The 84% Myth

There's a good chance this has been covered before, but I've seen a handful of people who aren't exactly sure why the "84% of Americans are Truthers" claim is a complete sham.

The claim originates from Alex Jones' website, on which is an article titled "Scientific Poll: 84% Reject Official 9/11 Story".

Now, here's the kicker: He links to the source of his numbers, which, when examined (not even closely) completely turns the claim on it's head.

Here's the actual question and results (source, linked to from Jones' own site):


Firstly, the question isn't even about the official account of events on September 11th. It's about what the government knew or didn't know prior to September 11th. He says it, but glosses over it.

Secondly, as anyone can see, Jones completely misrepresents the results of this poll. He shoehorns the "mostly telling the truth, but hiding something" and "Not sure" answers into "rejects the official account", where "Mostly lying" is the only answer that's even remotely relevant to his claim (keeping in mind, again, that this is about the government's statements of pre-9/11 knowledge and not the events on 9/11).

I can't even begin to believe that this could be an "honest mistake" (and one that hasn't been retracted in the 3 months since its posting). This was a deliberately constructed deception by Jones.

That it's so easily debunked is what makes this mind-boggling to me. Even worse is that people actually still believe it...


Actually that poll was one of the first things posted in the comment-section when I upped the Screw 911 Mysteries torrent:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2270949&postcount=92

I've come across that poll numerous times often together with the poll that shows that "45% of the US population blames the Bush administration for the 911-attack" - which incidently wasn't at all what the poll in question showed (It was about wether or not the US pop think that the Bush and the Clinton admininstration did enough to prevent them. And it acutally shows a slight increase since 2002 in how many think the government can prevent a future attack).

www.savethemales.ca said:
Americans Blame Bush for 9-11 Attacks
WASHINGTON (CNN) -- The percentage of Americans who blame the Bush administration for the September 11, 2001, attacks on New York and Washington has risen from almost a third to almost half over the past four years, a CNN poll released Monday found.
Cheers,
SLOB
 
Last edited:
What's a guy from Lubbock doing with water in his avatar?
It's not August!
Lubbock is pronounced Lu-bick, for non-West Texans out there, and it's primary import is dust.

Hey, a guy can dream can't he?

And we don't import dust, we grow it nice and fresh right here!
 
And, really, is 983 of 300 million (or 0.000327%) people representative?
 
Last edited:
And, really, is 983 of 300 million (or 0.000327%) people representative?


I think that is why the margin of error is +/- 4%.

It's interesting that only about 6% actually believe the CTs when you get specific.

I recall reading somewhere that in random polling, regardless of the question at hand, any answer will always get about 7%. In other words, 7% = zero.

So for example, if you polled "Are you a big freaky weirdo alien bug man?" at least 7% of respondants would answer "Yes, I am".

So really, if 6% of Americans believe in the CD theory, that means, correcting for the smart-a** factor, that actually -1% of Americans believe it. ;)

-Gumboot
 
I recall reading somewhere that in random polling, regardless of the question at hand, any answer will always get about 7%. In other words, 7% = zero.

So for example, if you polled "Are you a big freaky weirdo alien bug man?" at least 7% of respondants would answer "Yes, I am".

-Gumboot

:eye-poppi

What the? How?
 
The correct way to size up a sample is science in itself:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sampling_(statistics)


and you cant really judge a sample if the only information, as in this case is "conducted by telephone with 983 American adults". Lets say all those 983 adults lived at (this is an extreme example) a military base. Or if you called at the same time a day, only reaching those at home. 983 adults sounds like a very small sample though (and why did they pic just 983? Why not 1000? My guess is they did pick 1000 but could only reach 983 which in itself poses a problem) if it is to represent the entire US population.

Cheers,
SLOB
 

Ooooh, that is just too funny! Considering there are about a million geese that frequent this city, I find it hard to believe someone actually thought that was a picture of UFO's...

Did they leave a name or address? It think it's time to pull a dogbert and increase my savings. :D
 
Whilst I was born in the Grating State of Texas, I ave always felt that "True Texan" was a state of mind, rather than an accident of birth...

I misread this as "accident of girth" when I glanced at it. Pity, it's kind of funny that way.
 
I recall reading somewhere that in random polling, regardless of the question at hand, any answer will always get about 7%. In other words, 7% = zero.

So for example, if you polled "Are you a big freaky weirdo alien bug man?" at least 7% of respondants would answer "Yes, I am".

-Gumboot

:eye-poppi

What the? How?

There are some individuals out there who consider it their patriotic duty to screw up marketing polls and the like by giving the wrong answers. For instance, I make over $1million per year, have 16 kids, and live alone in 3 houses :)
 
There are some individuals out there who consider it their patriotic duty to screw up marketing polls and the like by giving the wrong answers. For instance, I make over $1million per year, have 16 kids, and live alone in 3 houses :)

Do each of the houses have a 17' concrete core?

I thought so.

Inside Job. :rolleyes:
 
So really, if 6% of Americans believe in the CD theory, that means, correcting for the smart-a** factor, that actually -1% of Americans believe it. ;)

-Gumboot
correcting for the +/-4% anywhere from -5% to 3% believe it
 
Smalle when you say that, Podner!

Whilst I was born in the Grating State of Texas, I ave always felt that "True Texan" was a state of mind, rather than an accident of birth...

So bush can be a true Texan in spite of being born in New Haven Connecticut? Are we inventing a True Texan fallacy?
 
There's a good chance this has been covered before, but I've seen a handful of people who aren't exactly sure why the "84% of Americans are Truthers" claim is a complete sham.

Something I noticed.
Alex jones claims that 84% are Truthers. Basically, 84% believes the government is lying.
I may have found out how he arrived at that "stunning" conclusion.
Keeping out the people who voted "is telling the truth"...when you add the other three together you get 84%. In his mind, people who are fence-sitters, are Truthers.
I am not saying he DID this maths, but when you know how Alex Jones works...it's not very hard to imagine
 
Something I noticed.
Alex jones claims that 84% are Truthers. Basically, 84% believes the government is lying.
I may have found out how he arrived at that "stunning" conclusion.
Keeping out the people who voted "is telling the truth"...when you add the other three together you get 84%. In his mind, people who are fence-sitters, are Truthers.
I am not saying he DID this maths, but when you know how Alex Jones works...it's not very hard to imagine
thats pretty much it, 16% thinks the govt is telling the truth, so the other 84% must think they are lying

when you deal with truthers a lot you realize most of the see only black and white, no shades of gray, if yo think they are telling the truth you must always think they tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, if you think they are lying they must be incapable of EVER telling the truth

just look at the some of the dicussions here that delve into the political, truthers are dumfounded by people who dont like bush but dont think he orchestrated 9/11, in their minds such an opinion cannot exist
 
I conjecture that the habit of banning those who disagree with the 'movement' on 911 truther forums has greatly contributed to the leveling off and susequent decline.

To a new poster it becomes apparent quickly that dissent is heavily discouraged and that many dissenters get banned for little other reason other than they are not following the doctrine of the truth movement. That plus infighting among 'truthers' make most people move on. Others who persist get banned.

This means that the forums are populated mostly by like minded persons. Discussion will then slow since there is little new to discuss in such a narrow feild. That makes many drift away. Soon one gets to a situation suchas at P4T that is pretty much stagnant. When a new poster does come on he/she is pounced on and either is welcomed or quickly banned.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom