves my point.
I agree it's great to have these things, but I think the people who invented them "kick a***", however they invented them.

(Great Music/Art was created because of the believe in some religion. I enjoy it, but I wouldn't say "religion is great because it gave me a lot of music to listen to")

FR
 
Fortunately, Lister was finally able to convince the surgical community that disinfection techniques against microorganisms really worked, and as a result the death rate from surgical infection dropped to almost nil.

Wasn't that Semmelweisz? As far as I remember the story he invented disinfection not by scientific means, but rather by accident...

*ok, I step off the soapbox now*

FR
 
Wasn't that Semmelweisz?

It's also simply wrong. The maternal death rate in the third world is still something like one in fifty, and that's not because "evil doctors" are delivering babies in the third word without washing their hands, while midwives are doing it properly and safely. If "midwives" were so great at doing home births in third world conditions in the fifteenth century, why can't they do it in the 20th?
 
I agree it's great to have these things, but I think the people who invented them "kick a***", however they invented them.

Don't you think it's great that someone else invented an intellectual framework to encourage the invention of these things?

Do you really think that modern medicine would be where it is today without someone else having invented "scientific thinking"?
 
Don't you think it's great that someone else invented an intellectual framework to encourage the invention of these things?

Yes, I do think it's great this framework has been invented.
I also think it's great that mechanics were invented.
Nevertheless I wouldn't say mechanics are good or bad or "kick a***". That depends on the people who use them (and for what).

Do you really think that modern medicine would be where it is today without someone else having invented "scientific thinking"?

No, did I say something like that?


"Science" is (amongst other things) a way (framework, as you say) to invent stuff. Like a screwdriver is something you can build stuff with. But I don't say "I like my watch and therefore I praise the screwdriver with which it was put together."

FR
 
I don't want to be the party pooper, but there are two things I'd like to add

1.) I don't think science "kicks a***" because it can't. I think science is a more educated form of curiosity and therefore rather neutral. Like a rock: It can be used to do different things (good and bad) but that doesn't make the rock good/bad.
And science can't "do" things either. The use of science might lead to pleasant inventions and also not so pleasant ones. (It's easier than ever to kill large amounts of people by the use of "great" inventions...)

2.) The "worst thing science does" (to stick with this terminology) is to turn people who concern themselves with it into believers. If somebody says "God is great, because I always have somebody who listens / because he made the earth / etc.", I find it strange enough.
But if somebody on a sceptics board says "Science is great because it brought me the internet / the cure for a sickness" I find it rather ironic, yet it proves my point.
I agree it's great to have these things, but I think the people who invented them "kick a***", however they invented them.

(Great Music/Art was created because of the believe in some religion. I enjoy it, but I wouldn't say "religion is great because it gave me a lot of music to listen to")

FR


Of course science is a human endeavor, and therefore it's the humans who use it who might be said technically to punt posterior, but I think it's nitpicking, and the music analogy doesn't work. The great religious music is great because it's good music not because it's good religion; even though we can credit the emotional experience of religion with at least some of the inspiration, it's not the only source of inspiration. We have plenty of evidence in the form of great secular music. It would be much harder to suggest that great scientific progress, and in particular the things people here are crediting science with, would have occurred without the use of scientific method. The great scientific discoveries and advances are great because of the science involved (and yes, I realize that's kind of a tautology, but that's the point). The people who did those wonderful things may have been nice, like my grandfather*, or they may have been nasty, like Sir Isaac Newton. They may have been Christians, Muslims or atheists, but when they did their science, that's what they did, and I think the results speak for themselves.

Anything can, of course, be misused, especially if it is powerful, and science is no exception. But I also don't think we can blame science itself for the fact that human beings, evil, greedy and violent creatures that we are, apply good science for bad technology.

*Science gives the butt a biff because long ago, my grandfather, while attempting to unlock the secrets of Roquefort cheese for the Department of Agriculture, found some interesting anomalies in the byproducts of fermentation of penicillium roqueforti. He took his findings to a little chemical company in Brooklyn, and talked them into giving him lab space to refine his discoveries. He did pretty well, and so did the company. What he came up with was the fermentation process for producing citric acid, among other things, including some pretty important research in the field of antibiotics. The little company was Pfizer.
 
[...], but I think it's nitpicking,

Ok, I'll try it differently. There are different ways to make a discovery or invent something:
1.) Accident (stumbling across sth.)
2.) Trial and error
3.) Scientific method

And probably others. Since 3.) seems to produce the most output and most likely the most complicated inventions I'd call it superior if you want to invent/research something.
I just think that moral judging doesn't apply. I wouldn't say trial and error is "good" or "bad". It just exists as a method.

However - and that is what amuses me - there are so many people on this forum chanting this "science is good" mantra, that it really reminds me of "praise the lord" ;-)

On a more serious note, though: I followed some of these "Creationists vs. Scientists" or "Evolution theory vs. ID" debates on this and other forums and I think part of the problem is that even scientists become so strong believers in the "goodness" of science that they fail to lead a good argument, which I think they could easily win just by the facts. But they get carried away and caught in the same web of believe as the other side: They become dogmatic and ignorant.

If you switch to a Christianity-Forum, you'll have similar threads to this one saying "God is great, because..."

FR
 
This was just supposed to be a little light hearted fun.

Thanks force_redo, for gaying it up.

Oh, and welcome to JREF!
 
This was just supposed to be a little light hearted fun.

Thanks force_redo, for gaying it up.

Oh, and welcome to JREF!

Yeah, I know. But reading on puzzled me a bit, though...
And thanks for the welcome.

And, by the way, I'm from a place where the concept of humour is not yet developed. (Or maybe I'm just a sad ****)

FR
 
Since [Scientific method] seems to produce the most output and most likely the most complicated inventions I'd call it superior if you want to invent/research something.
I just think that moral judging doesn't apply. I wouldn't say trial and error is "good" or "bad". It just exists as a method.
Is ass-kicking "good"? Not if you're on the receiving end. To my ear, "kicks ass" is a qualitative term more of superiority than of morality. You state above that science is a superior method of discovery/invention than its alternatives. Sounds to me as though you think science kicks ass.

eta: Oh, right. Welcome!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom