Good suggestion, OMGturt1es. Thirded.
For pure, sickening stundieheadedness I had to go with the Louder than Words team's press release. There are many classic cases of sheer stupidity in the nominations, but LTW's grandiose delusions on top of their known stupid beliefs get my official thumbs-down in this wrestling arena of splitters.
ETA: Good work again, Moby, with compiling the nominations.

That must take quite a while to do.
Suggestion
vetoed!
Sorry guys, but the only way to allow multiple votes is to allow multi-voting. There's no way to allocate preferences, or to limit the votes per person.
It's tricky, but you're going to have to live with picking your favourite of them all!

Yep, that's definitely a classic.
Moby, have you thought about getting in touch with the FSTDT webperson and helping create the CTSTDT site for these? I know they're not lost
forever here, but one link is easier than searching, at least for lazy types like myself.
I might drop them an email...
Finalist 10 has been selected on an incorrect basis and should therefore be voided. The original nomination was on the basis that petgoat proposed that the WTC was wired with explosives by motivated junkies.
Let's keep it factual.
Yes, let's do keep it factual. In my introduction to that nomination I mention that the junkies are 'patsies'. The section of post that made it through to the finals is what I considered to be the "Stundiest" part of the post, regarding the nature of junkies and how they would be recruited. The rest of the post is context, while the bit that made the finals is what put it over the edge.
So the request to void the nomination is denied.
The argument is not valid, as there are no operators. No "and," "or," "if-then," nothing. Just three unrelated statements. P says nothing about Q; Q does not support or expand P. R likewise just exists, neither posited by nor led to by p or q.
An argument must have at least one operator. His did not.
(ETA: never mind that all his "premises" got arrested for begging the question so much it was indecent.)
Bingo. (Well, partly. I'll continue this below.)
This Stundie worthiness of this nomination is disputed on two grounds...
1. Our interpretation of whether it is a field trip or a vacation is not Kevin Barrett's problem.
2. If using scene setting language is Stundie worthy then we'd better start nominating every author that ever existed.
This made it through to the finals for two reasons - that the trip Kevin Barrett describes sounds far more like a holiday than a business trip, and most importantly for the line,
"dreaming of interviews with elusive still-living suicide hijackers."
The hijackers are dead, William. Not elusive.
Request to void the nomination is denied.
Really, is this Stundie worthy on this basis?
Yes. It is an invalid argument that was used to advance the hypothesis that WTC 7 was a controlled demolition. It is made funnier because the author actually structures it as though it is a valid argument form, unaware that it is not.
I disagree.
All three points are related.
P - Y stated X
Q - Y is reliable
R - therefore X
OR:
John said the house burned down.
John is reliable.
Therefore the house burned down.
This makes sense. In fact, Prep2 in this regard is IDENTICAL to an argument frequently used by debunkers "Are you calling the FDNY liars?" etc. The corner stone of the entire debunking to the WTC7 CD argument is Prep2 - that there is no reason to believe the FDNY are being deceitful in their testimonies.
The conclusion is the ONLY logical conclusion based on Prep1 and Prep2. The problem is simply that Prep1 is not true.
Again, simply stating something that is not true is not a Stundie-worthy statement, otherwise every single CTer post should be nominated (okay there's probably a valid argument that they should!).
-Gumboot
The first thing to point out of course, is that the premises are incorrect. Right there rules out any hope of having a sound argument.
The second thing to point out is that mjd1982 is not using valid predicates in his argument. The supplied context is opaque, and as such cannot return a reliable truth value (see below for more discussion on this).
However, for arguments sake, let's try formalise what mjd1982 was arguing...
If we formalise what was actually said by mjd1982 into a formal logical argument, we end up with an invalid form. While tricky to do, the best I was able to manage was the following:
Tx: x is testimony that WTC 7 was blown up.
Sx: x was WTC 7.
Bx: x was blown up.
(∃x)(Tx & ~(∃y)(~Ty))
(∀x)(Tx ⊃ ~(~Tx))
∴ (∀x)(Sx ⊃ Bx)
Which in English translates as roughly:
There exists something such that it is testimony that WTC 7 was blown up, and there exists nothing that is testimony that WTC 7 was not blown up.
i.e. - There is testimony that WTC 7 was blown up, and it is uncontradicted.
For each thing in the universe, if it is testimony that WTC 7 was blown up then it is not testimony that WTC 7 was not blown up.
i.e. - We have no reason to disbelieve the testimony that WTC 7 was blown up.
Therefore, for each thing in the universe, if that thing is WTC 7 then that thing was blown up.
i.e. - WTC 7 was blown up.
Needless to say, this is not a valid argument. A counterexample to the argument can be found when:
Sa = 1
Ba = 0
Ta = 1
Tb = 1
Or in other words, when there is testimony that WTC 7 blew up, but when the object that corresponds to WTC 7 was not blown up. (i.e. People said that it blew up, but it actually didn't.)
You might wish to argue that this is not in fact the argument that mjd1982 put forward, but it is, quite frankly, the best argument I can make of it. Really, it is a non-issue however, because as I mentioned before the context given is not transparent, and so the argument cannot return a reliable truth value.
One other thing...
gumboot said:
All three points are related.
P - Y stated X
Q - Y is reliable
R - therefore X
OR:
John said the house burned down.
John is reliable.
Therefore the house burned down.
While you did make the successful leap to predicate logic (that I was avoiding in my explanation - because the argument is invalid regardless I thought I'd post the simple, snappy, form in which it was invalid), the argument you posted is a poor example to support mjd1982's case.
The reasons for such are a bit technical, but basically it has to do with the fact that, "the house burnt down," is not actually a valid predicate. This is because the context, "John said the house burned down," is an
opaque context - it does not define a predicate. We can plug whatever arbitrary statement we like in after "John said..." but we will never receive a reliable truth value.
To demonstrate an arbitrary statement:
John said seven.
John is reliable.
Therefore, seven.
John might have had perfectly good reasons for saying 'seven' (perhaps he was asked what five plus two equals), but the argument itself is nonsensical.
This problem is one that is often encountered when one is talking about specific lexemes, phrases or sentences. It is also a problem that is encountered when talking about what somenone has
said or
believes.
Just for another example of an opaque context (hopefully this will give you a little bit more understanding of what I am talking about):
"Mobyseven" has nine letters.
"Richard" does not have nine letters.
Therefore, Mobyseven is not Richard.
The context is once again opaque, as it does not define a predicate. In case something very drastic has happened since this morning, I assure you that Mobyseven
is Richard (even if I do not use my real name on the inter-webs very often).
And for those who were wondering - yes, a context that defines a predicate
is called a transparent context. Logicians are not a particularly imaginative bunch.
I hope that clears things up.
I dispute this nomination on the grounds that the relevance of these historical figures is subjective and that history has yet to judge any of the important figures in the 911 debate to the same extent.
With all due respect, William, the Louder Than Words crew are
not going to be remembered the same way as Rosa Parks, Nelson Mandela, et al are remembered, if they are remembered at all.
This is primarily because they are
wrong about the particular topic they are taking a stand for, and also because they have not done nearly as much or been nearly as courageous as the figures they compare themselves to.
I refer you to this month's language awards, where you can read a bit more detail about that particular statement in Redtail's nominated post.
And, last but not least, if you want to 'debunk' this month's Stundies, make your own damn thread about it and leave the people in this thread alone.
Mobyseven
Democratically Elected Tyrant