The ballad of the 911 shill

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here's an older Cardington study as well: http://www.mace.manchester.ac.uk/pr...gton_NaturalFiresLargeScaleCompartments94.pdf

In a much, much smaller fire environment than wtc 7, protected beams reached 750C in this test (See F47). Tony wants everyone to believe that an extra 100 C was impossible in a much larger building. There is also no support for Korol's use of a 25 min-only time frame to heat the elements.

I haven't been very closely involved in much of the engineering talk on this, as most it happened years before I looked at the internet. I do have basic understanding of engineering and thermodynamics.
Could you explain what is the significance of 850°C? Is that the temperature point that the beams are supposed to fail under their load?
 
I haven't been very closely involved in much of the engineering talk on this, as most it happened years before I looked at the internet. I do have basic understanding of engineering and thermodynamics.
Could you explain what is the significance of 850°C? Is that the temperature point that the beams are supposed to fail under their load?

The relevance of the 850 C to this discussion is because it was the max temperature reached by a beam in a fire simulation done by Dr. Craig Beyler in support of the Weidlinger Associates' expert report on the collapse of WTC 7, which was prepared by them in connection with the Aegis Insurance litigation. You can find that full report here: http://www.thorntontomasetti.com/projects/world_trade_center_7_collapse_investigation/

The report is significant as it has received professional accolades and it specifically corrects for a number of issues that truthers, such as Tony, have claimed were fatal to NIST's analyses. Yet, even after correcting for those issues, WAI still concluded that fires brought down the building.

In order to escape having to accept this reality, Tony has been looking for a reason to dismiss that conclusion. The one he has latched onto is a claim that the temperatures the beams reached in the simulation were unreachable. Of course, he has no actual basis for saying so, as he has demonstrated in three separate threads on this site. Now he's reduced to simply lying about the results of the well-known Cardington studies. Curious and sad behavior for a grown man.
 
The relevance of the 850 C to this discussion is because it was the max temperature reached by a beam in a fire simulation done by Dr. Craig Beyler in support of the Weidlinger Associates' expert report on the collapse of WTC 7, which was prepared by them in connection with the Aegis Insurance litigation. You can find that full report here: http://www.thorntontomasetti.com/projects/world_trade_center_7_collapse_investigation/

The report is significant as it has received professional accolades and it specifically corrects for a number of issues that truthers, such as Tony, have claimed were fatal to NIST's analyses. Yet, even after correcting for those issues, WAI still concluded that fires brought down the building.

In order to escape having to accept this reality, Tony has been looking for a reason to dismiss that conclusion. The one he has latched onto is a claim that the temperatures the beams reached in the simulation were unreachable. Of course, he has no actual basis for saying so, as he has demonstrated in three separate threads on this site. Now he's reduced to simply lying about the results of the well-known Cardington studies. Curious and sad behavior for a grown man.

Thanks for the detailed reply. I really don't want to read the reports. I was convinced when I watched it all happen on tv 15 years ago.

So the OP's argument isn't about stress point failures due to prolonged exposure to extreme heat? It isn't about load calculations. It's just "neener, neener, THEY can't replicate their experiment!, Conspiracy!... "??

ETA
I've always assumed that the gases created by all the burning synthetics, glasses, precious metals, chemicals, etc, etc, not to mention jet fuel, would have had some effects that can't be replicated in a scaled down test. Obviously the compartmentalized construction will help with combustion and heat retention.

As I said, a basic understanding of the situation. I don't see how anyone gets to the point of thermite, CD, wtfever. You need to ignore a lot of stuff.

Two 767's is a much stronger hand than nanonukes.
 
Last edited:
Ah, the "shill" accusation.

Simultaneously admitting narcissm (for being a free thinker and not being a "sheep") yet contradicting oneself (by being free to not believe in the "shills"s brainwashing).
 
Pathetic. Own up to your lies. Where's the 25 min time frame come from, Tony? Why are you misleading people with blatant falsehoods and garbage papers if you think that society depends on correct information and you see it as your personal mission to help society receive such information?

Thousands of experimental papers, prove exactly why Tony is wrong.
https://www.dieselnet.com/tech/dpf_regen.php

Soot will combust totally at 600C generating 1400C against any hot surface.
 
800 degree C gas temperatures won't be heating steel to 850 degrees C. They will be cooling it. You need gas temperatures much hotter. The heat flow rate is also dependent on the delta T.

You and Benthamitemetric apparently don't know much about heat transfer.

Well, the steel begins at room temp, approx 20C so the compartment gas temp is heating the steel the entire time that has temps are rising. It continues to heat as long as steel temp is less than gas temp. Gas temp is above 850 right through to what, about, the 75 - 80 minute mark.

Soooo, the steel is being heated for 75 - 80 minutes, of which approx 35 - 40 the gas temp is above 850C.

ETA: in WTC 7 the 7th through 13th floor were at room temp of 20C when the fires began over on the south side. Parts of the north side ambient temp on these floors could easily reach 80 - 100 C well before any north side compartment was on fire.
At no point were 850C, or above, gases transfering heat to a 20C steel structural member.

So, please answer the simple question, where does the 25 minute heating time frame come from?
 
Last edited:
Thousands of experimental papers, prove exactly why Tony is wrong.
https://www.dieselnet.com/tech/dpf_regen.php

Soot will combust totally at 600C generating 1400C against any hot surface.

IIRC a "clean burn" a location on a surface where soot has burned off.

Wood stove chimneys must withstand 1000C for an hour without burn through not because wood fires burn at 1000C, but because soot and creosote condense on the inner chimney surface when it is cold, and can build up. Later if the chimney gets hot enough to ignite this condensate it can easily reach 1000C. It is recommended, and in some jurisdictions mandatory, to replace insulated chimney after any chimney fire.
 
800 degree C gas temperatures won't be heating steel to 850 degrees C. They will be cooling it. You need gas temperatures much hotter. The heat flow rate is also dependent on the delta T.

You and Benthamitemetric apparently don't know much about heat transfer.

Educate me on heat transfer, Tony.

In the attached graphs, taken directly from the Cardington Study (pg. 41), for how many minutes is heat being transferred to the beam?
 

Attachments

  • Cardington Beam Temp.jpg
    Cardington Beam Temp.jpg
    20.7 KB · Views: 14
Last edited:
IIRC a "clean burn" a location on a surface where soot has burned off.

Wood stove chimneys must withstand 1000C for an hour without burn through not because wood fires burn at 1000C, but because soot and creosote condense on the inner chimney surface when it is cold, and can build up. Later if the chimney gets hot enough to ignite this condensate it can easily reach 1000C. It is recommended, and in some jurisdictions mandatory, to replace insulated chimney after any chimney fire.

True but wood stoves have restricted inlets that's why they seldom ever get over 1000C,
Now imagine an unrestricted air flow into the stack effect, temperatures can easily reach 1400C.
 
True but wood stoves have restricted inlets that's why they seldom ever get over 1000C,
Now imagine an unrestricted air flow into the stack effect, temperatures can easily reach 1400C.
The wood stove might reach 1000C and so might the lower end of the stovepipe, but the insulated chimney extending through the ceiling and roof shouldn't.

Yes, one instruction to homeowners experiencing a chimney fire ( sound is a loud roaring from the stove pipe, loud pinging from steel stove, stovepipe that begins glowing red, room temp spikes up to sauna temps and above) is to fully close all dampers.
One person described having done so and noting a high pitched whistle from the damper and door seal as the draft sucked air througn any small gap.
 
Oooh - I like having people who know what they are talking about ....

...on issues where I haven't a bleeding clue. :blush:

Soot is a refined fuel, all it needs is oxygen, and temperature to ignite it and because it is converted almost directly to CO2, it can burn at a higher temperature than fuels where heat energy is lost to pyrosis.

This is why Cole's experiment could not have produced reduced sulfur and why Tony does not understand complex fire events.

Their Ideas about fires are way to simplistic to be valid, the only question is, is it simply lack of knowledge, or is it by design?
 
A weak attack on reality, reason, and evidence. ich bin a shill in Tony's Fantasy CD

I thought people here might have something to say about this

The ballad of the 911 shill

I help to keep the masses in the dark.
The way I do it is mostly with snark.
To keep the masses as sheep they must not know
how they are moved to and fro.
We are the ones who can proudly say
we perform this mission to minimize the fray.

the ballad of the paranoid conspiracy theorist who thinks everyone who knows fire did it are shills - paranoid

You are spreading a lie of CD, mocking the murder of thousands with nonsense. 9/11 truth followers claim everyone who disagrees with the lie of CD are shills and they are super patriots, but the evidence free CD fantasy makes that a delusion.

99.9 percent of all engineers are shills? 9/11 truth has the signatures of less than 0.1 percent of all engineers... you lost this one because you have no evidence.
 
Last edited:
The wood stove might reach 1000C and so might the lower end of the stovepipe, but the insulated chimney extending through the ceiling and roof shouldn't.

Yes, one instruction to homeowners experiencing a chimney fire ( sound is a loud roaring from the stove pipe, loud pinging from steel stove, stovepipe that begins glowing red, room temp spikes up to sauna temps and above) is to fully close all dampers.
One person described having done so and noting a high pitched whistle from the damper and door seal as the draft sucked air througn any small gap.

I heat with wood, and have experienced a chimney fire, I used water to put it out.
Instant water to steam conversion, cools the fire and slows the draft though the Chimney.
 
I found two very good fire science papers (peer reviewed and published and all that), each of which contains a substantial literature review section that is helpful for navigating the world of fire experiment studies:

http://www.iafss.org/publications/fss/11/28/view/fss_11-28.pdf
http://www.research.ed.ac.uk/portal/files/11824750/Bisby1.pdf

Page 10 of the pdf of the second paper is particularly helpful for seeing how Tony and Korol are completely off base with their ridiculous 25 min magical teleporting fire heating model.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom