StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: Weyman Robbins Reading

RSL - I think you're doing a great job with this, just a small suggestion for the site. In each analysis you do, you list the statements and assess Right, Wrong or Unknown and summarise what that is as a percentage. Any change of showing a running total based on all your reports on the home page, something like:
18% accurate over 75 readings and 235 statements

I personally think that will hit home somewhat from the outset and maybe get people thinking before they even start going through all articles.
 
I'd like to see Stitch's idea implemented on the front page. Would be nice to have. I also agree with GT's statement that you should make a note that Danny and Daniel are very similar names.
 
Last edited:
I actually don't think it's a good idea. Cold-reading isn't a matter of math or a science. You just can't measure it like that.

Take Weyman Robbin's case. I, personally, would break it down to a perfect zero, bordering on a negative number. "Danny" doesn't count for even half a point because she said he was a child who helped Weyman play the choking game.
 
Kudos to the PI! He's the one who should be getting thanked, not Sylvia.
Agreed.

Robert, I'm sure you agonized over your decision on the killer's name but I think that if you don't give SB (does that stand for Super [Rule 8]?) at least a half point for the Daniel/Danny connection you may give your critics an easy opportunity to say that you are totally biased. you don't look at the results, blah, blah, blah.
Thanks for the thought.

Actually, someone asked me the same question via email. Here is my response to them:

MeInEmail said:
I had considered that, but if you notice, all of the statements I scored were just that: direct quotes of statements she made during the reading. Her statement where she used the name Danny is this:

"One of the kids is named Danny."

That is an inaccurate statement. If I wanted to break down her statements and interpret them ("One of the killers was named Danny" would be such an interpretation), I could break down others and lower her score even further. For example, her statement "Well, they're right in the s--they're right in your neighborhood, in the area, in the school, every--you know. I mean, they're..." could have been broken down into three statements ("They're right in your neighborhood." "They're in the area." "They're in the school"), scoring all three as Wrong. I thought it fairer to judge the entire statement as a whole, as I did with "One of the kids is named Danny."

It's not an exact science, and I don't think I could ever please everybody, but I try to be fair, and I think I was in this case.

I personally think that will hit home somewhat from the outset and maybe get people thinking before they even start going through all articles.
It is something I have considered for when I have the page up linking all of the readings. I will definitely have a Right/Wrong/Unknown column on that page, but percentage overall? It's hazy enough ranking these things one at a time. An overall rating? Hard to do. Thanks for the suggestion, though.
 
Hey, did anyone else have an immediate red flag raised upon reading the uncle's alibi? I guess you could say it's confirmation bias at work but, I swear, the second I read that, I went "Huh?".

He was babysitting him and he didn't know where he was for almost two hours? Are you kidding me? What was his Plan B excuse, he was fishing with two bags of cement on Christmas Eve?

At best, he must have been brain dead or criminally negligent.
 
Last edited:
True, he wasn't a child but I just can't imagine anyone trusted with taking care of me when I was 12 (such as my aunt, who often did babysit us) doing that.

Unless things work differently in Mariscopa, Arizona, would anyone here let a charge wander off without knowing where he was?
 
Depends on the place and community, really.

In the big cities, not a chance. Where I grew up, sure thing. I certainly was left on my own many times even before I was 12. Because the worst crimes that ever happened there was the kind that a rascal like myself would join in. Such as shoplifting a chocolate.
 
Re: Weyman Arizona Robbins



This in regards to My son Weyman Arizona Robbins, There were articles in the paper. On april 1,2003 there was a front page article regarding the arrest of my brother. it is located in the casa grande newspaper(The casa grande dispatch) there is also a article regarding the sentencing of my brother.
Yes sylvia Browne was wrong, she gave me the inspiration to go on with this case because she did tell me there was foul play, that is also what I believed in my heart, I was to scared to ask if my brother had anything to do with it but boy did I want to , the show was tape febuary 12, 2003 and did not air till may 2003, you have to understand that under the circumstances I was willing to do what ever to find out the truth about my sons death. I did not walk away from that show feeling as though I knew so when I returned home on friday I got on the phone and started calling P.I's and made an appointment to meet with one that monday, I also chose one that did not live or work in my county for I did not trust anyone in that area anymore , mainly law enforcement. This has been the most painful heartbreaking ordeal I have ever been through and the truth is , its not over,,, I will live the rest of my life with the pain of loosing my sweet weyman, and devestated over the fact that my own brother did this to my weyman, my children , and myself and devestated that no seems to care and believe that he did not do this even though he confessed, he was the one that even asked for a Plea, if this were me you can bet you sweet a** that I would never confess to anything I did not do, let alone sign a plea.
 

Attachments

  • 100_0349.jpg
    100_0349.jpg
    196.3 KB · Views: 5
Mrs. Robbins, I'm very sorry and very grateful that you've come forward to tell us more about Sylvia Browne.

If it's not too personal, I'd like to ask you about that second segment. Did you first contact The Montel Williams Show to tell them Daniel was arrested or did they follow up on you? What exactly made you give Sylvia Browne credit if you now know she was totally wrong?
 
First of all my Brothers Name is Martin, second I contacted them to let them know what had happened, my intentions in the follow up was to thank my private investigators BoB Arthur and Joyce Black ( global investigations) but they deleted that part, the part you heard was me reading from a script that was handed to me in the last 30 minutes of taping, I was very hurt and upset by this and thought it to be unfair and unjust, my investigators were the only ones that truely listened to me and in the investigation the only ones that helped me and stuck by me to the end. they have become good friends of mine, it just breaks my heart how some people use other peoples heartace and grief to make a show for themselfs, sylvia Browne and Montel both had a hand in that. even the show was edited.
 
misty419, I'm really sorry you have had to endure so much pain. I wish you well.

misty419's post raises a whole different dimension of the Montel/SB shows that might be worth exploring, RSL. Apparently, what you see is NOT what is real. misty419 had to read from a script. Important parts were left on the cutting room floor. Etc.

I don't know how one would pursue this any further without, say, a mole inside the Williams production staff, but it seems to me to relevant to the overall credibility of SB.
 
Oh, I was positive his first name was Daniel from the second segment. That's very misleading what they made you read. So she got nothing right, nothing.

I'm absolutely disgusted and appalled. That's unforgivable. How do those people sleep at night? Whenever I think I can't possibly like Sylvia and Montel less.

If you don't mind me asking, can you shed some light on some of the statements analyzed in Robert Lancaster's article? The ones he counted as "Unknown"?
 
misty419, I'm really sorry you have had to endure so much pain. I wish you well.

misty419's post raises a whole different dimension of the Montel/SB shows that might be worth exploring, RSL. Apparently, what you see is NOT what is real. misty419 had to read from a script. Important parts were left on the cutting room floor. Etc.

I don't know how one would pursue this any further without, say, a mole inside the Williams production staff, but it seems to me to relevant to the overall credibility of SB.

That's right. I've been on a Sylvia Browne episode myself so I know they also go on for a long time; they leave themselves plenty of room for editing, for a show that's an hour minus all the daytime, basic TV commercials.

What I'd like to know is, how do they select the homicide/missing persons families anyway? I know they ambulance chased Ryan Katcher's mother; do they do that for every guest?
 
Not a problem, when sylvia says my son was there the whole time she was wrong, Martin said that he hid my sons body outside in the wash and when it was dark he then went outside and made it look like a suicide, Besides I was standing out there when the light was shone on the spot he was later found in and he was not there, when he was found he was wearing a white shirt and when you got to the corner of the front of the house you could see him plane as day. second she said that the police had the red bandana, that again is untrue, the police without a doubt do not have the bandana, I believe my brother burned it , he was seen for several days burning things. hopes this helps
 
Last edited:
I was selected because I happened to be watching the show and seen at the end that if you needed answers to something strange that happened to you to call, I called and left a detailed message, I was then contacted the next day and then the following week was sent to new york, we started the show at 11:00 am and did not leave the studio until 7:00 Pm that night
 
Yes, that's very helpful, thanks alot again for sharing.

So I assume that since your brother struck a deal, he was found guilty and is now in prison?
 
Misty, I am very sorry for your loss.

I'm Robert Lancaster, the person behind the Stop Sylvia Browne web site, where I have an article about your experience with Sylvia Browne (the link is in the first post in this thread).

I would like to add your thoughts about the Montel experience to the article.

Would you be interested in having your side of the story added to the article? If so, I would be interested in doing so.
 
Yes !!! I would greatly like to tell my side of the story, everyone has a right to know the truth, I am surprised on how many people have really showed and intrest in this, most important I would like to remind everyone that this is about weyman, a 12 year old little boy whom lost his life in an awful way. just let me know what you would like from me in detail.
 
Sorry for your loss, Misty.

It is a good thing that you can be of help to open the eyes of the people being fooled and hurt by things like these. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom