StopSylviaBrowne: Followup to "Jewelry w/a 'Quality Issue'"

Can't recall if RSL mentioned this on the orig. article, but anyone that has purchased these pieces should contact their local States Attorney Generals Office.

Since many of these pieces were sold at the Hay House lectures, they were sold within the jurisdictions of these States Attorney Generals, and many of these do not take kindly to out-of-state companys doing fraud in their state.

I also know that products sold at lectures were not taxed on top of the sale price, and I have been told that no sales tax payments have been made to the states where these products were sold. I know for a fact that "customers" were advised that sales tax was included in the sales price at the lectures, even including the sale of the fake jewelry.

Since most checks were made out to SBC or SBE, depending upon what was purchased, they can not claim tax exempt status, and would clearly be violating the state laws where they sold products at lectures by not collecting and paying the required state sales tax.
 
This is the particular item I was referring to. The 4.5 carat top-of-the-line pendant.

(Image linked to from StopSylviaBrowne.com)
novusspiritus_jewelryqualityissue_1.jpg


I counted roughly 18 to 24 stones in the piece, being about 10pt to 20pt each, and it was advertised as being 4.5 carats of diamonds. The problem I had was that there is nothing to scale this picture to, so it could be altogether tiny, or it could be a Mr T sized neck-breaker.

I have now thought of another point - maybe they were indeed tiny stones, in the region of 5 points each. Which would mean that even with 30-odd stones in the piece, that is a total of less than 1 carat total gem weight, not 4.5 carats as advertised. Even if the manufacturing costs did fall below the retail sales price.

If so, that again is fraudulent advertising and sale on a grand scale. Misrepresenting your goods with the purpose of defrauding your customer is an indictable offence in all US states, I believe I would be rather sure of saying that.
 
Zep,

You are the type of person that SB and Co. never wanted to find out about this issue, because logic can see through fraud in any form it takes.

I'll again state that if SB and Co. were victims of fraud themselves, then why did they not advertise it instead of hiding it until RSL contacted them and told them he was writing an article about this?

Taken from the NS "Q & A" book:

"Wealth does not deter one's spiritual evolvement. Greed however, can literally capture a person and make them a slave."

Looks like SB and Co. are captives to their greed, and it looks as if Greed has blinded them.
 
Zep--that's not the $4990 pendant. That appears to be the $144 "Eclipse" pendant...yep, the name of the jpg is Eclipse. The Eclipse is still for sale, and advertised as having .25 ctw of diamonds.

I can't tell how big it is either, but it weighs a mere 1.6 grams as opposed to 4.6 grams for the ring version. The stud earrings are also .25 ctw, so this little guy is the size of two earrings. It looks to be on the order of 10 mm, and all that would fit with roughly 1 pt diamond chips.
 
Zep--that's not the $4990 pendant. That appears to be the $144 "Eclipse" pendant...yep, the name of the jpg is Eclipse. The Eclipse is still for sale, and advertised as having .25 ctw of diamonds.

I can't tell how big it is either, but it weighs a mere 1.6 grams as opposed to 4.6 grams for the ring version. The stud earrings are also .25 ctw, so this little guy is the size of two earrings. It looks to be on the order of 10 mm, and all that would fit with roughly 1 pt diamond chips.
Hmmm... You do look to be right. My mistake in linking to that particular pic! :o

However my point remains unchanged: It simply does not matter what the jewellery looks like. To obtain 4.5 carats of diamonds as raw material would cost more than the $4,000 sale price of the finished piece. Usually WAY more. Which means Sylvia Corp. has been trying some sort of scam somewhere along the line.

Incidentally, even with 1pt diamonds - chips - their price is about $10 each (i be checkin' a bling-bling websites makin' de grillz, yo!). So 4.5 carats is 450 x $10 = $4,500 - still more than the finished product sale price. So Sylvia Corp. were still fibbing their arses off, even if they were selling tiny real diamonds!

ETA: 25 pts at $10 per 1pt stone = $250. Selling for $144???!! So is she STILL at it?? ;)
 
Last edited:
Zep,

You are the type of person that SB and Co. never wanted to find out about this issue, because logic can see through fraud in any form it takes.

I'll again state that if SB and Co. were victims of fraud themselves, then why did they not advertise it instead of hiding it until RSL contacted them and told them he was writing an article about this?

Taken from the NS "Q & A" book:

"Wealth does not deter one's spiritual evolvement. Greed however, can literally capture a person and make them a slave."

Looks like SB and Co. are captives to their greed, and it looks as if Greed has blinded them.
Thanks. Logic is simply stating more clearly what is, so everyone can understand.

And I would suggest that she chose Greed as her god and lodestone right from the very start. All the rest, the spirituality, the "churches", the hypnosis, the books and media, have been simply mechanisms to attain that goal.

Now I have no issue with people being greedy and making the best of life and striving and amassing huge fortunes if that is their desire. But only if it is through totally legitimate means and does not harm other people as a result. Which is why I heartily endorse Rob's endeavours with regard to Sylvia Browne. She fails dismally on both counts.
 
These people will sell you .21 carats of 1 pt diamonds for $99. And here's a 1 carat lot of 10 point stones for just $760.

Now for all I know these people may be more crooked than even Sylvia, but I don't see any reason why that $4990 necklace couldn't have been made with 45 cheap stones for 4.5 * $760 + all the other costs involved in jewelry making.
 
These people will sell you .21 carats of 1 pt diamonds for $99. And here's a 1 carat lot of 10 point stones for just $760.

Now for all I know these people may be more crooked than even Sylvia, but I don't see any reason why that $4990 necklace couldn't have been made with 45 cheap stones for 4.5 * $760 + all the other costs involved in jewelry making.

Will jump in here with my diamond math:

100 points equals one carat.

On the first Ebay lot, you get 25 diamonds, each with .0084 points, which equals a total lot of 21 points, or .21 Total Carat Weight for all 25 diamonds.

To be a 4.5 Total Carat Weight, or 451 points of diamonds, one would need 535.72 of these diamonds as sold in the first Ebay lot, which would equal 21.43 lots of diamonds, at $99 each, would total $2,121.57 just in raw material, not counting shipping charges.
 
Don't forget to add the cost of the gold and manufacture and packaging and shipping, plus the jeweller's margin. And 500+ diamonds? They would cost a fortune to set, especially the small ones.

You also need to appreciate that such tiny stones would look more like sparkly mica than "real" diamonds. Not a Sylvia style at all.
 
The first lot (.21 carats) is a possible fit to the $199 necklace. There are 25 stones in that lot, and although it looks like there are more than 25 stones in the Eclipse necklace, these would be smaller stones and hence less than $99.

The second lot is 1 carat of 10 pt stones (10 stones). So 4.5 carats of these would be 45 stones, or 4.5 lots for $3420. These are very cheap stones, but apparently about the same quality as the stone used in the pendant, G/H rounds (see the Wayback ad). The cost of the rest of the materials and workmanship I estimate at about...oh $199.

So it is not unreasonable to estimate a cost to Browne for the necklace at around $3600, which she then sells for around $5000.

A legitimate zirconia jeweler would probably charge around $200 for the piece. Zircon jewelry tends to have honking big stones though, especially when they put 4.5 carats of them into a piece. That's why I wish we could see the pictures.

At this point I'm pretty well convinced that we do not have enough information to say "Those pieces are too cheap to be made with real diamonds."
 
Don't forget to add the cost of the gold and manufacture and packaging and shipping, plus the jeweller's margin. And 500+ diamonds? They would cost a fortune to set, especially the small ones.

You also need to appreciate that such tiny stones would look more like sparkly mica than "real" diamonds. Not a Sylvia style at all.

Some cross posting here...

No, 45 low quality 10 point stones will only run you around $3420. A typical gold necklace set with zircons can be had for $200, so that's my estimate of the other costs.

And that bracelet with 135 stones was comparable in price and carat weight, so the gold and labor of setting 135 stones is plausible for a piece that price.
 
Lol at the cartoon :)

RSL, I have a question. You have said alot of the people who go to the site are already suspicious and read one thing that's the last straw and brings them to this side of the fence.

Which article usually is it that does it for them?

For me, it would probably be Opal Jo Jennings or Shawn Hornbeck cause those are the cruelest and most dramatic examples.
 
Now I'm confused.

The notice on Browne's site mentions the "Eclipse" line. The Eclipse are the relatively cheap pieces with small, cheap stones. They are still being sold. They seem to be made with 25-30 1 point diamonds, which are only about 1 mm diameter.

The pieces that have been removed were the "Trinity" and "Signature" lines. These pieces were thousands of dollars and supposedly contained enough diamonds to be worth thousands of dollars. Assuming these pieces contained fairly big stones, you would make a lot of money by misrepresenting zircons as diamonds.

The Signature pendant claimed to contain 4.5 carats of diamonds, which could be 45 10 pt stones. Replacing these with zircons would be profitable, and $4990 would be a reasonable price for a diamond Signature.

If they were actually more like 9 half-carat stones then the pendant should cost more than $4990.

You could put zircons in the Eclipse pieces but it wouldn't help much. Those are junk diamonds which look pretty but have no real value. It doesn't seem likely that someone would take a $250 ring to a jeweler for an insurance appraisal.

So I have these questions:
Which pieces had the "quality issue?"
Are the pieces which were removed from the site the pieces that had the quality issue?
Were the cheap ($200-300) pieces the ones with the problem?
Why would anyone misrepresent zircons as junk diamonds? I doubt if it's profitable to even make cubic zirconias that tiny.

Oh, and who know what when. ;) That's still the real question.
 
I am really curious why the larger, more expensive ranges have been erased from the site without even a mention. Since the notice only mentions Eclipse jewellery it would imply that the larger pieces were okay, but I would be very suspicious. It would be great if somebody who owns one of those pieces could get it appraised and tell us what the verdict is. Surely some of SB's supporters would love to prove to us the quality of the product?
 
I was told all of the diamond jewelry, yet Rev. McClellan, or TU Designs, are only recalling the Eclipse Line. But, as pointed out, the more expensive lines have been discountinued, and as I recall, they were dropped around the same time that the "diamond issue" was really discovered.

There are so many webs woven withing the office and the corporations that it is hard to tell sometimes.
 
Really, really great work PastBrownFan and RSL!

The "deadline" is total crap. The only "deadlines" in this case are the applicable statutes of limitation on consumer fraud.

"Standing" is an issue for civil actions, not criminal ones. For instance, if I see a woman (or a bunch of SB fans) being brutally raped, I can report the crime to the appropriate authorities. Even though I am not the victim, the rapist (in this case, SB and NS), can be investigated and indicted.

I followed this jewelry issue for a couple of weeks after PBF first posted on the "Go Sylvia Brown" thread. It's the kind of charge that's particularly sticky for a defendant. If she--or anyone at NS--had knowledge (or perhaps even notice, which is slightly different) of the "defects," they are party to the fraud.

Their pathetic attempt to cover their asses by putting a notice on their website would, I think, make both a prosecutor and a jury laugh.

This is the kind of stuff that brought Al Capone down; she can't now deny that she knows about the fraud, since she's posted notice of it on her website. Even if she were making a good-faith effort to remedy the issue (which she has not), it wouldn't matter. You can't "uncommit" a crime.

I'm sure that RSL has this well in hand, but I'm going to look at the relevant California Criminal and Consumer Protection codes, and see what there is to see. I really think that this could be very, very serious for SB and NS, and that it's worth staying on!
 
Just wanted to bring this fraud back up top, and keep rubbing it in the face of SB and her staff.

I do hope that the CA AG really looks at this case long and hard, plus not much time left until their deadline comes up to return the jewelry.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom