StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: Renquin/Nelson/DesVergnes Reading

I was all set to still argue the odds clearly favor the "yes" answer with respect to "the vehicle will be found".

But after consideration I can't come up with a good arguement and concede....curse you and logic!

While it could be argued that most man made things, unless intentionally destroyed, are eventually found - especially in a populated area such as Orlando....there is no way to discount the "intentionally destroyed" aspect, say if they had been murdered vs accidential death.

Esp since she doesn't say WHEN the vehicle will be found. The men's bodies could be found the next day, but the vehicle 10 years later, and she would still be able to say she was "right" about the vehicle.
 
Grayman - True, though there are lots of folks that provide information wrt crimes that turns out to be false. She could simply argue she was doing her part as a citizen and providing what she thought to be truthful information, and it is law enforcements job to filter out/expend resources.

Don't get me wrong....I think she is a total fraud, liar, gravy sucking pig, palomino brazen hussy, etc.; I just don't think the Government (local or federal) could prove she intentionally provided false information to aid in concealing a crime.

The Government could play the "she knowlingly provided false information" (ie. made it all up) aspect; but there is a army of SB "believers" out there that would provide enough reasonable doubt.
 
Last edited:
I would add to your conclusion though that her hit rate, low as it is, still exaggerates the appearance of how helpful she is in these cases. Saying whether the body will be found or not does NOTHING to help investigators, for instance. And if police did spend time following up on any of the "information" she provided, the net effect to the investigation is definitely detrimental.

Yeah, psychics never give information that's practically useful but a family would want to know if the body will be found.

At least she didn't tell them they would never be found because they were eaten by alligators. Or fell into a tar pit. Or had aleady decomposed.
 
Last edited:
Esp since she doesn't say WHEN the vehicle will be found. The men's bodies could be found the next day, but the vehicle 10 years later, and she would still be able to say she was "right" about the vehicle.

I was all set to argue with RL following the same line you did with respect to in time most man made things are found.

While I think the odds still favor the "yes" answer, the "intentional destruction" aspect is difficult to ignore. In the end, I'd have to agree with RL in that this (the odds being heavly favorable to the "yes") is less provable.
 
Forget the $400....I want to see Browne apologize to all people everywhere for being a fraud that prey's on the naïve; but I don’t think either event will happen anytime soon.
 
Esp since she doesn't say WHEN the vehicle will be found. The men's bodies could be found the next day, but the vehicle 10 years later, and she would still be able to say she was "right" about the vehicle.

It's not even a prediction in Browne's context. What were the men going to do: destroy their SUV and hide the parts before boating?
 
It's not even a prediction in Browne's context. What were the men going to do: destroy their SUV and hide the parts before boating?

True.

That's only a prediction for the rental car company about whether they'd ever get their car back.

Speaking of which, what does a rental car company do if something like this happens? Charge the dead man's credit card?
 
[ Devils Advocate]
"Yes, but this is 9 she got wrong out of (insert random number).
Nobody can be right all the time"
[/Devil's Advocate]

Doesn't matter how stupid it is; one of her psychophants will say it.

Trouble is, the fans are always going to assume that every reading Sylvia gives that RSL does NOT cover are 100% accurate. They think he cherry picks for the 13% failures Sylvia allows herself. Nevermind the plea for examples of Sylvia giving accurate readings, they don't concern themselves with that. Innocent until proven guilty.

Maybe it would be helpful to those believers to analyse an entire transcript of one of Sylvia's Montel segments, to demonstrate that EVERY reading she gives during the show is cold reading or guesswork that could apply to anyone.
 
It is sad....

Pythra – Sadly you are right; folks that truly believe in SB will not be swayed by any reasonable, or logical argument, until something significant happens in their lives to make them rethink things.

But…if you listen to her “predictions”; really they are so open ended how can she miss on many of them? For example, her 2007 Predictions from the Montel Williams show (I don’t have a date, but the list I’m reading was posted DEC 2006) include:

Brad and Angelina will part ways
“TomKat” will part ways
Martha Stewarts show will be canceled
Tom Hanks will win some Excellence Award
Liz Taylor is dying
Major drug busts on East and West coasts
Democrat in office next time

And the list goes on….wow, predicting that couples will break up, TV shows will be canceled, or Tom Hanks will win an award – golly she has some insight!

Liz Taylor is dying –You mean to tell me she can tell that a old, over weight, in poor health woman is dying? Stop the presses! Geesh....anyone could make the same prediction about anyone....since EVERYONE living is dying.

Major drug busts on the East and West coasts – again ,what are the odds? Clearly she has a gift.

Democrat in office next time – her insight into the future is just kind of freaky!

Before the GOSYLVIA site locked down, they were dancing in the streets when the drug bust (40,000 lbs of cocaine was seized) in Calif. happened. And really, what are the odds there will not be some type of drug bust on the East Coast?

Those that have bought into her lies will hang total belief in her on anything she "gets right", in some way/shape/form no matter how obvious...and will overlook anything she gets wrong (since nobody can be right 100% of the time).

Her claim is what, around 85% accuracy....given the nature of her insights/predictions (such as from the 2007 list) in that they are so open ended, so vauge, so obvious, I'd guess if you did a total at years end of all of her "insights" she just might get close to that mark.

This is of course why she rarely provides specifics...WHEN and SPECIFICALLY WHERE will these drug busts occur...WHAT Democrat will win the election...WHEN will Liz Taylor die...WHAT specific award will Tom Hanks win, etc.

Of course, at this point my note has turned into a bit of a rant....and just points out what most folks on here already well know.
 
Last edited:
Pythra – Sadly you are right; folks that truly believe in SB will not be swayed by any reasonable, or logical argument, until something significant happens in their lives to make them rethink things.

This is wrong.
I truly believed in Sylvia a long time back, as did several new forum members we welcome here.

Maybe it depends on your definition of 'something significant', but for me, that was just finding a community of people who could provide 'reasonable, or logical argument'.

We need to not write off believers as lost causes, and continue to provide what information and evidence we can.
 
A catalyst that causes someone to question and re-evaluate their belief system is something I’d consider to be significant.

Generically speaking, a true believer does not typically seek out, or give merit to, views and opinions that discredit their beliefs without some type of catalyst (ie .”something significant).

The catalyst varies person to person; be it a death in the family, that prediction that just didn’t come true, or finding “a community of people.”
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom