Skeptical Inquirer July/August issue on 9/11 Truth, now at the Printer's

The glaring error in the article.

Well, Dave, not bad, but you should have checked with a chemist before adding this statement:
"Because thermite supplies its own oxygen (via iron oxides), it can even burn underwater."
Troofers have claimed that thermite supplies it's own oxygen and that's why it's not necessary to perform the analysis in an inert atmosphere.

The thermite reaction is an oxidation/reduction (redox) reaction, but not of the subset of redox reactions commonly called combustion, so it does not burn. The reaction is:

Fe2O3 + 2Al --> Al2O3 + 2Fe

Now, we can break this down to the ionic equation:

2Fe3+ + 3O2- + 2Al --> 2Al3+ + 3O2- + 2Fe

Now, we can eliminate the ions that have no affect on the reaction, which is to say, the spectator ions:

2Fe3+ + 2Al --> 2Al3+ + 2Fe

The half reaction equations are (reduced to the single atom):
Oxidation: Fe3+ + 3e- --> Fe
Reduction: Al --> Al3+ + 3e-
Thermite can react underwater, but not because it supplies it's own oxygen. More than likely, it is the combination of the intense heat vaporizing water and also causing thermal decomposition that prevents the water molecules from mixing with the reactants and quenching the reaction.
 
The glaring error in the article.

Well, Dave, not bad, but you should have checked with a chemist before adding this statement:
"Because thermite supplies its own oxygen (via iron oxides), it can even burn underwater."
Troofers have claimed that thermite supplies it's own oxygen and that's why it's not necessary to perform the analysis in an inert atmosphere.

The thermite reaction is an oxidation/reduction (redox) reaction, but not of the subset of redox reactions commonly called combustion, so it does not burn. The reaction is:

Fe2O3 + 2Al --> Al2O3 + 2Fe

Now, we can break this down to the ionic equation:

2Fe3+ + 3O2- + 2Al --> 2Al3+ + 3O2- + 2Fe

Now, we can eliminate the ions that have no affect on the reaction, which is to say, the spectator ions:

2Fe3+ + 2Al --> 2Al3+ + 2Fe

The half reaction equations are (reduced to the single atom):
Oxidation: Fe3+ + 3e- --> Fe
Reduction: Al --> Al3+ + 3e-
Thermite can react underwater, but not because it supplies it's own oxygen. More than likely, it is the combination of the intense heat vaporizing water and also causing thermal decomposition that prevents the water molecules from mixing with the reactants and quenching the reaction.

Thanks for the correction, o large one! I will check it out further. Perhaps you should mention in a brief LTE of S/I?
 
Surfing around a bit, I found Boloboffin's excellent mashup, "But WTC 7 Wasn't Hit By A Plane!":



Looks a bit bigger than "dust and paper", eh?

He's right that WTC7 wasn't hit by a plane but that was certainly the original plan. Circumstances arose that prevented the third plane hitting WTC7.
 
He's right that WTC7 wasn't hit by a plane but that was certainly the original plan. Circumstances arose that prevented the third plane hitting WTC7.

Was that because of the passengers who didn't exist and/or didn't call their relatives?
 
If I can just remember where it is on the enourmous magazine rack at the B&N.

I also can't wait for the letter to the editor page a few issues from now.
 
Last edited:
BTW Dave, "The Root of all Superstition is that men observe when a thing hits, but not when it misses" - Francis Bacon

I love crytograms!
 
BTW Dave, "The Root of all Superstition is that men observe when a thing hits, but not when it misses" - Francis Bacon

I love crytograms!

Thanks! If you get Skeptical Briefs, the fall issue will have a cryptogram puzzle featuring a quote by our very own Twinstead. 'Twas a relevant pithism on 9/11 truth.

:D
 
Last edited:
Free Copies Available!

From Man Boobz:

Free Skeptical Inquirer magazines

Post by BlackBloc on Wed Aug 10, 2011 12:29 pm
Skeptical Inquirer have extra copies of their 9/11 Conspiracy Theories issue to send to American residents, if that interests any of you. I thought it was a decent issue, apart from the ambivalent "Women in Science, Nature or Nurture" article which is a bit too deferential to Pinker and Summers and the like. However it's a pretty good reference piece for when you need to tsk tsk or roll eyes at a Truther in your entourage (helloooooo NWOSlave).

From the Skeptical Inquirer FB page:
If you'd like a free copy send us your name and address and we'll send you one while supplies last. US residents only (sorry). send to [email protected]
 
When will AE911 Truth Respond to 9/11 S/I Issue?

Ted Goertzel's article on 9/11 Truth and other conspiracies, from the Jan./Feb. 2011 Skeptical Inquirer, appeared on news-stands on November 26, 2010. 42 days later, Richard Gage's Architects and Engineers responded with a post titled "Skeptical Inquirer Attacks 9/11 Truth Movement, Avoids Vast Body of Scientific Evidence."

When the May/June 2011 issue of Skeptical Inquirer came out (April 8, 2011), it contained two letters-to-the-editor by AE911Truth supporters. AE911 staff posted the letters on May 4th, 2011, 26 days after the issue appeared on news-stands.

Here it is, August 16th, 2011, a full 67 days since the special issue of Skeptical Inquirer on 9/11 Truth appeared in the July/August issue (it hit news-stands on June 10th, 2011).

Either AE911Truthiness is working up one gangbuster of a rebuttal, or they're quietly ignoring the entire issue, realizing it is Truther Bane.

Any one care to guess which way it will go?
 
My copy arrived in the post two days ago, and I'm loving it! Full of skeptical goodness!

Great stuff, Dave!

I'd love to see the list of your questions for Jesse Ventura (that he refused to answer).
 
When will it be available on PDF? I know that some of the older issues can be found in that format.
 
Finally got permission to post my article from the July/August 2011 Skeptical Inquirer, here!

Regards, Dave

Thank you. If you plan on hosting it for awhile might I suggest adding it to the Gravysites sticky at the top of this subforum so that others can easily find it later on.

Regards, Sam I Am.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom