StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: "Your Father is Not Your Father"

I remember the discussion when the episode aired. Even reading about it again, I'm still flabbergasted.

I liked the inclusion of Browne's family history because it seems an obvious question of why in the world would she tell someone that, made up or not. And it seems perhaps she just doesn't think it's a big deal at all.
 
Exactly! I thought she had reached rock bottom, but this is a new low.

I also didn't think I could have any more contempt for Montel Williams, but he's also proved me wrong.

Whenever I think I couldn't like him and her any less, they surprise me.

I think any dark-skinned person could be "gypsy-looking" to Sylvia. I'd rather take the mother and daughter for Hispanic/ Latin.

I'd be shocked that Montel could be so jokey and display such levity about something this serious (as Sylvia did, as well) but then I saw him make light of someone's brother's death with mine own eyes. So nothing he does could shock me at this point.
 
The woman's first reaction when told that her father is not her father seemed to me that she wasn't shocked or upset, because she was choosing to ignore what Sylvia Browne said. She knew it was nonsense and not worth considering. Then Montel had to sell the idea to make it TV worthy. Montel really seems to do most of the work any more. Browne just sits there and rattles off anything that comes to mind.
 
Absolutely hateful.

If there was a Sylvia Browne 'Top 10' evil acts, this would be certainly be up there.

The woman was numb I think. She seemed very vacant in her reactions.

:<
 
I can't believe her, but I think Hitch got it right. I think the woman just dismissed what Sylvia said and let it roll off her back.

Robert, I hope you get in touch with her and see if she did go with the DNA test.
 
I think I'd chip in for the DNA test too, but first I need to know how much Skeptic Guy is extorting from us before he'll change his avatar.

That might bust the budget.
 
Robert- after seeing the video again, I'm convinced it must have been edited down, the way so many readings on "my" episode were. I'm positive that there would have been more of an exchange and more of an reaction from the woman.

Obviously, I have nothing to go on except that I've seen the way these readings are manipulated and a feeling that it couldn't have played out quite like this...but if you ever come into contact with her, you should ask her if there was anything more.
 
I think I'd chip in for the DNA test too, but first I need to know how much Skeptic Guy is extorting from us before he'll change his avatar.

That might bust the budget.

I can't. I have another 18-hours or so before I can. I participated in the "Let Another Forum Member Choose Your Avatar" thread. Some forumites are not my friend...
 
I can't. I have another 18-hours or so before I can. I participated in the "Let Another Forum Member Choose Your Avatar" thread. Some forumites are not my friend...


Your avatar is very, very, very disturbing on many, many, many different levels :( :eek:

I am counting down the 18 hours :)
 
Last edited:
An alternative explanation is that the woman was not told anything new. She already suspected that the man she called Dad was not her Father.
 
An alternative explanation is that the woman was not told anything new. She already suspected that the man she called Dad was not her Father.

dying people wanting to get things off their chest is common and seeking it in the illegitimate children angle is a safe bet.

When my grandfather was on his deathbed, he wanted to tell my dad something and my father cut in and said "you have another kid somewhere?". It's not that my granddad was a shameless philanderer but a secret that big can show on a person. I guess my father should charge for stating the obvious.
 
Last edited:
Niobe said:
dying people wanting to get things off their chest is common and seeking it in the illegitimate children angle is a safe bet.

On national television? If Sylvia is sincere in her words, it would have been better if she told the woman about what she suspects, in private.

What if the father is stil alive. That'll leave him with questions. It would affect his trust and would bring him pain as the whole nation knows about that "family secret".

I really wish he is still alive so that he can sue Sylvia for libel.

Money, we can let go. Trust and love is hard to regain.
 
Last edited:
Oh definitely, but I meant it's a safe bet in the cold reading angle / apparent lack of surprise on the woman's part.
 
Another great article, RSL. It's unbelievable how insensitive this woman is.

Do you think it's worth cross-referencing this article with the piece of the e-mail sent by the woman who had the reading with Chris Dufresne, i.e. the part that he claims that the woman's mother had an affair with the milkman?

As I mentioned in another post, there seem to be certain themes to their readings which crop up again and again. Take, for example, the fact that Browne frequently tells people to take lecithin or, her claims that she came up with the initials of the perpetrators in the Ski-Mask rapist case and the Polly Klaas case. Btw, isn't it interesting that she only seems to be psychic enough to come up with initials, and not full names? :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom