Teh 28th Annual Stundies: February 2007 Nominations !!!

Anyone get the feeling Mein Kampf would have sold better if Hitler had gone with the cake analogy?

" Existence impels the cake makers to lie and to lie perpetually, just as it compels the Nordic girl down the lane to wear warm clothing."*
- "Herr Hitler, don't you think your book should make sense?"
"Why start now?"

________
Actual quote: Existence impels the Jew to lies and to lie perpetually, just as it compels the inhabitants of the northern countries to wear warm clothing.

So when he titled his book "My Struggle" he should have called it "My Strudel"?

Sorry.
 
Bear with me on this.

I wish to nomite Jazz over on urban75 for his response to this technical post:

Architect said:
Your working hypothesis is that the load from the facade and floor failures should have redistributed to the core via the hat trusses, and that the core should have been able to take these increased loads because of the safety factors.

One of the first things we have to understand is what we mean by safety factor: the ratio of the breaking stress of a structure to the estimated maximum stress in ordinary use.

However it is important to understand that the loads/forces found on a complex structure such as WTC may be acting in any number of ways; for example horizontal bending or overturning moments, or gravity loads.

In the same vein, there is a difference between the safety factor of an individual part of a structure andthe structure as a whole. It is perfectly possible for a steel beam to have a high factor of safety against (say) buckling under vertical (gravity) loads but a different figure for other forces.

To claim a figure of 600%, or 200%, or 50% as a global safety factor therefore just betrays how little you understand the subject. 600% against what? Which kind of forces? How are they acting? We can therefore only really understand the performance of the structure through global modelling.

NIST actually do this - and not once, but three times. They look at the original design calculations, modern design calculations, and then a more forgiving global model of their own. The latter tells us that:

- Core columns in WTC typically had a Demand to Capacity Ratio (DCR) of 0.83 with around 10.6% of components exceeding design capacity under normal conditions.

- Hat Truss Columns had a typical DCR of 0.59, with 14.3% exceeding design capacity (some by DCRs of up to 1.95).

Other elements of the trusses had lower DCRs, however a truss is only as strong as the weakest member so we can set these to one side.

Now the section you quote Jazz, from page 133 of the PDF file, doesn't model the structural performance or indeed individual components. It's actually just a note of the NYC and Port authority design codes. So they don't actually prove anything very much.

So where does this take us:

Well, Hat Trusses may have had up to 0.4 "spare DCR" however this is in respect of design loads. The purpose of the hatt trusses was not to cantilever loads from envelope to carr, but even if it was then it certainly wasn't capable of taking double the design load.


To which he responded (eventually) with:

Jazzz said:
it really doesn't matter what technobabble you come out with, you are simply wrong and shown to be so.
 
pdoherty76

"I have a masters in maths. I think I understand the evidence better than a tour guide."
 
pdoherty76

"I have a masters in maths. I think I understand the evidence better than a tour guide."

Yeah, that was the same guy who asked us whether friction could possibly melt metal, and then didn't like the answer.

Shocking commentary on the state of education in Trooferville, that's what that is.

PD'oh has actually posted his degree certificate:

http://i166.photobucket.com/albums/u86/pdoherty76/LastScan.jpg

Note it isn't a masters in "Mathematical Physics" as he was fond of claiming. The course details are here:

http://www.manchester.ac.uk/undergraduate/courses/search/atoz/course/index.htm?code=01688&pg=1
http://www.maths.manchester.ac.uk/undergraduate/ugstudies/programmes/single-honours-maths.html

Note that the only compulsory applied mathematics courses are in statistics. PD'oh could easily have avoided all those mechanics courses.

(ETA: Looking closer, he should have learned something useful from this compulsory course:
http://www.maths.manchester.ac.uk/undergraduate/ugstudies/units/level1/MATH10222/
and possibly this one:
http://www.maths.manchester.ac.uk/undergraduate/ugstudies/units/level2/MATH20401/ )

Also, a second class, division two honours degree (aka a 2:2) is not particularly impressive. I'm not certain if he would have got a masters degree if he'd done a 3 year BSc and then applied to do a further postgraduate course.

Details of British degree classifications are here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_undergraduate_degree_classification

All in all though, I think that PD'oh is too crazy to use his intelligence and his education. As he said in the posts that he has now excised from Conspiracy Smasher "I realised I was arguing with the rational part of my mind."

This is the other thing that PD is using his photobucket account for:

http://s166.photobucket.com/albums/u86/pdoherty76/?action=view&current=doglaugh.gif
 
Last edited:
A nominee who may be banned by the time you read this

I've got to put a plug in here for newcomer MaGZ ("Missiles at Ground Zero"):

The FBI has changed their approach to the anthrax investigation now that they know Israel was responsible.
The FBI knows Israel sent the anthrax because they have read the article "The Anthrax Mystrey: Solved".

It's not circular reasoning exactly, more like a spiral... orbiting, what else, irrational hatred of Israel. Alas.
 
I truly admire those of you who delve into the CT world on a more regular basis then I do.

Every time I do I feel like Nicholas Cage at the end of 8mm.
 
Let's hear it for our new friend MaGZ, who in a few posts managed to disparage two U.S. fighter pilots, thousands of WTC 7 occupants and witnesses, Jews, firefighters, and the English language. Here's a sample:

"The Fire Department may have set the tanks on fire in order to burn off the fule. Once the fule was gone then a CD could begin."

Personally, I can't wait for the fule to be gone.
 
I nominate Lyte Trip:

:eye-poppi

You could cut that up into 3 different quotes, and each would be worthy of a Stundie!

And, I nominate C7's flat out wrong:

Desel fuel doesn't explode. Thats why they use it.

Post here

And C7 again, he's been solid lately:

I can better assess the damage, sitting here at my computer 5 years later, because i can see the other 2 [perhaps 3] sides of wtc 7 that the firefighter could not see.

-When asked if he would know more than a firefighter who was at ground zero on 9/11 about the state of the fire in WTC 7. Alas, I do not think this is the full quote; can someone find a link to the post at LCF where he said this? I can't find it...
 
Last edited:
From David Ray Griffin, "one of the worlds most credible and respected 9/11 researchers", answering a question from JREF's Architect:

Let me also add that architects and engineers are not necessarily, as you suggest, “best placed to consider the underlying causes of the collapse.” They build things; they do not destroy things.

The sad part is that he indeed is one of the worlds most credible "researchers" in the "Truth Movement".
 
:eye-poppi


And C7 again, he's been solid lately:

-When asked if he would know more than a firefighter who was at ground zero on 9/11 about the state of the fire in WTC 7. Alas, I do not think this is the full quote; can someone find a link to the post at LCF where he said this? I can't find it...

It was here 2nd post down.
 
In their new thread about freefall :rolleyes: :

astorstraussenheim@LCF said:
All the science B*******T is getting to me. One minute it's there, ten seconds later, it's gone. My eyes are my science!
I wonder if MA in Mathematics PDoherty agrees ... :)

ETA: yes, he does!

pdoherty76@LCF said:
I posted this on my blog many months ago and the response I got was "the buildings didnt fall at freefall".

Oh really? Why does the 911 commision and my eyes say they did?
Well, maybe his little brother is at it again.
 
Last edited:
Lava, volcanoes, meteorites...

Stundie said:
Its about me finding out the truth of the events on 9/11 as I do not believe them. You believe the official story, then fair enough! What I do not get is why you are defending it so vigorously? Even when there are clear holes in the story!!

Jones could be totally wrong with the Thermite theory, but we have no other theory which explains all this phenomenon. Thermate would explain the reports of molten steel being found and the meteorite!!

So it's the most logical theory, and has more evidence to suggest it's true than your kerosene fires theory!! Stundie

He's on to me....

Stundie said:
I see stalkerboy is doing what he loves best, stalking my posts and checking for any kinds of errors for his Stundie collection of paragraphs for his prized Stundie quotes sections.

Cause stalkerboy can't have a piece of my hair, or steal my underwear from my washing line, or send me poisen pen letters! Stalker boy instead of debating issues, would prefer to point out grammitical errors as a way of proving himself right and me wrong.

Your collections of my quotes proves that you are Stundie Superfan Stalker No1! hahahahahaha!!! Stundie
 
This one may have been posted already...but it's worth another look inside the mind of the CT.

stundie @ SLC said:
Hello fellow JREFer.....I take it you have come across from the JREF pond to support you JREF buddies who are taking a serious kicking!!

However, this has been discussed at length in various thread...over the last few days. Infact I have provided loads of examples!!

One of which is "I have never done LSD!" Which is a fact! Because I haven't done LSD.

Now if I do some LSD at any time in the future, then that FACT has changed....Not my belief...There are countless others examples I have given!!

Facts change when new evidence outrules the old one, some facts will never change, but other will. Hence facts can change depending on what evidence we have at the time.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom