Summary of WTC tower collapses

I'll never understand why these need to be so wordy.

20 floors fell on one floor. One floor couldn't hold the weight, so 21 floors fell on one floor, which couldn't hold the weight. So 22 floors....

repeat until completed.

Please show a picture, or anything, that shows 20 floors of WTC1 or WTC2 falling.
 
Do your own bleeding homework.

If at this stage in 2016 you are denying that the Top Sections of WTC1 and WTC2 fell as part of the collapse....go find some silly patsies to sell your snake oil to.

Please show a picture, or anything, that shows 20 floors of WTC1 or WTC2 falling.

That was the text of my post. There should only have been two options. The first option was to post something that meets the requirements of my request. The second option should have been to ignore it if you could not fulfill the request, or chose not to fulfill the request.
 
Please show a picture, or anything, that shows 20 floors of WTC1 or WTC2 falling.

That was the text of my post. There should only have been two options. The first option was to post something that meets the requirements of my request. The second option should have been to ignore it if you could not fulfill the request, or chose not to fulfill the request.


Please post a picture showing those two options exist and that they are the only two options.
 
Please post a picture showing those two options exist and that they are the only two options.

A skeptic made a claim. I asked anyone to provide proof this claim is true. If no one can provide this proof, then the claim should be retracted.
 
I don't want to make that claim but by your logic if they didn't fall they must still be up there.

I never said they did not fall. Where did I say the towers did not fall? Please copy and paste the text where I have claimed that the towers did not fall.
 
Can you elaborate on this comment?

Gladly, you've wrecked what I considered to be an informative thread, and hereafter, (if your current pattern of behaviour is any indication) it won't be worth reading owing to your 'contributions'. I hope that is sufficiently clear and no more discourse with you on the matter will be considered.

Oh, and Bob is a 9/11 truther on a few sites I'm on, and his posting style is highly reminiscent of yours (that is not a positive appraisal), and he has the same talent for shutting down discussion of 9/11 as you evince.
 
Last edited:
It should be noted that when people refer to the collapse phase of the lower section... below the plane strike... referred to by some as "ROOSD" and the period before ROOSD is referred to as "initiation"... this is somewhat misleading.

In actual fact, I would suggest that there was a sort of continuous process of stage/phase transition. That is to say ROOSD did not have a t=0 when it began but there was a process which transitioned into ROOSD... which did not involve heat driving destruction, but mechanical disintegration of the normal temperature structure from gravity driven mechanical "collisions" of loose building components with the intact structure below...

In order for ROOSD to get going... material needs to crash down and destroy floor slabs. That material has to be freed from the structural matrix... or the if it remains locked into it... the entire top would have to be freed ( pushed or pulled off column alignment to drop. I suspect this did not happen. It was more of the former and a some of the later.

The phase transition may have been very rapid and in a very compressed time frame... much like the concept of aggregate FOS being driven below 1 by whatever means. Until a member is seeing loads exceed its yield strength is remains static and functioning. The instant the loads exceed capacity or the capacity drops below the loads the member sees... failure has occurred.

It seems absurd to thing that over time the structure kept getting hotter and weaker throughout a few levels as the sole means of driving capacity down below FOS 1. This is not to say that heat was not cutting into axial capacity. It must have played some role.

Surely core beams were losing capacity, expanding, concrete slabs within the core spalding and breaking up. Perhaps partial collapses were loading up floors below pushing them closer and closer to their limit such that one the straw dropped the at capacity floor and loads upon it crashed down starting local "mini" cascading in bay failures in the core region.

The phase transition is almost impossible to conceptualize and explain. But it seems to be a process were the effect of heat was causing mechanical failures (dropping mass) which facilitated the distorting of the frame itself in a gutted hot zone.

I suspect the failure of people to understand how heat leads to freed collapsing mass which then can destroy what it falls on is the basis for so much skepticism which gives rise to belief that fires cannot collapse strong steel framed buildings.

Would column shortening cause a building to collapse? I think not. Column buckling would. Column misalignment would. Was there enough head to induce buckling in enough columns? That is... a threshold amount to begin the fatal load redistribution and drive axial capacity below FOS 1... and all remaining columns instantly buckle the with the remain structure moving laterally as it dropped?

How was HEAT undoing things which lead to what is referred to as ROOSD or the runaway floor collapse?
 
Gladly, you've wrecked what I considered to be an informative thread

Oh, and Bob is a 9/11 truther on a few sites I'm on, and his posting style is highly reminiscent of yours (that is not a positive appraisal), and he has the same talent for shutting down discussion of 9/11 as you evince.

What you are claiming is that asking someone to prove ONE statement has "wrecked an 'informative' thread".

LOL.

I wish I could send this thread to every person on this planet, because you have done what I have worked so hard to do. You have given me a gift I can not repay you for. You have shown that the "skeptics" on this forum absolutely run away when confronted by a legitimate request for proof. It's there, clear for anyone to see. I made one simple request, which no one has even made an attempt to fulfill, and you claim I have "wrecked" this thread.

Awesome. Everyone on the planet needs to see this. What more proof does anyone need to show that this forum is a hoax? Really? What more proof do you need? All you want to do is fantasize about what you think happened. All you want to do is validate your delusions, and when you are asked for proof of just one statement, you claim the thread is wrecked.

Incredible.

And thanks. This thread needs to be a sticky.
 
What you are claiming is that asking someone to prove ONE statement has "wrecked an 'informative' thread".

LOL.

I wish I could send this thread to every person on this planet, because you have done what I have worked so hard to do. You have given me a gift I can not repay you for. You have shown that the "skeptics" on this forum absolutely run away when confronted by a legitimate request for proof. It's there, clear for anyone to see. I made one simple request, which no one has even made an attempt to fulfill, and you claim I have "wrecked" this thread.

Awesome. Everyone on the planet needs to see this. What more proof does anyone need to show that this forum is a hoax? Really? What more proof do you need? All you want to do is fantasize about what you think happened. All you want to do is validate your delusions, and when you are asked for proof of just one statement, you claim the thread is wrecked.

Incredible.

And thanks. This thread needs to be a sticky.

Who are the skeptics?
 
Oh for....

facepalm.jpg~c200


Sander, please proceed (if you're not done), I'm actually enjoying the material. I might go over old threads at Metabunk until this guy gets the axe. You've much there as well as Oz etc...
 
Last edited:
Who are the skeptics?
For the purposes of this forum, the widely-accepted definitions are that a truther is someone who questions the official story, and a skeptic is someone who supports it. The official story is, basically, everything contained in the 9/11 CR and the NIST WTC7 report.

If you wish to add to these definitions, please do so.
 
Last edited:
Please show a picture, or anything, that shows 20 floors of WTC1 or WTC2 falling.

That was the text of my post. There should only have been two options. The first option was to post something that meets the requirements of my request. The second option should have been to ignore it if you could not fulfill the request, or chose not to fulfill the request.
Actually among other options there is the option of pointing out a false dichotomy on your part
 
Oh for....

[qimg]http://rs479.pbsrc.com/albums/rr154/EpIcFaIl11/facepalm.jpg~c200[/qimg]

Sander, please proceed (if you're not done), I'm actually enjoying the material. I might go over old threads at Metabunk until this guy gets the axe. You've much there as well as Oz etc...
Currently I'm massively frustrated with a couple of topics on Metabunk. Put simply I've temporarily given up in disgust at the unacknowledged drift in focus.

The old problem - no clarity of objective - so drifting all over the place when (I think) the foundation options have been clearly identified.

(Add comment about "putting examples of species equus ferus caballus in proximity to aqueous fluid will not necessarily predispose to imbibing.")



AND - in this thread - I'm biting my tongue to resist responding to Sanders Post #53 and the multiple bits of confusion/errors it contains.

OP a thread Sander -- someone - and we can go over the many issues yet again. F'rinstance the four (if I count right) self contradictions.
 
Last edited:
Please show a picture, or anything, that shows 20 floors of WTC1 or WTC2 falling.

That was the text of my post. There should only have been two options. The first option was to post something that meets the requirements of my request. The second option should have been to ignore it if you could not fulfill the request, or chose not to fulfill the request.

Here.


Is your google broken or what?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom