StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: Weyman Robbins Reading

yet another great job! The weight of your evidence keeps building...hopefully some believers will begin seeing SB for the fraud she is.
 
You're welcome!

I'm confused about the bandana. Did the uncle put it there to try to disguise the murder as a choking game accident? And what happened to it later?

I think you could have picked her predictions apart even further. Such as that she only even guessed it was the choking game after Montel got all the circumstances of the murder and a description of how the boy was found out of Misty.
 
Last edited:
Seems to me, based on what Robert has there...that the "choking game" is incidental and irrelevant...probably, Montell saw a nice, sensational angle by bringing it in and SB went with it. Not really an epidemic in our schools, so far as I can see or have read. SB often intimates at some sort of senational foul play...
 
Too bad we don't have video for this. Or any other information about the case cause I have a few more questions about it. It's pretty odd how there are no newspaper accounts but, then again, if even the police on the case didn't care the boy was killed...
 
The ultimate in hedging one's bet:
This was foul play. This was other kids. They were playing this stupid game.

She's covered if it's foul play and she's covered if it was just an accident resulting from a stupid game. Those are two mutually exclusive scenarios.

I'm reminded of Jim's hair-ball reading in Huckleberry Finn where he covers all possibilities, and the only hard prediction (that he'll die by hanging) is one that by the time it's verifiable, the sitter will be in no position to care about:
Yo' ole father doan' know yit what he's a-gwyne to do. Sometimes he spec he'll go 'way, en den agin he spec he'll stay. De bes' way is to res' easy en let de ole man take his own way. Dey's two angels hoverin' roun' 'bout him. One uv 'em is white en shiny, en t'other one is black. De white one gits him to go right a little while, den de black one sail in en bust it all up. A body can't tell yit which one gwyne to fetch him at de las'.
But you is all right. You gwyne to have considable trouble in yo' life, en con- sidable joy. Sometimes you gwyne to git hurt, en sometimes you gwyne to git sick; but every time you's gwyne to git well agin. Dey's two gals flyin' 'bout you in yo' life. One uv 'em's light en t'other one is dark. One is rich en t'other is po'. You's gwyne to marry de po' one fust en de rich one by en by. You wants to keep 'way fum de water as much as you kin, en don't run no resk, 'kase it's down in de bills dat you's gwyne to git hung.

Nice article, as always!
 
Yeah, I noticed that. Misty asks her if there was foul play and Sylvia says "Yes and no. It was and it wasn't."

I'm glad she did, though. Think how disasterous it could be if a psychic says it wasn't murder when it was. Enspecially in a situation like this, when the police arrived at the wrong conclusion and the family is running around on their own, convinced it was foul play.

The police ruled it an accident and closed the books on it and if Misty hadn't pressed on on her own, the guy would never have been caught. So thank God Sylvia told her it was a murder.And wasn't.
 
Last edited:
Another great article, Robert. Thanks very much for your efforts.

I’ve only seen the Montel Show a couple times. Do they ever have follow-up shows and review Sylvia’s predictions? I would think likely not, as they probably wouldn’t have much to talk about.
 
I have what is probably a dumb question, but, as far as I can tell, you could pretty much take any one of Sylvia's Montel readings and it would be wrong. The only hold-up, I guess, is that you have to be able to find information about the actual case.

That would be a really funny thing to do. Look back in the records and pick a Sylvia reading at random and find it to be wrong. OTOH, that could be just what EEM is doing...
 
Not quite. I specifically search for missing person's and homicide cases in the transcripts available on Lexis Nexis and, with the scraps of information provided in the readings (partial names, sometimes full names, approximate dates, states, cities, the name of a college or school, mentions of other players in the case), I try to follow up on all of them.

It's not random at all. In fact, it takes a lot of work and alot of sorting through many possible matches. It often takes me five to ten searches to dig up a full name. That's what most of my job consists of- just trying to put together the full name of the victim (the state he/she lived in and month and year of the crime are also helpful). After that, searching newspaper accounts is 1-2-3.

You understand, don't you? I mean, try searching Lexis Nexis for, say, "Angela" who was "murdered" or "Michael" who "disappeared". I'm literally searching through the haystack for a needle. Like in an autopsy, you have to know specifically what you're looking for in order to find it.

The vast majority of those that can be tracked down are as yet unsolved cases. Which is why they came to Sylvia Browne in the first place and why she can say anything she wants to about them- because most of these cases are at an absolute dead end and are never going to be solved.

This thread has a list of them: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=85304

It's very rare that I find something good enough for Robert's site. Almost all of the cases that I find are those that it's impossible to find any more material about them, cases that are dead in the water and unsolved where Sylvia will never be proved demonstrably wrong and cases that are, for one reason or another, unverifiable.

Such as one where Sylvia told a family their son didn't commit suicide but was murdered. Due to the circumstances (the police ruled it a suicide, didn't open a murder investigation, the only evidence pointing to foul play is that his sister thought she saw someone strange in the building minutes before he was found dead, it happened long ago) it might never be possible to know whether that was the cae or not.

Some are incredibly sad. Such as that of a teenage girl gone missing who was most likely kidnapped by her father's friend. Sadly, the only suspect in the investigation committed suicide shortly after she disappeared, destroying the only lead investigators had.

Or the parents of a baby girl who's paranoid schizophrenic grandmother kidnapped her and took her to a local river after which she was arrested without the child. The parents suspect she passed the kid to someone else in a kidnapping ring because the river was searched and no body was ever found and the grandmother has never confessed to murder but it seems to me she drowned the baby and that's that. After all, a body so small could easily have never been found.

Something like that, it's impossible to know how right or wrong SB was and might never be and is therefore completely useless to us. So you see, I follow up on one dead end, as far as the site is concerned, after another and hit the jackpot roughly 1 in 35 cases but there's no other way to do this kind of research.
 
Last edited:
yet another great job! The weight of your evidence keeps building...hopefully some believers will begin seeing SB for the fraud she is.
That is already happening, HS.

Nearly every day I receive email from one or more people who believed in Browne's nonsense, but after reading the site, do not believe in it any more.

And I think it is safe to assume that for each of these people there are a number of others who also came to that conclusion, but who didn't write.

I think that many (if not most) of these people would have come to that conclusion even without the SSB site's help, but the site definitely helped them get there faster.

Either way, the site is helping people. Just how many, we will never know.

I'm confused about the bandana. Did the uncle put it there to try to disguise the murder as a choking game accident? And what happened to it later?
No idea. No idea why the murderer would have put it on his ankle, either.

She's covered if it's foul play and she's covered if it was just an accident resulting from a stupid game. Those are two mutually exclusive scenarios.
Yes, I had meant to point that out. Thanks for reminding me, I migh add it in this evening.

Nice article, as always!
Thanks, Joe!

Another great article, Robert. Thanks very much for your efforts.
Thanks, M9B!

I’ve only seen the Montel Show a couple times. Do they ever have follow-up shows and review Sylvia’s predictions? I would think likely not, as they probably wouldn’t have much to talk about.
I have heard that they had a "follow-up show" or two some years back, but I am not aware of any recently. I have seen two instances of someone from a previous show coming back on to confirm something (the two sisters with the lupus/tipped uterus reading was one), but not an entire show devoted to it.

I have what is probably a dumb question, but, as far as I can tell, you could pretty much take any one of Sylvia's Montel readings and it would be wrong. The only hold-up, I guess, is that you have to be able to find information about the actual case.

In order to prove or disprove one of her readings/predictions on the show:

1. You have to be able to be relatively certain it was given fairly. This means you would have to exclude any reading/prediction which might have been given to a stooge, or given about a situation to which Browne had prior knowledge. This eliminates almost every reading she gives on the show. About the only things this leaves are (some of) her annual predictions, and the missing person homicide readings she gives on the show.

2. You have to be able to determine whether or not her prediction/reading was accurate. So, of those readings not eliminated by rule #1, we are left with those of her annual predictions which are testable, and those missing person and homicide cases which were later solved.

It is that last grounp that QG and EMM have been focusing on, and EMM gave a pretty good description of how tough it is to find cases which can be identified given the info in the show, and for which have a resolution available to a public search.
 
Speaking of follow-ups, there is another one I can think of. This military man, Terry Webb, went missing in Pennsylvania and his daughters appeared on the show and got the usual nonsense from Browne.

Someone was arrested and found guilty in his murder and the body was found and prior to his trial, his daughters inexplicably appeared on Montel to thank Sylvia. They shoehorned what she told them and asked her about the guy charged and how the trial would go and so on.

Incredible, how people can give SB credit for anything and I mean anything. Even when she's proven demonstrably wrong in something any sane person would consider a disaster.
 
Good job, both of you.

Just one little suggestion on the accuracy rate of your articles. Should it not be, to use this one as an example, 18-x%, rather than just 18%, where the 'x' refers to the percentage if the Unknown factors are indeed true, which they technically could be? After all, if she's wrong about the 'unknowns', which technically she could be, the percentage is higher than 18%. It doesn't matter much, seeing, as you say, apparently every article that measures her accuracy finds an accuracy percentage far lower than her stated 85%, but I think it'd be a more honest way of representing the statistics.
 
Thanks, Safe Keeper!

Actually, I was wondering whether it would be possible to find out the whole story by accessing the trial records. Aren't they open to the public?

Where did the murder take place? I know Weyman lived in both Arizona and Ohio...
 
I'm curious who initiated the the follow-up. I'm also curious just how instrumental Sylvia was in Ms. Robbins' decision to hire a private investigator since it seems as if Sylvia just confirms what the police (wrongly) ruled, although adding other children involved.

What Ms. Robbins has gone through and continues to endure is horribly tragic.

(also, you have a small typo in www.weymanrobbins.com at the bottom, though the link does work)
 
I seem to remember reading on one of the tributes that she actually hired the investigator before she appeared on the show. I'd certainly think so because he managed to solve the case before the episode aired.

Actually, let's give a big hand to the PI- he's the one who brought the killer to justice, not this con artist. :mad:
 
Good job, both of you.
Thanks, S-K!

Just one little suggestion on the accuracy rate of your articles.
I understand your point, but I've chosen to show the percentage we KNOW to be correct. Perhaps I should make that clearer.

Where did the murder take place? I know Weyman lived in both Arizona and Ohio...
Maricopa, Arizona.

(also, you have a small typo in www.weymanrobbins.com at the bottom, though the link does work)
Thanks, Kilgore. I will try to remember to fix it this evening.
 
I seem to remember reading on one of the tributes that she actually hired the investigator before she appeared on the show. I'd certainly think so because he managed to solve the case before the episode aired.

Actually, let's give a big hand to the PI- he's the one who brought the killer to justice, not this con artist. :mad:

From the follow-up it she said that Sylvia gave her reason to go on, implying (to me anyway) that that's the reason she hired a PI. I mean, it even if she hadn't gone on Montel, the PI wouldn't have left her at a loose end. But yes, you're right, the timing would be odd and he'd have had to have worked VERY fast (unless there was a long time between the time the show was taped and when the show was aired).
 
Kudos to the PI! He's the one who should be getting thanked, not Sylvia.
 
Robert, I'm sure you agonized over your decision on the killer's name but I think that if you don't give SB (does that stand for Super [Rule 8]?) at least a half point for the Daniel/Danny connection you may give your critics an easy opportunity to say that you are totally biased. you don't look at the results, blah, blah, blah.

Just a thought.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom