StopSylviaBrowne: Browne Attempts to Silence My Site


Like I already said, I disagree.

BTW, in all the threads discussing this, I have yet to see anything mentioning the idea that the best conmen are the ones that believe their own cons. I am perfectly willing to grant Sylvia the authenticity of her belief and religious claims; this is in no way inconsistent with her being a junkyard dog when it comes to her income.

As to why she would be afraid to testify under oath about her beliefs, she would not be the only believer to think that faith cannot stand on its own, but has to be protected. Neither would she be the only believer to think that cheating is a permissible way to "supplement" the miracle.

You guys really do underestimate the wonders of rationalization, don't you?

No, but I have a very hard time believing that Sylvia Browne really believes her own crap. What do you base that on?
 
I wonder has she ever claimed that she isn't in it for the money? If so then that would be inconsistent.

Of course she's inconsistent! But she's only inconsistent when you're on the outside, looking in. If she really believes what she says, then it's all perfectly logical from her point of view. If you truly are trying to figure out her motives, stop trying to impose your own point of view on her actions.

Which brings up another point I haven't seen discussed in these threads. Just suppose that Sylvia truly is deluded about her "gift." Then I suggest she will act pretty much the same as any other person will act to protect her delusion.
 
Last edited:
No, but I have a very hard time believing that Sylvia Browne really believes her own crap.

That is a measure of your own mindset, and nothing else.

What do you base that on?

As I said, the best con men believe their own cons. As evidenced by her income, Sylvia is a good con man.

Besides, as I mentioned to Darat, I believe her actions to be consistent with someone under a true delusion.
 
Last edited:
So here we are, condemning $ylvia Browne in no uncertain terms for pretending to know people's innermost thoughts without even having spoken with them.

And here we are, stating in no uncertain terms that we know $ylvia Browne's innermost thoughts, without even having spoken with her.

Bravo for life's little ironies. :clap:
I, for one, don't give a spiral crap what her innermost thoughts are, Beeps. The evidence IS that she makes a truckload of money for blatantly lying her arse off to grieving people, picking their pockets, and kicking them in the nuts.

Does that give her a huge adrenalin-rush so she feels like King Kong on steroids? F[rule-8]ked if I care. But in the same process, has she ripped off gullible and vulnerable people of great lumps of their money, given them lies and pain, and run away from them cackling? Now I care. So do others.
 
Of course she's inconsistent! But she's only inconsistent when you're on the outside, looking in. If she really believes what she says, then it's all perfectly logical from her point of view.

What is?

If you truly are trying to figure out her motives, stop trying to impose your point of view on her actions.

I haven't - I've looked at the evidence, that is not imposing my "point of view" on her actions but using reason.


Which brings up another point I haven't seen discussed in these threads. Just suppose that Sylvia truly is deluded about her "gift." Then I suggest she will act pretty much the same as any other person will act to protect her delusion.

And?
 
So here we are, condemning $ylvia Browne in no uncertain terms for pretending to know people's innermost thoughts without even having spoken with them....snip....

As far as I know she does not claim to know people's "inner thoughts"?
 
I'm not altogether sure just how useful a discussion of her motives really is.

Whether it is money or power, whether she truly believes it or not, it doesn't change the fact that she should stop.

And offhand I don't see how knowing her motives can help us in strategizing how to make that happen.
 
Randi's books go into delusion and its implications fairly completely; there's no need for me to restate them.

That doesn't help me understand what you were saying.

And, frankly, delusion answers a lot more questions about Sylvia's motivation and actions than ...snip....

What evidence do you base that conclusion on? (Oh and I have never said she is not delusional or that she is.)
 
I'm not altogether sure just how useful a discussion of her motives really is.

Whether it is money or power, whether she truly believes it or not, it doesn't change the fact that she should stop.

And offhand I don't see how knowing her motives can help us in strategizing how to make that happen.

I strongly disagree; I believe there is a lot of truth in "know your enemy", understanding her motivation could really help with forming the most effective strategy to stop her.
 
Re: Is Browne being delusional to herself?

While I can't seem to find it immediately, I did read an account (on this forum) of someone who tried to get a refund on their "Sylvia Browne Show" ticket because Sylvia failed to provide them a satisfactory reading. The narrative then described what happened, and the immediate impression I gained from the description was that the whole "Sylvia Browne Travelling Roadshow and Circus" is simply an updated and expanded version of Madame Zenda, the carnie sideshow fortune-teller.

In fact, her act remains precisely that, which is why it is so derned easy to discredit, but it has been the surrounding business structure that has been vastly improved over the sideshow tent. It is clear it is modelled closely on the fundamentalist preachers like Popper, the Bakkers and so on - lots of worship not of God but of the preacher...and MUCH passing of the offering plate and heavy doses of televangelism. In fact she even started her own religion, that Novus Spiritus rubbish, to use the same money-spinning mechanisms. Why? because this evangelism thing's a huge money-earner (and tax-dodge! I forgot that!) when it is aimed at the tens of millions of gullible believers in the USA. It's an old game: If just one million people donate $10 each...*

So, short answer is most likely: No, she is not self-delusional about her "powers". Maybe she IS about her business abilities, or with her trust in the people who make her business decisions. Personally, I think she is the top dog, she's calculating and heartless, and makes the decisions herself accordingly.


*Now do the same sum with 100 million people at $700 each - that's the power of going on Montel. :eek:
 
As I said, the best con men believe their own cons. As evidenced by her income, Sylvia is a good con man.

Besides, as I mentioned to Darat, I believe her actions to be consistent with someone under a true delusion.

Why would someone truly deluded care about Randi and Lancaster?
 
I strongly disagree; I believe there is a lot of truth in "know your enemy", understanding her motivation could really help with forming the most effective strategy to stop her.

Agree 100%.
 
I'm not altogether sure just how useful a discussion of her motives really is.

Whether it is money or power, whether she truly believes it or not, it doesn't change the fact that she should stop.

And offhand I don't see how knowing her motives can help us in strategizing how to make that happen.

I strongly disagree; I believe there is a lot of truth in "know your enemy", understanding her motivation could really help with forming the most effective strategy to stop her.
Rob, I have to agree with Darat. Practical experience with similar attempts such as your excellent effort indicates that it is critical to appreciate EXACTLY which of Sylvia's buttons you can push and which you should not to get your desired result. Can I suggest you email the webmaster at www.ratbags.com for more details on precisely this subject - there is a very recent precedent to your efforts...

But please rest assured: There seems to be full agreement that taking down Sylvia Browne is a praiseworthy goal worth pursuing, and we are trying to support you any way we can.
 
That would mean that Sylvia is not in control of her own company. .

By this account, any manager who doesn't take care in person of every single aspect of the defence of their interests should be considered not being in control of their own company ... absurd.

Note that we don't know whether she's actually totally in control of her own company, and that should also be factored in assessing what her next moves may be.

Which speaks against money being her primary motivation

doesn't follow ...


If you cannot know what her real motivations are, then you cannot say anything about money being her primary motivation.

Neither can you tell about power ...
 
Seriously Claus people like Zep and me can point to actual evidence of how she structures her business, how she conducts her business and so on (and indeed even the fraud case against her) to show that her behaviour is in line with someone or a business trying to maximise their income and or revenue.

Hmm...I don't know. I think Claus is right here. I agree that she's constructed her business to maximize income, but I'm not so sure that it's now for purely financial reasons.

I mean, she doesn't need any more money - I'm sure she has more than enough to live out the rest of her life in luxury without having to do another reading or write another book for as long as she lives.

I look at it this way: by taking so much money from her followers via readings, books, lectures, tours, boat trips and such, she ensures that they retain a vested interest in believing her powers are real. Most people who have paid a lot of money for something would balk at the thought of having wasted that money to a con artist, and will even go so far as to invest more cash into the same con trick. They probably have thoughts along the lines of: "I've already invested $700 for a reading and over £300 in books and a lecture, and I'm not having that money wasted. So she must be real. I'll buy another book."

This is the way Slyvia gains power over her followers. I think she knows this and that is the main reason for her extortionate fees. She may have had the income as priority one when she was starting out, but now the power over her followers is the top priority.
 
Last edited:
I'm not altogether sure just how useful a discussion of her motives really is.

Whether it is money or power, whether she truly believes it or not, it doesn't change the fact that she should stop.

And offhand I don't see how knowing her motives can help us in strategizing how to make that happen.


Knowing her motives would help tremendously in a) predicting what her next move(s) will be, b) exposing her to (some of) her devout followers.
 
By this account, any manager who doesn't take care in person of every single aspect of the defence of their interests should be considered not being in control of their own company ... absurd.

Note that we don't know whether she's actually totally in control of her own company, and that should also be factored in assessing what her next moves may be.

Threatening with legal action is a very serious business for any kind of company. It is simply not plausible to believe that Sylvia herself didn't orchestrate this.

doesn't follow ...

I disagree.

Neither can you tell about power ...

There is absolutely no doubt that Sylvia Browne holds tremendous power over her followers. Power is a drug that is hard to give up.

Hmm...I don't know. I think Claus is right here. I agree that she's constructed her business to maximize income, but I'm not so sure that it's now for purely financial reasons.

I mean, she doesn't need any more money - I'm sure she has more than enough to live out the rest of her life in luxury without having to do another reading or write another book for as long as she lives.

She is now so rich that her income from doing readings doesn't add much to the full picture. So why continue, even if money was her primary motivation? She is not getting any younger (that is one hell of a photoshopped picture on her website), and it does take some strength to do readings all day.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom