Now I'm confused.
The notice on Browne's site mentions the "Eclipse" line. The Eclipse are the relatively cheap pieces with small, cheap stones. They are still being sold. They seem to be made with 25-30 1 point diamonds, which are only about 1 mm diameter.
The pieces that have been removed were the "Trinity" and "Signature" lines. These pieces were thousands of dollars and supposedly contained enough diamonds to be worth thousands of dollars. Assuming these pieces contained fairly big stones, you would make a lot of money by misrepresenting zircons as diamonds.
The Signature pendant claimed to contain 4.5 carats of diamonds, which could be 45 10 pt stones. Replacing these with zircons would be profitable, and $4990 would be a reasonable price for a diamond Signature.
If they were actually more like 9 half-carat stones then the pendant should cost more than $4990.
You could put zircons in the Eclipse pieces but it wouldn't help much. Those are junk diamonds which look pretty but have no real value. It doesn't seem likely that someone would take a $250 ring to a jeweler for an insurance appraisal.
So I have these questions:
Which pieces had the "quality issue?"
Are the pieces which were removed from the site the pieces that had the quality issue?
Were the cheap ($200-300) pieces the ones with the problem?
Why would anyone misrepresent zircons as junk diamonds? I doubt if it's profitable to even make cubic zirconias that tiny.
Oh, and who know what when.

That's still the real question.