Summary of WTC tower collapses

Brilliant stuff JDH - Even in "pedantic engineer mode" I would not fault it as a good summary.


Overall most of your paragraphs identify and concisely catalogue multiple subtler points of engineering. Many of which have attracted lengthy debate.

A lot of details summarised in few words.


PS
One - only one - minor "nit".

Possibly a reference to "well outside design envelope" in your second paragraph - the key issue being it was way beyond what would reasonably be designed for rather than "rarely reached" - it has AFAIK only been reached on two occasions. WTC1 and WTC2.
Why'd you put that in small font. I'm an old guy too ya know(junior to you, but still old).:D

Point noted. I'll take it into account. Perhaps elaborate on the "normal" or "expected" progression of an office fire. That such a wide horizontal and vertical involvement is designed in fire codes to take hours.
 
oh yes, had not thought of the other connotation of "admirable" or "valuable".

Perhaps "considerable", instead.
By all means.

I've abandoned that recent recycling of the same old evasions and mendacious misunderstandings - must be the fifth consecutive year for the same ritual.

So - lets see what March/April 2017 brings. :rolleyes:
 
By all means.

I've abandoned that recent recycling of the same old evasions and mendacious misunderstandings - must be the fifth consecutive year for the same ritual.

So - lets see what March/April 2017 brings. :rolleyes:

My plan (and with plans nothing can go wrong,,, go wrong,,, go wrong,,, with plans,,, plans,,, orange baby trains)
is to have a summary squirreled away on my tablet to copy and paste when the need opportunity arises. that or to simply link to a post with a finalized version.
 
Thanks JSO

You are of course welcome!

Difference of opinion noted

No problem

While perhaps not a lot, I believe it was significant enough to compromise the resistance to heating. IOW, the fuel was an accelerant in fire spread, loss of fire retardant is an accelerant in steel heating. One more reason the building succumbed so soon.


For sure POST plane impact the core was effected by heat... which both weakened the steel but more importantly and more likely the cause.. they heated the core bracing which LENGTHENED and pushed against the columns. A column which has lost bracing was vulnerable to movement. This led to shearing the column to column splices... which were weak in shear to begin with. When the bearing is decreased.. the column can transfer loads.. it does one of 2 things... cripples or drops dragging everything connected to it down... but to do THAT the columns has to then separated from what it's connected to above.. another column to column connection which can shear and likely does... What would happen to a column which no bearing and 15 floors of loads attached to it?



I see the core as being impacted by a huge heating effect, basically from all sides. The perimeter was necessarily cooler due to the open air. As core columns suffered load creep due to increasing loss of capacity from heating, loads would slowly transfer to other columns.

Maybe... the heating was likely INSIDE the core and a lesser extent in the OOS area... but there on the opposite side of impact... the fuel had momentum and likely mostly ended up away from the impact area. But the impact of the fuel with core columns would atomize and disperse it laterally.

From what mechanism?


Core aggregate axial capacity was largely lost from column destruction and displacement caused by columns misalignment caused by beam expansion.


Slow creep driven loss would simply see the core shortening at those columns affected. This would cause the tower to move and twist. It did.

If the core was "shortening" the antenna would have sunk as it did and the hat truss fractured

The very first fracturing would be due to upper column sections spearing the floor. Those column sections are right next to their counterparts below, which is also where truss seats are. Breaking a seat is going to fail that truss's usefulness immediately.


The truss seats all failed from floor collapses not columns hitting them from above... on the core side no columns even aligned with the trusses!


Belt girder would be pretty insignificant in holding the core together. Tearing away the truss connections to that girder would weaken the girder itself(its a violent action)

The girder would not be weaken by loads being removed.. if that happened it would be the same strength with less stress/loads on it. It did not hold the core together.. it transferred OOS loads to the perimeter core columns.


I wanted to avoid anthropomorphism such as "raced".

OK makes sense

No significantly different from what I said.


Let me insert my comments in red... I add this is my conceptualization of the capacity erosion and core "destruction" in the initiation period... When the last core column ... the 4 in the case of 1 wtc could no longer hold the belt girder... and the floor sections connected to it... they buckled... the top twisted and dropped... The collapsing antenna was the tell tale that the hat truss had collapsed and the center of the core beneath it was "gutted"/gone/dropped.
 
Let me insert my comments in red... I add this is my conceptualization of the capacity erosion and core "destruction" in the initiation period... When the last core column ... the 4 in the case of 1 wtc could no longer hold the belt girder... and the floor sections connected to it... they buckled... the top twisted and dropped... The collapsing antenna was the tell tale that the hat truss had collapsed and the center of the core beneath it was "gutted"/gone/dropped.

Ahhh, yes,, beam expansion in the core. They would heat faster than the columns due to size alone. Were they embedded in the concrete at all, or were the core slabs on top of them?

Did the antenna (As a tech I hate that term, the antenna is attached to that. That is a "tower" but that would confuse matters) drop suddenly at onset of, but leading in respect to, collapse?
 
While perhaps not a lot, I believe it was significant enough to compromise the resistance to heating.
It was "enough" and "in the right places" - the absolute quantity or proportion is not important. Too much of the truther false concept of a need for "global heating". Only the NEXT element in the cascade to failure sequence needed to be heated. Naturally nearby ones would also - realities of heat movement dynamics and probable related hysteresis in same.

From what mechanism?
Precisely. And it has zero relevance to your point - the columns failed.

The main cause of very first fracturing would be due to upper column sections spearing the floor. << True if you correct the nuance - "very first" may be wrong at micro detail level. Those column sections are right next to their counterparts below, << true which is also where truss seats are. <<True Breaking a seat is going to fail that truss's usefulness immediately. <<True
The main point is that you explain reality without the long time heresy of "accumulating debris" as primary cause.

No significantly different from what I said.
None of Sander's relevant points actually disagree with your explanation. Mostly they are details which do not affect the actual point you made. That puts it as concisely as I can - I've been trying to avoid the derails of Sanders comments - I see I'm too late. :o
 
Last edited:
I see the core as being impacted by a huge heating effect, basically from all sides. The perimeter was necessarily cooler due to the open air. As core columns suffered load creep due to increasing loss of capacity from heating, loads would slowly transfer to other columns.

Maybe... the heating was likely INSIDE the core and a lesser extent in the OOS area... but there on the opposite side of impact... the fuel had momentum and likely mostly ended up away from the impact area. But the impact of the fuel with core columns would atomize and disperse it laterally.

My reference is wrt fire situation after the aircraft fuel is gone. Heating due to office contents fires. On some floors there'd be a lot of rubblized contents IN the core, whereas in the building prior to impact, the core had much less combustibles. In addition fires in the OOS surround the core. Over three or four levels the core would at some point be surrounded by IR emitting office fire even IF there is notthing actually IN the core area that is combusting.
Imagine the stresses on a column that is very hot on one side for 3 meters then very hot on another side the next 3 meters then very hot on another side for the next 3.
Who wrote "Twist and Shout"


ETA: anyway, later guys. Friday night and I gotta wanna,,, go home and watch TV with my wife.
 
Last edited:
^^ If we are into chasing derails I'll take my parking brakes of. :D

We have MULTIPLE explanations of the initiation cascade failure process.

Your OP JDH is a SUMMARY and Sander's alternate details do not change your SUMMARY.






:( Excuse the SHOUTING. :o
 
Last edited:
Perimeter column "trees" peel away, the first to do so are on the order of 1000 feet above ground as they pivot away.
This could use a bit of expansion, perhaps. A reason for outward movement.


Anyone?
Not sure expansion is needed - my suggestion is keep the tight focus on SUMMARY.

The central issue of contention over "Perimeter Peel Off" is truther claims for explosive projection. Truther nonsense is not the focus of the summary - it is a summary of reality.

Similarly no need to allude to misunderstandings - whether truther, debunker or shared by some on both sides. Stay with what really happened. Your thinking on the points that matter is as clear and concise we will see. And you are dealing with a few identified details and nuances.
 
Last edited:
Ahhh, yes,, beam expansion in the core. They would heat faster than the columns due to size alone. Were they embedded in the concrete at all, or were the core slabs on top of them?

Did the antenna (As a tech I hate that term, the antenna is attached to that. That is a "tower" but that would confuse matters) drop suddenly at onset of, but leading in respect to, collapse?

I forget the world -columns- 4 corner columns

The heat expansion would likely not lengthen the columns... but it would lengthen the beams which were seeing the full heat gradient at the top of each floor which is on fire. The heat gradient in the slabs destroyed their integrity as well.

The slabs were likely resting ON the bracing... they may have had some shear studs to make the slabs and beams composite.

The antenna had about a 30' square steel "pyramid" structure to spread the loads to bear on several cross beams of the hat truss AND to act as an end plate for it.

It appears that the antenna collapse because the hat truss collapsed in the center... and that collpases in the center because the columns beneath it could not transfer loads to the cold undamaged section below. It's likely or possible that the 15 floors hung or pulled down in the center of the truss causing it to breaking. They had supported it and then they became a load trying to hang from it.
 
Last edited:
I see the core as being impacted by a huge heating effect, basically from all sides. The perimeter was necessarily cooler due to the open air. As core columns suffered load creep due to increasing loss of capacity from heating, loads would slowly transfer to other columns.

Maybe... the heating was likely INSIDE the core and a lesser extent in the OOS area... but there on the opposite side of impact... the fuel had momentum and likely mostly ended up away from the impact area. But the impact of the fuel with core columns would atomize and disperse it laterally.

My reference is wrt fire situation after the aircraft fuel is gone. Heating due to office contents fires. On some floors there'd be a lot of rubblized contents IN the core, whereas in the building prior to impact, the core had much less combustibles. In addition fires in the OOS surround the core. Over three or four levels the core would at some point be surrounded by IR emitting office fire even IF there is notthing actually IN the core area that is combusting.
Imagine the stresses on a column that is very hot on one side for 3 meters then very hot on another side the next 3 meters then very hot on another side for the next 3.
Who wrote "Twist and Shout"

ETA: anyway, later guys. Friday night and I gotta wanna,,, go home and watch TV with my wife.

The core up there had almost the same density of office use and contents.. some bathrooms and a few elevator and HVAC shafts.
 
Sure Mark. That is the long held and often expressed NoahFence version. Perfectly valid as the top level macro summary.

BUT...I'll take it your tongue is in your cheek. ;)

muh tumb izzz nowt fimwee pwanted imm tseeek :p

The above explanation already exceeds the conceptual capabilities of the typical CT, so not much point in going deeper most of the time if the intended audience are CT's.
 
I forget the world -columns- 4 corner columns

The heat expansion would likely not lengthen the columns... but it would lengthen the beams ....
.

Columns under load will not lengthen on being heated. Instead they will squash or creep. Like trying to support a load with part of your column slowly turning to plastercine. Steel still has to expand but cannot do so along its long axis, so it bulges and deforms further weakening the section that then squashes under the load. Beachnut had a photo that showed this iirc(I might not)
Column slowly shortens.

Of course if this occurs near a ceiling then it is also in the same region of expanding floor beams. Add to it a partial loss of SFRM and you have sort of a perfect storm.
 
Last edited:
Revised

Generic Description of the Collapse Progression of the Two WTC Towers:

Video evidence demonstrates aircraft impact destroyed or bent a number of perimeter columns. A lesser amount of core column severance or damage is expected. Some floor spans also directly damaged.

Aircraft fuel spread through several vertically adjacent floors of the structure and ignited. This created a condition of very large area office contents fire on those floors with various levels of rubblization of the contents. This is a fire condition well beyond design expectations for fire spread. Office fires are expected to usually begin small, in a waste basket, or an electrical fault in a device or circuit, for instance.

Aircraft impact debrided spray on fire insulation in varying degree, on a significant number of structural components on impact floors. This reduced fire resistance of those structural steel components.

Structural response to impact was a redistribution of loads previously carried by missing or foreshortened ( due to being bent) columns. Load redistribution was not even across all remaining columns.

Fire spread and movement was similar, but not identical, on each involved level and also spread to higher levels. Heat began affecting steel structural components, both vertical and horizontal, and the connecting components between them on all fire involved levels.

Floor spans had long trusses with their lower chords exposed to the heat and the trusses in several areas began sagging. A few areas had already seen truss or truss to perimeter connection failure at impact.

Perimeter columns and truss to perimeter connecting components heated less than the core columns and truss to core structure components. The interface between long span trusses and core was a belt truss rather than direct connection to core columns.

Core columns are subject to heating basically from all sides, over the several floors fully involved in the fires, and over the course of fire spread around each level.
( that is to say a column at level x may heat more on one face than that same column at level x-1 or x+1 but that over the several levels involved some columns are heated on all sides and taking into account the changes through time)
The capability of the structure to resist any collapse was being eroded. One very obvious indication of this is the inward bowing of part of the perimeter. Each tower also twisted and tilted noticeably up to collapse. These demonstrate that the structure was responding to further weakening due to the heat. Loads were continually changing and redistributing during this time.
At some point a redistribution caused one or more columns to exceed its capacity. Column capacity in this case does not necessarily mean it original engineered load bearing ability. Loads were not necessarily on axis (due to impact or heat unduced creep, or expandin floor beams) and columns were not necessarily at room temperature, both of which would tend to lower any individual column's strength.

At this point a progression of column failures occurs. A column or columns fail and in redistributing the load, cause other columns to exceed capacity, causing another rapid load shift. Column failures rapidly progressed to all columns over one or more levels

A large section of the upper building is now falling, accelerating to next contact. A combination of factors result in few, if any, buckled columns impacting on lower parts of themselves. Upper falling section column ends are the first contacts with lower structure. That contact would be proximate to the lower section columns and thus the greatest impact occurs near or directly on lower floor truss to column connecting components.

This is occurring both to long span truss to column connecting components, at perimeter and belt truss, as well as with the core's beams running between core columns.

As upper mass continues its lowest floor begins contacting lower floors. This first contact is between floor systems that are already severely compromised. They are among those that have been affected by impact and heat and one has suffered loss of connections to columns as per last paragraph.

Concrete floor pans shatter.

Both upper structure and lower structure now have major connection failures, both in the vertical/horizontal connections as well as connections between column sections. The later is due to both the destruction of Lateral Support and the buffeting collisions from the falling mass.
Perimeter column "trees" peel away, the first to do so are on the order of 1000 feet above ground as they pivot away.

Collapse continues with a relatively small amount of falling mass being ejected at the collision interface. Since initial contact was an order of magnitude greater than that which the long span open floors could absorb, little effect is seen on the falling mass. This means that the still intact portion of upper mass will continue to accelerate.

Again first contact is the lower column ends, they will spear through that next lower floor. These next long span floors will now be impacted by more mass , albeit more rubblized, that is necessarily moving faster than first contact. Those floor spans must also be hit by an order of magnitude greater load than they can withstand, and indeed greater than at that earlier, first contact impact.

There existed no mechanism by which this floor pan, truss and perimeter peel, destruction could be arrested as this continues.

The core area beam destruction lags that of the long span destruction since those beams are heavier and shorter. Perimeter peel necessarily lags long span destruction as it is a direct result of that long span truss destruction.

Core columns stripped of inter-core Lateral Support succumb to a combination of slender column buckling and heavy buffeting from falling debris. A relatively small, heavily damaged, portion of the core remains after long span floor and perimeter destruction (no longer being buffeted by debris impact) but cannot remain intact and it comes apart as well
 
Last edited:
Agreed - great effort.

A few typos and two points of pedantry.

I've only posted the suggestions - the bits I've left out I agree with and commend your presentation style.

Revised

Generic Description of the Collapse Progression of the Two WTC Towers:
.... and columns were not necessarily at room temperature, <<Awkward wording??

Column failures rapidly progressed to all <<?? not "all" columns over one or more levels

A large section of the upper building is now falling, accelerating to next contact.... << You are conflating two stages and the transition. BUT probably valid for the level of audience for this summary - the two issues are - (1) not "all columns" - just to the stage where the Top is no longer supported THEN the surviving columns fail near instantly. (2) explicit distinguishing of "initiation" and "progression" HOWEVER I think your judgement of the level of sophistication needed by your intended audience could be spot on. So leave it as is?

A combination of factors result in few, if any, buckled columns impacting on lower parts of themselves. Upper falling section column ends are the most significant first contacts with lower structure. (I think you should get away with "first" but it is probably not strictly true.)

Again first contact is the lower column ends, <<Depends how far down - remember we have simultaneousness destroy down and destroy up - not crush either way. So by 15 >> 20 storeys the integrity of top block is gone. It starts with column end impacts dominating BUT as it falls it becomes dominated by "accumulated debris"

The core area beam destruction lags << "lags" is a reasonable probability - it certainly would not lead
Core columns stripped of inter-core lateral support succumb to
<<changed to lower case
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom