TheBigKahuna
Thinker
- Joined
- Aug 29, 2009
- Messages
- 162
The glaring error in the article.
Well, Dave, not bad, but you should have checked with a chemist before adding this statement:
"Because thermite supplies its own oxygen (via iron oxides), it can even burn underwater."
Troofers have claimed that thermite supplies it's own oxygen and that's why it's not necessary to perform the analysis in an inert atmosphere.
The thermite reaction is an oxidation/reduction (redox) reaction, but not of the subset of redox reactions commonly called combustion, so it does not burn. The reaction is:
Fe2O3 + 2Al --> Al2O3 + 2Fe
Now, we can break this down to the ionic equation:
2Fe3+ + 3O2- + 2Al --> 2Al3+ + 3O2- + 2Fe
Now, we can eliminate the ions that have no affect on the reaction, which is to say, the spectator ions:
2Fe3+ + 2Al --> 2Al3+ + 2Fe
The half reaction equations are (reduced to the single atom):
Oxidation: Fe3+ + 3e- --> Fe
Reduction: Al --> Al3+ + 3e-
Thermite can react underwater, but not because it supplies it's own oxygen. More than likely, it is the combination of the intense heat vaporizing water and also causing thermal decomposition that prevents the water molecules from mixing with the reactants and quenching the reaction.
Well, Dave, not bad, but you should have checked with a chemist before adding this statement:
"Because thermite supplies its own oxygen (via iron oxides), it can even burn underwater."
Troofers have claimed that thermite supplies it's own oxygen and that's why it's not necessary to perform the analysis in an inert atmosphere.
The thermite reaction is an oxidation/reduction (redox) reaction, but not of the subset of redox reactions commonly called combustion, so it does not burn. The reaction is:
Fe2O3 + 2Al --> Al2O3 + 2Fe
Now, we can break this down to the ionic equation:
2Fe3+ + 3O2- + 2Al --> 2Al3+ + 3O2- + 2Fe
Now, we can eliminate the ions that have no affect on the reaction, which is to say, the spectator ions:
2Fe3+ + 2Al --> 2Al3+ + 2Fe
The half reaction equations are (reduced to the single atom):
Oxidation: Fe3+ + 3e- --> Fe
Reduction: Al --> Al3+ + 3e-
Thermite can react underwater, but not because it supplies it's own oxygen. More than likely, it is the combination of the intense heat vaporizing water and also causing thermal decomposition that prevents the water molecules from mixing with the reactants and quenching the reaction.