Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
What are you seeing the players do or say that leads you to think the filibuster will be gone or modified? Anything recent?

Nothing particular. I think it’s been more clear through their public comments that a GOP return to normalcy, like moderates like Manchin and Biden have been predicting, isn’t going to happen. Filibuster on a bipartisan probe into Jan 6 because it’s not targeting Antifa is pretty good evidence they won’t get 60 on much and the low hanging fruit is gone.

I think it’s critical to pass voter reform by the mid terms. And there’s only one way that happens
 
Nothing particular. I think it’s been more clear through their public comments that a GOP return to normalcy, like moderates like Manchin and Biden have been predicting, isn’t going to happen. Filibuster on a bipartisan probe into Jan 6 because it’s not targeting Antifa is pretty good evidence they won’t get 60 on much and the low hanging fruit is gone.

I think it’s critical to pass voter reform by the mid terms. And there’s only one way that happens
Hopefully the Biden administration is calculating that it's worth it to spend some amount of time now in pursuit of bipartisanship (for the ability to say they've tried) while planning to change the filibuster before it's too late so they can pass the voting reform bill, which really has to pass before the midterm elections.
 
I hope so as well. They’ve introduced hundreds of targeted voter suppression bills at the state level across the country recently. It was already difficult to win; in WI last election Dems got something like 60% of the statewide vote and lost state seats, and it’s not going to get any easier the longer they sit on it.

I often wonder who the appearance of trying for bipartisanship is aimed at though. The GOP has been filibustering bills where they’ve requested provisions and compromises and voting them down anyway for years. I don’t know who these token efforts are aimed at.

Also, I think the Dems holding a 50/50 Senate was basically a miracle. Wouldn’t plan on holding both houses after 2022 regardless of what they do now. This is the time to level the playing field. It may be a while before they get another chance.
 
Last edited:
I hope so as well. They’ve introduced hundreds of targeted voter suppression bills at the state level across the country recently. It was already difficult to win; in WI last election Dems got something like 60% of the statewide vote and lost state seats, and it’s not going to get any easier the longer they sit on it.

I often wonder who the appearance of trying for bipartisanship is aimed at though. The GOP has been filibustering bills where they’ve requested provisions and compromises and voting them down anyway for years. I don’t know who these token efforts are aimed at.

Also, I think the Dems holding a 50/50 Senate was basically a miracle. Wouldn’t plan on holding both houses after 2022 regardless of what they do now. This is the time to level the playing field. It may be a while before they get another chance.
I would guess voters who value bipartisanship.
 
I often wonder who the appearance of trying for bipartisanship is aimed at though.
As another poster suggested, its probably aimed at moderate voters...

From: CNN
Americans of all political stripes agree that attempts at bipartisanship in Washington are a good thing...87% say that attempts at bipartisanship are a good thing, including 92% of Democrats, 90% of independents and 77% of Republicans. But 60% say they see bipartisanship as unlikely on upcoming legislation...

Of course, its possible for a person to CLAIM they want bipartisanship, but not actually care about it. (And I suspect at least some republicans who claim they want 'bipartisanship' simply want the Democrats to capitulate, without giving up anything themselves.)
 
As another poster suggested, its probably aimed at moderate voters...

From: CNN
Americans of all political stripes agree that attempts at bipartisanship in Washington are a good thing...87% say that attempts at bipartisanship are a good thing, including 92% of Democrats, 90% of independents and 77% of Republicans. But 60% say they see bipartisanship as unlikely on upcoming legislation...

Of course, its possible for a person to CLAIM they want bipartisanship, but not actually care about it. (And I suspect at least some republicans who claim they want 'bipartisanship' simply want the Democrats to capitulate, without giving up anything themselves.)

I don’t think bipartisanship is achievable on many of these issues at this time and I think everyone who’s paying attention knows that also. To me it seems like a waste of time to offer watered down compromises they have no intention of accepting anyway, when ultimately their goal is to simply run out the clock.
 
I don’t think bipartisanship is achievable on many of these issues at this time and I think everyone who’s paying attention knows that also. To me it seems like a waste of time to offer watered down compromises they have no intention of accepting anyway, when ultimately their goal is to simply run out the clock.

To get into a slight nuance... compromise between differing groups of people that each share a larger goal of working to improve the nation is, ideally, what bipartisanship is. That the Republican Party has been very blatantly putting party over nation for quite a fair while now pretty well negates so much of how meaningful the positives of the term even are.
 
To explain most Democrats' behavior, simply remember that they're paid by the same people who pay the Republicans.
 
To explain most Democrats' behavior, simply remember that they're paid by the same people who pay the Republicans.

Money paid by taxpayers essentially gets thrown in a big pool; we don't get to choose where our money goes once we pay our taxes. But we do get to choose where our votes go and the people voting for Democrats are most certainly not the same people who are voting for Republicans.
 
A questionable prediction.

It is, but I think there is reasonable evidence to support it.

The GOP controls the majority of state legislatures and they're moving heaven and earth to make it as difficult as possible for the *wrong* sort of people to vote. If their efforts are successful then it gets increasingly difficult for the Democratic Party candidates to get elected.

The Senate electoral map for the Democrats isn't as unfavourable as it was in 2018 and 2020, but they are defending four seats in Arizona, Georgia, New Hampshire and Nevada where there are very competitive races. It wouldn't take much bad news to tip them in the GOP's favour. Arizona and Georgia are also likely to have tough new voter ID laws in place as well.

The GOP is gearing up to allow state legislatures to overturn results where the legitimacy of the result is in doubt (i.e. where the GOP candidate did not win). In close results, this cold very well be the deciding factor.
 
Money paid by taxpayers essentially gets thrown in a big pool; we don't get to choose where our money goes once we pay our taxes. But we do get to choose where our votes go and the people voting for Democrats are most certainly not the same people who are voting for Republicans.

I think Delvo is referring to donors, not taxpayers.

The implication is that the majority of Democrats are "soft" on Republicans because they rely on, and are at the beck and call of, the same donors.
 
It is, but I think there is reasonable evidence to support it.

The GOP controls the majority of state legislatures and they're moving heaven and earth to make it as difficult as possible for the *wrong* sort of people to vote. If their efforts are successful then it gets increasingly difficult for the Democratic Party candidates to get elected.

The Senate electoral map for the Democrats isn't as unfavourable as it was in 2018 and 2020, but they are defending four seats in Arizona, Georgia, New Hampshire and Nevada where there are very competitive races. It wouldn't take much bad news to tip them in the GOP's favour. Arizona and Georgia are also likely to have tough new voter ID laws in place as well.

The GOP is gearing up to allow state legislatures to overturn results where the legitimacy of the result is in doubt (i.e. where the GOP candidate did not win). In close results, this cold very well be the deciding factor.

But...

Let's say they get rid of the filibuster, as you suggested.

Voting rights of some sort, massive jobs/infrastructure bill, wealthy people start paying more in taxes, some tax cuts from the Recovery Act stay, and that's the start.

Also, a lot of these voting restrictions get blown away (this may happen via courts regardless, but they can't even start again)

1/6 gets investigated, And Trump keeps yammering "oh no, the elections are rigged, look at me everyone, I hate republican X, I love that Greene woman, Three cheers for Gaetz!". Assuming he isn't on trial or in prison by then - the latter is very unlikely.

and unlike 2010 when (I cannot stress this enough!) moderate dems all ran away from the ACA and refused to be seen with Obama who (again I cannot stress this enough!) was opposed because the right hates black people in positions of power while younger voters insisted that Obama "didn't get medicare for all" and "didn't leave Afghanistan" (both of which he said he would not do), dems are united around a popular old Christian white guy who a great majority agrees is great. And the press seems to have noticed, *finally* that this isn't a both sides issue.

Yes, anything's possible. China could just collapse economically, and drag the US down with it. But honestly, looking at things as they are...well, there's a reason the GOP is rushing to restrict voting access, to the point of likely harming their own strongest bloc as well - elderly white people.

I'd be cautious before giving the GOP too much strength, is all.
 
Last edited:
But...

Let's say they get rid of the filibuster, as you suggested.

Voting rights of some sort, massive jobs/infrastructure bill, wealthy people start paying more in taxes, some tax cuts from the Recovery Act stay, and that's the start.

That assumes that all 50 Senators that vote with the Democratic Party (48 Democrats and 2 Independents) will vote in favour of those things. It would only take one or two Democratic Senators from more Republican leaning states to get cold feet about some of the items in any bill for it to fail.

Also, a lot of these voting restrictions get blown away (this may happen via courts regardless, but they can't even start again)

AIUI, unless a Voting Rights bill gets passed (and I think it's a big ask in the time before the 2022 elections), then the states have considerable latitude for action.

1/6 gets investigated, And Trump keeps yammering "oh no, the elections are rigged, look at me everyone, I hate republican X, I love that Greene woman, Tree cheers for Gaetz!". Assuming he isn't on trial or in prison by then - the latter is very unlikely.

and unlike 2010 when (I cannot stress this enough!) moderate dems all ran away from the ACA and refused to be seen with Obama who (again I cannot stress this enough!) was opposed because the right hates black people in positions of power while younger voters insisted that Obama "didn't get medicare for all" and "didn't leave Afghanistan" (both of which he said he would not do), dems are united around a popular old Christian white guy who a great majority agrees is great. And the press seems to have noticed, *finally* that this isn't a both sides issue.

I hope that the press have learned, but the amount of publicity that clowns like Greene and Gaetz are getting IMO shows that they haven't.

Yes, anything's possible. China could just collapse economically, and drag the US down with it. But honestly, looking at things as they are...well, there's a reason the GOP is rushing to restrict voting access, to the point of likely harming their own strongest bloc as well - elderly white people.

I'm sure that they'll find a way to allow Mee-maw and Pop-pop to vote by absentee ballot whilst restricting certain "undesirable" voters from casting their almost certainly fraudulent votes by mail. :rolleyes:

Likewise with access to cast early ballots and/or getting access to a polling station on election day.

I'd be cautious before giving the GOP too much strength, is all.

They seem to be getting very good at getting more than their share or representation.
 
Without serious change in the behavior of at least one of the parties, it won't matter a bit who wins next time, just like the most recent change in power hasn't mattered a bit. The Democrats have the ability to do what they want now, so what they're doing now demonstrates what they want: nothing at all on taxes on people who actually have money to tax, minimum wage, student debt, Medicare For All or even reduction in Medicare age limit or even any other adjustments to the ACA at all like a "public option", police reform... the infrastructure things is still continuing to fizzle away to nothing as we speak... not even the slightest peep about Israel's latest mass-murder spree, nevermind just not supporting them at it anymore... or the bigger version of the same thing by the Saudis... all while hiding behind excuses that they could change/ignore if they chose to like the filibuster and the reconciliation process & parliamentarian but are leaving propped up just to hide behind. What is there that would be any good that they're putting the slightest bit of actual effort into, either directly (actually using the powers of the offices they occupy) or even indirectly (making their cases in public and daring the opposition to oppose)? Do you want to give them credit for the apparent decrease in border-prison kids? OK, let's go with that. They've got that, and not going out of their way to deliberately make the plague worse. Wow.

Yes, if they were to start fighting for any of these things, they'd lose some (but not most) of the fights, at first... which would be when they'd just keep fighting. But they're not even trying. Just a few of them are barely even talking about maybe someday trying on just a sliver of it. This is not the behavior of people who want to do better. It's barely even the behavior of people who care whether anybody out there is somehow even tricked into thinking they want to do better. And the reason why is mentioned just a few posts above: their real bosses didn't hire them to do better and don't pay them to do better.
 
Last edited:
Without serious change in the behavior of at least one of the parties, it won't matter a bit who wins next time, just like the most recent change in power hasn't mattered a bit.

Let's just be totally clear here. It's mattered quite a lot. Has everything we think would be best for the country happened already? Of course not, but let's not pretend that there isn't a huge difference between Trump and the GOP working hard to screw things up and break the nation ever more and Biden and the Democrats not doing *enough* good fast enough, especially when taking in account their focus on addressing multiple major and countless minor emergencies largely created by and left by the GOP.
 
But...

Let's say they get rid of the filibuster, as you suggested.

Voting rights of some sort, massive jobs/infrastructure bill, wealthy people start paying more in taxes, some tax cuts from the Recovery Act stay, and that's the start.

Also, a lot of these voting restrictions get blown away (this may happen via courts regardless, but they can't even start again)

1/6 gets investigated, And Trump keeps yammering "oh no, the elections are rigged, look at me everyone, I hate republican X, I love that Greene woman, Three cheers for Gaetz!". Assuming he isn't on trial or in prison by then - the latter is very unlikely.

and unlike 2010 when (I cannot stress this enough!) moderate dems all ran away from the ACA and refused to be seen with Obama who (again I cannot stress this enough!) was opposed because the right hates black people in positions of power while younger voters insisted that Obama "didn't get medicare for all" and "didn't leave Afghanistan" (both of which he said he would not do), dems are united around a popular old Christian white guy who a great majority agrees is great. And the press seems to have noticed, *finally* that this isn't a both sides issue.

Yes, anything's possible. China could just collapse economically, and drag the US down with it. But honestly, looking at things as they are...well, there's a reason the GOP is rushing to restrict voting access, to the point of likely harming their own strongest bloc as well - elderly white people.

I'd be cautious before giving the GOP too much strength, is all.

Not to mention look what's going on in Arizona. That audit to keep Trump appeased is absolutely, insanely embarrassing. The conspiracy theorist put in charge of the "audit" needed to subcontract the actual work and the company they hired didn't renew their contract halfway through because, most likely, they're spinning around lazy susan's and have a few seconds to check each ballot for bamboo. Plus if his blog is any indication, nobody but politicians are listening to Trump these days anyway so every day of his political irrelevance makes the whole party look worse and worse.
 
That assumes that all 50 Senators that vote with the Democratic Party (48 Democrats and 2 Independents) will vote in favour of those things. It would only take one or two Democratic Senators from more Republican leaning states to get cold feet about some of the items in any bill for it to fail.

It's preferable there's one or two people can be reasoned with than none.
 
Not to mention look what's going on in Arizona. That audit to keep Trump appeased is absolutely, insanely embarrassing. The conspiracy theorist put in charge of the "audit" needed to subcontract the actual work and the company they hired didn't renew their contract halfway through because, most likely, they're spinning around lazy susan's and have a few seconds to check each ballot for bamboo. Plus if his blog is any indication, nobody but politicians are listening to Trump these days anyway so every day of his political irrelevance makes the whole party look worse and worse.

At the federal level, *if* they pass legislation (which means tossing the filibuster), I see three potential problems:

1: the courts. I've said repeatedly that John Roberts' gutting the VRA was an incredibly bad decision (even Taney figured out a way to justify the Dred Scott decision in some sort of tradition - this court is just making things up).

2: The states just outright cancelling elections. This wouldn't go well for anyone.

3: outright violence from MAGAts. Which they seem to enjoy.

Again, this isn't at all new. They've put in "managers" in the place of local governments that fail to fix anything at best (and outright poison people at worst, like in Flint MI), stripped governors and other state officials of power, and generally made it clear for decades now that they hate democracy unless it elects them.

*shrug* dunno why voters (and, really, white voters especially) haven't picked up on this yet... Granted, some people love an authoritarian that they can see as on their side, that's just how humans are, but I doubt this is some outright majority of white American voters, and them only, even looking to modern Europe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom