StopSylviaBrowne: Followup to "Jewelry w/a 'Quality Issue'"

A friend of mine had a grandmother who had a lovely wedding diamond that she proudly wore for over 50 years. It finally needed to be fixed and it was discovered that the diamond was fake. Some very clever forger decades ago sold her husband a fake. She was very hurt and angry that they had been fooled for almost her entire life. After so long she couldn't bear to part with the ring, but she never could look at it and not feel like that forger was still laughing at her and her husband. And how many other people parted with hard-earned money during the Depression just to get a fake?
Sylvia is no better. If she was she would make certain that ALL customers who purchased the CZ would obtain new and genuine pieces.

I doubt that the idea of selling cheapo fakes instead of real diamonds came from $ilvia. At least, I have not heard of any evidence that would point in that direction. And personally, I find it very unlikely.

My wild guess is that somewhere in the chain of production and distribution something went very, very wrong. I mean, let's say you are in the business of producing those ugly rings. If you have a client ordering 1000 pieces of this or that "diamond" ring, you definitely know the difference between the phone number of De Beers for an order, or the phone number of a make-me-a-fake factory.

My second wild guess is that $ilvia Corp. wants to play this low profile, because having experts check the diamond(s) of such a (relatively) cheap piece might exceed the value of it.
 
You're right, selling cheapos certainly did not originate with $ilvia. It's probably my own moral weakness, but if I were in this situation I would do everything I could to make things right with my customers.
You're second guess is probably the right one. I doubt she wants to risk losing the money to have everything checked out properly.
 
If the factory sold Sylvia zirconias at (wholesale) diamond prices, she should be able to force the factory to reimburse her. Furthermore, she should be able to demand an apology which she can then pass on to her customers.

If they don't play nice, then she might be able to sue them for harming her reputation, as well as fraud.

If an employee is responsible, then why did no one notice the difference in factory prices and sales prices? Perhaps the employee was pocketing the difference. This person needs to be identified and arrested, and possibly the money needs to be reclaimed.

Did she sue them? Has she reached a private agreement? Was someone arrested? Does anyone have any information about this?
 
Would a genuine psychic not be able to tell she was being fleeced by her suppliers?
 
If the factory sold Sylvia zirconias at (wholesale) diamond prices, she should be able to force the factory to reimburse her. Furthermore, she should be able to demand an apology which she can then pass on to her customers.

If they don't play nice, then she might be able to sue them for harming her reputation, as well as fraud.

If an employee is responsible, then why did no one notice the difference in factory prices and sales prices? Perhaps the employee was pocketing the difference. This person needs to be identified and arrested, and possibly the money needs to be reclaimed.

Did she sue them? Has she reached a private agreement? Was someone arrested? Does anyone have any information about this?

One would think that if you, as the retailer, were swindled by the supplier that you would not only sue, but do so openly, and highly publicize that you were wronged, and likewise your customers were wrong. Especially when one is selling an item that is designed for a non-profit, religious organization mainly selling said items to their followers, and potential members via public appearances and speaking engagements.

One does seem to show complicity when one tends to hide disclosures such as NS did, and by stating, as can be seen here that they were going to notify and publicize this, they only continue in showing deception and a huge lack of respect for those who purchased these items in good faith.

I would strongly advise those involved at NS headquartes to go back and read what a church is really about, why people join a church, and what the mission and purpose of a church is, and to see if their actions are in harmony with such.
 
Am I the only one here who wouldn't put it past Sylvia to knowingly sell fake diamonds as yet another way to fleece the naive? :confused:
 
Would a genuine psychic not be able to tell she was being fleeced by her suppliers?

Shouldn't she have known all this years before? "Ah, no. Let's not start even thinking about selling this diamond jewelry stuff. *burp* Francine told me this will come to a bad end."



@PastBrowneFan: Thank you for all the information and thoughts you provide.
 
Am I the only one here who wouldn't put it past Sylvia to knowingly sell fake diamonds as yet another way to fleece the naive? :confused:

Nope. I would not put it past her either.


RSL, very well done. However I agree, the deadline is bulls***. Fraud is fraud.
 
Am I the only one here who wouldn't put it past Sylvia to knowingly sell fake diamonds as yet another way to fleece the naive? :confused:
I thought about this point a few weeks back when this topic was first raised, and did some rule-of-thumb research. Here's my thinking on it.

1) Real cut diamonds, unmounted, are expensive. And their price goes up exponentially as the size of the stone increases. Lots of small diamonds making up a certain carat weight will always cost less in total than one big diamond of the same weight.

2) Unset diamonds of about one quarter carat (25 points) medium quality would cost a jeweller very roughly US$400 each trade price.

3) The largest piece sold by Sylvia Corp. (now withdrawn from sale) was a pendant in white gold with 4.5 carats of "diamonds" in it. From the picture of it, these appeared to be roughly 15 or so stones. So I estimated the pricing for eighteen 25 point stones.

4) Arithmetic: 18 x $400 = $7200. Add the cost of the white gold, the jeweller's margin, and sundry packaging and handling costs, and you are looking at an approximate US$8,000 to US$8,500 wholesale item cost to Sylvia Corp. If the jeweller was any sort of business-man, this would have been negotiated and made very clear prior to any transactions and shipment.

5) And yet the RETAIL price from Sylvia corp. to their customers for this particular item was US$4,000!!! That is, they would have made a $4,000-plus loss on each one, had they been real diamonds.

6) If the jeweller was trying to rip off Sylvia Corp. by selling CZ as diamonds, this would have been a major business mistake. Such a ripoff could not be hidden for long. And given the litigious nature of Sylvia Corp., the jeweller's name would have been on court documents from Sylvia Corp's lawyers at the speed of light long ago. As far as I'm aware, this never happened. So a rip-off scenario by the jeweller seems extremely unlikely.

So there are two possible conclusions:

a) Sylvia Corp. was indeed taking roughly a $4000-plus loss on every such item sold. Given what is known of Sylvia Corp., and the fact they would more likely be making a 100% profit off each one instead, this seems highly, HIGHLY improbable.

b) Sylvia Corp. knew damn well from the outset they were NOT real diamonds when they purchased them. It is far more likely they ordered them made from CZ right from the beginning. Which means the original advertising to their customers was a deliberate falsehood. And as mentioned above, I don't know what the legal situation is in CA and the rest of the USA, but it needs official review...and hopefully strong action.
 
Last edited:
Well, on E-bay a found what claims to be a diamond bracelet with 4.5 total carat weight.

This bracelet has 135 diamonds. That's the only thing comparable I could find. All the Wayback images seem to be busted--can't say if they are 135 itty bitty zirconias or not.
 
Something is not right here with the above reasoning. The link to e-bay says that a 8 inch Diamond tennis Bracelet 14K White Gold 4.5 ctw is worth US $4,525.00. This is not much more than the pendant Zep has mentioned. It Bracelet does appear to have smaller diamonds though.
 
Something is not right here with the above reasoning. The link to e-bay says that a 8 inch Diamond tennis Bracelet 14K White Gold 4.5 ctw is worth US $4,525.00. This is not much more than the pendant Zep has mentioned. It Bracelet does appear to have smaller diamonds though.

Exactly, a bunch of small diamonds will be a lot cheaper than a single diamond of the same weight.
 
StopSilviaBrowne.com comes at #3 on Google when searching for "Sylvia Browne". This is pretty good going for such a young website.

I would recommend that everyone who has a blog link to SSB to raise the rankings still further.
 
I thought about this point a few weeks back when this topic was first raised, and did some rule-of-thumb research. Here's my thinking on it.

1) Real cut diamonds, unmounted, are expensive. And their price goes up exponentially as the size of the stone increases. Lots of small diamonds making up a certain carat weight will always cost less in total than one big diamond of the same weight.

2) Unset diamonds of about one quarter carat (25 points) medium quality would cost a jeweller very roughly US$400 each trade price.

3) The largest piece sold by Sylvia Corp. (now withdrawn from sale) was a pendant in white gold with 4.5 carats of "diamonds" in it. From the picture of it, these appeared to be roughly 15 or so stones. So I estimated the pricing for eighteen 25 point stones.

4) Arithmetic: 18 x $400 = $7200. Add the cost of the white gold, the jeweller's margin, and sundry packaging and handling costs, and you are looking at an approximate US$8,000 to US$8,500 wholesale item cost to Sylvia Corp. If the jeweller was any sort of business-man, this would have been negotiated and made very clear prior to any transactions and shipment.

5) And yet the RETAIL price from Sylvia corp. to their customers for this particular item was US$4,000!!! That is, they would have made a $4,000-plus loss on each one, had they been real diamonds.

6) If the jeweller was trying to rip off Sylvia Corp. by selling CZ as diamonds, this would have been a major business mistake. Such a ripoff could not be hidden for long. And given the litigious nature of Sylvia Corp., the jeweller's name would have been on court documents from Sylvia Corp's lawyers at the speed of light long ago. As far as I'm aware, this never happened. So a rip-off scenario by the jeweller seems extremely unlikely.

So there are two possible conclusions:

a) Sylvia Corp. was indeed taking roughly a $4000-plus loss on every such item sold. Given what is known of Sylvia Corp., and the fact they would more likely be making a 100% profit off each one instead, this seems highly, HIGHLY improbable.

b) Sylvia Corp. knew damn well from the outset they were NOT real diamonds when they purchased them. It is far more likely they ordered them made from CZ right from the beginning. Which means the original advertising to their customers was a deliberate falsehood. And as mentioned above, I don't know what the legal situation is in CA and the rest of the USA, but it needs official review...and hopefully strong action.

Zep, I don't think you can calculate the cost of such pieces like this if you can't have them examined by an expert. There are way too many unknown variables and too much guesswork in that calculation for my taste, such as quality, size and number of stones.

I'm not an expert either, but some years ago had the oportunity to talk to an expert from De Beers, and she explained quite a lot to me. This was in preparation for a TV show where the contestants could win a diamond worth $500,000. Long story short, this whole diamond business is very complicated, without an expert looking at one of those holy rings we are in the dark.
 
I have no idea about the cost of diamonds or the quality of the jewellery sold on SB's site, but I do find it interesting that after the diamond debacle was brought to the attention of her staff, some lines of jewellery (Trinity and Signature) disappeared from Sylvia's site completely without a trace. Only the Eclipse range is named in the notice.

Perhaps the reason they're trying to downplay this issue is because they were knowingly using CZ in the more expensive pieces but got fleeced themselves with the Eclipse line. They wouldn't want to bring attention to the fact that dodgy diamonds might be associated with Novus Spiritus jewellery. This is only speculation of course, but I agree with PBF that it's strange how Sylvia & co are trying to keep quiet about this rather than loudly express their outrage.
 
Zep, I don't think you can calculate the cost of such pieces like this if you can't have them examined by an expert. There are way too many unknown variables and too much guesswork in that calculation for my taste, such as quality, size and number of stones.

I'm not an expert either, but some years ago had the oportunity to talk to an expert from De Beers, and she explained quite a lot to me. This was in preparation for a TV show where the contestants could win a diamond worth $500,000. Long story short, this whole diamond business is very complicated, without an expert looking at one of those holy rings we are in the dark.
Well, I suppose should have shown my research, but I did go to a number of diamond merchant sites, and also the current wholesale diamond markets. And I also contacted a number of manufacturing jewellers. The reason I didn't show details was that it's a VERY closed market, and the people are well known to each other...it's considered good business practice to be discrete. ;)

And as mentioned above, the pricing can vary greatly depending on the sizes of the diamonds being used, and also their quality. So there is certainly some variability possible in my figures.

For example, if I had calculated using low grade 10pt diamonds, the piece price drops to about $5,000 all up, which MAY be reasonable, although still well above the price the finished items as being sold by Browne. But 10pt diamonds are about the size of a pinhead, and about 45 of them would be required to make 4.5 carats. The picture of the pendant was definitely only in the order of a dozen to 20 stones in it. Not masses of tiny diamonds set like marquesite.

By comparison, a single 4.5 carat diamond is going to set you back somewhere from $50,000 to $100,000, and a fine grade stone significantly more than that! But we are talking Elizabeth Taylor engagement rings here. Should Browne have been flogging a single diamond of that size, she would have been seriously insane selling it for $4,000.

What I SHOULD do is the same calculations using CZ. However I understand a rough guide is to use a cost price of ~10% of the equivalent sized diamond price, with the other materials and manufacturing costs being the same. And my impression is that, due to the fact it is man-made and not "found", CZ pricing is linear depending on the size - a 2 carat CZ is approximately twice the price of a 1 carat CZ. Hence its attractiveness for making affordable showpiece jewellery - it's price-effective! I certainly I stand to be corrected on this at this time.

But using this as a guide, and considering the original example I used, a 25pt CZ would cost about $40, so 18 x $40 = $720. Plus ~$1000 for metal and manufacture, a CZ items comes to ~$2000. Selling at $4000 means a 100% markup, which is almost precisely what would be expected from Browne Corp. ;)
 
Last edited:
I didn't want to question your research, sorry if it came across like that.

Regarding your math, also take into consideration that CZ are considerably heavier than real diamonds. Cubic Zirkonia weigh roughly 75% more than a natural diamond of the same size. In other words, a CZ stone the size of a 1ct diamond weighs approximately 1.75 ct. That's why the crap they sell on television homeshopping channels has more carat than your Queen's Crown Jewels. :)
 
I didn't want to question your research, sorry if it came across like that.

Regarding your math, also take into consideration that CZ are considerably heavier than real diamonds. Cubic Zirkonia weigh roughly 75% more than a natural diamond of the same size. In other words, a CZ stone the size of a 1ct diamond weighs approximately 1.75 ct. That's why the crap they sell on television homeshopping channels has more carat than your Queen's Crown Jewels. :)
I did not know that! That would mean you can get less size of CZ for the same weight (carats). Which means cheaper still!

As I said originally, this could all be very variable - many factors involved. But I think the point remains: based on the prices of the raw materials and approximate manufacturing costs, all indications are that Browne Corp. KNEW IN ADVANCE they were CZ items, and then deliberately advertised them falsely as diamonds. And that's fraud.
 
The e-bay bracelet says it uses .08 pt and .06 pt diamonds. There has to be an error somewhere. She apparently means 8 pt and 6 pt diamonds. Not all the 135 diamonds are that big--only 1/3 of them, the center stones. I found a chart that says a typical round 10 pt diamond is 3 mm, which is bigger than most pinheads, but certainly pretty small.

Anyhow, it looks like Browne's price and carat weight is plausible only for a piece that uses hundreds of 2-3 mm stones. I sure would like to see a picture of Browne's stuff.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom