StopSylviaBrowne: Browne & Christianity, Levels of Creation

That said, I do not retract my assessment that she exhibits the utmost contempt for her audience.

Yes, and I am saddened that more of her followers don't see that. Even if people were to believe in ADC I would hope that they could see how rude she is to some of her audience members.

As for the rest of your post, let me repeat what I said in post #11: I agree with your statement that some of her followers are just supertitious and stupid, I just disagreed with the numbers. Upon reflection, I realized my disagreement may have been out of place given that you never were more specific than saying "a significant percentage."

I think my primary motivation for not letting your original post stand without some criticism was knowing that some believers and some fence-sitters lurk here to see what is going on. I don't want those people to think that skeptics are heartless a-holes.
 
I think my primary motivation for not letting your original post stand without some criticism was knowing that some believers and some fence-sitters lurk here to see what is going on. I don't want those people to think that skeptics are heartless a-holes.
I appreciate that. It's also important, I think, not to appear to blame the victim, especially when you seek to direct the criticism exclusively at the charlatan.

In this thread, my disgust is directed exclusively at Browne. Shame on her.

(I expect it's been posted elsewhere, but she is the featured guest on Montel tomorrow, although this may be a rerun. Shame on him, too, by the way.)
 
I appreciate that. It's also important, I think, not to appear to blame the victim, especially when you seek to direct the criticism exclusively at the charlatan.

Yes and no.

Remember Clancie? She knew that psychic Robert Brown was a crook, yet she continued to claim that he was real, to other believers. I have no problems criticizing that, in no uncertain terms.

It is because of people like Clancie that psychics like Sylvia Browne can go on scamming people.
 
I know you say that the first is not skeptical - but I think your concluding line "However, none of them could tell me if there were any such prohibitions against merely pretending to talk with the dead, which is what Browne appears to be doing." does the rest of the article a bit of a disservice - I think a more powerful ending would be along the lines of:"
On a tangential note, not only does scripture prohibit contacting the dead, but it also states that doing so is not actually possible, and that any actual spirits contacted would be impostors -- "demons and unclean spirits" masquerading as the dearly departed.
 
RSLancastr
Just done a search on Google. Your site is not mentioned if I type SylviaBrowne. You may need to fix this. If I type "Sylvia Browne" then it is the first site on the second page.

Your results may differ slightly as I am in Australia.
 
Robert, I think it would be helpful to add this to the Browne and Christianity article: Sylvia doesn't believe in the existence of Satan or Hell, something she's stated in one book and on Montel.

She says that the second she was told those things in Catholic school as a child she "simply knew they weren't true and were just invented to scare people".

Now, could someone please explain to me how it's possible to believe in both a heaven/ Other Side and in reincarnation?
 
Robert, I think it would be helpful to add this to the Browne and Christianity article: Sylvia doesn't believe in the existence of Satan or Hell, something she's stated in one book and on Montel.
EMM, thanks for the suggestion, but I intentionally left these out of the article.

I was trying to contrast her take on things with those of "mainstream Christianity," and so I tried to stick to topics on which mainstream Christianity has somewhat of a consensus, so I would not have to compare her take with that of various denominations.

As I understand it, there is a wide variety of interpretations on the subjects of Hell and Satan within mainstream Christianity. Is Hell a physical place? An allegory? Is it simply being "absent from the presence of God?" Various denominations have their own takes on this, so I left it off of the list.
 
"light coma" is particularly funny for those of us who are fans of Arrested Development.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom