StopSylviaBrowne: Browne Attempts to Silence My Site

I haven't read all the article, but I do know that in the UK this would be laughable. I assume it's not much different under US laws.

You would only need to worry if you were either using sylviabrown.com (or similar) as a straight domain name or if your domain name was of a derogatory nature (e.g. sylviabrowne-is-a-fraudulent-scumbag-and-no-more-psychic-than-my-dogs-ass.com)

EDIT: OK, read the full letter now - it's a joke. Yes, if the website was named so as to cause possible confusion (re affiliation) to people searching for "sylvia browne" then you might need to take this more seriously, but seeing as the title of the site is STOPsylviabrown then I am hard-pressed to imagine how a URL could be less indicative of affiliation!
 
Last edited:
Whoa, calm down.

While The Lancaster sure has the support of JREF, it is quite another matter for JREF to fund or even support a lawsuit against The Lancaster.

While I have no doubt that this is just a pathetic attempt of silencing The Lancaster (sheesh, they can't even spell the name of their client right???), without the case ever going to court, let's not get ahead of ourselves and include JREF in this. That is entirely JREF's decision, if and when it comes to a lawsuit.
Yes, I know it's their decision rather than mine, I'm just pointing out that their decision would almost certainly be "yes", if money turns out to be needed and if they were asked.
 
RS, you've struck a nerve, that's for sure. I think that the largest load of BS I've seen in a while.

Isn't there some legal fund for skeptics - or did I dream this?

Edit: Looks like that's been discussed while I was typing.
 
You would only need to worry if you were either using sylviabrown.com (or similar) as a straight domain name or if your domain name was of a derogatory nature (e.g. sylviabrowne-is-a-fraudulent-scumbag-and-no-more-psychic-than-my-dogs-ass.com)
I think any decent lawyer could argue that this was fair comment.
 
Just noticed that she chose lawyers who have a duck as a logo - very fitting to defending outrageous quackery

(OK, so it may be a swan... :) )
 
Last edited:
Just to reiterate what everyone else has said here, "Go, Robert!" Damn fine job.
How can we help?
 
Had a good bit of advice, but Doc A beat me to it.

I'm going to assume that the foundation would be delighted to be associated with a defence against this suit, if they actually file. There's also the ACLU, of course. This is obviously a freedom of speech issue.

Frankly, though, I think you could probably defend it yourself, as it's got no legs.

And Robert, as with everyone else, I want to congratulate you, not just for the incredible job you've been doing, but for your instincts from the outset. If you've got them picking on questionable copyright infringement issues, it means your original decision to apply high standards of "reporting" were absolutely correct. Hanging her with her own words and acts was absolutely the was the right way to go. If they thought there was something bigger, they'd surely be coming after you with heavier threats. This isn't to say they won't, and with that in mind, I think maybe you should contact Randi. Sylvia doesn't want any part of Randi, as is quite obvious. If they were to receive a response from ________, Attorneys for the James Randi Educational Foundation, you'd probably curl those nails!

@Claus - The Doc already posted the "evidence". What more than Randi's own statement as to the purposes of the JREF would one require to consider that this might be a very appropriate call to make. Randi's been in the same skirmish (and on the same TV show), and an obvious attempt to muzzle criticism (much inspired by Randi, I'm going to guess) is exactly what such a legal fund should be used towards, IMHO.
I don't think there's anything wrong with members and supporters of the JREF to suggest that this is a good idea. The JREF will make the final decision, but I don't think they work or live in a vacuum. (In fact, I wouldn't be at all surprised if Jeff and/or Randi haven't already started considering this. It's almost as if that paragraph was written to specifically cover this instance.)
 
As others have already said, she really has no legal grounds for trying to shut you down, and is only attempting to intimidate you.

However, if you don't want to risk spending a small fortune on legal fees, transfer the domain hosting and registration to a service in a country where U.S. trademarks and copyrights do not apply.

Then send her lawyers a photocopy of your butt.
 
Oh puleease. If SB thinks that a letter from lawyers is going to work then she's sadly mistaken. Any litigation by SB would be heavily counterproductive.
 
I agree with those who take this as a good sign. RSL has ruffled some feathers. Nicely done.
 
I think when ever I use here name from now on, I'll add (SM) just to be a smart ass. In a way, that detracts from any credibility she may try to cling to - a service mark shows even more interest in money - or at least it does to me.
 
Just say the word and I'll donate to a legal defense fund.

You know that the kind of lawyer that will defend against these silly charges will come a lot cheaper that the ones that will file them!. Plus you might get legal fees awarded which will mean you are taking Sylvia's money.

But I would be very surprised if this ever goes anywhere.
 
Slight derail: Anyone with Photoshop skills here? Can someone stick Sylvia's face in this photo for my blog?


 
I tend to agree this is good news--it means you're making an impact, Bob, and you have her running scared. w00t. :D

On the other hand, though, she DOES have deep pockets. Hell, she makes (excuse me, CHARGES :rolleyes:) $750 for 20 minutes of babbling on the phone. Even if the terms of the legal threat are laughable, even dragging you through court can be long and costly.

I'm sure I don't need to tell you that you have lots of people here willing to help contribute to a defense campaign, but I'd suggest securing yourself an attorney as soon as possible. Showing it to an attorney you know is great, but it's best to be prepared to have someone represent you.

I'd also suggest getting on the phone with Randi and seeing if, at minimum, he can give you some helpful advice (FSM knows he's been in this spot before) and, even better, maybe you and JREF can collaborate together on the legal front.

But back to my first point--congratulations on getting Dr. Claw so worked up she's siccing her lawyers on you. :D
 
That letter from Sylvia's attorneys looks pretty much like the standard 'scare' boilerplate letter that you can get any attorney to write for $150.

I honestly cannot recall a website losing a lawsuit for using someone else's name, unless they were blatantly attempting to profit from it. Now, if RSL had used the domain www.Iamsylviabrowne.com, that MIGHT be an issue...........
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom