[Split]Income Tax conspiracy - split from: ZEITGEIST, The Movie

I think they have known for awhile that a lot of income tax is not collected.

http://www.uhuh.com/taxstuff/gracecom.htm#IRSWasted

Except that's talking about illegal wage earnings and overinflated government spending. Jump ahead ten years and you find that people really did get ticked-off at the government for ridiculous spending (hundred-dollar hammers, or something to that effect), and there is still a constant process of penalizing employers who are found to be paying people under the table.

If what you are trying to point out is that the system isn't perfect, I doubt you're going to find anyone who disagrees on that mark. There is debate over how imperfect it is and how to make it work more efficiently, but that's a whole different debate than all of the anti-Fed conspiracy theorizing.

By the way, JREF-ers: I'm working on a document covering the creation of the Fed, some basic info on income taxes, and some brief information on personal banking (link). I haven't gotten very far yet because I only just started putting it together-- I have a few dozen sources I'm pulling information from-- but if anyone wants to either offer some constructive criticism (I'm open to suggestions for clarifying or correcting things in it) or let me know if there are other things I should add I encourage the input. I'm doing this as a favor for someone, and because I'm already working on a similar type of document on the movie Zeitgeist (into which much of this info will probably go). This is literally a first draft, so I expect there are corrections I need to make and clarifications in language I should cover. The more help the better, IMO.
 
Except that's talking about illegal wage earnings and overinflated government spending. Jump ahead ten years and you find that people really did get ticked-off at the government for ridiculous spending (hundred-dollar hammers, or something to that effect), and there is still a constant process of penalizing employers who are found to be paying people under the table.

If what you are trying to point out is that the system isn't perfect, I doubt you're going to find anyone who disagrees on that mark. There is debate over how imperfect it is and how to make it work more efficiently, but that's a whole different debate than all of the anti-Fed conspiracy theorizing.

By the way, JREF-ers: I'm working on a document covering the creation of the Fed, some basic info on income taxes, and some brief information on personal banking (link). I haven't gotten very far yet because I only just started putting it together-- I have a few dozen sources I'm pulling information from-- but if anyone wants to either offer some constructive criticism (I'm open to suggestions for clarifying or correcting things in it) or let me know if there are other things I should add I encourage the input. I'm doing this as a favor for someone, and because I'm already working on a similar type of document on the movie Zeitgeist (into which much of this info will probably go). This is literally a first draft, so I expect there are corrections I need to make and clarifications in language I should cover. The more help the better, IMO.


Well done thus far.

You are missing a link for [13.].
 
Well done thus far.

You are missing a link for [13.].

Whoops. I knew I missed one of them.

I'll go add it: http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/today/dec23.html

I'm trying to remember the names of a few members here who are also history and/or economics buffs. In re-reading it I can already see where I need to clean up the flow of the sentences into one another, and it would help if I can run it by as many pairs of eyes as possible to make sure it works.

Admittedly, I'm much better at this when dealing with ancient Mid-Eastern history, but since much of this falls inder American history and I'm fairly well-versed in that as well, I'm giving it a shot. I haven't yet decided if I'm going to reference the books I have yet for the Fed one, though, because this is the kind of issue that as much instant and public-access information as possible makes for an easier read.
 
Whoops. I knew I missed one of them.

I'll go add it: http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/today/dec23.html

I'm trying to remember the names of a few members here who are also history and/or economics buffs. In re-reading it I can already see where I need to clean up the flow of the sentences into one another, and it would help if I can run it by as many pairs of eyes as possible to make sure it works.

Admittedly, I'm much better at this when dealing with ancient Mid-Eastern history, but since much of this falls inder American history and I'm fairly well-versed in that as well, I'm giving it a shot. I haven't yet decided if I'm going to reference the books I have yet for the Fed one, though, because this is the kind of issue that as much instant and public-access information as possible makes for an easier read.

Maybe JonnyFive? That's all who I can think of at the moment.
 
There is a law for every tax. but there is NO law for the income tax. The IRS is a MAFIA the government is controlled by a mafia thats why they get away with it. dont worry we will defet theme for you.

If you dont pay your income tax and you go to court and you win. didnt he win then? what planet is this? you people have real problems.... what did tommy haft to pay? show me a link, does it matter what he had to pay? no. wake up sometime please.


Mal--listen carefully:

He. Still. Had. To. Pay. His. Taxes.


What I really, really wonder about is why, as a non-US-citizen, you are so incensed about this issue? I can't recall ever once in my life coming close to thinking about, much less caring about, the tax laws in Ecuador or Botswana or New Zealand. So I have to know: why do you care?
 
28% of the Senate did not vote on the bill.

43 yeas

25 nays

27 not voting

Um, so? Are you saying 27 lazy senators are the conspiracy "smoking gun" in this case? :)

Remember, even though 28% didn't vote, 72% did. The fact is that even that vote wasn't the "beginning" of the Fed, as it was a process of continually growing federal measures going back at least as far as the Civil War, and that the idea of a central bank was nowhere even close to a new idea by the end of the nineteenth century.

Essentially, it looks conspiracy-like until you take American history into account, and then it looks like exactly what it is: a country slowly shifting from an agrarian society to an industrial/metropolitan society. Neither good nor bad, it just is*.


* not that some people haven't made a judgment about it being better or worse, but progress is progress and there are always people who think the grass is greener on the other side.
 
I wonder if he can explain what this part of the constitution is saying:

"The Congress shall have the power to lay and collect taxes on income, from
whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration."

So the constitution grants Congress the right to tax income, and Congress grants the IRS the IRS the responsibility of collecting tax for Congress via the IRC.

His argument about the IRs not making laws is like saying the Police don't make laws. Of course they don't. They enforce them, just like the IRS does.

And maybe he should read code 61 of the IRC.

Sure i can explain

It would be good to start with two simple definitions.

http://www.answers.com/topic/tax?cat=biz-fin

Direct Tax:
A tax, such as property tax, levied directly on the taxpayer.

I removed income tax from that definition because we will find it simply doesn't fit.

Same Source
Indirect Tax:
A tax, such as a sales tax or value-added tax, that is levied on goods or services rather than individuals and is ultimately paid by consumers in the form of higher prices.

Now if we look at thoe they seem pretty clear right? One is a direct tax from person A to government. Indirect tax is a tax from person A to Company B to government. Examine the definitions more closely though. Look at indirect taxes. Levied on services. An individual who provides a service is a person whos pay should be considered an Indirect tax. Your job is nothing more then a service to the company or person paying you to do that service. That service is thus an indirect tax, and that should be your income tax. That income, from the service you provided, is indirectly taxed since it was a service. So then why would they consider income tax a direct tax? Further more why are they taxing the individual directly for the service if the tax should be that of an indirect tax?

Now its time we bring up the 16th amendment.

http://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/constitution.amendmentxvi.html
Amendment XVI
The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

this was subject to a great deal of controversy. In short just what does this act mean? Well In the Supreme Court ruling "Stanton VS Baltic Mining Co., 240 U.S. 103 (1916)" we get a better idea of how the Supreme Court decided what it meant.

http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?friend=nytimes&court=us&vol=240&invol=103
...settled that the provisions of the 16th Amendment conferred no new power of taxation, but simply prohibited the previous complete and plenary power of income taxation possessed by Congress from the beginning from being taken out of the category of indirect taxation to which it inherently belonged, and being placed [240 U.S. 103, 113] in the category of direct taxation subject to apportionment... "

It makes it perfectly clear here that such Income taxes were meant to be Indirect taxes. So why did they make the 16th amendment? Well as you can see it was to prohibit the complete power of taxation possessed by congress from moving income tax from indirect to direct taxation. In a sense, it was to avoid income tax to become direct taxes.

In short, the 16th amendment is talking in terms of indirect taxes. For an indirect tax, no apportionment is required, and no census is either. It is not changing the direct taxing laws. It is not changing indirect tax laws. It is stating that congress may lay and collect income taxes which are indirect taxes. this was to prevent congress from making income taxes direct.

So now we see why the 16th amendment was formed. Now that leaves the main question, why is people being directly Taxed on income taxes? Well the truth is your not suppose to be. The person who is RECEIVING the good or service your job provides them is the person who is suppose to be paying an income tax. They are suppose to pay you your wages + the indirect tax. So when your working as a construction worker, the company who is paying you should be paying you your wages + whatever the income tax for that service is.

So how come you are being charged income tax? Unless your paying for a service or good, rather then being paid for one(job), you shouldn't encounter income tax. You cannot come to any other conclusion then that you are being robbed by the IRS. The income tax should not be a tax that you pay everytime you get your paycheck. You are not paying for a good or service, you are providing one. As the definition said, Indirect tax is ultimately paid by THE CUSTOMER. Why is it being paid by you, the provider of the service then?

That is what you must ask yourself.

IRS is NOT the law and they ignore the supreme court and the law. some people seems to think that IRS is the law and accepts anything they say.

If you want to read more supreme court cases where they acknowledges that the 16th amendment dont have the power to tax an direct income tax please read here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3246359&postcount=53

Also, PL 83-591 is IRS Code not law (see http://www.ssa.gov/OP_Home/comp2/F083-591.html ). I.e. ‘a code of ethics’ verses a statutory law, code is code not law unless you live in Louisiana where a code based legal system based on Napoleonic Code was adopted. Most states adopted English Common Law which is NOT a code based system. More on LAW at http://www.libertyforlife.com/law/law.html see CCP 22 - Incidentally the same applies to the Family Code, Vehicle Code and Criminal Code – the Courts have simply pulled a fast one and ignore the law. However they try to cover their steps by getting people to accede to contract law – i.e. they get your to agree to go to jail or pay a fine for an ‘infraction’ or pay tax, etc.

So the IRS always offcourse fails to point out where you can find the liability provision. Some people dont deal well with the fact that they cant find a provision that doesn't exist. The word income is not even defined anywhere in the internal revenue code, it just says income without a definition of what income is.

I love the part of Aaron russos film america freedom to fascism where he gets thretend by the IRS guy.

IRS guy says: "the internal revenue code is authorized by the 16th amendment"

Arron russo brings up the court cases i have showed you

IRS guy answers: "You gonna take a 1920 case and superimpose it on the internal revenue code that was writen after it, no thats not..."

He said that the internal revenue code is authorized by the 16th amendment. The supreme court said the 16th amendment did NOT give the government any new taxing power, this decisions has never been overturned , as the IRS would like you to believe.

Then the IRS guy says that the lower courts cant overrule supreme courts .

And then i cant believe what he says, the IRS guy says on camera that supreme court decisions do not apply to the IRS.....

And then the IRS guy threatens arron by saying "Nothing will help you"

Watch 30:00 http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...=53&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=0

Its time to wake up people.
 
Last edited:
omg. you are so stupendously ignorant, its not even funny. nothing you have posted proves your claims. even your video.

DO you have a problem with reading? There are numerous cases WHERE TAX Protesters HAVE lost, with EVERY claim you are stating.
 
What do the courts say about tax protester claims to the contrary?

“Indeed, as we have repeatedly held, the entire Internal Revenue Code was validly enacted by Congress and is fully enforceable.”
United States v. McDonald, 919 F.2d 146 (10th Cir. 1990); United States v. Studley, 783 F.2d 934, 940 (9th Cir. 1986).

“Congress’s failure to enact a title [of the United States Code] into positive law has only evidentiary significance and does not render the underlying enactment invalid or unenforceable. See 1 U.S.C. § 204(a) (1982), (the text of titles not enacted into positive law is only prima facie evidence of the law itself). Like it or not, the Internal Revenue Code is the law, and the defendants did not violate Ryan’s rights by enforcing it.”
Ryan v. Bilby, 764 F2d 1325, 1328 (9th Cir. 1985).

“The petitioner’s argument that the Internal Revenue Code was not enacted by Congress is equally meritless. The Internal Revenue Code of 1954 was enacted by the 83rd Congress on August 16, 1954 (ch. 736, 68A Stat. 3) and has been amended by Congress with some frequency since that time.”
Urban v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1991-220, affd. per curiam, 964 F.2d 888 (9th Cir. 1992).

“In his opposition, Plaintiff asserts that ‘Title 26 U.S.C. (including section 6321) has not been enacted into positive law, and is not the law, but is only prima facie evidence of the law.’ ... Congress’ failure to enact a title into positive law has only evidentiary significance and does not render the underlying enactment invalid or unenforceable. See 1 U.S.C. section 204(a). ‘Like it or not, the Internal Revenue Code is the law’. [Citations omitted] Plaintiff’s positive law argument is without merit.”
Bilger v. United States, 87 AFTR2d Par. 2001-468, No. CIV F 00-6486 OWW JLO (U.S.D.C. E.D.Ca. 1/9/2001).

“On appeal he [Scott] makes the same arguments advanced and rejected countless times in tax protestor litigation, such as that the Tax Code is not binding “positive law,” and wages are exempt from taxation because they are not income. [Citations omitted] Needless to say, these contentions do not state a claim against the United States, let alone support a lien against its agents.”
United States v. Scott, 1999 U.S. App. LEXIS 16877; 99-2 U.S. Tax Cas. (CCH) P50,745; 84 A.F.T.R.2d (RIA) 5342, (7th Cir. 1999).

“Similarly frivolous is his claim that a summons could not be issued because title 26 has not been enacted into ‘positive law.’”
United States v. Hooper, 1995 U.S. App. LEXIS 38246; 76 A.F.T.R.2d (RIA) 8026, 1995 WL 792039 at *1 (9th Cir. 1995).

“Finally, we reject as frivolous Kolchev’s remaining contentions asserting that his wages are not taxable income, see 26 U.S.C. § 61, that notices of deficiency may only be issued to government employees, [citation omitted], that the IRS code is not enforceable because it has not been enacted into positive law, [citation omitted], and that the Commissioner lacked delegated authority to issue the notice of deficiency, [citation omitted].”
Kolchev v. Commissioner, 1995 U.S. App. LEXIS 2683; 75 A.F.T.R.2d (RIA) 839, (9th Cir. 1995).

“The appellant’s argument regarding the validity of Title 26 is frivolous. The validity of Title 26 is not affected merely because it has not been codified as ‘positive law’.”
Hackett v. Commissioner, 791 F.2d 933 (6th Cir. 1986).

“The claim that Title 26 was not enacted into ‘positive law,’ has been rejected as ‘frivolous,’ ‘baseless,’ ‘specious,’ and ‘preposterous.’ [Citations omitted]”
United States v. Maczka, 957 F.Supp. 988, 991 (W.D.Mich. 1996).

See also, United States v. Zuger, 602 F.Supp. 889, 891-92 (D. Conn. 1984) (‘holding that the failure of Congress to enact a title as such and in such form into positive law . . . in no way impugns the validity, effect, enforceability, or constitutionality of the laws as contained and set forth in the title’ and describing argument as “specious”), aff’d. without op., 755 F.2d 915 (2d Cir.), cert. denied, 474 U.S. 805 (1985); Young v. Internal Revenue Service, 596 F.Supp. 141, 149 (N.D.Ind. 1984) (asserting that ‘even if Title 26 was not itself enacted into positive law, that does not mean that the laws under the title are null and void’ and referring to the “positive law” argument as “preposterous”); United States v. Cooper, 170 F.3d 691 (7th Cir. 1999); United States v. Sloan, 939 F.2d 499, 500 (7th Cir. 1991), cert. den. 112 S.Ct. 940 (1992); Coleman v. Commissioner, 791 F.2d 68, 70 (7th Cir. 1986); Lovell v. United States, 755 F.2d 517, 519 (7th Cir. 1984); Sullivan v. United States, 788 F.2d 813, 815 (1st Cir. 1986); Sloan v. United States, 621 F.Supp. 1072, 1076 (N.D.Ind.1985) (litigants advancing ‘frivolous’ arguments such as assertions that the Internal Revenue Code is not positive law subjected to sanctions under Rule 11, FED. R. CIV. P.), aff’d in part and appeal dismissed, 812 F.2d 1410 (7th Cir.1987) (table).

The claim that “[t]he Internal Revenue Code is not law (or ‘positive law’)” has been identified by the IRS as a “frivolous position” that can result in a penalty of $5,000 when asserted in a tax return or included in certain collection-related submissions. Notice 2007-30, 2007-14 I.R.B. 883.

Malmoesoldier was provided with the link where he could find all these citations of court decisions a good page and a half ago, yet he continues to repeat a claim that has been repeatedly repudiated in the only venue that counts- the courts.

:deadhorse:hb:
 
I realize it's not very nice to talk around people instead of asking them directly, but the latter approach seems unlikely to meet with any success.

What could malmösoldiers stake in the nature of US income tax possibly be? I just don't get it.

How does one fail so utterly to examine and respond to the evidence presented? Is it just raising confirmation bias to an art form or is it something else?
 
Sure i can explain

It would be good to start with two simple definitions.



I removed income tax from that definition because we will find it simply doesn't fit.

Same Source


Now if we look at thoe they seem pretty clear right? One is a direct tax from person A to government. Indirect tax is a tax from person A to Company B to government. Examine the definitions more closely though. Look at indirect taxes. Levied on services. An individual who provides a service is a person whos pay should be considered an Indirect tax. Your job is nothing more then a service to the company or person paying you to do that service. That service is thus an indirect tax, and that should be your income tax. That income, from the service you provided, is indirectly taxed since it was a service. So then why would they consider income tax a direct tax? Further more why are they taxing the individual directly for the service if the tax should be that of an indirect tax?
what you've just described is a payroll tax. for a lot of people, the income tax basically is a payroll tax. but they're not necessarily the same thing.

Now its time we bring up the 16th amendment.


this was subject to a great deal of controversy. In short just what does this act mean? Well In the Supreme Court ruling "Stanton VS Baltic Mining Co., 240 U.S. 103 (1916)" we get a better idea of how the Supreme Court decided what it meant.



It makes it perfectly clear here that such Income taxes were meant to be Indirect taxes. So why did they make the 16th amendment? Well as you can see it was to prohibit the complete power of taxation possessed by congress from moving income tax from indirect to direct taxation. In a sense, it was to avoid income tax to become direct taxes.

In short, the 16th amendment is talking in terms of indirect taxes. For an indirect tax, no apportionment is required, and no census is either. It is not changing the direct taxing laws. It is not changing indirect tax laws. It is stating that congress may lay and collect income taxes which are indirect taxes. this was to prevent congress from making income taxes direct.

no. as i explained, the 16th amendment was a direct result of a Court case that stated that income taxes levied on rents received from real property were a direct tax that violated the apportionment clause (the case didn't say what taxes on wage income are). the 16th amendment makes clear that income taxes do not have to follow apportionment. that is all the 16th amendment does. it does not say that congress may only create indirect income taxes. congress already had that power without question. the 16th amendment clarifies (by removing a restriction) congress's power, rather than constricting it.

So now we see why the 16th amendment was formed.

but obviously, you don't.


Now that leaves the main question, why is people being directly Taxed on income taxes? Well the truth is your not suppose to be. The person who is RECEIVING the good or service your job provides them is the person who is suppose to be paying an income tax. They are suppose to pay you your wages + the indirect tax. So when your working as a construction worker, the company who is paying you should be paying you your wages + whatever the income tax for that service is.
it really doesn't matter who the legal burden is on, the economic burden is the same (absent transactions costs, which can be sizeable with the current US tax code, regs, etc.).

So how come you are being charged income tax? Unless your paying for a service or good, rather then being paid for one(job), you shouldn't encounter income tax. You cannot come to any other conclusion then that you are being robbed by the IRS.

actually, if you get the premises right, you come to a completely different conclusion

The income tax should not be a tax that you pay everytime you get your paycheck. You are not paying for a good or service, you are providing one. As the definition said, Indirect tax is ultimately paid by THE CUSTOMER.

this is what happens when you use soft definitions written by people who don't know what they're talking about. ultimately, the burden is actually shared between producer and consumer, unless the supply and demand curves are perfectly elastic or perfectly inelastic.


Why is it being paid by you, the provider of the service then?
that's only the legal burden. big deal.

That is what you must ask yourself.

because it's a lot harder for the average joe to hide income than the average company. further, a very large proportion of income tax revenues comes from people who aren't employed, or whose salary is not the main source of their income. believe it or not, but the bottom half of taxpayers pays about 3% of the income tax. (not to be confused with the federal payroll taxes, which are only levied on wages)


IRS is NOT the law and they ignore the supreme court and the law. some people seems to think that IRS is the law and accepts anything they say.

i agree with you on the first part, the IRS is not the law (although the regulations have the effect of law under the APA). i disagree with you on the second part. they don't ignore the Court. you ignore the Court.

If you want to read more supreme court cases where they acknowledges that the 16th amendment dont have the power to tax an direct income tax please read here:

let's see, you've got the case that prompted the 16th amendment (which was overturned by the 16th amendment, essentially), and then you've got a couple of cases that agree with me (which is, the 16th amendment conferred no new power of taxation, it merely says that income taxes need not follow apportionment laws).


Also, PL 83-591 is IRS Code not law (see ). I.e. ‘a code of ethics’ verses a statutory law, code is code not law unless you live in Louisiana where a code based legal system based on Napoleonic Code was adopted. Most states adopted English Common Law which is NOT a code based system.

i realize that, not being in a common law system, you have no idea what you're talking about.
a statute is a law. the difference between common law systems and civil law systems is that in the common law, courts are allowed to make law on top of and in the gaps of the statutes, and they follow a system of precedence so that there is predictability. legislatures can generally contradict the courts by creating a statute. if i remember my civil law correctly, courts have very little power to interpret statutes, and don't have a formal system of precedence (though, for predictabilities' sake, they do so informally)

btw - the US 'Code' only exists because it's much easier to read the statutes of the US (and everywhere else, for that matter) when they're grouped by subject matter (such as US Code Title 11, Bankruptcy, or US Code Title 26, Internal Revenue Code). a code is nothing more than a subject matter grouping of the various statutes that congress has passed. try reading a raw public law - it isn't fun.

More on LAW at see CCP 22 -
which reads:
22. An action is an ordinary proceeding in a court of justice by
which one party prosecutes another for the declaration, enforcement,
or protection of a right, the redress or prevention of a wrong, or
the punishment of a public offense.
Incidentally the same applies to the Family Code, Vehicle Code and Criminal Code – the Courts have simply pulled a fast one and ignore the law.

what are you talking about?

However they try to cover their steps by getting people to accede to contract law – i.e. they get your to agree to go to jail or pay a fine for an ‘infraction’ or pay tax, etc.

again, what are you talking about? no one goes to jail over contract law.

So the IRS always offcourse fails to point out where you can find the liability provision.

it's 27 USC 1

Some people dont deal well with the fact that they cant find a provision that doesn't exist. The word income is not even defined anywhere in the internal revenue code, it just says income without a definition of what income is.

defining what counts as income is pretty much what the rest of the code and regs are about (it starts at 27 USC 61 and goes on from there). the simple definition of income that the tax was passed with is: anything that increases a person's wealth.

since then it's gotten more complicated, first because of questions like: if you had to buy your uniform for work, should the first few dollars that your employer pays you (up to the cost of that uniform) be counted as income? (the answer is: depends). secondly (and mostly) because congress figured out that it can use the tax code as a carrot and stick to get society to bend to its will -- hillary's medical care plan? tax you if you don't buy insurance.

or, if you just mean what is 'income,' the dictionary suggests
the monetary payment received for goods or services, or from other sources, as rents or investments.

believe it or not, when something isn't explicitly defined in a statute or contract the usual and ordinary meaning of the word is applied.

I love the part of Aaron russos film america freedom to fascism where he gets thretend by the IRS guy.

IRS guy says: "the internal revenue code is authorized by the 16th amendment"

Arron russo brings up the court cases i have showed you

IRS guy answers: "You gonna take a 1920 case and superimpose it on the internal revenue code that was writen after it, no thats not..."

He said that the internal revenue code is authorized by the 16th amendment. The supreme court said the 16th amendment did NOT give the government any new taxing power, this decisions has never been overturned , as the IRS would like you to believe.

Then the IRS guy says that the lower courts cant overrule supreme courts .

And then i cant believe what he says, the IRS guy says on camera that supreme court decisions do not apply to the IRS.....

And then the IRS guy threatens arron by saying "Nothing will help you"

Watch 30:00
Its time to wake up people.

great, you've got some dude asking a bunch of questions of some low level clerk who barely passed his accounting class. big deal.
 
Last edited:
great, you've got some dude asking a bunch of questions of some low level clerk who barely passed his accounting class. big deal.

How can anything else you have written be trusted when you blatantly lie in your above statement?

Sheldon S. Cohen Testimony Before the Full Committee
of the House Committee on Ways and Means


By way of background, I served in the Internal Revenue Service on several different occasions. During the period 1952-1956, I served as a legislative draftsperson during the drafting of the 1954 Code and Regulations. In the period from January 1964 through January 1969, I served as Chief Counsel for one year and then as Commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service for four years.

Now, are you going to argue that a man who wrote the IRS code, was the chief Counsel, and was Commissioner is a low level clerk?

:boggled:
 
moving-boxes-file.jpg


The boxes has spoken!
 
what you've just described is a payroll tax. for a lot of people, the income tax basically is a payroll tax. but they're not necessarily the same thing.



no. as i explained, the 16th amendment was a direct result of a Court case that stated that income taxes levied on rents received from real property were a direct tax that violated the apportionment clause (the case didn't say what taxes on wage income are). the 16th amendment makes clear that income taxes do not have to follow apportionment. that is all the 16th amendment does. it does not say that congress may only create indirect income taxes. congress already had that power without question. the 16th amendment clarifies (by removing a restriction) congress's power, rather than constricting it.



but obviously, you don't.



it really doesn't matter who the legal burden is on, the economic burden is the same (absent transactions costs, which can be sizeable with the current US tax code, regs, etc.).



actually, if you get the premises right, you come to a completely different conclusion



this is what happens when you use soft definitions written by people who don't know what they're talking about. ultimately, the burden is actually shared between producer and consumer, unless the supply and demand curves are perfectly elastic or perfectly inelastic.



that's only the legal burden. big deal.



because it's a lot harder for the average joe to hide income than the average company. further, a very large proportion of income tax revenues comes from people who aren't employed, or whose salary is not the main source of their income. believe it or not, but the bottom half of taxpayers pays about 3% of the income tax. (not to be confused with the federal payroll taxes, which are only levied on wages)




i agree with you on the first part, the IRS is not the law (although the regulations have the effect of law under the APA). i disagree with you on the second part. they don't ignore the Court. you ignore the Court.



let's see, you've got the case that prompted the 16th amendment (which was overturned by the 16th amendment, essentially), and then you've got a couple of cases that agree with me (which is, the 16th amendment conferred no new power of taxation, it merely says that income taxes need not follow apportionment laws).




i realize that, not being in a common law system, you have no idea what you're talking about.
a statute is a law. the difference between common law systems and civil law systems is that in the common law, courts are allowed to make law on top of and in the gaps of the statutes, and they follow a system of precedence so that there is predictability. legislatures can generally contradict the courts by creating a statute. if i remember my civil law correctly, courts have very little power to interpret statutes, and don't have a formal system of precedence (though, for predictabilities' sake, they do so informally)

btw - the US 'Code' only exists because it's much easier to read the statutes of the US (and everywhere else, for that matter) when they're grouped by subject matter (such as US Code Title 11, Bankruptcy, or US Code Title 26, Internal Revenue Code). a code is nothing more than a subject matter grouping of the various statutes that congress has passed. try reading a raw public law - it isn't fun.


which reads:


what are you talking about?



again, what are you talking about? no one goes to jail over contract law.



it's 27 USC 1



defining what counts as income is pretty much what the rest of the code and regs are about (it starts at 27 USC 61 and goes on from there). the simple definition of income that the tax was passed with is: anything that increases a person's wealth.

since then it's gotten more complicated, first because of questions like: if you had to buy your uniform for work, should the first few dollars that your employer pays you (up to the cost of that uniform) be counted as income? (the answer is: depends). secondly (and mostly) because congress figured out that it can use the tax code as a carrot and stick to get society to bend to its will -- hillary's medical care plan? tax you if you don't buy insurance.

or, if you just mean what is 'income,' the dictionary suggests


believe it or not, when something isn't explicitly defined in a statute or contract the usual and ordinary meaning of the word is applied.



great, you've got some dude asking a bunch of questions of some low level clerk who barely passed his accounting class. big deal.

great, you've got some dude asking a bunch of questions of some low level clerk who barely passed his accounting class. big deal.

Maybe you dont know the difference between direct and indirect income tax? there is a big difference as i explained. And in the internal revenue code it just says income without a definition of what income is, I WONDER WHY.


No the IRS IGNORES the suprme court and the supreme court dont support your claims. i haft to ask you if you can read? because the court cases makes it perfectly clear that the 16th amendment dont have the power to tax an direct income tax. Is it that you cant read english that well? or did you maybe lie because you dont like the facts?, if you want to tell me the truth do so but dont respond with ignorant posts with false claims after i have proved with 100% evidence that there is no law (Arus808 mentality "hmm people has lost in court agains IRS with your claims the court didnt listen to theme, doesnt that mean that the courts are right and the claims are false?, i mean if the courts says so it must be true, lets ignore the supreme court decisions like the IRS does, the courts have put people in jail, anyway i dont care about the truth just do what the government says, respect theme okey") Sorry this law that dont exist makes it legal to defend yourself when the cops comes to your house to take your taxes IF they use violence against you.

great, you've got some dude asking a bunch of questions of some low level clerk who barely passed his accounting class. big deal.

That "nobody" who didnt pass his accounting class wrote the tax code

Sheldon cohen Former commissioner Author/tax code.

So i think he passed hid accounting class ;) and that interview with him shows the mentality of the IRS, they ARE a mafia
 
Last edited:
How can anything else you have written be trusted when you blatantly lie in your above statement?

Sheldon S. Cohen Testimony Before the Full Committee
of the House Committee on Ways and Means




Now, are you going to argue that a man who wrote the IRS code, was the chief Counsel, and was Commissioner is a low level clerk?

:boggled:
i didn't watch the video (4 am, others being asleep, and no speakers hooked up to this computer). made an assumption about what was going on in it. sorry.





anyone want to refute anything else in my post?
 
Last edited:
i didn't watch the video (4 am, others being asleep, and no speakers hooked up to this computer). made an assumption about what was going on in it. sorry.





anyone want to refute anything else in my post?

Yes people here makes assumptions alot. read my last post please.

Maybe you dont know the difference between direct and indirect income tax? there is a big difference as i explained. And in the internal revenue code it just says income without a definition of what income is, I WONDER WHY.


No the IRS IGNORES the suprme court and the supreme court dont support your claims. i haft to ask you if you can read? because the court cases makes it perfectly clear that the 16th amendment dont have the power to tax an direct income tax. Is it that you cant read english that well? or did you maybe lie because you dont like the facts?, if you want to tell me the truth do so but dont respond with ignorant posts with false claims after i have proved with 100% evidence that there is no law

As the supreme court cases says and as the 16th amendment always has said congress can only tax an indirect income tax NOT an direct income tax.

And that interview with Sheldon cohen shows the mentality of the IRS, they ARE a mafia.
 
Last edited:
Maybe you dont know the difference between direct and indirect income tax? there is a big difference as i explained.
yes, there is a difference legally, direct taxes must be apportioned. the 16th amendment says that, for income taxes, apportionment is to be ignored ("without apportionment" and "without regard to"). so it doesn't really matter if they are direct or not.

do note that an early supreme court case, Hylton v. U. S., 3 Dall. 171, said that the only direct taxes were taxes per capita/poll taxes and taxes per acre. the whole point of direct tax apportionment, after all, was to keep the slave-holding and thinly populated southern states from being taxed into nothing.

that interpretation was upheld ~75 years later in Veazie Bank v. Fenno (8 Wallace, 533). and then later an income tax on wages and interest on bonds was upheld (along with the notion that the only direct taxes are capitation/poll taxes and taxes per acre) in Springer v. United States, 102 U.S. 586 (1881).

in fact, the only case that ever said any kind of income tax was a direct tax was Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co. and that was limited to income taxes on rents from property. that was also the case the 16th amendment overturned.

And in the internal revenue code it just says income without a definition of what income is, I WONDER WHY.
murder statutes don't define what killing is.

again, basically the whole tax code and regs are about figuring out what is income (and then manipulating that definition to fit whatever policy the government feels like pushing). i know you don't have to do our income taxes so you don't have any experience in it. but that really is what it is about.

did you read 27 USC 61?


No the IRS IGNORES the suprme court and the supreme court dont support your claims. i haft to ask you if you can read? because the court cases makes it perfectly clear that the 16th amendment dont have the power to tax an direct income tax. Is it that you cant read english that well? or did you maybe lie because you dont like the facts?, if you want to tell me the truth do so but dont respond with ignorant posts with false claims after i have proved with 100% evidence that there is no law (Arus808 mentality "hmm people has lost in court agains IRS with your claims the court didnt listen to theme, doesnt that mean that the courts are right and the claims are false?, i mean if the courts says so it must be true, lets ignore the supreme court decisions like the IRS does, the courts have put people in jail, anyway i dont care about the truth just do what the government says, respect theme okey") Sorry this law that dont exist makes it legal to defend yourself when the cops comes to your house to take your taxes IF they use violence against you.

let's take a look at your quote from the baltic mining case:
But, aside from the obvious error of the proposition, intrinsically considered, it manifestly disregards the fact that by the previous ruling it was settled that the provisions of the 16th Amendment conferred no new power of taxation, but simply prohibited the previous complete and plenary power of income taxation possessed by Congress from the beginning from being taken out of the category of indirect taxation to which it inherently belonged, and being placed [240 U.S. 103, 113] in the category of direct taxation subject to apportionment by a consideration of the sources from which the income was derived,-that is, by testing the tax not by what it was, a tax on income, but by a mistaken theory deduced from the origin or source of the income taxed.
now, it is important to realize what is going on here. mr. justice white is explaining that income taxes are inherently in the category of indirect taxation. he is saying that the 16th amendment prohibits the Court from taking the income tax out of the category of indirect taxes (which is what it did in the Pollock case ~20 years earlier, being the case that prompted the 16th amendment). he further explains that the Court's previous test erroneously classified the tax based on the source of the income taxed (in the Pollock case it was on rents from property, a property tax is a direct tax, a tax on rents from property might as well be a property tax according to the Pollock decision).

let's add the unnamed actor back into mr. justice white's quote
But, aside from the obvious error of the proposition, intrinsically considered, it manifestly disregards the fact that by the previous ruling it was settled that the provisions of the 16th Amendment conferred no new power of taxation, but simply prohibited the previous complete and plenary power of income taxation possessed by Congress from the beginning from being taken BY THE COURTS out of the category of indirect taxation to which it inherently belonged, and being placed [240 U.S. 103, 113] BY THE COURTS in the category of direct taxation subject to apportionment by a consideration of the sources from which the income was derived,-that is, THE COURTS GOT IT WRONG IN POLLOCK by testing the tax not by what it was, a tax on income, but by a mistaken theory deduced from the origin or source of the income taxed.

so, i fully agree, congress didn't have the power to create a direct non-apportioned income tax (not sure how an apportioned income tax would work, but that is neither here nor there). but that is a moot point as the 16th amendment says that apportionment can be ignored (without apportionment, and without regard to the census). further, as mr. justice white states in the baltic mining case: the income tax is an indirect tax (note that he took that same position in dissent in the Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co. decision.)

if you'd have asked mr. justice white, he would have told you that the 16th amendment wasn't really needed, all that was needed was a court case overturning the wrongfully decided Pollock case.

That "nobody" who didnt pass his accounting class wrote the tax code

Sheldon cohen Former commissioner Author/tax code.

So i think he passed hid accounting class ;) and that interview with him shows the mentality of the IRS, they ARE a mafia

yeah, sorry about that. again, didn't watch the video as it was just about 4 am, other people were asleep, and i don't have any speakers hooked to this computer so it wouldn't have done me much good anyway.


i agree that there is little difference between the government and the mafia. i guess the government gets you a little more for your protection money than the mafia does. and they generally aren't as violent if you don't pay your protection money. and they leave you alone once you've paid, generally.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom