William Rea
Banned
- Joined
- Sep 4, 2006
- Messages
- 983
The argument is not valid, as there are no operators. No "and," "or," "if-then," nothing. Just three unrelated statements. P says nothing about Q; Q does not support or expand P. R likewise just exists, neither posited by nor led to by p or q.
An argument must have at least one operator. His did not.
(ETA: never mind that all his "premises" got arrested for begging the question so much it was indecent.)
Really, is this Stundie worthy on this basis?