The big list of things Science can do.

Is ass-kicking "good"? Not if you're on the receiving end.

True. And curiosity really sucks if you're a cat.

To my ear, "kicks ass" is a qualitative term more of superiority than of morality. You state above that science is a superior method of discovery/invention than its alternatives. Sounds to me as though you think science kicks ass.

eta: Oh, right. Welcome!

Yes, I think science is a superior method of research/invention. And, if you want "kicks a***" in this field. But it wasn't science that discovered "penicillium roqueforti" (quite impressive story, that is), it was bruto's grandfather.
And it wasn't science that understood it's potential in medicine, it was bruto's grandfather.
And it's not science that's giving me antibiotics when I need them, it's my doctor.

Bruto's grandfather and my doctor and many other people "kick ar**".
If Bruto's granddad's invention/discovery was accidental or science or intuition doesn't make it more or less "a*** kicking", does it?

Hence, the "big list of things science can do" is rather short. Nevertheless it's very important.
Edit: (Science that is, not the list)

FR
 
Last edited:
I don't want to be the party pooper, but there are two things I'd like to add

1.) I don't think science "kicks a***" because it can't. I think science is a more educated form of curiosity and therefore rather neutral. Like a rock: It can be used to do different things (good and bad) but that doesn't make the rock good/bad.
And science can't "do" things either. The use of science might lead to pleasant inventions and also not so pleasant ones. (It's easier than ever to kill large amounts of people by the use of "great" inventions...)

2.) The "worst thing science does" (to stick with this terminology) is to turn people who concern themselves with it into believers. If somebody says "God is great, because I always have somebody who listens / because he made the earth / etc.", I find it strange enough.
But if somebody on a sceptics board says "Science is great because it brought me the internet / the cure for a sickness" I find it rather ironic, yet it proves my point.
I agree it's great to have these things, but I think the people who invented them "kick a***", however they invented them.

(Great Music/Art was created because of the believe in some religion. I enjoy it, but I wouldn't say "religion is great because it gave me a lot of music to listen to")

FR

No one here thinks that science is alive. Scientists deserve credit when they properly apply the scientific method.

Whenever you hear "Science kicks a**...", just pretend it says "Science is useful because...."

Welcome, but relax alittle. We aren't being dogmatic, just playful.
 
I notice that little coward Kilik ran away from this thread after these two posts showed up. Gees, wonder why....


Perhaps he found my statement comparing his comprehension skills to a rotting watermelon a bit too insulting ;)
 
Perhaps he found my statement comparing his comprehension skills to a rotting watermelon a bit too insulting ;)

Even a rotting watermelon of ignorance contains seeds of potential learning.


Ha ha... just kidding! Had you going there for a second, didn't I?
 
True. And curiosity really sucks if you're a cat.



Yes, I think science is a superior method of research/invention. And, if you want "kicks a***" in this field. But it wasn't science that discovered "penicillium roqueforti" (quite impressive story, that is), it was bruto's grandfather.
And it wasn't science that understood it's potential in medicine, it was bruto's grandfather.
And it's not science that's giving me antibiotics when I need them, it's my doctor.

Bruto's grandfather and my doctor and many other people "kick ar**".
If Bruto's granddad's invention/discovery was accidental or science or intuition doesn't make it more or less "a*** kicking", does it?

Hence, the "big list of things science can do" is rather short. Nevertheless it's very important.
Edit: (Science that is, not the list)

FR


Of course my grandfather is the hero in this story, but he is that because he was a scientist. It was science (before my grandfather came along) that discovered penicillium roquefortii, whose effects on cheese were known long before scientists figured out what it was. He did not arrive at his discoveries by faith or accident, after the first accidental observation that led him on his path of discovery, which was itself a byproduct of the work of a chemist at work. He arrived there by science. He was a biochemist, and a very good one, and he knew what he was doing, and he knew how to do it. If he had made his discoveries by accident, it's possible some other scientist would have made something of them eventually. But he would not have.

Of course, science is a human endeavor. It is not an entity in and of itself, but it is a type of human endeavor that has a certain character, and that, the character of science as exemplified by scientists, is what we're celebrating here.
 
Kilik needs to stop, turn around, and retrace his steps on the Divine Path and learn basic spelling and punctuation.
 
Ok, I'll try it differently. There are different ways to make a discovery or invent something:
1.) Accident (stumbling across sth.)
2.) Trial and error
3.) Scientific method

And probably others. Since 3.) seems to produce the most output and most likely the most complicated inventions I'd call it superior if you want to invent/research something.
I just think that moral judging doesn't apply. I wouldn't say trial and error is "good" or "bad". It just exists as a method.

However - and that is what amuses me - there are so many people on this forum chanting this "science is good" mantra, that it really reminds me of "praise the lord" ;-)

On a more serious note, though: I followed some of these "Creationists vs. Scientists" or "Evolution theory vs. ID" debates on this and other forums and I think part of the problem is that even scientists become so strong believers in the "goodness" of science that they fail to lead a good argument, which I think they could easily win just by the facts. But they get carried away and caught in the same web of believe as the other side: They become dogmatic and ignorant.

If you switch to a Christianity-Forum, you'll have similar threads to this one saying "God is great, because..."

FR

If one wants to nitpick we should be saying "The Enlightement was good because..."

If nothing else, we've borrowed the terminology and description ("science") of the folks who have eschewed "Western" "Modern" or "Secular" methods for methods of dubious worth and questionable utility who do not care to rigorously interpret the results.

Advancements made in the face of beliefs (spontaneous generation versus Pasteur), in the face of outright opposition (Galileo, Copernicus, et al), or in the face of unscientific thought insisting on there not being a contest (Kansas...), are all considered under this blanket. The method by which ideas were found (brute force, serendipity, or reason) is not as important as that they were recognised, analyzed, and used for the betterment of our lives. Religion has not discovered anything that wasn't already there: community. Psychics have discovered the placebo effect over and over, and ridden confirmation bias until it is then supposedly contactable by some of their members. Betterment of mankind's lot comes from recognizing advances and keeping after them until the social tide turns. It is more than method; it is the social responsibility of people who recognize new discoveries and follow up with the notion that it is a gift to all mankind.

Now, Pat Robertson, on the other hand, so far has lined his own pockets and not really given anything new to society even in the realm of hardened bigotry and high-handed rhetoric.

So, yes, Science does kick ass, Virginia.
 
It's also simply wrong. The maternal death rate in the third world is still something like one in fifty, and that's not because "evil doctors" are delivering babies in the third word without washing their hands, while midwives are doing it properly and safely. If "midwives" were so great at doing home births in third world conditions in the fifteenth century, why can't they do it in the 20th?
Considering that the maternal death rate in certain hospitals in the pre-disinfection First World was as high as twenty-five in fifty, I'd say the modern Third World still has that by-gone era beat. (Hint: Look up "puerperal fever".)
 
Also, we must consider that midwives had a good reputation in the fifteenth century because they were compared with doctors in the fifteenth century.

It's not just third world conditions, it's the mindset.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom