StopSylviaBrowne: Browne Attempts to Silence My Site

Well, that man has my undying respect and admiration. I consider him among the four finest human beings ever to have lived (Natalie Portman and Gilgamesh being two of the other three).

Are you a lawyer LL? If so, I would be interested on your opinion on this.

Robert's lawyer clearly defended against the claims made against Robert, finishing with a statement that there was no case to answer.

If Sylvia's lawyers wished to reserve these issues for later action, would their future position be potentially weakened if they do not send a pithy reply saying "well, we don't agree with you"?
 
Question for Loss Leader (and maybe RSL's attorney): Browne is now permitting someone allegedly unconnected to her to use a domain name somewhat similar to "stopsylviabrowne". Would this have any effect on any future attempt to go after RSL on trade mark grounds? There is a concept of dilution of a trade mark (I think this applies in the UK and US at least), whereby a trade mark can lose protection if the trade mark owner allows its use other than as a trade mark (this is why, for example, Google objects to the use of its name as a verb). Would the concept come into play here?

It's certainly an interesting question. Unfortunately, there is no actual answer. It is such an unusual set of circumstances and so fact-dependent, that the only place the answer resides is in the minds of the judge or jury that would eventually have to consider the question.

I don't know what RSL's lawyer would say, but if I had to guess I would think that it has no effect on StopSylviaBrowne whatsoever. This new site was created with the permission and endorsement of Browne. So, in that way, it is different from using "Xerox" or "Google" as a verb. It still references quite clearly the subject of the trademark (Sylvia herself) and not some more general concept like "psychics" or "women with hideous fingernails and a smoker's cough".

The new site also doesn't make it any more or less likely that an unsophisticated consumer would believe 'StopSylviaBrowne" is actually endorsed by her. If there were dozens of fan sites and critic sites like there are for, let's say, the TV show American Idol, maybe people should be expected to realize that the site they are on is NOT an official site. Here, there are two sites - pro-Sylvia and anti-Sylvia. I don't think those issues come into play.

All in all, I would suspect the new site is designed just to pull web hits away from StopSylviaBrowne.Com and not to strengthen any trademark claim.
 
Are you a lawyer LL? If so, I would be interested on your opinion on this.

Robert's lawyer clearly defended against the claims made against Robert, finishing with a statement that there was no case to answer.

If Sylvia's lawyers wished to reserve these issues for later action, would their future position be potentially weakened if they do not send a pithy reply saying "well, we don't agree with you"?

I am a lawyer. In my opinion, their answering or not answering would not only have no effect on their future position, but the very fact of whether they answered or not would be inadmissible as any proof of anything.

That's just my opinion and other lawyers may differ.
 
All in all, I would suspect the new site is designed just to pull web hits away from StopSylviaBrowne.Com and not to strengthen any trademark claim.
I wasn't suggesting that it was intended to strengthen the trademark claim; I was suggesting that allowing a third party to use the name might weaken the trademark claim.
 
I wasn't suggesting that it was intended to strengthen the trademark claim; I was suggesting that allowing a third party to use the name might weaken the trademark claim.

It won't weaken Sylvia's trademark of her own name. It won't strengthen her position as regards RSL. It won't do anything but increase the signal noise out on the internet with the hope of obscuring RSL's broadcasts.
 
It's not exactly a win. All that happened was that RSL signaled that he was prepared to defend himself and Sylvia chose not to attack at this time. The threat is still out there and the attack may come at any time.

It's good news that Sylvia's letter was a bluff - at least in terms of what she was prepared to do to enforce it at that moment. But it is not a win.

This round is undecided...

"A lack of victory is not defeat,
And a lack of defeat is not victory."​

I think this is a Lao Tzu quote, but I don't have my copy of "The Art Of War" in front of me.​
 
Last edited:
She can also just ride it out, just let the sands of time cover it all up. Which is what she seems to be doing right now.

That assumes that Robert's site is doing very little damage to her. If that assumption is correct then that option is reasonable. But if Robert's site is doing damage to her then she must react or retire.

Time is on Robert's side not Sylvia's. She will make more mistakes that Robert will find out about and put on his website. So the damage will accumulate.

This also shows that every day that Robert's website is up is a victory for Robert.
 
This round is undecided...

"A lack of victory is not defeat,
And a lack of defeat is not victory."​

I think this is a Lao Tzu quote, but I don't have my copy of "The Art Of War" in front of me.​

It was Sun Tzu who wrote The Art of War; Lao Tzu wrote the Tao Te Ching.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom