StopSylviaBrowne: Browne & Christianity, Levels of Creation

I know you say that the first is not skeptical - but I think your concluding line "However, none of them could tell me if there were any such prohibitions against merely pretending to talk with the dead, which is what Browne appears to be doing." does the rest of the article a bit of a disservice - I think a more powerful ending would be along the lines of:

"Sylvia Brown, if she believes in her Church's tenets and what she has published in her books cannot claim to be a Christian as she does not believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God and mankind's only Saviour."
 
As for the second one... honestly she sounds like a drunk trying to explain something to someone who is sober - she comes out with words and fragments of phrases yet it is nothing more then an incoherent burble with no reason behind it.
 
I think a more powerful ending would be along the lines of:

"Sylvia Brown, if she believes in her Church's tenets and what she has published in her books cannot claim to be a Christian as she does not believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God and mankind's only Saviour."
That would definitely be a powerful ending if I were a Christian. Being an agnostic, I don't think I have much place saying who can and cannot claim to be a Christian.

All I felt comfortable doing within the context of that article is pointing out major differences between Browne's brand of Christianity, and that of "mainstream" Christianity.

I leave the "she is/isn't a Christian" opinions to Christians.
 
As for the second one... honestly she sounds like a drunk trying to explain something to someone who is sober - she comes out with words and fragments of phrases yet it is nothing more then an incoherent burble with no reason behind it.
Yup. I thought it pretty much spoke for itself, and simply used the "fairy story" as a way of closing the article.

Personally, I think she sounded like a junior high student doing an oral book report on a book after only reading the table of contents.
 
That would definitely be a powerful ending if I were a Christian. Being an agnostic, I don't think I have much place saying who can and cannot claim to be a Christian.

All I felt comfortable doing within the context of that article is pointing out major differences between Browne's brand of Christianity, and that of "mainstream" Christianity.

I leave the "she is/isn't a Christian" opinions to Christians.

Fair enough.
 
Yup. I thought it pretty much spoke for itself, and simply used the "fairy story" as a way of closing the article.

Personally, I think she sounded like a junior high student doing an oral book report on a book after only reading the table of contents.

I do wonder how much of her published material she has actually authored herself? In all her appearances I have seen and heard she hardly seems able to construct a sentence - yet her published words (that I've read on your site) at least manage to resemble sentences - even if their content is as nonsensical as anything she normally says! I suspect she has quite extensive help.
 
What I find fascinating is the absolute, utter contempt that Browne has for the public. She assumes a populace that is superstitious to the Nth degree and as stupid as a sack of corn meal.

And she makes her living from the unfortunate fact that a significant percentage of the public falls into this category. Well, you know what they say about a fool and his/her money....
 
What I find fascinating is the absolute, utter contempt that Browne has for the public. She assumes a populace that is superstitious to the Nth degree and as stupid as a sack of corn meal.

And she makes her living from the unfortunate fact that a significant percentage of the public falls into this category. Well, you know what they say about a fool and his/her money....

I think you may be going too far here. Many of her clients are filled with grief to the point that their judgement is clouded. Still, I will agree that some of her believers fall into the category that you describe.
 
I think you may be going too far here. Many of her clients are filled with grief to the point that their judgement is clouded.
I agree, Ladewig. Since putting up the site, I have corresponded with a number of people who fell for Browne while in such a state and later regretted it.
 
Sylvia's Plagiarism?

I apologize for not having the article to hand, but in one issue of the Skeptical Inquirer, a comparison was given between Sylvia's writing on some occult matter and a piece by Joe Nickell, I believe. She copied him almost word for word. I'll try to find it, but forgive an old lady who's had too much dinner on New Year's Day and is comfortably settled in her Lazy-Boy.
 
I think you may be going too far here. Many of her clients are filled with grief to the point that their judgement is clouded. Still, I will agree that some of her believers fall into the category that you describe.
This is a good point. Curiously, I'm reminded of Captain Kirk's remark, that "Desperation is a highly emotional state," an observation with which Mr. Spock agreed.

I suspect that Kirk's remark was rather an understatement. Desperation is not only highly emotional, it is a nemesis to logical thinking. Desperation smothers rationality. Desperation is a state of surrender to insanity. Other highly emotional states, such as fear, joy, love, amusement, and even grief do not block out all rational thinking, although they can make rational thinking more difficult.

Desperation is different. Desperate people lose all sense of reason and for that reason are easy prey for charlatans. Sadly, I have seen this happen, even to members of my own family.

It is desperation, not mere grief or any other emotion, that drives people to consult so-called psychics or other charlatans. Many people think that maybe, just maybe, Browne has some legitimate information that will answer their questions. If they weren't in a state of desperation, they'd recognize at once that she is talking out of her bung hole, to put it euphemistically.

That said, I do not retract my assessment that she exhibits the utmost contempt for her audience.
 
So there's seven levels below, and seven levels above. So what I did was, everything that's, you know, like gnomes and fairies, and any thought that we have, is on the lower level.

Sylvia Browne believes in gnomes and fairies?

Yup.

Sylvia Browne believes in gnomes and fairies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom