StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: Renquin/Nelson/DesVergnes Reading

From the "MISSING" Web Site:

[Sylvia says] ... Perhaps this "TIC TOC" is a bumper sticker or a licence plate.

Perhaps this "TIC TOC" is what you hear when you knock on Sylvia's head?

Robert, thanks for adding another article to your site that clearly shows how Browne is simply making stuff up and screws the desperate.

Hey, and lot's of thanks to QG as well!
 
New article up today:

Montel: Renquin/Nelson/DesVergnes Reading

Sylvia Browne tells the families of three missing men what happened to their loved ones. Was she right?

Another article based on QuestioningGeller's findings.

You state:

"Two right out of twelve predictions, making for 16.6% correct (and note that the two she got right were simple yes/no questions which anyone would have a 50% chance of getting right)."

when talking about her accuracy rate.

A situation where there are two possible answers does not necessarily lead to a 50% probability she could get it right. One of the two possibilities could be much more likely than the other. When you have three men who have been missing for a year, it is much more likely that they are dead than that they are not. And since Sylvia probably knows this, she will probably choose to answer that they are dead more times than not. This gives anyone a much higher chance than 50% of getting it right.

Linda
 
I noticed that recently you've added things like "was she right?" "is it true?" in the headlines.

I kinda enjoy it when it's more direct, like "She was wrong," "She was proved wrong again," "She's a witch." (ok, the last one is mine).

I believe a direct answer would make it more helpful for those who are not going to read every article on that page.. and of course would make Sylvia seem even worse.
 
Another excellent article Robert.
You said "So far, I have documented these missing person cases which Browne dealt with on the Montel Williams show, every one of which she got very, very wrong:
- Opal Jo Jennings
- Ryan Katcher
- Shawn Hornbeck and Shawn Hornbeck (follow-up)
- Lynda McClelland
- Holly Krewson
- Eve Brown
... and now, this one, with Scott Renquin, Dan Nelson and Roger DesVergnes.
Seven cases, nine missing persons. Browne wrong on every single one of them."

That alone is such an enormous amount of evidence to prove she's a lying and always incorrect fraud and yet you provide so much more (proof) in your articles.
You're really doing a phenomenal job at picking apart her lies and exposing her and you're obviously reaching a lot of people with the truth... (and you know that's pissing her off immensely!! ;) ).
 
I agree with Linda (aka fls); on both of her "right" answers the odds were clearly not 50/50.... Consider:

- She said the 3 men were dead; this was after ~ 6 months of no contact with family or friends, even during the "holiday" season

- She said the vehicle would be found; that is awfully open ended...unless totally destroyed in some fashion, of course it would eventually be found.

On both, how could she possibly miss with "yes" answers.
 
Another excellent article Robert.
You said "So far, I have documented these missing person cases which Browne dealt with on the Montel Williams show, every one of which she got very, very wrong:
- Opal Jo Jennings
- Ryan Katcher
- Shawn Hornbeck and Shawn Hornbeck (follow-up)
- Lynda McClelland
- Holly Krewson
- Eve Brown
... and now, this one, with Scott Renquin, Dan Nelson and Roger DesVergnes.
Seven cases, nine missing persons. Browne wrong on every single one of them."

That alone is such an enormous amount of evidence to prove she's a lying and always incorrect fraud and yet you provide so much more (proof) in your articles.
You're really doing a phenomenal job at picking apart her lies and exposing her and you're obviously reaching a lot of people with the truth... (and you know that's pissing her off immensely!! ;) ).

You bring up an important point. It's not just that we can find examples where she's wrong. It's that every single time that it's possible to make that determination, she turns out to be wrong or only trivially correct (i.e. she's says something that anyone could come up with).

I know Robert may be getting tired of (or embarrassed by) "great job" and "me too", but I still have to say that his approach provides a shining example of how to actually accomplish that which most of us (I'm speaking for myself here) only pay lip-service to. He truly provides me with inspiration and optimism.

Linda
 
You bring up an important point. It's not just that we can find examples where she's wrong. It's that every single time that it's possible to make that determination, she turns out to be wrong or only trivially correct (i.e. she's says something that anyone could come up with).

Yup. :) And I like you said below...
A situation where there are two possible answers does not necessarily lead to a 50% probability she could get it right. One of the two possibilities could be much more likely than the other. When you have three men who have been missing for a year, it is much more likely that they are dead than that they are not. And since Sylvia probably knows this, she will probably choose to answer that they are dead more times than not. This gives anyone a much higher chance than 50% of getting it right.
Linda

I agree. The chances that three guys who simultaneously go (and stay) missing out of the blue would lead (most) anyone to conclude they were dead. Flipping a coin would give a definite 50/50 chance of guessing either heads or tails but like you said, Sylvia (or anyone else) had a much greater chance at being right under those circumstances/knowing what she knew.

I know Robert may be getting tired of (or embarrassed by) "great job" and "me too", but I still have to say that his approach provides a shining example of how to actually accomplish that which most of us (I'm speaking for myself here) only pay lip-service to. He truly provides me with inspiration and optimism.

Linda

He does do a superb job and deserves all of the accolades he gets, even if he's sick of or embarrassed by them. :)
 
In this one just the facts alone are damning but I did particularly enjoy the closing statement practically begging for a case where she was right.

I was going to suggest a bit of rewording regarding the 50% chance of being right. Something to the tune of "Someone with no prior information would at least have a 50% chance by flipping a coin." Implying that Sylvia was throwing those out with knowledge that would have tipped one answer as being more probable. But that might be leading the witness..

Thinking about it a bit more, though and by giving just the 50% odds, it's a very conservative approach which perhaps better fits the site.

Great work, and also great work to QG for his excellent research!
 
I think its safe to conclude that they did not hit a "log" and call that "wrong" instead of "unknown" regarding the accident. According to the story, "The ramp slopes down sharply from where it leaves the highway near a high overpass, then flattens out and ends at an abrupt left turn onto Celebration Boulevard."

The stories don't talk about damage to the car or an accident before the "abrupt" turn.

Also the original discussion: Browne wrong again and police waste time: Renquin, Nelson, and DesVergnes.
 
New article up today:

Montel: Renquin/Nelson/DesVergnes Reading

Sylvia Browne tells the families of three missing men what happened to their loved ones. Was she right?

Robert, I hope that with this stories on your website other families with cases in which Browne wrong will come forward. With the details of the names and dates, it will make it much easier to find clippings.

Then once it is clear Browne is below the 20% accuracy range, we can discuss an article called "The Curse of Sylvia Browne" much like the Geller Curse.

I also hope that police interested in using psychics come across these stories. It's one thing for a desparate family to go to a psychic, it's another for police to change their operations because of one.
 
[ Devils Advocate]
"Yes, but this is 9 she got wrong out of (insert random number).
Nobody can be right all the time"
[/Devil's Advocate]

Doesn't matter how stupid it is; one of her psychophants will say it.
 
[ Devils Advocate]
"Yes, but this is 9 she got wrong out of (insert random number).
Nobody can be right all the time"
[/Devil's Advocate]

Doesn't matter how stupid it is; one of her psychophants will say it.

I don't understand that argument. If you are talking to the dead/have an image in your mind, shouldn't that conversation/image be correct?

Someone who has the facts will be correct, someone who is making stuff up will sometimes be right/wrong.
 
[ Devils Advocate]
"Yes, but this is 9 she got wrong out of (insert random number).
Nobody can be right all the time"
[/Devil's Advocate]

Doesn't matter how stupid it is; one of her psychophants will say it.

If Robert is successful in his endeavour, I imagine another one will spring up to take her place very soon after.

My personal opinion is that the one-psychic-at-a-time approach will be fruitless in the long run. What needs to be done is to make the whole product type (of life after death) unattractive to consumers. Unfortunately I have no (ethical) ideas about how this could be achieved:(
 
I could have "predicted" they drove into a lake at night. Anyone could have "predicted" that. Sylvia can't hit the easiest pitches thrown at her.

Isn't it amazing that no one can think of a single case she allegedly got right?

For all the people in the world who believe Sylvia Browne can see where missing people are, not a single one can name a single case where this was so. It blows my mind.

I thought you'd be debunking annecdotes, urban legends and half-truths and cases she got right because of lucky guesses and common sense.

No, it's even easier cause she's gotten none right. Not in 50 years. Not even because of regular policework or coincidence. And everyone in somehow under the impression she does so every week.
 
Robert, thanks for adding another article to your site that clearly shows how Browne is simply making stuff up and screws the desperate.
Thanks, wahrheit!

Hey, and lot's of thanks to QG as well!
Definitely!

And since Sylvia probably knows this, she will probably choose to answer that they are dead more times than not. This gives anyone a much higher chance than 50% of getting it right.
You are of course correct. I will note this in the article later, thanks!

I kinda enjoy it when it's more direct, like "She was wrong," "She was proved wrong again," "She's a witch." (ok, the last one is mine).
I have generally used the "She was wrong" when the question is totally clear cut, as in "She said he was dead. She was wrong." In cases such as this one, where it is a more complex issue, I want the reader to come to his or her own conclusion.

Another excellent article Robert.
Thanks, Jeff!

I agree with Linda (aka fls); on both of her "right" answers the odds were clearly not 50/50.... On both, how could she possibly miss with "yes" answers.
I'll definitely be updating the reference to the alive/dead prediction, but I don't think I'll do so with the "vehicle will be found" one. It's a bit less provable, I think. But thanks for the input!

I know Robert may be getting tired of (or embarrassed by) "great job" and "me too", but I still have to say that his approach provides a shining example of how to actually accomplish that which most of us (I'm speaking for myself here) only pay lip-service to.
Thanks, Linda. You;re very kind. And no, I'm by no means tired of it. :)

Thinking about it a bit more, though and by giving just the 50% odds, it's a very conservative approach which perhaps better fits the site. Great work, and also great work to QG for his excellent research!
Thanks!

I think its safe to conclude that they did not hit a "log" and call that "wrong" instead of "unknown" regarding the accident.
I know, but it's not clear-cut enough for me, so I left it in the Unknown category.

[ Devils Advocate]
"Yes, but this is 9 she got wrong out of (insert random number).
Nobody can be right all the time"
[/Devil's Advocate]

Doesn't matter how stupid it is; one of her psychophants will say it.
Of course they will. And they would be right. But of course, that implies that she actually gets some right, which is something they've yet to give any example of.

If Robert is successful in his endeavour, I imagine another one will spring up to take her place very soon after.
Quite likely.

My personal opinion is that the one-psychic-at-a-time approach will be fruitless in the long run. What needs to be done is to make the whole product type (of life after death) unattractive to consumers. Unfortunately I have no (ethical) ideas about how this could be achieved:(
I understand. But since Browne is arguably the most popular one in the USA, I think that what I am doing has an effect beyond just her.

I could have "predicted" they drove into a lake at night. Anyone could have "predicted" that. Sylvia can't hit the easiest pitches thrown at her.
Ah, but it wasn't a lake - it was a pond!

So far, EeneyMinnieMoe's accuracy rating: ZERO PERCENT!!! :D
 
Robert, I appreciate that you're being as fair as possible in judging hits and misses.

I would add to your conclusion though that her hit rate, low as it is, still exaggerates the appearance of how helpful she is in these cases. Saying whether the body will be found or not does NOTHING to help investigators, for instance. And if police did spend time following up on any of the "information" she provided, the net effect to the investigation is definitely detrimental.
 
Great job, Robert! I think you are wording things just right in evaluating her performances.
I also agree that the effect will encompass more than just her. Taking down a big celebrity will definately have an effect on the other famous ones that are even close to her in notoriety. When Sylvia goes down in flames I'm sure that many people say to themselves, "hmmm...now that reminds me of First-name-synonomous-with-a-toilet Edward when he said..." or "hmmm...reminds me of Alison Dubious when she said..." and so on and so on.
Again, nicely done! And thanks to QG of course. His help is invaluable. : )
 
Vehile will be found....

I was all set to still argue the odds clearly favor the "yes" answer with respect to "the vehicle will be found".

But after consideration I can't come up with a good arguement and concede....curse you and logic!

While it could be argued that most man made things, unless intentionally destroyed, are eventually found - especially in a populated area such as Orlando....there is no way to discount the "intentionally destroyed" aspect, say if they had been murdered vs accidential death.

BTW - I'll add to the voices and say the SSB site is excellent; you've done a fantasic job laying out the facts in a unbaised manner.

It would be easy to do the "she is a gravy sucking pig" line...but by taking the unbaised manner, there is enough factual information to get all but the "true belivers" thinking.
 
Florida authorities checked out some of the leads and found nothing, according to an Attleboro detective who has been a liaison to the families.

Is there any way Browne can be held accountable for the man-hours and tax dollars wasted on her "leads" with this case or others?

A person who learns of the crime after it is committed and helps the criminal to conceal it, or aids the criminal in escaping, or simply fails to report the crime, is known as an "accessory after the fact".
-From this site.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom