Teh 28th Annual Stundies: February 2007 Nominations !!!

Stundie said:
As I said, if you want to believe I'm some sort of uneducated fool, then so be it. I'm certainly not going to prove you otherwise!! hahahahaha!! Stundie

True dat.
 
We urgently need to petition the mods here to unban Stundie!
No, no... the SLC forum is jumping now because so many of you are going there to see him for yourselves! Pre-Stundie, the place was dead...
 
Still debating over at SLC with Stundie about "facts can change vs. facts cannot change". Needless to say...it's a never ending go-around. So given that Stundie believes that facts are based on beliefs, we had this little exchange.

HyJinX at SLC said:
So, when you were three years old and believed in Santa Claus...that means it was a fact that he existed...correct?
Now that you're all...ahem...grown up...that fact has changed? Has that fact changed to he no longer exists or that he never existed?

Please let me know your thoughts.

Stundie said:
(I'm being Stundie)

Yes. It changed. For 3 years olds Santa Claus exists and is very real. The evidence is there. Mom and Dad talk about him. He brings presents. All of the other kids talk about him. He even drinks the milk and eats the cookies! What more proof do they need?

Once they get older- they understand that it is a hoax perpretrated by their parents. Now Santa doesn't exist- they understand that he never did exist. The facts change, subjective facts that is.

I need a drink.
 
A lesson in the tower falling. Could be a Judy Wood fan.

from a new guy
I think it's worth printing the whole quote, to catch the full arrogance of respublicus' physics smackdown. All he needs is the "clunkity-clunk!"

UH, ohkay now, let's take this real slow now, i know heavy brainwashing has deleterious effects on your brain function. So this is going to be reaaalll eeazy, now

1. video evidence
get a clock or a watch. have you seen one of those before? Ask you mommy, maybe she has. Then get a video. Find somebody who can read the clock. clock the collapse.

2. Ok, this is a little bit harder but you can do it. You need to know a little bit of arithmetic and measures.

We'll keep it reeaaal simple. Let's say each floor pancakes really fast - say in one second flat.
There are 110 floors.
How many seconds. Take your time now.
Ok, give up?
Ok i will tell you.
It's 110 seconds.
Almost two minutes. Those are marked by the long hand on the clock, see?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2317910&postcount=706
 
Still debating over at SLC with Stundie about "facts can change vs. facts cannot change". Needless to say...it's a never ending go-around. So given that Stundie believes that facts are based on beliefs, we had this little exchange.
I need a drink.

I could only take so much of that over there.

So, as evasive as this character is, what's the final verdict from Stundie? Did Santa exist as a FACT when he was three years old or didn't he? And if Santa exists as a FACT for every three year old (and if you swing a cat at any moment of any day you're bound to hit a three year old somewhere) does that mean that Santa is a FACT regardless of the age of the one looking for him? In other words, if Santa is a fact for all three year olds, and there is never a moment in time when there isn't a three year old, does that mean that Santa is always a fact?

Oh, and can you round up all the Post-Modernists and sink them in the ocean? Once they're out of our experience they will never have existed anyway.
 
Actually, HyJinX, that Santa response is from Lowball Plath, trying to Stundify his thinking. Notice the good spelling; you'll never see that in a Stundie post.
 
Actually, HyJinX, that Santa response is from Lowball Plath, trying to Stundify his thinking. Notice the good spelling; you'll never see that in a Stundie post.

I should have known! Damn...he got me! :covereyes

I was going to go back in for another round...but I'm having a difficult time getting out the fork I placed into my forehead during my last go-around with him. Wildcat was right...Stundie's logic is flawed at the very core of his critical -thinking skills. He's broken...never to realize it for himself.
 
nicepants@SLC said:
All I want is for stundie to explain what makes a fact different from a belief.


stundie@SLC said:
A fact is a belief based on what we believe to be true about something depending on the information at the time.

A belief is something we believe in!
(bolding mine)

ironically he uses the word "believe" (or forms of it) more in his defintion of fact that in his definition of belief
 
Once I get to the required posts I plan on using this simple but yet still funny quip for my Sig.

In the thread speaking about the "dancing israelis" Killtown offered up this piece of evidence regarding how they were "celebrating" while watching everything unfold.

"Operatives are usually the cocky type." - Killtown


It's gold Jerry, gold!
 
Last edited:
Perhaps we should coin a new term "Stundiefact" based on Stundie's attitude about what a belief is.


Stundiefact: (Noun) : A belief that someone, somewhere, believes to be true at some point based on whatever information they believe. This may or may not be actually true, and if the person's beliefs change, this "fact" will change as well. The stundiefact is condidered "proven" as long as someone believes it, but if no one believes it, then it is no longer true. Ex. It is a proven [stundie]FACT that the earth was flat.

Whenever stundie claims that something is "fact" or "proven" we should use the stundiefact definition so as to avoid confusing it with an actual fact.

That's as close as I can get to his logic. The tragic thing is he doesn't even realize how screwed up it is!
 
Perhaps we should coin a new term "Stundiefact" based on Stundie's attitude about what a belief is.


Stundiefact: (Noun) : A belief that someone, somewhere, believes to be true at some point based on whatever information they believe. This may or may not be actually true, and if the person's beliefs change, this "fact" will change as well. The stundiefact is condidered "proven" as long as someone believes it, but if no one believes it, then it is no longer true. Ex. It is a proven [stundie]FACT that the earth was flat.

Whenever stundie claims that something is "fact" or "proven" we should use the stundiefact definition so as to avoid confusing it with an actual fact.

That's as close as I can get to his logic. The tragic thing is he doesn't even realize how screwed up it is!

I'd rather eat my own foot than go back for more of his "deluge of stupid". Nice job Nicepants. It's sad to see that Stundie will never see the errors of his ways. Pathetic really.
 
I don't care what you guys say. This quote from Stundie takes the whole thing in my opinion:

"Yes I did notice, but its actually the explosives which have ALREADY pulverised the concrete and the collapse then blows out the dust clouds! Hence the big thick clouds of dusts which look more like a pyroclastic flow!!"-Stundie

Just read the dust cloud thread. See if you can escape with your sanity.

http://screwloosechange.xbehome.com/index.php?showtopic=1444
 
Last edited:
I want to nominate Dylan for this hastily deleted gem, spotted by Sophia8...

Dylan Avery said:
One of the people who saw the plane hit, Lt. Col. Karen Kwiatkowski, Ph.D, has this to say:
"... The scene, in short, was not what I would have expected from a strike by a large jetliner. It was, however, exactly what one would expect if a missile had struck the Pentagon."

So there we apparently have it from the man himself. A plane hit the pentagon and caused counter-intuitive damage. I also love the way he helpfully added the Ph.D to add authority to his witness. I guess that's one mystery solved.
 
Explaining why WTC7 was "pulled":

The purpose of the national security team in pulling the building would be to save the sensitive files and hard dives not to destroy them. Once the building was down, the remains could be taken to a secret location and all of the sensitive material could be retrieved and secured.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom