Stundie Finals For May - Vote Now!

May Finalists

  • DYA - Shows his true colours.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • YBZ - "...a report that says the twin towers were hollow."

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • PAD - "Everyone agrees that the impact itself had no real affect on the structure."

    Votes: 6 4.9%
  • SCG - Atta, the "crazed, cocained-up, drug-smuggling" federal agent.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • LTW - "Like Rosa Parks, Simon Wiesenthal, Winston Churchill, and Nelson Mandela..."

    Votes: 25 20.3%
  • DRG - Explosives causing steel to melt.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • DrJ - Big rocks and "Hokie stone" facades.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • DJJ - Most uses of 'truth' in a nonsensical post.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • ROD - "judy wood rocks"

    Votes: 4 3.3%
  • PtG - Operation: Junkie.

    Votes: 5 4.1%
  • KvB - Kevin goes on location.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • DgH - "Because WE ARE IGNORANT OF 911 FACTS, WE DEMAND PROOF."

    Votes: 9 7.3%
  • SFT - On why you don't have to pay income tax unless you are a PERSON.

    Votes: 2 1.6%
  • MJD - [i]p, q, therefore r[/i] as an argument for the demolition of WTC 7.

    Votes: 1 0.8%
  • FRL - On why we have to go to war occasionally.

    Votes: 3 2.4%
  • MaK - "You need a pointy bit on the front. No pointy bit = no entry."

    Votes: 15 12.2%
  • 28K - The "[sic] wooden poll" experiment.

    Votes: 9 7.3%
  • wtb - "facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts."

    Votes: 20 16.3%
  • LUC - On the limited application of the scientific method.

    Votes: 8 6.5%
  • CAP - COnfuses a volcanic eruption with a nuclear weapons test.

    Votes: 4 3.3%

  • Total voters
    123
  • Poll closed .
The argument is not valid, as there are no operators. No "and," "or," "if-then," nothing. Just three unrelated statements. P says nothing about Q; Q does not support or expand P. R likewise just exists, neither posited by nor led to by p or q.

An argument must have at least one operator. His did not.

(ETA: never mind that all his "premises" got arrested for begging the question so much it was indecent.)

Really, is this Stundie worthy on this basis?
 
The argument is not valid, as there are no operators. No "and," "or," "if-then," nothing. Just three unrelated statements. P says nothing about Q; Q does not support or expand P. R likewise just exists, neither posited by nor led to by p or q.

An argument must have at least one operator. His did not.

(ETA: never mind that all his "premises" got arrested for begging the question so much it was indecent.)



I disagree.

All three points are related.

P - Y stated X
Q - Y is reliable
R - therefore X

OR:

John said the house burned down.
John is reliable.
Therefore the house burned down.

This makes sense. In fact, Prep2 in this regard is IDENTICAL to an argument frequently used by debunkers "Are you calling the FDNY liars?" etc. The corner stone of the entire debunking to the WTC7 CD argument is Prep2 - that there is no reason to believe the FDNY are being deceitful in their testimonies.

The conclusion is the ONLY logical conclusion based on Prep1 and Prep2. The problem is simply that Prep1 is not true.

Again, simply stating something that is not true is not a Stundie-worthy statement, otherwise every single CTer post should be nominated (okay there's probably a valid argument that they should!).

-Gumboot
 
Are you saying that I need a Degree in Communication to post?
You know very well that question you just posted is a strawman. You also know that you're not going to fool people on this forum with it. Try answering Gumboot's question instead of playing word games.
 
-5-

Nominated by Civilized Worm

[The Louder Than Words crew compare themselves to important historical figures...]


Originally Posted by Loose Change press release
Like Rosa Parks, Simon Wiesenthal, Winston Churchill, and Nelson Mandela, we will not veer from our course and we will not shut up.

I dispute this nomination on the grounds that the relevance of these historical figures is subjective and that history has yet to judge any of the important figures in the 911 debate to the same extent.
 
Last edited:
It is your problem, because you are the one disputing the nomination.

It is not my problem, if 8den is unable to comprehend my basically stated argument then I have no wish to dispute the nomination with him. There would clearly be no point debating with someone incapable of comprehending at that basic level.
 
You know very well that question you just posted is a strawman. You also know that you're not going to fool people on this forum with it. Try answering Gumboot's question instead of playing word games.

How is it a strawman? Gumboot asked me if I have studied Communication as a tertiary subject. I asked if that level of study is required to post here?

Are your comprehension skills also lacking?
 
I dispute this nomination on the grounds that the relevance of these historical figures is subjective and that history has yet to judge any of the important figures in the 911 debate to the same extent.
It is nominated for the arrogance it displays.

It is not my problem, if 8den is unable to comprehend my basically stated argument then I have no wish to dispute the nomination with him. There would clearly be no point debating with someone incapable of comprehending at that basic level.
Personal attack against 8den reported for breech of civility rule
How is it a strawman? Gumboot asked me if I have studied Communication as a tertiary subject. I asked if that level of study is required to post here?

Are your comprehension skills also lacking?
He asked if you studied communication as a tertiary subject. He did not ask you if you had a degree in communication. Neither did he suggest that such a degree should be required. Your responding to his post as though he had done so is where you committed the strawman fallacy.
 
I disagree.

All three points are related.

P - Y stated X
Q - Y is reliable
R - therefore X

OR:

John said the house burned down.
John is reliable.
Therefore the house burned down.

This makes sense. In fact, Prep2 in this regard is IDENTICAL to an argument frequently used by debunkers "Are you calling the FDNY liars?" etc. The corner stone of the entire debunking to the WTC7 CD argument is Prep2 - that there is no reason to believe the FDNY are being deceitful in their testimonies.

The conclusion is the ONLY logical conclusion based on Prep1 and Prep2. The problem is simply that Prep1 is not true.

Again, simply stating something that is not true is not a Stundie-worthy statement, otherwise every single CTer post should be nominated (okay there's probably a valid argument that they should!).

-Gumboot

Apart from the last bracketed part of the last sentence I wholeheartedly agree with Gumboot on this one.

Good post.
 
It is nominated for the arrogance it displays.

In which case it is a personal attack on the people and not and attack on their argument.

Personal attack against 8den reported for breech of civility rule.

No problem.

He asked if you studied communication as a tertiary subject. He did not ask you if you had a degree in communication. Neither did he suggest that such a degree should be required. Your responding to his post as though he had done so is where you committed the strawman fallacy.

It is my understanding that tertiary is study at higher education level.

I thought I was asking a question not making an argument, I will of course now revise my procedures for the use of question marks in sentences.
 
Last edited:
It is not my problem, if 8den is unable to comprehend my basically stated argument then I have no wish to dispute the nomination with him. There would clearly be no point debating with someone incapable of comprehending at that basic level.

No See, I speakie the english verly good. You said it had been selected on an incorrect basis, and refused to elaborate as to why. I asked for clarification you declined. And got in a huff.
 
And what relevance does that have?

I think it would be good if you would provide some input into the other threads here instead of nitpicking at a bit of fun we have while we're debating the real issues in other threads.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom