StopSylviaBrowne - Open Letter to Montel Wiliams: An Answer?

So what was answered?

In fact, you just made a rather limp attempt to shift a critique of an obviosu appeal to emotion and nebulous concepts by making an appeal to more emotion.

I've already showed elsewhere that Sylvia Browne's matching rate from live, unedited sessions from Larry King (as well as those for other readers) is not stellar. Asking if one finds her entertaining or not is irrelevant, as the issue is one of examining claims, you know, actual skepticism?

Is the new skepticism to revert to appeals to emotion, politics, and stuff like that? Where are actual objective, numerical analyses of readings that you guys should be producing?
 
However, the whole article is dishonest. If Montel responds, he is already seen as a supporter of Browne, which goes against what skeptical clubs stand for. If he doesn't reply, he is demonized as being without honor. Pseudoskeptics make sure to set up a lose-lose scenario in their lame battle to 'get' Sylvia Browne (in this case by using a talk show host as proxy).
Why do you assume that there is no response Montel could make that would adequately explain his airing of Sylvia episodes? If Montel responds, and justifies these episodes, what then? (The lose-lose scenario is yours--does that make you a pseudoskeptic?)

I can conceive of several responses that Montel might give to Hal's letter that would satisfy me--some I would disagree with, but would certainly accept as legitimate. Of course, I am not (nor is anyone I know) a member of a "skeptical club", so perhaps your post is not intended to describe my behavior. I can also conceive of the possibility that Montel might have a response that I had not anticipated at all, one which demonstrates his honor while simultaneously defending his airing of Sylvia episodes.

Your description of a "lose-lose scenario" presupposes both Montel's behavior and the behavior of "skeptical clubs". With those presuppositions, perhaps the article might be dishonest; I suggest, though, that this speaks more to your presuppositions than to either Montel or skeptics.
 
Is the new skepticism to revert to appeals to emotion, politics, and stuff like that? Where are actual objective, numerical analyses of readings that you guys should be producing?

Just to get the rest of us up to speed, could you please expand on this "new skepticism", and point out where RSL's site claims to be part of it? Maybe I missed getting the manual in the mail or something...
 
So what was answered?

In fact, you just made a rather limp attempt to shift a critique of an obviosu appeal to emotion and nebulous concepts by making an appeal to more emotion.

I've already showed elsewhere that Sylvia Browne's matching rate from live, unedited sessions from Larry King (as well as those for other readers) is not stellar. Asking if one finds her entertaining or not is irrelevant, as the issue is one of examining claims, you know, actual skepticism?

Is the new skepticism to revert to appeals to emotion, politics, and stuff like that? Where are actual objective, numerical analyses of readings that you guys should be producing?

Answer the question, T'ai. Do you find Sylvia Browne entertaining?

Your response need not be more than 2-3 letters and a punctuation mark.
 
T'ai Chi - I think it more accurate to say that Sylvia Browne's matching rate from live, unedited sessions from Larry King is none existent, unless you have better evidence.

But that would be an appeal to logic, evidence and "stuff like that".
 
Last edited:
What are you whining about? Skeptics bemoaning the damage a phony psychic does? That bothers you? Don't read it.

As far as producing cogent analyses of claims, go to some of the other threads. They're there just waiting for you to ignore them. :xtongue
 
As incredibly dangerous and offensive as her work as a "psychic detective" is, even if Sylvia Browne had never done a single missing persons case, she'd still be extraordinarily harmful.
Agreed, EMM. Thanks for spelling it out from first-person perspective.

I didn't commit the first to memory and I reread the current article, but just on a 'gut feeling' it now reads more akin to the rest of your articles, a little distant and fact driven. I did prefer the first better, but then there is the audience to consider...

Umm, Kilgore? I haven't changed it. :confused:

(Edited to add: By "I toned it down, believe me" I meant that I had toned it down before even putting it on the site.)

Sometimes I feel like I'd really like you to let loose some choice words-you-can't-say-on-television..
You and me both, Kilgore.

But I know that would do more harm than good.
Yup.
 
Last edited:
Hell, even getting him to answer the question "Do you believe Sylvia Browne is psychic?" would be a start. I've read three quotes now of him dancing around it.

I can see that now:

Skeptic: Do you believe Sylvia Browne is psychic?

Montel: No, I do not. I'll say it now and I'll say it again. I don't believe in psychics. I believe in Sylvia Browne becausewhat she has isn't psychic abilities, its intuition. And I've seen her do amazing things right here in this room, yada, yada, yada, blah, blah, blah.

He's not going to let you interrupt and ask a follow-up question, just go off on his speech.

Here's something about Montel (from someone who's been on his show three times now): he's an extremely charismatic and convincing speaker. It's a testament to him that he almost made a skeptic like me suspend my disbeliefs about SB's abilities. I'd buy the Brooklyn Bridge with the Eiffel Tower "thrown in absolutely free!" from him.

He wasn't a motivational speaker once for nothing. He's not a talk show host for nothing. He's hard to confront because he's so beguiling and knows exactly how to make himself completely and totally innocent.

You see it when he talks about politics- he knows absolutely nothing about it (what well-informed observer of politics would agree with him that George Bush is going to be the president to legalize marijuana?!) but manages to fake his way through and sell you on it the way a self-help guru or bs motivational speaker manages to convince an audience of what they know ain't so.

He gets away with dancing around it is what I'm saying. In print, he comes off much weaker.
 
Last edited:
In fact, you just made a rather limp attempt to shift a critique of an obviosu appeal to emotion and nebulous concepts by making an appeal to more emotion.
Declaring false hope "horrible," and then relating instances of Sylvia Browne giving false hope, as LostAngeles did, is not an Appeal to Emotion. This is a perfectly valid argument.

And I must point out that emotion is not excluded from logical argumentation. It is acceptable when it is (A) relevant and (B) used for motivational rather than diversionary purposes. Thus, there are Relevant Appeals to Emotion and Fallacious Appeals to Emotion. It's important to distinguish between the two.
 
Oh, Rob-

I recently came across the Stop Kaz site and I re-read it (cause I've checked it out before) and a detail caught my attention: the mention of ladders in the elevator shafts in the whole The Towering Inferno story of her escape.

I remembered you telling Penn Jillette about this on his radio show and I asked my father, a building repairman, if he has ever seen ladders in elevator shafts.

"Oh yeah, sure, all the time."

"Really? On what floor?"

"On the basement floor. From the last floor to the bottom of the pit. To climb down to clean out the bottom of the elevator shaft."

"You've never seen it anywhere except in the pit? You know, how in movies like Die Hard or The Poseidon Adventure they climb down ladders?"

"That's impossible."

I knew there was something fishy about her story! :)
 
Last edited:
SG- You are so right when you say the Williams has no honor. Honor can not be bought. All MW cares about these days are ratings and the almighty buck. He makes me want to puke.
 
Gut feelings and that sense of knowing something just ain't right can be construed [sp?] as "psychic abilities". Personally, I believe the word and today's meaning of psychic is more of a generic term rather than something specific. One can tune into intuitive system [for lack of a better phrase]. One can also fine tune that system. A hightened sense of awareness of your surroundings is a good example. I believe LEO's [law enforcement officers] and such are a good example of this.

I hope I explained this right. ;)
 
Questions for Montel
1. See post 7
2. What is intuition (in detail)?
3. Give examples of the amazing things she has done.

If he losses his enthusiasm for her, then maybe he will not come to her rescue when she gets into trouble.
 
Umm, Kilgore? I haven't changed it. :confused:

(Edited to add: By "I toned it down, believe me" I meant that I had toned it down before even putting it on the site.)
Ohhh, well then never mind. :blush: It must have just been from having read it once, then a couple hours later rereading it (and the power of suggestion... curious, that..).
 
I just dont get it.

A guy who is close to tears most of his shows because of the injustices that face our society is saying he finds Sylvia and her scamming people of money "hysterical".

I'd be interesting in hearing that interview myself. (though I obviously believe you)
 
So what was answered?

In fact, you just made a rather limp attempt to shift a critique of an obviosu appeal to emotion and nebulous concepts by making an appeal to more emotion.

I've already showed elsewhere that Sylvia Browne's matching rate from live, unedited sessions from Larry King (as well as those for other readers) is not stellar. Asking if one finds her entertaining or not is irrelevant, as the issue is one of examining claims, you know, actual skepticism?
Not stellar?! :jaw-dropp

According to the transcripts on your Aura site, she manages to guess once out of 14 attempts at cause of death (where the reader suggests cause before sitter).

(your references:
Transcript/Reading
2 10
2 11
2 15
2 22
3 39
3 40
3 43
6 56
9 80
9 82
9 86
14 178
16 204
16 218)

Even then, her guess was "Percussion to the head" and the cause of death was being hit by a truck!!!!!! (http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0005/05/lkl.00.html)
So I think I was being pretty generous in giving her even THAT hit (no pun intended).

Is the new skepticism to revert to appeals to emotion, politics, and stuff like that? Where are actual objective, numerical analyses of readings that you guys should be producing?
When are you going to add Cold Reader data to your, currently one-sided, analysis?
 
Last edited:
He wasn't a motivational speaker once for nothing. He's not a talk show host for nothing. He's hard to confront because he's so beguiling and knows exactly how to make himself completely and totally innocent.
Agreed, EMM.

Thus, there are Relevant Appeals to Emotion and Fallacious Appeals to Emotion. It's important to distinguish between the two.
Yup.

"You've never seen it anywhere except in the pit? You know, how in movies like Die Hard or The Poseidon Adventure they climb down ladders?"

"That's impossible."

I knew there was something fishy about her story! :)
Yeah, the "pit" is mentioned on the site, in the article about the elevator pros weighing in. Glad your Dad clinched it for ya! :)

Ohhh, well then never mind. :blush: It must have just been from having read it once, then a couple hours later rereading it (and the power of suggestion... curious, that..).
Good to know, though! Next time someone complains about an article, I'll just say "Okay, I've reworked it, what do you think now?" :D

I'd be interesting in hearing that interview myself. (though I obviously believe you)
D'oh!!!

I should have mentioned here that the entire 15-minute segment can be downloaded from this page:

http://1067freefm.com/pages/1345.php

Scroll down and look for "4/25- Seg 8- Montell Williams calls in"

I was going to put that link in the article's "Related Links" section, but that day's entries will only be available for another few days.
 
Thanks for the follow-up, Robert. I'm still hopeful Hal will get a proper response from Montel, but I'm not holding my breath.
 
Robert, I went to the Junkies website and listened to the parts you quoted in your article. I filled in who the hosts were for what questions they asked:

J.P. Flaim: Talking to talk show host Montel Williams, and today he's got psychic Sylvia Browne on. Can you ask her who’s going to win the NBA finals? I need to make some money.

(Montel) Williams: Yeah! You know what, I’m trying to make some money too... I'm gonna ask her, I’ll see if she’ll, she'll give it up. It’s really funny she’s ah, she's not a big sports fan but she will definitely throw down on personalities and what’s going on in people’s relationships in a heartbeat.

Eric Bickel: Do you believe in that stuff Montel? Be honest.

Williams: No!! Come on, I’ve said it clearly on my show a million times, I don’t believe in psychics. You know, I happen to believe that, that for, for whatever reason, this woman has a little bit more intuition than most people I know...



Williams (cont'd): ...you look at her, you listen to her, she gives some of the funniest answers, people love her, and hate her! But you have a right to do either one. She happens to be on today if you want to love her or hate her, or look at her and just laugh.

Eric Bickel: Is she one of those who claims she can talk to the dead, and all that?

Williams: Umm…she doesn’t claim like she actually talks to them, but she kinda...

Eric Bickel: They communicate some how?

Williams: They pass through her. Yeah, she communicates, they pass through.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom