Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
MPhil thesis on Charles Brockden Brown: American Gothic in the age of a new dawn.

After which, while working as editor at an academic publishing firm, got a National open university MA in Economics, with Statistics and Indian History as minors.

Quite the underachiever, aren't ya? :p
 
Tell me about it...my parents still think I wasted my life by not "become an Engineer or a Doctor like Mr. Sharma's good little kids."

I had a good friend, recently passed away, who came from India to the US when he was three years old. He earned a Ph.D in Petrochemical Engineering from Rice University which is a very highly regarded university. His parents never got over him not becoming a 'real' doctor...although his son did and is now in medical research. He was one of the nicest guys I've ever known.
 
Michel H, you really need to read up on International Economics and how National budgets work. There is distinct evidence of the lack of fundamental knowledge of the subject in your posts.
This is more a personal attack than an actual argument.
 
Again, you're trying to equate modern nation-state financing to a household or personal budget.

By your definition of "broke" nearly every country* on earth is too. In addition to almost every major corporation.

* the bulk of exceptions being those who have large reserves of mineral wealth they exploit. Despite their admirable balance sheet, they all seem to have appalling standards of living, however and I doubt very seriously you would want to live in any of them.
Do you remember the 2007-2008 financial crisis? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_crisis_of_2007-2008).

With the bankruptcy of the Lehman Brothers bank, it was quite severe.

If the U.S. debt-ceiling limit is not raised in time, we could perhaps see a crisis which is even worse (while it is true that I am not an economist).

It is true that it has become very common for states to borrow money and to have large national debts, but I think that this is not an entirely healthy policy, it generates risks of default, it encourages laziness.

With the kind of approval ratings that he has now, Biden should not think he is God, and should (in my humble opinion) make concessions, not only to his fellow Democrats, but also to Republicans that he has long frequented as a senator.
 
"You noticed I have a pattern" is not a personal attack.

Being told you are wrong is not a personal attack.

Being told you are wrong AND have an obvious ulterior motive is not a personal attack.

"Personal Attack" does not equal "Negative comment of a personal nature."
 
These are arguments ...

But America is broke, and debt default is threatening.

.

America is not "broke" in any way. In fact, America could pay off the entire debt any time it wanted it. All it has to do is print the money to do it.

Now, you could argue (correctly) that this would lead to an economic disaster, and you would be exactly right. Which is why the US doesn't do that.

There is a balance between printing new money and borrowing. The risk of printing money is inflation. The risk of borrowing is out of control interest rates. But so far, that's not a problem. Interest rates are very low, so it's better for the government to keep borrowing.

It's not broke, it just chooses to borrow money because it's better fiscal policy.
 
Do you remember the 2007-2008 financial crisis? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_crisis_of_2007-2008).



With the bankruptcy of the Lehman Brothers bank, it was quite severe.



If the U.S. debt-ceiling limit is not raised in time, we could perhaps see a crisis which is even worse (while it is true that I am not an economist).



It is true that it has become very common for states to borrow money and to have large national debts, but I think that this is not an entirely healthy policy, it generates risks of default, it encourages laziness.



With the kind of approval ratings that he has now, Biden should not think he is God, and should (in my humble opinion) make concessions, not only to his fellow Democrats, but also to Republicans that he has long frequented as a senator.

Concessions have already been made. Repeatedly.

What concessions have the Republicans (and 2 Democratic Senators) made?

ETA: Lehman Brothers is yet another entirely different matter. They overexposed themselves to underperforming assets and got caught holding the bag when the music stopped (terrible mixed metaphor, but whatevs).
 
Last edited:
Trump didn't have a $2 trillion plan to rebuild infrastructure (https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/31/business/economy/biden-infrastructure-plan.html). His wall, though perhaps absurd, didn't cost 2 trillion dollars (it was cheaper).
Trump's Wall was cheaper than Biden's infrastructure plan, but it was also almost completely useless.

On the other hand, the infrastructure plan will have some direct benefits that will be felt all across the U.S.... better roads/bridges, support for new industries, etc.

Given a choice, I think a billion dollars wasted on a useless wall is a bigger problem than a trillion dollars spent for something that might actually be useful.
 
Concessions have already been made. Repeatedly.

What concessions have the Republicans (and 2 Democratic Senators) made?
ETA: Lehman Brothers is yet another entirely different matter. They overexposed themselves to underperforming assets and got caught holding the bag when the music stopped (terrible mixed metaphor, but whatevs).

Well, Susan Collins has suggested (Yahoo News) that some in the GOP might be willing to vote to raise the debt limit to help pay for the debts incurred as a result of their own past programs if the Dems are willing to forego their own present and future programs. Yes, their "concession" is that they won't wreck the economy as long as Democrats don't get all uppity and act like they won that last election. That's fair, right?
 
Last edited:
Trump's Wall was cheaper than Biden's infrastructure plan, but it was also almost completely useless.

On the other hand, the infrastructure plan will have some direct benefits that will be felt all across the U.S.... better roads/bridges, support for new industries, etc.

Given a choice, I think a billion dollars wasted on a useless wall is a bigger problem than a trillion dollars spent for something that might actually be useful.

To delve a little deeper into the wall bit, there's also efficiency of use to consider. Walls already existed at the places on the border where they would be most useful, so the issue of greatly diminishing returns on further investment is already in play there. Also, there are dramatically more efficient alternatives for dealing with the unwalled portion. Surveillance drones, in particular, can do just as useful a job or better for a tiny fraction of the cost, initial and ongoing (and manpower, really). The only possible advantage of a full wall would be as a symbolic deterrent, and there's little to no reason to believe that that would actually help the situation in the first place when there are already plenty of quite serious deterrents in play. On the flip side of that, the focus on the wall completely directed Republican time and resources away from, for example, the already existing official points of entry, where the really overwhelming portion of the issues that they claimed to seek to address with the wall were actually happening.

In short, the wall had nothing to do with good governing and everything to do with being a cynical political strategy.

That's nearly the opposite of Biden's infrastructure plan, which is pretty much all about good governance.
 
Last edited:
Trump didn't have a $2 trillion plan to rebuild infrastructure (https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/31/business/economy/biden-infrastructure-plan.html). His wall, though perhaps absurd, didn't cost 2 trillion dollars (it was cheaper).

Biden, though probably more humane and rational, thinks perhaps he is the "Napoleon of infrastructure".



The only reason the US needs (note, needs, not "wants") a $2 Trillion infrastructure plan now is because of decades of Republicans refusing to allocate any money to infrastructure when they were in charge, and then whining about how the Democrats were "wasting money" any time the Democrats tried to deal with the situation while the Democrats were in power.

At some point, you either pay the ******* money to rebuild some ****, or you just accept that every bridge and dam in the country is going to just fall over.

It's well past the time someone stood up and told the whiners that it's time to spend this money. It will only get even more expensive the longer you wait.
 
Or just mint a handful of those 1 trillion dollar coins some have been discussing!

https://www.axios.com/trillion-doll...len-223e7722-d7ba-47c9-b5f6-49a841d181de.html

Or mint a single Triganic Pu.

The Triganic Pu is a unit of galactic currency, with an exchange rate of eight Ningis to one Pu. This is simple enough, but, since a Ningi is a triangular rubber coin six thousand eight hundred miles along each side, no one has ever collected enough to own one Pu.
 
America is not "broke" in any way. In fact, America could pay off the entire debt any time it wanted it. All it has to do is print the money to do it.

This isn't the standard of how to determine if America is "broke". Here is the real standard:

Democrat in the White House = America is "broke".

Republican in White House = don't even mention the debt or deficit....
 
This isn't the standard of how to determine if America is "broke". Here is the real standard:

Democrat in the White House = America is "broke".

Republican in White House = don't even mention the debt or deficit....

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jude_Wanniski

The Two Santa Claus Theory
The Two Santa Claus Theory is a political theory and strategy published by Wanniski in 1976, which he promoted within the United States Republican Party.[15][16] The theory states that in democratic elections, if Democrats appeal to voters by proposing programs to help people, then the Republicans cannot gain broader appeal by proposing less spending. The first "Santa Claus" of the theory title refers to the Democrats who promise programs to help the disadvantaged. The "Two Santa Claus Theory" recommends that the Republicans must assume the role of a second Santa Claus by not arguing to cut spending but offering the option of cutting taxes.[citation needed]

According to Wanniski, the theory is simple. In 1976, he wrote that the Two-Santa Claus Theory suggests that "the Republicans should concentrate on tax-rate reduction. As they succeed in expanding incentives to produce, they will move the economy back to full employment and thereby reduce social pressures for public spending. Just as an increase in Government spending inevitably means taxes must be raised, a cut in tax rates—by expanding the private sector—will diminish the relative size of the public sector."[16] Wanniski suggested this position, as Thom Hartmann has clarified, so that the Democrats would "have to be anti-Santas by raising taxes, or anti-Santas by cutting spending. Either one would lose them elections."[17]
 
Tax cuts (especially weighted towards the top) do not increase economic activity enough to pay for themselves.

The two most stimulative forms of government expenditure are food stamps and unemployment assistance.

Putting money in the hands of people who have none means immediate purchase of basic necessities. Groceries are purchased, utility bills are paid, etc. Those businesses then pay their workers, replenish supplies, consume services to maintain operations, etc.

Each transaction is taxed some and the government recovers the outlay within a 3-6 month window. Lather, rinse, repeat.

Put $100 in a poor person's hands and it will be cycling through the economy within days. Give a rich person $100, they increase their investment portfolio and expect to extract yet more wealth out of the real economy. How many times have we seen corporations take subsidies meant to spur job growth and instead use it for stock buybacks to prop up their share price and then the board gives itself a big bonus?
 
Or mint a single Triganic Pu.

The Triganic Pu is a unit of galactic currency, with an exchange rate of eight Ningis to one Pu. This is simple enough, but, since a Ningi is a triangular rubber coin six thousand eight hundred miles along each side, no one has ever collected enough to own one Pu.

Hitchhiker’s Guide?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom