[Split]Income Tax conspiracy - split from: ZEITGEIST, The Movie

there is no law

So, again, where are the millions NOT paying then?

And why has it taken so long to come to light?
 
Last edited:
I've already watched Freedom to Fascism. I've already given you the law. Why are you ignoring the evidence and link-spamming?

This isn't supposed to be a monologue. It's supposed to be a dialogue. You've made many points. I've provided you evidence that you are wrong. You've totally ignored me and continued to repeat your points.

I'm afraid at I'm at a loss what to do in this situation. I've never had someone continue to repeat things that have been disproven, and refuse to acknowledge contradictory evidence.
 
I'm afraid at I'm at a loss what to do in this situation. I've never had someone continue to repeat things that have been disproven, and refuse to acknowledge contradictory evidence.

I thought that was par for the course here with Truthers and such?
 
I thought that was par for the course here with Truthers and such?

Yes but no! Usually they try to deal with it. They at least try to take contradictory evidence and give it a cursory dismissal based on twisted and broken logic or a poor understanding of science.

He's just pretending I never said it.
 
Last edited:
I am disappointed in all of the regular posters here that respond to the originator this thread beyond the point of stating the law and responding only to questions arising therefrom.

It's almost as if you as a skeptic are males and trolls are your blow-up doll female substitute. It's still masturbation. Now, I've nothing against masturbation, either as a practice or a habit, but it should really be kept a little more private. It makes you look as silly as the troll, what with you pretending that the blow-up doll is real and all.
 
Last edited:
I am disappointed in all of the regular posters here that respond to the originator this thread beyond the point of stating the law and responding only to questions arising therefrom.

It's almost as if you as a skeptic are males and trolls are your blow-up doll female substitute. It's still masturbation. Now, I've nothing against masturbation, either as a practice or a habit, but it should really be kept a little more private. It makes you look as silly as the troll, what with you pretending that the blow-up doll is real and all.
yep one post could be enough for rational people.
 
Last edited:
beachnut, in future, please report any similar abusive PMs. They are to be treated like posts in that respect. You do not need to report this one.
 
There is no law? Why would you ignore the 16th amendment to the CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES? How much more governmental authority to impose an income tax do you need?
 
because MS isn't even an American, so that pesku US Constitution is something 1) he wouldn't read 2) he could care less about.

of course, one has to wonder why a foreigner must lecture us AMericans on our own tax laws.
 
What's amusing is that the Cryer case demonstrates the precise opposite of what Malmo claims.

It was a criminal case of tax evasion.

In pre-trial motions, Cryer extensively made the argument that there was no obligation to pay tax, etc.

These motions were uniformly denied by the court, and the case proceeded to trial.

Cryer was acquitted by the jury.

According to Malmo's logic, the fact that OJ Simpson was found not guilty means that there is no law against murder.

People are charged with all sorts of crimes on a regular basis, and people are quite often found not guilty of those crimes.

The fact that someone can be found not guilty of a crime, does not mean that there is no law against the crime.

The trial itself demonstrates that, yes, tax evasion is a crime. If it were not a crime, there would not have been a trial. However, whether a jury found Cryer guilty or not guilty is completely beside the point. Juries do not determine questions of law, they merely determine questions of fact.
 
According to Malmo's logic, the fact that OJ Simpson was found not guilty means that there is no law against murder.

Actually, I think his logic would dictate that because OJ Simpson was found not guilty of murder in America, it means there is no law against murder in Australia.
 
I am disappointed in all of the regular posters here that respond to the originator this thread beyond the point of stating the law and responding only to questions arising therefrom.

It's almost as if you as a skeptic are males and trolls are your blow-up doll female substitute. It's still masturbation. Now, I've nothing against masturbation, either as a practice or a habit, but it should really be kept a little more private. It makes you look as silly as the troll, what with you pretending that the blow-up doll is real and all.


The hammer meets the head of the coffin nail.


(It's a two fer')
 
I wonder if he can explain what this part of the constitution is saying:

"The Congress shall have the power to lay and collect taxes on income, from
whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration."

So the constitution grants Congress the right to tax income, and Congress grants the IRS the IRS the responsibility of collecting tax for Congress via the IRC.

His argument about the IRs not making laws is like saying the Police don't make laws. Of course they don't. They enforce them, just like the IRS does.

And maybe he should read code 61 of the IRC.
 
The hammer meets the head of the coffin nail.


(It's a two fer')
Two fer -
gnomeleft.gif
gnome.gif
- No more Swedish tax experts please.
 
Last edited:
I would like to clear up a common misconception on the authority for Congress to pass income tax laws. The source of that authority is not the 16th Amendment. The source is Art. I. Sec. 8 -

Section 8. The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes, duties, imposts and excises, to pay the debts and provide for the common defense and general welfare of the United States; but all duties, imposts and excises shall be uniform throughout the United States;


The reason for the 16th Amendment is that the Supreme Court decided, with regard to the tax on income and rents from property in the Income Tax Act of 1894, that income taxes (at least on property) are a direct tax. This is important because Art. I, Sec. 2, Cl. 3 states that direct taxes must follow the rules of apportionment. Apportionment is how the distribution of Congresspeople to States in the House of Representatives is determined. Obviously, an income tax won't work very well if it must be apportioned.

In short, all the 16th Amendment does is state that income taxes are not subject to the rules of apportionment that other direct taxes are subject to. It is not the source of Congress's power to levy income taxes.
 
I would like to clear up a common misconception on the authority for Congress to pass income tax laws. The source of that authority is not the 16th Amendment. The source is Art. I. Sec. 8 -

The reason for the 16th Amendment is that the Supreme Court decided, with regard to the tax on income and rents from property in the Income Tax Act of 1894, that income taxes (at least on property) are a direct tax. This is important because Art. I, Sec. 2, Cl. 3 states that direct taxes must follow the rules of apportionment. Apportionment is how the distribution of Congresspeople to States in the House of Representatives is determined. Obviously, an income tax won't work very well if it must be apportioned.

In short, all the 16th Amendment does is state that income taxes are not subject to the rules of apportionment that other direct taxes are subject to. It is not the source of Congress's power to levy income taxes.

Yes, thank you

I tried injecting this into this thread by pointing this out to our tax protesting friend after he told me that "everyone knows" Congress didn't have that power before the 16th amendment. But I've since seen several people (debunkers, mostly) making the same mistake as our tax protester friend.

The common tax protester tactic preys upon this myth by reciting the supreme decision that the 16th amendment did not give any new powers of taxation. This is an excellent refutation to people who erroneously believe that power came from the 16th amendment. (This situation is identical to 9/11 debunkers preying on the steel-melting belief by reciting that the fires weren't hot enough to melt steel. This tactic preys upon a popular misconception.)

As the same decision clearly spells out, Congress has always had the power to tax income.
 
Last edited:
So that's it then?

No rebuttals or retorts to the above two posts?

Good.

This whole income tax is illegal has always struck be as one of the most flagrant violations of common sense reasoning to ever be tossed out there.

Seems to me, that an accountant, any accountant could greatly increase his business at personal income tax time by advertising ' Hey...get your taxes done by my firm, and we'll deal with the IRS when they come knocking at your door as part of our package!!!"

At least, if I lived in the US, I'd be shopping for an accountant with that philosophy.

So the 16th Amendment is immaterial, and the US gov't has always been "authorised" to collect income tax, and it's only when someone is charged with tax evasion that they trot out this whole income tax is illegal theory in order to beat charges of tax evasion....even though if they do beat those charges, they're still on the hook for the taxes they owe.

Who was that producer guy who made that movie ? The guy who owed two million in back taxes and was pissed off enough about it to spread this idea through You Tube...Leading to interesting threads like this.
 
So the 16th Amendment is immaterial...
Not exactly. I'm not the expert here, but I think that the 16th Amendment is necessary to have the tax established in its current form; i.e., without regard to apportionment.

Who was that producer guy who made that movie ?
I think you mean Aaron Russo, who made From Freedom to Fascism.
 
So, again, where are the millions NOT paying then?

And why has it taken so long to come to light?


I think they have known for awhile that a lot of income tax is not collected.

http://www.uhuh.com/taxstuff/gracecom.htm#IRSWasted


PRESIDENT'S PRIVATE SECTOR SURVEY ON COST CONTROL
A REPORT TO THE PRESIDENT
VOLUME I
APPROVED BY THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE AT
ITS MEETING ON JANUARY 15, 1984

Resistance to additional income taxes would be even more widespread if people were aware that:

One-third of all their taxes is consumed by waste and inefficiency in the Federal Government as we identified in our survey.

Another one-third of all their taxes escapes collection from others as the underground economy blossoms in direct proportion to tax increases and places even more pressure on law abiding taxpayers, promoting still more underground economy-a vicious cycle that must be broken.

With two-thirds of everyone's personal income taxes wasted or not collected, 100 percent of what is collected is absorbed solely by interest on the Federal debt and by Federal Government contributions to transfer payments. In other words, all individual income tax revenues are gone before one nickel is spent on the services which taxpayers expect from their Government.
 
Last edited:
Another one-third of all their taxes escapes collection from others as the underground economy blossoms in direct proportion to tax increases and places even more pressure on law abiding taxpayers, promoting still more underground economy-a vicious cycle that must be broken.
They're talking about people being paid under the table, and say it hurts "law-abiding taxpayers."

You know, the ones who actually pay their taxes like they're supposed to and like the law says they have to.

And yes, I'd like to heartily discourage Americans from taking legal advice from non-Americans with personal biases. When the site's back up, I'll link to a great story about a guy who had his profile and chatlog posted on Perverted Justice and listened to Norweigans running an anti-PJ website telling him he should call the police and file harrassment charges.

The "victim" listened to them and wound up going to jail for soliciting a minor. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom