Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
You do get that "infrastructure plan" means jobs are created, therefore people have money to spend on goods, and thus improves our economy, right?
Yes, but you have to pay the salaries of all these workers.

Do you launch an ambitious modernization plan when you are still a feeble man (or woman), in a process of recovering?
 
Yes, but you have to pay the salaries of all these workers.

Do you launch an ambitious modernization plan when you are still a feeble man (or woman), in a process of recovering?

You do when the same people are the reason the man is having such a hard time recovering.

Your "sick man" metaphor is dishonestly wrong.
 
Okay. Why is this a problem now and now a year ago when Trump was President?
It seems to be more a problem now, since:
Biden warns ‘meteor headed to crash’ into US economy amid debt struggle
(https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/oct/04/joe-biden-debt-limit-republicans-democrats).

Trump didn't have a $2 trillion plan to rebuild infrastructure (https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/31/business/economy/biden-infrastructure-plan.html). His wall, though perhaps absurd, didn't cost 2 trillion dollars (it was cheaper).

Biden, though probably more humane and rational, thinks perhaps he is the "Napoleon of infrastructure".
 
You do when the same people are the reason the man is having such a hard time recovering.

Your "sick man" metaphor is dishonestly wrong.

Yes, but you have to pay the salaries of all these workers.

Do you launch an ambitious modernization plan when you are still a feeble man (or woman), in a process of recovering?
Yes. This is exactly the time to launch federal programs. See for example:


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Conservation_Corps
 
No, don't. Economics, the Dismal Science, is the same anywhere you go. I for one value your input.

American politics? Hey, jump right in. You wouldn't learn anything special by visiting the US.

Some of the dumbest and worst-informed opinions on America are held -- and bellowed -- by native-born Murricans. Well hell, that's old stuff right there.

:thumbsup::thumbsup:
 
Thank you. Well work done decades ago towards an MPhil degree in English with a thesis on early postcolonial American fiction from a Marxian critical perspective and a demanding supervisor who was in the midst of it during the Kent State shoot out helped.

Say wot? :p
 
You are really demonizing the Republican party here.

You would do that with Trump, I would (perhaps) say ok ...

But the whole Republican party?

Really no decent people there?

When I speak of the Republicans, I'm speaking about those in power right now: the extreme right wing Trumpist Congressmembers and those who put their personal agenda before the good of the country like McConnell.

There are plenty of decent and honest Republicans but I fear they have been drowned out and disempowered by those I describe above.
 
Is there like a newsletter that goes out that tells people what to talk about when they want to avoid the subject?

We're already got a "Oh so you're saying just because people vote for Republicans they hold Republican opinions" thread going on.
 
The U.S. National debt is about 130% of GDP now, and has increased fast recently, which means that the U.S. is paying their bills more and more by borrowing Chinese money, see this webpage: https://www.statista.com/statistics...us-in-relation-to-gross-domestic-product-gdp/.



This seems especially dangerous (though I am not an economist) because of the threat of debt default:



(https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/oct/04/joe-biden-debt-limit-republicans-democrats).
The default wouldn't be because of inability to maintain revolving debt agreements, but because we made a rule saying we wouldn't beyond a certain point.

That's a strange definition of being "broke."
 
Yes, but you have to pay the salaries of all these workers.



Do you launch an ambitious modernization plan when you are still a feeble man (or woman), in a process of recovering?
Yes, that's exactly when "you" (the government) do so. Businesses can't (and won't) just decide to build public works.

We've gone entirely backwards for decades. Spending when the economy is hot (and the price of things is high) and belt-tightening when it slows down (when things are cheap and when that belt tightening exacerbates the slowdown even more).

Government should save up during the boom and spend on the dips. It is both cost-efficient and mitigates the recessions.

The government is the only entity that can swim against the current in such a fashion, as profit seeking entities can't justify it (or stay in business long).

Public spending is not properly compared to business or household/individual budgeting.
 
The default wouldn't be because of inability to maintain revolving debt agreements, but because we made a rule saying we wouldn't beyond a certain point.

That's a strange definition of being "broke."
Even if you can find bankers who are willing to lend money to you, this doesn't mean you aren't broke.

This may give you a delusion of infinite wealth and power, but it is just a delusion.

What is really typical of broke people is that they borrow a lot (and perhaps more and more).

Having said this, the U.S. is clearly not the poorest in the world (far from it).

But wanting to borrow more and more to finance grandiose projects may not be the right thing to do when your country is still a half-sick man.

To me, it doesn't seem difficult to say "instead of spending 2 trillion on infrastructure, and I am clearly going into the wall, I am going to spend just one trillion."
 
Last edited:
I've been saying for years now how if we really want to fix and build our infrastructure and create new jobs and opportunities, we need a new CCC.

It was one of the most successful aspects of the New Deal, and we could really use it today.

I've also thought that. But you know the opposition: commiesocialistlibtards!!

Conservatives were also against the CCC and other New Deal projects in the 30's. Go figure. But, man, they do love those tax cuts for corporations and the wealthy!
 
Even if you can find bankers who are willing to lend money to you, this doesn't mean you aren't broke.

This may give you a delusion of infinite wealth and power, but it is just a delusion.

What is really typical of broke people is that they borrow a lot (and perhaps more and more).

Having said this, the U.S. is clearly not the poorest in the world (far from it).

But wanting to borrow more and more to finance grandiose projects may not be the right thing to do when your country is still a half-sick man.

To me, it doesn't seem difficult to say "instead of spending 2 trillion on infrastructure, and I am clearly going into the wall, I am going to spend just one trillion."

Biden and the Dems are compromising:

Democrats have a new deadline to enact President Joe Biden’s economic agenda.

The party will try to pass both a bipartisan infrastructure bill and a broader investment in social programs by the end of October, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., told his caucus in a letter Monday. The party aims to approve the plans before the Oct. 31 expiration of major transportation funding programs, which the infrastructure legislation would renew.

To pass what they bill as a transformative investment in the social safety net and climate policy, Democrats will have to satisfy progressives who thought an initial $3.5 trillion price tag was too small and at least one centrist who wants to spend no more than $1.5 trillion. Negotiations around the plan, which kicked into high gear last week, would have to yield a breakthrough in the coming days for Congress to write and pass a bill in time.

“Not every member will get everything he or she wanted,” Schumer wrote to Senate Democrats. “But at the end of the day, we will pass legislation that will dramatically improve the lives of the American people. I believe we are going to do just that in the month of October.”

The Senate leader said he wanted to reach a final deal “within a matter of days, not weeks.”
https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/04/sch...cture-build-back-better-plans-in-october.html
 
These are arguments ...

But America is broke,

It doesn't really work that way. Going past that, though, there's the issue of where that money's going, though. Investment versus exploitation. Democrats are trying to do the former, which has quite the history of paying itself off with interest. Republicans keep trying to do the latter, which has quite the history of not paying off very well at all.

and debt default is threatening.

May as well point directly at the Republicans for that.

But, don't you think it may be wise and justified for some Republicans to be concerned about big spending, big deficits and big debt?

It can be! Not just Republicans, of course. Responsible spending should be an important thing across the political spectrum. Not just with the totals, of course. Establishing oversight on the distribution of large amounts of funds to ensure that they're being used properly is something that should be standard and normal. Unfortunately, as we've seen yet again in recent times, Republicans are firmly opposed to such (when they're in charge, at least), which led to a LOT of misuse and exactly the kinds of bad things that they rail against. Democrats, on the other hand, are more likely to overdo it on that front than neglect it. As a general rule, though, Democrats have been much more responsible on budget issues than Republicans, though Republicans do a much better job with messaging (and that's not hurt by how shameless they're willing to be).

In a democracy, shouldn't they be listened to, with their opinions taken into account, rather than be treated with contempt?

Sure! It's just when they've made it perfectly obvious that they're not offering opinions on the topic in good faith, that is what earns them that contempt.

You are really demonizing the Republican party here.

You would do that with Trump, I would (perhaps) say ok ...

But the whole Republican party?

Really no decent people there?

The whole Republican party? If you're including the average voter registered as Republican, there are certainly are plenty of more honest people there desire for the Republican Party to work in the best interests of the US. However, Republican politicians and propagandists far too commonly ignore most of the opinions of the voters, though, in favor of their special interest masters, as well as employ tactics that are directly harmful to the US in a myriad of ways as they work to secure and gain more power. Feel free to look back just a few months to that utter farce that was far too many of them refusing to acknowledge Biden's win, despite knowing plenty well that Biden won fair and square.
 
Last edited:
Even if you can find bankers who are willing to lend money to you, this doesn't mean you aren't broke.

This may give you a delusion of infinite wealth and power, but it is just a delusion.

What is really typical of broke people is that they borrow a lot (and perhaps more and more).

Having said this, the U.S. is clearly not the poorest in the world (far from it).

But wanting to borrow more and more to finance grandiose projects may not be the right thing to do when your country is still a half-sick man.

To me, it doesn't seem difficult to say "instead of spending 2 trillion on infrastructure, and I am clearly going into the wall, I am going to spend just one trillion."
Again, you're trying to equate modern nation-state financing to a household or personal budget.

By your definition of "broke" nearly every country* on earth is too. In addition to almost every major corporation.

* the bulk of exceptions being those who have large reserves of mineral wealth they exploit. Despite their admirable balance sheet, they all seem to have appalling standards of living, however and I doubt very seriously you would want to live in any of them.
 
Last edited:
The default wouldn't be because of inability to maintain revolving debt agreements, but because we made a rule saying we wouldn't beyond a certain point.

That's a strange definition of being "broke."


Broke? America would have to come up with something north of twenty trillion dollars to work our way back up to just "broke".
 
Michel H, you really need to read up on International Economics and how National budgets work. There is distinct evidence of the lack of fundamental knowledge of the subject in your posts.
 

MPhil thesis on Charles Brockden Brown: American Gothic in the age of a new dawn.

After which, while working as editor at an academic publishing firm, got a National open university MA in Economics, with Statistics and Indian History as minors.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom