The 84% Myth

Cl1mh4224rd

Philosopher
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
9,778
There's a good chance this has been covered before, but I've seen a handful of people who aren't exactly sure why the "84% of Americans are Truthers" claim is a complete sham.

The claim originates from Alex Jones' website, on which is an article titled "Scientific Poll: 84% Reject Official 9/11 Story".

Now, here's the kicker: He links to the source of his numbers, which, when examined (not even closely) completely turns the claim on it's head.

Here's the actual question and results (source, linked to from Jones' own site):

When it comes to what they knew prior to September 11th, 2001, about possible terrorist attacks against the United States, do you think members of the Bush Administration are telling the truth, are mostly telling the truth but hiding something, or are they mostly lying?

Telling the truth|16%
Hiding something|53%
Mostly lying|28%
Not sure|3%

Methodology: Telephone interviews with 983 American adults, conducted from Oct. 5 to Oct. 8, 2006. Margin of error is 4 per cent.
Firstly, the question isn't even about the official account of events on September 11th. It's about what the government knew or didn't know prior to September 11th. He says it, but glosses over it.

Secondly, as anyone can see, Jones completely misrepresents the results of this poll. He shoehorns the "mostly telling the truth, but hiding something" and "Not sure" answers into "rejects the official account", where "Mostly lying" is the only answer that's even remotely relevant to his claim (keeping in mind, again, that this is about the government's statements of pre-9/11 knowledge and not the events on 9/11).

I can't even begin to believe that this could be an "honest mistake" (and one that hasn't been retracted in the 3 months since its posting). This was a deliberately constructed deception by Jones.

That it's so easily debunked is what makes this mind-boggling to me. Even worse is that people actually still believe it...
 
Last edited:
My personal fave, via Scripps Howard.

Question/VAR 28:

The Pentagon was not struck by an airliner captured by terrorists but, instead was hit by a cruise missle fired by the U.S. military.*

Very likely 6%
Somewhat likely 6%
Not likely 80%
Don't kniow 7%
Other response 1%

and..
Question/VAR 29:

The collapse if the twin towers in New York was aided by explosives secretly planted in the two buildings.*

Very likely 6%
Somewhat likely 10%
Unlikely 77%
Don't know 6%
Other response 1%

yet...
Question/VAR 26:

The federal government is withholding proof of the existence of intelligent life from others planets?*

Very likely 16%
Somewhat likely 22%
Unlikely 54%
Don't know 8%

http://www.newspolls.org/question.php?question_id=715


Owwwwchee!
 
Does anyone have the poll that shows that decreasing education level shows an increase in 9/11 conspiracy belief?
 
Does anyone have the poll that shows that decreasing education level shows an increase in 9/11 conspiracy belief?

I don't think this is the only one that says that, it is pretty consistent.

The level of suspicion of U.S. official involvement in a 9/11 conspiracy was only slightly behind the 40 percent who suspect "officials in the federal government were directly responsible for the assassination of President Kennedy" and the 38 percent who believe "the federal government is withholding proof of the existence of intelligent life from other planets."

The poll found that a majority of young adults give at least some credence to a 9/11 conspiracy compared to less than a fourth of people 65 or older. Members of racial and ethnic minorities, people with only a high school education and Democrats were especially likely to suspect federal involvement in 9/11.


http://www.scrippsnews.com/911poll
 
84%. That's an easy one to debunk.

Number of twoofers at Ground Zero on 9/11/06: 800-1,000

Number of twoofer candidates elected in 2006: zero

Number of twoofers doing something constructive/significant with their amazing proof: zero

Most revolutionary movements would triumphantly sweep to power with 84% public support.

Yet the twoof movement's 84% apparently adds up to a bunch of teenage stoners, deranged theology profs and retarded hippies posting spam and BS on message boards.
 
Here is one I doubt we will ever actually be able to really DEBUNK, but one I would love to see beaten down...

"Truthers are Millions strong now, and growing stronger everyday".

TAM:(
 
Does anyone have the poll that shows that decreasing education level shows an increase in 9/11 conspiracy belief?

Yep. That's quite evident from the statistics, although of course not emphasized by the Deniers. The Zogby Poll details from May (Word document) reads in part:

24. Some people believe that the US government and its 9/11 Commission concealed or refused to investigate critical evidence that contradicts their official explanation of the September 11th attacks, saying there has been a cover-up. Others say that the 9/11 Commission was a bi-partisan group of honest and well-respected people and that there is no reason they would want to cover-up anything. Who are you more likely to agree with?

US government and 9/11 Commission are NOT covering up 48%
US government and 9/11 Commission are covering up 42
Not sure 10

Close to half (48%) agrees the U.S. government and 9/11 Commission are not covering up anything, yet nearly as many (42%) believe the government and 9/11 Commission are covering up. One in ten (10%) is unsure.

Both men and women and residents in each of the four regions are more likely to say the U.S. government and 9/11 Commission are not covering up anything. Majorities who agree include Republicans (64%), 50-64 year-olds, married adults, suburbanites (59%), Protestants, those with at least some college education, and people with annual household income of $50,000 or more (57%).

Majorities (50%-56%) of Democrats, 18-29 year-olds, Hispanics, single adults and those who are divorced/widowed/separated, residents of small cities, and adults with less education than a high school diploma believe the government and 9/11 Commission are covering up something. Nearly half of independent voters (48%) agree.

The Scripps-Howard Poll that was widely quoted as showing 36% of the people believed in 9-11 Nuttery also contained similar findings--the average level of woo definitely declines as one gets more education.

My favorite poll result though has to be one from USA Today, from last August.

As the five-year anniversary of the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks approaches, nearly three-fourths of those responding to a CNN poll said they believe Osama bin Laden is planning another significant attack against the United States.

Seventy-four percent of the 1,033 adult Americans polled said they believe an attack is being planned, according to the poll conducted by Opinion Research Corporation on behalf of CNN.

So 74% of Americans clearly don't buy 9-11 Denial. That leaves 26%. The Cartman kids.
 
Last edited:
Majorities (50%-56%) of Democrats, 18-29 year-olds, Hispanics, single adults and those who are divorced/widowed/separated, residents of small cities, and adults with less education than a high school diploma believe the government and 9/11 Commission are covering up something. Nearly half of independent voters (48%) agree.

The Left, The young/naive, The downtrodden, The lonely, The bitter, The isolated, the uneducated, are all more likely...well that makes sense, people in all these areas IN GENERAL, tend to be more paranoid and/or suspicous over their government.

TAM
 
The statement that someone believes the gummint is "covering something up" isn't sufficient to infer that they've gone twoofy. Without specifics about the beliefs involved, there's no way to draw a supportable conclusion to that or any other effect.

It's no more irrational to assume that a blue-ribbon panel's report about a disaster probably contains a dose of bureaucratic CYA somewhere than it is to assume that it doesn't.
 
Once again, to quote that great American philosopher, Eric Cartman:

Cartman: They aren't going to find out who did it, but they will make up a scapegoat, send him to detention, and make us all believe it. It will be 9/11 all over again.

Kyle: Will you shut up about 9/11!

Cartman: Kyle, why are you so afraid of the truth?

Kyle: Because anybody who thinks 9/11 is a conspiracy is a retard!

Cartman: Oh really, well did you know that over 1/4th of the people in America think that 9/11 was a conspiracy? Are you saying that 1/4th of Americans are retards?

Kyle: Yes, I am saying that 1/4th of Americans are retards.

Stan: At least 1/4th.

Kyle: Let's take a test sample. There's 4 of us, you're a retard. That's 1/4th.
 
Here is one I doubt we will ever actually be able to really DEBUNK, but one I would love to see beaten down...

"Truthers are Millions strong now, and growing stronger everyday".

TAM:(

Well, a random sample of truther websites shows that its a novelty and its wearing off...

361745b9d33ee5c6c.png

361745b9d33f2715e.png

361745b9d33f55b38.png

361745b9d36c8521e.png

361745b9d36cab34a.png

361745b9d36cd52f2.png

361745b9d59f43608.png

361745b9d59f68799.png

361745b9d59f8e4dd.png

361745b9d609ade71.png

361745b9d609d4f3e.png
 
I'd love to see one of those graphs for Pilots for Truth. I imagine it would be fairly flat.
 
I'd love to see one of those graphs for Pilots for Truth. I imagine it would be fairly flat.

I tried it but it seems like its not been around long enough to get an Alexa graph. If you want to compare other sites go to www.alexa.com. I used the 3 yr graph with maximum smoothing.
 
A smidge of Truthers

Thanks to all of you for another informative thread. Your efficiency at debunking is impressive for a bunch of government shills, or elitists, or whatever we are.

Obviously, this "everyone is waking up" meme is part of the same mental disorder that causes the Truthers to see nonexistent conspiracies in the first place. Leave it to Alex Jones to make the silliest claim possible.

(If you listen to Alex for a while, you realize that numbers mean nothing to him. Alex just throws out big numbers, then makes them bigger and bigger. At this point, Alex is saying the White House stole three trillion dollars from the Pentagon--or was it six trillion? You can tell that boy is a Texan.)

The Scripps Howard poll strikes me as the most accurate--where the question was completely unambiguous and direct. So the Truthers turn out to be about 6% of the populace--or less.

I'll also bet that half or more of the people who said "yes" to the poll would reconsider once they looked into the matter and saw how silly the "inside job" story is. So you end up with a mere smidge of Truthers. They may be the same guys who think Elvis is still alive.
 
Last edited:
Just for reference, here is the graph for this forum ;):

Hans :D

ETA: Oh, Spins beat me to it, heheh.
 

Attachments

  • graph.png
    graph.png
    4.5 KB · Views: 6

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom