StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: "Your Father is Not Your Father"

I seem to remember back in an old Physical Anthropology class that when we started learning about blood types etc. there was a study done in some small town in the U.S. where they were mapping blood types for some reason*. An interesting side effect of the study was finding out that a surprising percentage of the townspeople had children with blood types that couldn't have come from their fathers. The upshot being that this sort of thing (infidelity and children from different fathers) isn't as rare as one would think.

My point being that again, the more prevalent this sort of thing is, the more likely that Sylvia just got a good guess in (if she is in fact right on this one).

*Man, I wish I could remember the actual study. Anybody have an idea?
 
Last edited:
Not sure, Sasha. The transcript has the woman saying "I love my daddy" which may or may not mean he is still alive. But a careful listening to the video makes me think she says "I loved my daddy." Certainly, if he is still alive, this being shown on national television must have had an effect on him.

Slowing it down, it sounds like " 'cause I'd lost my daddy." If she just says her v like an s then it is most likely a present tense love rather than the past tense loved. Either way, it doesn't matter much because she could still use the present tense "love" even if her father is dead.

I hope she contacts you and is willing to put the guess to the test.
 
Oh definitely, but I meant it's a safe bet in the cold reading angle / apparent lack of surprise on the woman's part.

An alternative explanation is that the woman was not told anything new. She already suspected that the man she called Dad was not her Father.

I'm telling you, the episode was edited. I'd lay money on it, having seen how readings are cropped, reaction shots are matched, etc. That could not have been the entire exchange- just doesn't play quite the way it would have in real time.

Another scenario that occurs to me is that this woman's family situation was one that would have made this impossible.

For example, perhaps the mother she refers to was actually her stepmother, making this information nonsensical. And she was too puzzled or shocked to say so.

Or maybe, conversely, she was raised by her stepfather and didn't want to say "Well of course my father wasn't my biological father."
 
Btw, isn't it interesting that she only seems to be psychic enough to come up with initials, and not full names? :rolleyes:

Hold up now, she almost always calls them dark-skinned / swarthy even if the actual perpetrators are lily white. It's the color of their soul shining through, you see?
 
I sincerely hope that this woman persues this matter (if possible), instead of blindly accepting Browne's "psychic" revelation. It is obvious however, that even if the daughter is able to arrange a DNA test, and even if it proves that the father figure in question is indeed the parent, Browne has still done considerable damage to the mother's reputation. It is a terrible shame that the family cannot seek legal redress against the Montel Williams show and/or Browne in the event that the reading proves to be erroneous.

How anyone can still entertain the possibility that Ms. Browne is a compassionate individual is quite beyond me. Once again, she has demonstrated through her attitude and actions that she is little more than a crass boor. If Browne had but one decent bone in her body, she would have taken this poor lady aside and imparted the geneological "knowledge" in secret, away from the audience and cameras.:mad:
 
Last edited:
How anyone can still entertain the possibility that Ms. Browne is a compassionate individual is quite beyond me. Once again, she has demonstrated through her attitude and actions that she is little more than a crass boor. If Browne had but one decent bone in her body, she would have taken this poor lady aside and imparted the geneological "knowledge" in secret, away from the audience and cameras.:mad:

There's a good reason why she doesn't pull people aside and give them shocking news in private: the outlandish drivel she spouts is one more thing that makes her "real" in the eyes of her believers. They figure she couldn't possibly know something like this unless she could see it through her spirit guides. Compassion, of course, never enters into her schtick.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom