StopSylviaBrowne - Email: "Sylvia and a 9/11 Widow"

What about advertising a service you know you cannot provide? As in medical advice when you have no medical qualifications? Talking to the dead when you know you cannot talk to the dead?
It appears Sylvia usually follows up her "medical" advice by suggesting people see a doctor, so that could be her "out" in those instances.

As for knowing that she can't talk to the dead, as much as we skeptics believe that she knows she can't talk to them, she insists she can. Thus the burden to prove she can't falls to us. And as skeptics we are all too aware of the difficulty of proving a negative. :(

About the only thing we can do is what Robert Lancaster has done: try as far as possible to expose her incompetence and crassness. Now, if the media in the USA turned on her, with every superstar talking head from Oprah to Leno having people like Randi on to expose her and her methods, Sylvia's empire would tank pretty fast. Look what happened to Popoff after Randi and Carson exposed him. Popoff has since made a comeback, but that was only because Carson died and Randi lost a friend who was willing to supply him with a national stage.
 
Last edited:
I am so disgusted by Sylvia Browne that I can't think of anything to say except, Robert, you are a man of amazing patience and strength of will. I don't know how you manage to maintain your objectivity.
 
I've been a long time peeping Tom on this forum and I have been often enlightened, occasionally amazed, and always hugely entertained but this is the first I've been sickened by a post. And the first time that I've responded. I own a small bookstore in a huge country north of the States and this has proven the final straw for me and the author Sylvia. I'm against censorship in principle but I can no longer in good conscience continue to help fatten Sylvia's harpy fund by flogging her dangerous, repulsive dreck. Please keep up this important work, Mr Lancaster, the world needs more of your ilk (and less of hers)
 
Well done on another great article
Thanks, Rob! All I did was give that woman a soapbox.

I wonder what it feels like to work for someone who you know cannot do what she claims?[.QUOTE]I don't know about you, but for me, that desribes half the bosses I ever had! :D

But I know what you mean.

Or even worse, be a volunteer who helps SB?
I have to wonder how much the volunteers actually know.

It would be interesting to know if a recording of the interview exists.
I doubt it, but if there is, it would be at SB headquarters.

That is just horrible. I think that is definitely one of the saddest and most infuriating stories I have heard about Sylvia to date. It made me angry and brought tears to my eyes to read what happened to her and what they did.
Same hear, Ex-M.

And I add my sense of sadness for the woman who actually endured Sylvia nonsense a lot longer than I would have. She showed great bravery and dignity in coming forward, and it's hopefully another nail in the coffin of Sylvia Browne's own particular brand of hateful and hurtful nonsense.
I agree.

RSL - Just to state the obvious, the work you do in terms of your site makes a difference.
Thanks, Brick.

There is a small comfort in knowing she has at last found a measure of happiness through her second marriage.
Yes.

As for SB, this episode is so far beyond the realm of decency that if I wish there was a deepest circle of hell reserved for her. How horribly twisted she must be inside to perpetrate this type of psychological torment in order to validate her own sense of worth.
I think it definitely shows her true colors, Boo.

Inexcusable, indefensible. I can't even see how one of her followers can explain this away. Her victim wasn't a "dark entity" or some nonsense. If this was just one of the, what, 13% of the times Sylvia is wrong, how can she come off and say her victim was one of "those people"?
Because her fans don't follow up on her statements. That's part of what the site does.

If anyone in the Sylvia Browne organization has a conscience, they should feel deeply ashamed.
I would hope so, Monza. But I wouldn't bet any money on it.

You can't make this up. She is actually worse than I thought, if that was possible.
She seems to keep topping herself.

This reminds me of the reading she did for a woman on the Montel Williams show.
Yes, that was one of the very first articles on my site, and one of the reasons I decided to start the site in the first place. The woman on the Montel show ended up contacting me:

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/montel_911fireman.shtml

Oh, and thanks to her for telling us that Sylvia's staff so heavily push her lectures and whatnot even before the high-priced reading. I had never heard that before, or if I had I don't recall it. Talk about having an obsession with money. : (
It's what they are all about, apparently.

One of the top 10 most devastating articles you've published, for sure.
Thanks, Eenie.

Ugh. Oh. That makes me sick.

I wonder if Sylvia really believed she was being set up.
Hard to say.

It appears Sylvia usually follows up her "medical" advice by suggesting people see a doctor, so that could be her "out" in those instances.
Actually, from her Montel appearances, I'd say she seems to say this very seldom.

I am so disgusted by Sylvia Browne that I can't think of anything to say except, Robert, you are a man of amazing patience and strength of will. I don't know how you manage to maintain your objectivity.
Thanks, DR. Almost didn't recognize you with your new avatar!

Wow. Just, wow.

This article so perfectly shows how Sylvia Browne operates.
Sad but true, Kakariki.

I own a small bookstore in a huge country north of the States and this has proven the final straw for me and the author Sylvia. I'm against censorship in principle but I can no longer in good conscience continue to help fatten Sylvia's harpy fund by flogging her dangerous, repulsive dreck.
That's appreciated, Bickerer!

Please keep up this important work, Mr Lancaster, the world needs more of your ilk (and less of hers)
You're very kind. Oh, and welcome to non-lurker status! :)
 
To be fair, your recollection is not entirely accurate. You might want to reread the article on www.stopsylviabrowne.com if you are pointing out that item to other people.

However, your second paragraph is absolutely correct.

Yes, you are correct. That was the story I was referring to. Thanks for the link to correct my errors. I would have found it and linked to it myself, but I am lazy. :)
 
That is an incredible story.

Sylvia's paranoia and insecurity came out in that story. She's wrapped herself up in this empire which hinges on deceit. It's when the deceit becomes incredibly obvious to both parties and she can't get away with it that she becomes poisonous and maniacal.

Sylvia operates on probability guesses and she seems to have found it impossible that a firefighter on 9/11 could have died in any other way than entering the towers. When her extremely high probability guess was shown to be wrong she made another guess, that it was more likely that she was being deceived by an imposter than being presented with a real account.

I don't know what to conclude from this.

I really want to understand how Sylvia rationalises her behaviour, I would be interested to find out who Sylvia idolises, who she respects. Who in her life has shaped her as a moral being. Does Sylvia respect anyone's opinion of her? Does anyone with good morals have any impact or influence on Sylvia's life.

Is her current behaviour a result of many years of denial, avoiding anyone who doubts or disapproves of her behaviour?

Rant over.

Thanks Rob for this article and thanks to the author for speaking about her experience.
 
Wow....just....wow....I seriously feel ill right now.....Browne is one frakked up individual. Now I need to go vomit somewhere.
 
I own a small bookstore in a huge country north of the States and this has proven the final straw for me and the author Sylvia.
As a great fan of small bookstores in large countries, I offer you a warm welcome to the forum, and commend you on your stance.

(Does your bookstore have anything on heraldry?)
 
Yup--she (or her people) hear about a firefighter who died on that date and automatically assumes it was related to the terrorist attack on the WTC.

This story is right up there with the "she was shot" for a Sylvia gaffe.

How devastating to the widow. Thanks to her for sharing this painful story.

<derail>This reminds me of one of my pet rants. Shortly after 9/11 when our national leaders were falling over each other to spend money to protect us from terrorist attacks in the U.S., one of the skeptic mags ran an article reminding us of the realistic risks of terrorist attack compared to other risks.

Among other things they pointed out that a similar number of people are killed in traffic accidents just about every month. I believe a similar number are killed in gun-related deaths (about half of which, IIRC, are suicides).

They got ripped by people basically saying you can't compare highway accidents to 9/11 fatalities. Critics of the article say this some how lessens the value of the lives lost on 9/11.

I say their point of view is incredibly dismissive of the tragedies visited on a great many more families all the time by these other horrible deaths. Just because a death wasn't the result of a foreign aggressor doesn't mean it isn't just as tragic to the loved ones.

And yes, I believe the billions of dollars spent on "Homeland Security" could have prevented a substantial number of these other deaths.
</derail>
 
Last edited:
<derail>This reminds me of one of my pet rants. Shortly after 9/11 when our national leaders were falling over each other to spend money to protect us from terrorist attacks in the U.S., one of the skeptic mags ran an article reminding us of the realistic risks of terrorist attack compared to other risks.

Among other things they pointed out that a similar number of people are killed in traffic accidents just about every month. I believe a similar number are killed in gun-related deaths (about half of which, IIRC, are suicides).

<derail type="further">
Bruce SchneierWP has a blog where he talks about security: real, perceived, and otherwise.

Another good read is the essay by Bruce Mann titled "Homeland Insecurity,"published in the September 2002 edition of Atlantic Monthly.
</derail>
 
I just cannot fathom what would have prompted these people to call that poor woman back and tell her she was a liar. Good grief. I guess it was their idea of damage control after "The Great Sylvia" so blatantly fouled up that reading, but still, that is just unbelievable, low-class, and flat out evil. Boo! Hiss!

This story, above all others it seems, should be the voice from the rooftops that (I sincerely hope) would wake some people up.
 
Robert, I'm so grateful for all you do. There's nothing more I'd like than to see scum like this squashed into silence by a vanished audience and you chip away at that goal every day.

I still can't get over the fact that they called her back to blame her a second time. They either truly believe they're working for a master psychic or they're a full deck of bullies. I always believe the latter but wonder if they do believe in her abilities. They've seen all her failures, after all. =/
 
Kate,

I'll bet that at this point it's cult-like behavior. Even if they know it's crap they don't want to say so from fear of being ostracized.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom