Stephen J Gould (text claiming debunktion)

CFLarsen said:
He was? What of it? I don't see the relevance. Could you explain?
Relevant in that it gives Jew-hating conspiracy theorists a tie-in for their attacks on science. It's cross-fertilized demagoguery, like attacking the Jews of Hollywood.
 
CFLarsen: I’m not saying the site’s author is motivated primarily by simple anti-semitism; it’s much more complicated than that. All quotes from him.
we must encourage the breeding of people with a higher intellect, people better able to understand what motivates them and who can eventually revolt against the subjugation by the state or the controlling elite
…
Anyone who is familiar with the United Nations, NATO, the European Economic Union, and the New World Order knows that we are on the brink of giving up national sovereignty for world totalitarianism
…
I advocate two primary future viable options for eugenics: a return to nationalism, where competing nations will experiment with various social and scientific agendas to raise their peoples to higher levels of intelligence, followed by other traits the population desires to promote; and/or, to increase group solidarity and practice eugenics without borders. The second one has been practiced by Jews for thousands of years, but it can be a dangerous road to follow for it invariably leads to group conflict in the nations where Jews dominate.
…
[referring to Jews] Because of the form of their genetic selection process, they have primarily developed their verbal skills, making them uniquely adept at manipulation, deception, propaganda, academics, the media, etc. This would not normally be a problem, except that they have managed with this verbal skill to control politics and national policy, while those with other skills have built the technological foundations of great nations in Europe and America. That is, the Jewish contribution may not have been very great or even negative, as their accumulation of far greater wealth than any other ethnic group has to do with their abilities in manipulation of other people through the power of words rather than through constructing or building industry.
…
My objection to Jewish influence in America therefore is strictly political and aimed at the Jewish Left, not the empirical Jewish right, and there are many of them who reject multiculturalism and genetic assimilation. These Jews I embrace, those that are on the side of eugenics and human advancement.
…
Gould et al. has been promoting the Jewish reaction against the Holocaust and/or a Jewish evolutionary strategy by subverting any concepts or scientific knowledge that would make it more difficult for Judaism to function as a secular religion based on ingroup racial purity, while appearing to be universally concerned with a classless society
…
My genes, my race's genes, are to me one and the same. We either collectively work to preserve those genes or they will be lost—wiped out by other competing races who wish us harm. That is a basic premise of evolution. Individuals, races, and species all compete for survival. The White race is under attack globally, and for me eugenics is one way to preserve—and improve—a race that is worth keeping in tact.
…
eugenics for Whites is a matter of deprogramming ourselves from the false promises of socialism, Marxism, diversity and egalitarian dogmas
…
As the war on terrorism drags on, it will also be glaringly evident to Western culture that we are different from Semitic tribalism and fanaticism. These differences are also genetic, and we may see some realignment in existing factions. If Islam wants us out of the Middle East—fine—as long as we can remove Semites from the West. So radical Islam may be just what the radical right needs to make the case that other races are indeed dangerous and should be considered so until proven otherwise.
…
Jews, who constitute only 2% of the population, dominate most of the important institutions: academics, politics, the media, the professions, and particularist organizations that influence our culture
To summarise, here is his ‘thesis’ as I understand it:
  • The New World Order is about to take over.
  • It must be opposed by high intelligence achieved through eugenics.
  • This can best be brought about by racial segregation and competition between races, nations etc.
  • Therefore racial mixing is bad.
  • And liberal social policies are bad.
  • And genetic determinism is good.
  • Right-wing Jews are good (i.e. the ultra-orthodox and extreme Zionists who oppose both biological and cultural mixing).
  • Jews belong in the Middle East, not the West, and good Jews understand this (or at least have decency to keep themselves to themselves if they live in the West).
  • However, there is a powerful conspiracy of left-wing Jewish anti-reductionist academics who oppose this, and their science is motivated by the conspiracy.
Jews may actually know that they are wealthier and have more power because they are genetically more intelligent on average, but they lie about it as a means to protect themselves from what they fear is a hostile gentile world that remains particularistic. That is, they fear the other and they must therefore try and deceive others into believing that humans are really all the same, only our cultures differ. This has been a recurring theme in the academic wars over intelligence, sociobiology, eugenics, behavior genetics, evolutionary theories, the nature/nurture debate, etc. On one side are primarily pure scientists who pursue facts as they find them, and on the other side are politically motivated Marxists who are highly over-represented by Jews. Jews, because of their fears of being singled out for resentment because of their power and success, have adopted a campaign to deceive and hold back from the public the work by academics on the importance of genetic intelligence on social outcomes. That is, Jews collectively and knowingly try to manipulate scientific discourse in an attempt to deny the salience of human genetics.
 
Lucky,

Aha.

If you have a point, let's hear it. Don't just quote people. Make a statement. Let your point be known. Say what you want to say.

Just don't waste everybody's time by making them guess what it is you want to say.
 
From CFLarsen:
Lucky,

Aha.

If you have a point, let's hear it. Don't just quote people. Make a statement. Let your point be known. Say what you want to say.

Just don't waste everybody's time by making them guess what it is you want to say.
I did not ‘just quote people’. I did my best to give carefully considered and useful answers, first to WhiteLion’s question and then to yours. I have now spent some considerable time examining that deeply unpleasant site and trying to summarise it and analyse the beliefs of the author, Matt Nuenke. Believe me, if you want to take over the task you’re more than welcome!

If you look again at my summary (and the quote below it) my point should be fairly plain. Gould and his work fit Nuenke’s left-wing Jewish anti-reductionist conspiracy theory perfectly; that is the reason for the page linked to in the OP. Understanding the purpose of the collection of criticisms gives a useful perspective when evaluating its worth.

Obviously, though, exposing the motives of critics is not to answer the criticisms. Many scientists have valid and honest criticisms of parts of Gould’s work (in my opinion, some of them are justified, some not). But the biased, unrepresentative and largely non-scientific collection presented on the site provides no basis for a useful discussion.

Incidentally, as an arch-quibbler you can probably resolve this minor worry. Nuenke says:
Any material on this site can be used for the dissemination of these ideas and a eugenics' program without my permission.
I used the material in order to expose it, but I think I could quote the whole site without violating the permission, because dissemination, if used correctly, doesn’t imply endorsement. Opinion, please?
 
WhiteLion: there’s no such word as debunktion!

I know this very well, still there seem to have been little confusion about it as I am sure you understood the context of it.

Also, I suppose you are aware that Gould was Jewish? If you don’t see the relevance of that I suggest you take a closer look at the rest of the site, as Sanamas just pointed out.

I am aware of this of course, though I do not see the scientific relevance.

I do feel that there is something wrong about your question, as it seems you are asking us to do your thinking for you. You need some means of evaluating and deciding between our opinions, and I can’t see that you have.

I agree that I should have studied the works of Gould, Lewontin to name a few before I threw myself into a debate with the WN's.
I swiftly ordered a few books by them for starters, though they seem to dwell in procrastination land as of yet.
 
WhiteLion said:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote (Lucky): Also, I suppose you are aware that Gould was Jewish? If you don’t see the relevance of that I suggest you take a closer look at the rest of the site, as Sanamas just pointed out.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am aware of this of course, though I do not see the scientific relevance.
I don't think that Lucky sees any scientific relevance either. I think that this is the point he wants to make here: that Gould being not only a Marxist but also Jewish makes him fit right into the slot that the Stormfronters/Matt Nuenke have reserved for this kind of people. They don't want to look at Gould's arguments, his research. It is not a question of science, it's a question of the the way WNs think of the world: in terms of race, racial war/competition, with the Jews as the the opponent of Arians, but with respect for Zionists as worthy opponents, whereas Marxist Jews are the real baddies, a distinction that old-school Nazis wouldn't make! To Hitler, Jews were all the same, the arch-enemy, they might be poor or Marxists or they might be rich industrialists. In both cases, in Hitler's opinion, they were simply out to destroy the German people/race, but had two different ways of doing so.
I haven't looked into the nuances of the Stormfronter ideology, but from the excerpts presented in this thread it seems to me that the reason for the distinction between good and bad Jews is that this particular brand of fascism is American and as such would like to distinguish between the Jews that serve American nationalism in the Middle East (the Zionists) by fighting their Arab neighbours and the Marxists like Gould who are anti-nationalists, or, as the Nazis liked to put it, vaterlandslose Gesellen.

By the way, Lewontin is probably Jewish too. I don't remember. (I judge science by looking at what it has to say, not at who's saying it.)
I agree that I should have studied the works of Gould, Lewontin to name a few before I threw myself into a debate with the WN's.
I swiftly ordered a few books by them for starters, though they seem to dwell in procrastination land as of yet.
You've got something to look forward to! Enjoy!
 
Francois Tremblay said:
Well, it's nice to see the anti-reductionist commies come to the defense of their champion. We can't criticize him because he's dead ? That is the stupidest argument I've ever heard. That's now how science works - we criticize people's works, alive or dead.

At least this thread gives us the occasion of seeing who the collectivists are.

Would you like to explain how reductionism applies here, why people who oppose your viewpoint are "commies", and what the problem is, instead of simply spouting what looks like unsupported insults?

You may have a point, but it's indetectable hidden in your vilification.
 
From dann:
I don't think that Lucky sees any scientific relevance either. I think that this is the point he wants to make here: that Gould being not only a Marxist but also Jewish makes him fit right into the slot that the Stormfronters/Matt Nuenke have reserved for this kind of people. They don't want to look at Gould's arguments, his research.
Thank you, dann; that is what I meant, except that I think they also know enough about his work to see that it’s generally incompatible with their eugenics philosophy.
Gould and his work fit Nuenke’s left-wing Jewish anti-reductionist conspiracy theory perfectly
I thought I had explained myself clearly enough, but apparently not.

Please could someone tell me what a WN is.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom