Mumbles
Philosopher
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2008
- Messages
- 8,726
Elsewhere... The Supreme Court made another particularly notable bad decision.
Supreme Court's conservatives deal historic blow to the Voting Rights Act's last remaining pillar
Now, instead of needing to prove pointed discriminatory effect, the bar's been moved to proving pointed discriminatory intent - aka, Republicans can just pretend to be blithering idiots to prevent brazen voter suppression laws from being struck down. They do seem to be excellent at acting as blithering idiots, regardless, though.
Expected but unhelpful - as I said, state courts will be more in play here. Note that the CRA blocks effect because this is the exact - precise - reasoning used to implement literacy tests, poll taxes, and the like "Effect" was used specifically so racist legislators couldn't come up with anything in the future. Robert is not stupid, by the way, this is what he ultimately wants to do, despite the plain words of the 15th amendment that gives this power to congress, and not to the supreme court. I'd say he wants to be remembered alongside Taney, but he's only going after the post-Reconstruction dweebs that nobody talks about, but right-thinking people despise as an idea. But like Shelby, it's ignorant, engages in fiction (in this case the "voter fraud" that has been used against black voters for well over a century, but never found.), and is plainly looking back on Jim Crow fondly.
(Kagan basically calls out Alito - who wrote the majority - on all of this)