StopSylviaBrowne - Contradiction: Do Angels Have Wings?

...an Aztec-Incan woman named Iena, although I took it upon myself to change her name to Francine. She was born in northern Colombia in 1500 and was killed in a Spanish attack on her city in 1520. That was her only incarnation on this earth...

O....K.

First, the Aztec empire didn't stretch into South America, but was solely within the borders of present day Mexico.

Second, the only part of Colombia that was part of the Incan empire was conquered after 1525, 5 years after Francine/Iena was killed.

Third, the part of Colombia that did become part of the empire was the very South-western part of the area, not the northern.

Sylvia Browne is a liar.
 
Forth. How can you have a woman being part of two different civilisations?
Aztec
Incan

Anyone who is not convinced of the evidence of what Sylvia Browne is will never be convinced of the evidence.
 
I would be laughing if I wasn't so disturbed by the fact that so many people believed the drivel that she spews.
 
I was a little dubious of the topic of this article when I started reading. Does it really matter if an imaginary animal is supposed to have wings or not? Sylvia could dismiss these contradictions as the toll of time on her memory, or Francine being confused or whatever. It does get a bit more interesting when the philosophy switches from "no wings whatsoever" to a detailed description of the appearance of the wings seen on different kinds of angel.

I found the most interesting part of this article to be the analysis of Sylvia's trance session, and how blatantly obvious is is that she's faking it. I think you should do an article directly addressing the issue of "Francine," and maybe discuss the historical inaccuracy CFLarson brought up. Francine and the idea of spirit guides are massively popular among Browne's followers.
 
Over on the GSB site, all the posters there have giant avatars with faeries and angels on them, with wizzo '70's LSD-inspired colour-schemes. And they chat earnestly on and on about angels and faeries and so on, like they were really really real.

In short, these people are many sandwiches short of a picnic, which makes them ideal "marks" for Sylvia to exploit to the hilt. How does she do that? Easy: If they're buying, she's selling. Feed their juvenile fantasies with this sort of stuff about angel's wings, and thus win them over. Then she just milks them for all it's worth.

Now please note the last quote in my sig.
 
Last edited:
Good article, Robert. Sadly, these kind of things are probably more apt to open peoples eyes to what Sylvia Browne is than the fact she has spit on people who are suffering to advance her own agenda.
 
The article states:

In some versions of the story, the archangel simply vanishes after smiling. In at least one other version, the archangel tells her its name (Ariel), and why it is there (to guard Browne's granddaughter).

If indeed you have proof that Sylvia tells stories about angels talking to her, that would directly contradict the following information in the FAQ on Sylvia's website concerning the differences between angels and spirit guides (emphasis mine):

Angels, on the other hand, are special creations made by God who never live a physical life. They all have the same appearance, tall and beautiful, but they do not speak. They also come to your side when you need help, and will always come if you simply ask God to send assistance. So if you are hearing, or even sensing, a voice then it is your Spirit Guide speaking, not an Angel.

I also found this sentence to be a bit awkward (perhaps too many commas):

Many of Browne's followers know that early on, Browne said that angels do not have wings, and that later, she says she found out differently, and now says that indeed, all angels have them.

-Bri
 
Why do angels need wings? Are they subject to the laws of physics? Do they have hollow-bones that make them able to achieve lift off? It would seem a vestigial appendage for a spirit creature -- sort of like a kidney or Sylvia's nose.
 
O....K.

First, the Aztec empire didn't stretch into South America, but was solely within the borders of present day Mexico.

Second, the only part of Colombia that was part of the Incan empire was conquered after 1525, 5 years after Francine/Iena was killed.

Third, the part of Colombia that did become part of the empire was the very South-western part of the area, not the northern.

Sylvia Browne is a liar.

CF is dead-on. While there may have been some interaction between the Aztek and Incan empires...it was limited and periferal to the two cultures. Their interactions were minimal. They didn't share a common language or trade.

What does Azteck/Incan mean? What does Brown thinks it means?

It would be an anthropological first....
 
Over on the GSB site, all the posters there have giant avatars with faeries and angels on them, with wizzo '70's LSD-inspired colour-schemes. And they chat earnestly on and on about angels and faeries and so on, like they were really really real.
[...]

They are really really real, in Browne's mythology anyway. They reside on the first or second levels of the underworld (I forget which is where on the first couple; fairies, gnomes, elves...). They don't often interact with people, but do help children. If memory serves, Sylvia has actually seen one. Francine has seen a dragon, too, but dragons are in one of the middle levels and those aren't much fun to visit. There's a cut-off one one of the first few levels, such that Lilith keeps them confined to the just underworld, thank God. I really don't think there's anything she doesn't believe in, UFOs, the Loch Ness monster, Atlantis... She has it all covered.
 
Well this may be interesting then... I've been listening to Sylvias Hay House radio shows and here's what she says on the 3-10-05 show called "Spirit Guides, Ghosts and Messages Our Loved Ones".

In the first 15 minutes of the show she mentions that:
"I was so stupid that I, even in my lectures, that I actually told people that angels didn't have wings until I saw an angel and literally saw one- it had gorgeous wings with maroon tips to them and then I asked my guide an I said 'Why do they have wings, are they floppin around and flying around?' and she said no, no, no this is a badge of what phylum they come from- whether they're charities or virtues or cherubim or seraphim or the big guys, the big guns, the thrones and the principalities..."

She doesn't give any date as to when she realized how stupid she was or when Francine enlightened her on angels wings though.

Also (incidentally) towards the end of that show she tells a caller named Sheryl that she has fibromyalgia (Sylvia tells many people on her radio show that they have fibromyalgia). Sheryl asks Sylvia if she could spell that disease for her and Sylvia replies (obviously annoyed) "F-I-V-R-E-M-A-L-A" then she pauses for a couple seconds and quietly says "malay".
Sheryl then asks if she'll be OK with that (disease) and Sylvia assures "Oh yeah" before disconnecting her and moving on.

A masters in English and she can't spell fibromyalgia when put on the spot?? :confused:
 
You're dead right of course, Robert. She's just flapping in the wind.
:)

O....K.

First, the Aztec empire didn't stretch into South America, but was solely within the borders of present day Mexico.

Second, the only part of Colombia that was part of the Incan empire was conquered after 1525, 5 years after Francine/Iena was killed.

Third, the part of Colombia that did become part of the empire was the very South-western part of the area, not the northern.

Sylvia Browne is a liar.
Yeah, I chose not to go into that in this article. There will most likely be an entire article devoted to Francine herself.

Forth. How can you have a woman being part of two different civilisations?
Aztec
Incan

Anyone who is not convinced of the evidence of what Sylvia Browne is will never be convinced of the evidence.
Browne says she researched it, and the only time the two civilizations met was in Colombia in th early 1500s. It will be part of a "Francine" article.

I would be laughing if I wasn't so disturbed by the fact that so many people believed the drivel that she spews.
:(

I was a little dubious of the topic of this article when I started reading. Does it really matter if an imaginary animal is supposed to have wings or not?
Try researching it through several books and audio atapes and see how silly you feel. :boggled:

I found the most interesting part of this article to be the analysis of Sylvia's trance session, and how blatantly obvious is is that she's faking it. I think you should do an article directly addressing the issue of "Francine," and maybe discuss the historical inaccuracy CFLarson brought up.
Yup, it's planned.

In short, these people are many sandwiches short of a picnic,
I don't think that's an altogether fair assessment, Zep. I think that most of them are certainly choosing to believe in stuff that makes them feel good. I don't think this means they are crazy, or stupid.

...which makes them ideal "marks" for Sylvia to exploit to the hilt. How does she do that? Easy: If they're buying, she's selling. Feed their juvenile fantasies with this sort of stuff about angel's wings, and thus win them over. Then she just milks them for all it's worth.
Agreed 100%.

Good article, Robert. Sadly, these kind of things are probably more apt to open peoples eyes to what Sylvia Browne is than the fact she has spit on people who are suffering to advance her own agenda.
I think that both types of articles will help a different group of people.

If indeed you have proof that Sylvia tells stories about angels talking to her, that would directly contradict the following information in the FAQ on Sylvia's website concerning the differences between angels and spirit guides (emphasis mine):
Yes, I considered that. But she says that the angel "told" her, which doesn't necessarily mean that it spoke the words aloud. It could have told her telepathically.

I also found this sentence to be a bit awkward (perhaps too many commas):
Yeah, I meant to go back and fix it. Done, thanks!

Why do angels need wings? Are they subject to the laws of physics? Do they have hollow-bones that make them able to achieve lift off? It would seem a vestigial appendage for a spirit creature -- sort of like a kidney or Sylvia's nose.
In at least one point, she says that they are used to "enfold and protect us" or words to that effect. Also that they are like a badge, to help tell the different "phyla" apart. And they are pretty.

What does Azteck/Incan mean? What does Brown thinks it means?

It would be an anthropological first....
I'll be looking into it.

But how many can you fit on a pin????
Depends on whether or not they are dancing.

All of them and you'd still have room for Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster.
Okay, now you're just being silly. :D
 
Heck, I still don't get how a spirit guide is different from an angel. Or how spirit guides don't contradict the cosmology of reincarnation and the afterlife.
 
Yes, I considered that. But she says that the angel "told" her, which doesn't necessarily mean that it spoke the words aloud. It could have told her telepathically.

Except that the description in the FAQ seems to specifically preclude that possibility (emphasis mine):

So if you are hearing, or even sensing, a voice then it is your Spirit Guide speaking, not an Angel.

It seems a stretch to imagine that the FAQ implies a distinction between telepathic communication and "sensing a voice."

-Bri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom