Stephen J Gould (text claiming debunktion)

Jono

Master Poster
Joined
Feb 3, 2005
Messages
2,054
Location
Sweden
A link to a text that claims exposing Stephen J. Gould as a fraud and debunked.

http://home.comcast.net/~neoeugenics/gou.htm

What do you people make of this text?

Got the link from one of those pesky WN:s insisting I check it out.

Also, does anyone here know more about how Richard Hawkins adresses sociobiology?
 
I read all Gould's books save for his big academic treatise on Evolution, and found him a cogent champion of Darwinian evolution.

Years ago, when the Biological Determinism thing was going on, after Wilson published his big book on animal societies, he did contribute an article to the collection "Not In Our Genes". This was a collection of essays railing (in mostly political terms, as I recall) about "the new eugenics".

Gould's article (again, it's been years...) was rather mild, stating in essence that the answer to the "nature or nurture" question was "Yes."

He was percieved as aligning himself with the anti-determinism crowd at the time. He's publically admitted that his father was of Marxist sympathies, and that he "learned Marxism at his father's knee".
Considering some of the luminaries that see something to admire in Marx, this is hardly a condemnation. There are still those that equate Soviet totalitarianism with Marxism.
 
Gould is gold.

Excessively knowledgable, readable and convincing. He is comparable to Sagan.
 
I've managed to watch a couple videos of his lectures, and he's awesome. Very eloquent. His books are also quite good ( I love 'Wonderful Life'). He was very intelligent man, and it's really too bad that he died as young as he did.
 
It's clear from much of Gould's writing that he was strongly emotionally opposed to genetic reductionism as a significant factor in the mechanics of natural selection.

He was undoubtedly socialist by American standards politically. He made no secret of that and it is common among eastern academics anyway.

Gould made much of the social context of science in his popular essays, giving many illustrations of historical social bias among scientists, but he seemed (to me) strangely unaware of his own biases. Nothing unique there either.

His opinions on many issues differed from those of Dawkins and their differences were blown up by publishers and the press into an implied enmity. While they were not personal friends, it is pretty clear that they were never personal enemies either- just two academics with a strong popular publishing record who were rivals for a similar market.

He was a fine scientist and an excellent writer and , like all powerful characters, a man of stubborn and strong opinion. I enjoyed many of his books, though I wish he had left "Wonderful Life" unwritten.
I always preferred both Dawkin's genetic vision and his explanatory style, which I find clearer than Gould's sometimes over-elaborate explanation.

I also think the time to criticise Gould's social attitude to science was when he could respond.
 
WhiteLion said:
A link to a text that claims exposing Stephen J. Gould as a fraud and debunked.
http://home.comcast.net/~neoeugenics/gou.htm
What do you people make of this text?
Got the link from one of those pesky WN:s insisting I check it out.
Also, does anyone here know more about how Richard Hawkins adresses sociobiology?
It's Dawkins, not Hawkins, and Stephen Jay Gould and Richard Dawkins disagreed about many things when Gould was still alive.

Did you read the text, WhiteLion? I ask you because it is obviously not one text but a collection of texts that have only one thing in common: They criticize Gould and/or Richard Lewontin.

I found one quotation (I didn't read the whole text), apparently authored by the both of them, that I definitely disagree with:
"Lewontin and another colleague wrote at about this time [the seventies], "As working scientists in the field of evolutionary genetics and ecology, we have been attempting with some success to guide our own research by a conscious application of Marxist philosophy. . . . There is nothing in Marx, Lenin or Mao that is or that can be in contradiction with the particular physical facts and processes of a particular set of phenomena in the objective world.""

I do not doubt that they actually wrote this, but I find it most praiseworthy that they didn't stick to it. This is bull! "a conscious application of Marxist philosophy", my @#§! One thing is true, however. I am a Marxist myself (see my sig), unlike the majority of the other posters in this forum. I have read Das Kapital a couple of times, in Danish, English and German, and I tend to agree with the Lewontin-Gould quotation that there is nothing in Marx that is in contradiction with physical facts in the objective world. I can't even see how that should be possible, since Marx was a social scientist and not a physicist, a chemist or a biologist. He wrote about about (bourgeois) society, capitalism, and in Das Kapital he explained the laws that it obeys. These laws don't contradict any law of nature, you might even say that they can't contradict any law of nature since their subject matter is very different from nature. Marx is not concerned with gravity or chemical bonds, he investigates the 'nature' of capital, the realtions between buyers and sellers of commodities and between workers and the owners of companies.

I haven't read a lot of Lenin's books and very few of Mao's papers, and I wasn't very impressed by any of them. (I have yet to read one sensible sentence by Mao, and I don't think that it's a question of pearls from his pen being lost in translation.)
My point is that this quotation from Gould and Lewontin obviously is from a kind of manifesto written before they turned into real scientists!

Once again I recommend that you read The Mismeasure of Man and decide for yourself if it lives up to their youthful manifesto. I would say that it lives up to the intentions of Marx (and I think that Marx would have approved of it) exactly because it doesn't let itself be guided by any kind of idealism or philosophy!

Engels once defended Marx against praise from his son-in-law, the socialist Lafargue:
"Marx would object to the political ideal that you want to attribute to him. When we are dealing with a man of science, the science of economics, then ideals are not allowed, you produce scientific results, and if you are also a man of the party, then you struggle to turn these scientific results into practical politics. But if you have an ideal, then you can't be a man of science, because then you are prejudiced." (Marx-Engels-Werke #36, p. 198, in my own translation)

But why don't you do what you ought to do? Why don't you simply read how Gould looked into the flawed theories and reasearch of people like Broca, Binet, Cyril Burt and all the other so-called scientists who obeyed an ideal and see for yourself the kind of research that Marxists like Lewontin and Gould make? Then you won't have to depend on people telling you what to think of all the links that the Nazi Stormtroopers are undoubtedly full of, even though I doubt that they've read them.

It's a tough job, but somebody's gotta do it ...

And, by the way, it just occurred to me when browsing through your link: If you want to tease these bastards, who are so preoccupied with the IQs of blacks and whites, you should ask them how jews score in IQ tests!
 
Soapy Sam said:
Gould's sometimes over-elaborate explanation.
It just occurred to me that Nietzsche in Die fröhliche Wissenschaft reflects on the different styles of scientists - depending on the walks of life you come from. Generals as scientists have another approach than politicians, for instance.
He juxtaposes school teachers and preachers on the one hand with Jews on the other. Where preachers are used to a congregation of believers, Jews are used to being met with suspicion. Therefore, Nietzsche claims, preachers tend to think that they can get away with any assertion, as long as they are adamant about it. Jews, on the other hand, tend to analyze carefully and systematically explain every step they take when presenting their findings.

But, of course, Nietzsche wrote his stuff more than 100 years ago in Europe ...
 
Jas said:
I've managed to watch a couple videos of his lectures, and he's awesome.
On line? Do you have links? Or titles, if they are for sale somewhere?
 
Looks like a cowardly posthumous attack, and one that is heavy on claims and terribly short on actual evidence, i.e. the relating of actual observances to what he said.
 
Well, it's nice to see the anti-reductionist commies come to the defense of their champion. We can't criticize him because he's dead ? That is the stupidest argument I've ever heard. That's now how science works - we criticize people's works, alive or dead.

At least this thread gives us the occasion of seeing who the collectivists are.
 
Francois Tremblay said:
Gould was an anti-reductionism fool.
He was definitely an anti-reductionist, but why do you find it foolish to be so?
Well, it's nice to see the anti-reductionist commies come to the defense of their champion.
Yes, I'm an anti-reductionist and a 'commie' and I haven't tried to hide the fact. What is your problem with that?
We can't criticize him because he's dead? That is the stupidest argument I've ever heard. That's now how science works - we criticize people's works, alive or dead.
I couldn't agree more with you! (Are you sure you're not a closet anti-reductionist commie?) But if your reference is to Soapy Sam, then de doesn't quite say what you think he does: "I also think the time to criticise Gould's social attitude to science was when he could respond." He's not talking about Gould as such or his science as such, but only about his social attitude to science. Still, I don't see what should prevent anybody from criticizing that, too!
At least this thread gives us the occasion of seeing who the collectivists are.
Who are the 'collectivists' and why are you so happy to see who they are?
 
Bikewer said:
Considering some of the luminaries that see something to admire in Marx, this is hardly a condemnation. There are still those that equate Soviet totalitarianism with Marxism.

Even though Lenin put the Marxist communsits to death when he assumed power.
 
Simply put, Gould et al. has been promoting the Jewish reaction against the Holocaust and/or a Jewish evolutionary strategy by subverting any concepts or scientific knowledge that would make it more difficult for Judaism to function as a secular religion based on ingroup racial purity, while appearing to be universally concerned with a classless society.

Did nobody catch this in the opening paragraph?

Also take a look at the mission statement of the homepage:

http://home.comcast.net/~neoeugenics/mission.htm

Finally, you may ask why so many of my articles are intertwined with the Jewish approach to eugenics and why I use them over and over again to make numerous points about human behavior AND about the need for racial consciousness. First, Jews are one of the few identifiable groups (actually, the Ashkenazi Jews specifically) who have practiced eugenics with tenacious success that has raised their intelligence to a remarkably high level, along with increasing group cohesiveness leading to extreme ethnocentrism or xenophobia. Several issues arise from this achievement. Because of the form of their genetic selection process, they have primarily developed their verbal skills, making them uniquely adept at manipulation, deception, propaganda, academics, the media, etc. This would not normally be a problem, except that they have managed with this verbal skill to control politics and national policy, while those with other skills have built the technological foundations of great nations in Europe and America. That is, the Jewish contribution may not have been very great or even negative, as their accumulation of far greater wealth than any other ethnic group has to do with their abilities in manipulation of other people through the power of words rather than through constructing or building industry. Skilled craftsmen and technicians are as important as lawyers, politicians, academics or journalists; but the rewards have gone to the elite who have the power of the word over the skill of the craftsmen.

Why should we take a eugenics nut who enjoys ranting about the manipulative Jews seriously? It seems that this guy has a problem with Gould's views because they undermine the strict genetic determinism required for his nutty beliefs. His criticism of Gould is hardly based in science.
 
WhiteLion: there’s no such word as debunktion!

More to the point: what on earth could it mean to debunk a world-class scientist, an acknowledged expert in several areas, with a career lasting nearly 40 years? Absolutely nobody has ever suggested that any of his work is fraudulent, or that his work as a whole has been debunked.

There are fierce scientific disputes about many of the areas he worked in, and he was frequently embroiled in controversies. The articles and excerpts on the page you linked to are mostly from respectable sources, but they do not represent a scientific debate. The tone and language of some of them is barely acceptable for scientific discourse, the selection is completely one-sided, and most of the contents are barely scientific. Very few are from biologists; most are from psychologists, sociologists of science and the like. Many are not primarily about Gould.

The authors all have an axe to grind (a legitimate one, in most cases). There is a common theme to do with genetic determinism; in particular the value of single-scale intelligence tests, the reality of genetically-based racial differences in intelligence, and, in general, the importance of genetically-based psychological differences between groups (such as males and females).

I do feel that there is something wrong about your question, as it seems you are asking us to do your thinking for you. You need some means of evaluating and deciding between our opinions, and I can’t see that you have.

If you are going to get your scientific information and opinions from web sites rather than from studying science then you need at least to develop some judgement about the value and reliability of the sites you choose. As for the motives of the site’s author in assembling this rag-bag of hostile writings, it is obvious that he has strong objections to Gould’s scientific conclusions and political and social views, without having the ability to contest them himself.

Also, I suppose you are aware that Gould was Jewish? If you don’t see the relevance of that I suggest you take a closer look at the rest of the site, as Sanamas just pointed out.

WNs?
 
Lucky said:
Also, I suppose you are aware that Gould was Jewish? If you don’t see the relevance of that I suggest you take a closer look at the rest of the site, as Sanamas just pointed out.

He was? What of it? I don't see the relevance. Could you explain?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom