StopSylviaBrowne - Contradiction: Do Angels Have Wings?

Oh yeah, on the Montel episode I was on, there were alot of people asking about their spirit guides and angels and paranormal experiences with and about dead relatives who they thought might be spirit guides but I didn't take notes on that so much.

I remember that there was a young man who was told his spirit guide was Marcellus and got a long description of him. I'd lay a million dollars on the line that had he asked Sylvia that again 15 minutes later, his spirit guide's name and description would be anything but that.

Oh- a few years ago, there was a widely circulated video of a woman on Montel who claimed to have captured an angel's wing in a vacation photo. SB of course enthusiastically verified it.
 
I remember that there was a young man who was told his spirit guide was Marcellus and got a long description of him. I'd lay a million dollars on the line that had he asked Sylvia that again 15 minutes later, his spirit guide's name and description would be anything but that.
Well, doesn't she claim that a person can have more than one spirit guide?

My spirit guide is a book on distillation.
 
The article on Holly Krewson really pissed me off. What SB said about the young woman was vile and so very wrong. And the fact that her mother died thinking her daughter was a junkie stripper is criminal.

SB needs to be stopped.
 
The article on Holly Krewson really pissed me off. What SB said about the young woman was vile and so very wrong. And the fact that her mother died thinking her daughter was a junkie stripper is criminal.

SB needs to be stopped.

The whole article was sickening. As if SB wasn't enough, reading the transcript of the phone call almost made me puke.
What sick, twisted mind does a thing like that?
 
It's funny. Every time I hear talk of Psychics and spirit guides all I can think about is Homers Coyote spirit guide from The Simpsons. Complete with the voice of Jonny Cash.

:)
 
Soooo, according to Sylly ... there's a rank of angelic beings called Carrions?
According to tradition, there are nine orders of angels, arranged in three triads. The first triad is the seraphim (a seraph has six wings), cherubim (a cherub has four wings, and is nothing like the popular image of a winged toddler), and the thromes (which also have six wings). The second triad has the dominations, the virtuers and the powers; the third triad consists of the principalities, the archangels, and the angels.

Carrions do not appear in any of the lists of angels I've seen.

You'd think carrions would have black wings, and maybe a gobbet of rotting flesh stuck between their teeth.
 
Maybe the Carrions are the patron-angels of traveling and protect all bags taken on board by the traveler and not placed in the luggage area of the plane (which, incidentally, has no angels protecting it, thus causing lost luggage)?
 
Heck, I still don't get how a spirit guide is different from an angel.
According to Browne, a Spirit Guide was at one point was a human. Angels were never human, they are a different species altogether. In this, she is in accord with Biblical doctrine. Although Hollywood likes to portray people as becoming angels after they die, Biblical doctrine says otherwise. An angel always was and always will be an angel.

Or how spirit guides don't contradict the cosmology of reincarnation and the afterlife.
According to Browne, we keep reincarnating until we learn all the lessons we are meant to learn. After that, some of us will choose to become spirit guides, and will go through special training on The Other Side. I think that is how she says it works, but I also recall her saying that someone of us already have been spirit guides, so I am not sure how that works. If we had learned enough lessons to become a spirit guide, why would we come back again?

I could easily have any or all of that wrong.

The article on Holly Krewson really pissed me off. What SB said about the young woman was vile and so very wrong. And the fact that her mother died thinking her daughter was a junkie stripper is criminal.
Agreed.

SB needs to be stopped.
Someone should start a web site! :)

Soooo, according to Sylly ... there's a rank of angelic beings called Carrions? :confused:
I don't know if it is original to Browne, but if you Google "carrion angels," there are more than a few pages with the term out there, including what appears to be a band by that name.

One site says that they are those angels which are in charge of getting rid of unpleasant things/beings on earth, and likened them to the spooky dark beings in the movie "Ghost."

The whole article was sickening. As if SB wasn't enough, reading the transcript of the phone call almost made me puke.
What sick, twisted mind does a thing like that?
Yeah, it was pretty vile. I wouldn't be surprised if Kelly has stories of similar things happening to the families she works with.
 
Yeah, the celebrated film critic Roger Ebert once talked about this in his column:

Movie Answer Man


Roger Ebert / December 29, 1996

Q. In your review of "The Preacher's Wife" you state: "Surely the makers of this film do not believe that humans go to heaven and become angels. As we all know, angels were created by God as his first companions, and he created humans much later..." Perhaps you meant this comment ironically. I do not think Hollywood filmmakers take their theology from catechisms, serious theological works, or (God forbid) the Bible. Rather I presume their view of God, angels, the afterlife, etc. comes mostly from other movies, and television. The defining example for most filmmakers is, I suppose, "It's a Wonderful Life," where Clarence (who has yet to earn his wings) is identified as a clock maker who had died 200 years before. (Alan K. Scholes, Crestline, CA.)


A. As I pointed out in a recent article on this very question, it is universally agreed among those religions that believe in them that angels have no sexual feelings, no bodies, no gender, and can love only God. They are NOT former humans who have returned from heaven for a visit from earth. Angels like Clarence, John Travolta's "Michael" and the [URL="http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/classifieds?category=search1&SearchType=1&q=Denzel%20Washington&Class=%25&FromDate=19150101&ToDate=20071231"]Denzel Washington[/URL] character in "The Preacher's Wife" represent just plain sloppy theology from Hollywood.
 
Soooo, according to Sylly ... there's a rank of angelic beings called Carrions? :confused:

Definition of "carrion"

Well, of course. Unfortunately, this rank of angels can only fly on commercial airlines, and even then, only under the seat, or in the overhead compartments.

How rude to make fun of her spelling disability.
 
The article on Holly Krewson really pissed me off. What SB said about the young woman was vile and so very wrong. And the fact that her mother died thinking her daughter was a junkie stripper is criminal.

SB needs to be stopped.

The Krewson material upset me very much, but this one is absolutely horrible in so many ways as well.
 
As opposed to the scientific kind of theology?

You know what he meant.

Even though I have no religious beliefs now, I'm still annoyed when someone, say, thinks pastors are Catholic priests who are allowed to marry. So I'd see why he'd call them sloppy.
 
I don't think that's an altogether fair assessment, Zep [...they are many sandwiches short of a picnic]. I think that most of them are certainly choosing to believe in stuff that makes them feel good. I don't think this means they are crazy, or stupid.
Hmmm...

I think perhaps that I meant that in the same way we say that granny is going dotty on her old age, or that you always barrack for the perpetually-at-the-bottom-of-the-league team. That is, not so much in the sense of being so mentally unstable as to cause public worry and need institutionalising and medication, but more in the sense of overindulging in a relatively harmless but strange quirk or habit that makes absolutely no sense to the majority of the population.

I could have also used expressions like:

-- The lights are on but no-one is home
-- Don't have both oars in the water
-- Harmlessly potty

For mine, the faery-folks are welcome to their "hobby". But my point was that Sylvia doesn't believe in it any more than we would - in fact, not at all - and she only pretends she does in order to exploit them cruelly.
 
One spelling error:

"Compared to the number of people reading Browne's books in the late 1990s, the number of people who had attended Browne's "trance sessions" in 1991 was miniscule."

Should be minuscule.
 
What a great article, RSL. I'll admit, I wasn't too excited when I read the article's title but I was pleasantly surprised that you managed to open a hole the size of the grand canyon out of a simple discrepancy that's gone long overlooked. Beautiful work, sir. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom