StopSylviaBrowne - Open Letter to Montel Wiliams: An Answer?

This article seems to have a bit more emotion to it. Deservedly so, but it does seem a bit unlike other articles. Very well done. I only wish that somehow Montel would read it.

From the postcard: "Many of our show ideas come directly from letters just like yours." Hm... Somehow, I doubt that. But it'd be nice if they did tape a show questioning the honor of Montel.

And as for Montel's comment about you can love her, hate her, or laugh at her, I don't think anyone is laughing at this point, except Sylvia herself.

Now the audio clip stops after 15 seconds.. I tried with both VLC and Windows Media Player.
 
Last edited:
Because I live in the DC area, and the Junkies are one of the morning programs I occasionally listen to, I was going to see which of the Junkies was actually talking. Unfortunately, the audio link does not seem to be working. However, out of the four Junkies, John Auville ("Cakes"), Eric Bickel ("EB"), Jason Bishop ("Lurch"), and J.P. Flaim ("J.P."), J.P. Flaim is usually the one who asks guests questions. However, until I hear the audio I won't be able to tell.

ETA: I tried listening to the audio again, and it worked for about 15 sec., like Kilgore Trout said. To me, it sounds like the host is J.P. Flaim.
 
Last edited:
If the producers were really given the information, maybe another response will come from them*. Perhaps this one they just send out, by default, first, to anyone who writes a letter.


(* Yeah, I know. It's very slim. But, still a possability, right?)
 
My guess is that someone needs to actually ask Montel this about Sylvia in person and on air and make damn sure he doesn't sidestep the issue. My first question would be "How do feel about Sylvia being wrong about a, b, and c [names of the victims] predictions? How can you justify you supposed honor in defrauding these families of these victims?" I'd love to hear his answer to those questions.
 
My guess is that someone needs to actually ask Montel this about Sylvia in person and on air and make damn sure he doesn't sidestep the issue. My first question would be "How do feel about Sylvia being wrong about a, b, and c [names of the victims] predictions? How can you justify you supposed honor in defrauding these families of these victims?" I'd love to hear his answer to those questions.


Exactly. And if he truly feels justified in having Sylvia on his show then he should have no problem being asked these questions and having his answers go on the record. If he continually sidesteps the questions then he must be aware that makes him appear to be greedy and uncaring.
 
I can't really say I'm all that surprised.
Nor I, sad to say.

This article seems to have a bit more emotion to it. Deservedly so, but it does seem a bit unlike other articles. Very well done. I only wish that somehow Montel would read it.
:(

No, I know what you mean. And believe me, I toned it down.

From the postcard: "Many of our show ideas come directly from letters just like yours." Hm... Somehow, I doubt that. But it'd be nice if they did tape a show questioning the honor of Montel.
Ouch.

And as for Montel's comment about you can love her, hate her, or laugh at her, I don't think anyone is laughing at this point, except Sylvia herself.
I do get the occasional email from someone who thinks Browne is really amusing. I point out a few specific articles on the site, and they usually become quickly unamused.

Now the audio clip stops after 15 seconds.. I tried with both VLC and Windows Media Player.
I am having some trouble with FTP at the moment, or perhaps it is just with that one file. I'll mention on thisthread when it is fixed.

ETA: I tried listening to the audio again, and it worked for about 15 sec., like Kilgore Trout said. To me, it sounds like the host is J.P. Flaim.
Once the whole clip is working, I'd be curious to know if yo still think so. It sounded to me like one guy asking all the questions, but I would swear to it.

If the producers were really given the information, maybe another response will come from them*. Perhaps this one they just send out, by default, first, to anyone who writes a letter.
You know, it's even possible that Montel will still respond to it. Maybe the letter has been sitting in a big bin with thousands of other letters, and they're just now getting to it. In fact, I meant to mention that in the article. Maybe I'll insert it.

My guess is that someone needs to actually ask Montel this about Sylvia in person and on air and make damn sure he doesn't sidestep the issue.
Hell, even getting him to answer the question "Do you believe Sylvia Browne is psychic?" would be a start. I've read three quotes now of him dancing around it.

If he continually sidesteps the questions then he must be aware that makes him appear to be greedy and uncaring.
Agreed.

Unbelievable. Williams has no honor.
I'm hoping some day he will prove otherwise.
 
My guess is that someone needs to actually ask Montel this about Sylvia in person and on air and make damn sure he doesn't sidestep the issue. My first question would be "How do feel about Sylvia being wrong about a, b, and c [names of the victims] predictions? How can you justify you supposed honor in defrauding these families of these victims?" I'd love to hear his answer to those questions.

I nominate Jon Stewart and the Daily Show for this.

-David
 
The "Ask Montel" girl told you so. That must be the standard answer he invented for any skeptic who's path he might cross: "She's just super intuitive, I don't believe in psychics and I've never had any psychic but her on ever."
 
"honor" is such an ill-defined thing. In fact, the web page owner nor the article writer didn't even define it.

However, the whole article is dishonest. If Montel responds, he is already seen as a supporter of Browne, which goes against what skeptical clubs stand for. If he doesn't reply, he is demonized as being without honor. Pseudoskeptics make sure to set up a lose-lose scenario in their lame battle to 'get' Sylvia Browne (in this case by using a talk show host as proxy).

Why not just stick to science? Nah, not emotional enough. ;)
 
"honor" is such an ill-defined thing. In fact, the web page owner nor the article writer didn't even define it.

However, the whole article is dishonest. If Montel responds, he is already seen as a supporter of Browne, which goes against what skeptical clubs stand for. If he doesn't reply, he is demonized as being without honor. Pseudoskeptics make sure to set up a lose-lose scenario in their lame battle to 'get' Sylvia Browne (in this case by using a talk show host as proxy).

Why not just stick to science? Nah, not emotional enough. ;)
Slightly off topic, but I am curious-is there any paranormal silliness you won't defend, or is it an "in for a penny, in for a pound" type of deal?
 
To answer T'ai Chi's question:

The other day, I posted a transcript here. In it, Browne says, and I underlined it:

...But I think false hope is also horrible, don't you think? I think that's terrible. I mean, every day, they're waiting -- and I heard a little bit before you came on - - the phone to ring, her to show up. That's horrifying. That's horrifying.
...

False hope is horrible. The hope that your granddaughter is still alive, even if she's in horrible conditions, you might get her back, see her smile again. The hope that your mother has simply gone off her rocker and is alive somewhere. The hope that your daughter is alive, although on drugs, and you'll see her again, you can bring her home. Those are false hopes given by Browne for, "entertainment purposes."

Well, T'ai, are you entertained? Answer us honestly now, do you find Sylvia Browne entertaining?
 
Something I've wanted to get across for a long time-

As incredibly dangerous and offensive as her work as a "psychic detective" is, even if Sylvia Browne had never done a single missing persons case, she'd still be extraordinarily harmful.

I'll never forget the grieving people I saw on Montel's show, people in tears, coming to her for information about people they've lost, that she coldly and cheaply lies to.

A woman who burst into tears when told her deceased mother was happy with the care they had given her. A mother who's son committed suicide. A very young man who had unexpectedly lost his father.

Not only is she stepping on their memories, she's exploiting their grief and adding to it with the cold and compassionless way she treats them and their suffering. And severly adding to their distress when they find out she's a fraud. That's when she gives them good news. When she gives them bad, she adds to whatever guilt and remorse they had, like with the man who wanted to know if his brother forgave him for whatever it is he did.
 
Last edited:
No, I know what you mean. And believe me, I toned it down.
I didn't commit the first to memory and I reread the current article, but just on a 'gut feeling' it now reads more akin to the rest of your articles, a little distant and fact driven. I did prefer the first better, but then there is the audience to consider... Sometimes I feel like I'd really like you to let loose some choice words-you-can't-say-on-television.. But I know that would do more harm than good.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom