Skeptical Inquirer July/August issue on 9/11 Truth, now at the Printer's

Reaction in Germany

From diesseits.de, The online magazine for secular humanism :

Translation:

Press review: "Skeptical Inquirer" July / August 2011

Conspiracy theories, alternative medicine and belief in spirits - these are the major themes that run through the summer issue of "Skeptikal Inquirer". - Thomas Hummitzsch

The English-language magazine of the American Skeptics Organization Committee for Skeptical Inquiry is concerned, ten years after the terrorist attacks on Al-Qaeda's New York and Washington with the various conspiracy theories and their durability. For example, explains the physicist and mathematician Dave Thomas, why was the collapse of Building 7 World Trade Center, even if it was not even directly hit by airplanes. Conspiracy theorists have claimed repeatedly that the collapse of the building is proof that the attacks have been a covert intelligence and attack the buildings were actually demolished.

The social scientist Jamie Bartlett and Carl Miller talk about their experiences with British conspiracy theorists and their true motivations. An important role among the conspirators to play "message" to victims of Nine Eleven. With this obvious nonsense grapples the spirits of the skeptics expert Joe Nickel.

Yup, auto-translation still has room for improvement! ;)
 
From diesseits.de, The online magazine for secular humanism :

Translation:

Press review: "Skeptical Inquirer" July / August 2011



Yup, auto-translation still has room for improvement! ;)

I didn't get it, so I had to read for myself :D
Human translator says:
Ten years after Al Quaeda's terror attacks agains New York and Washington, the English-language magazine of the American skeptical organisation Committee for Skeptical Inquiry concerns itself with the various conspiracy theories and their durability. For example, the physicist and mathematician Dave Thomas explains why building 7 of the WTC could collapse, even though it wasn't hit dircectly by a plan. Conspiracy theorist have claimed repeatedly that the collapse of the building is proof that the terror attacks were a covert intelligence operation, and that the buildings were really exploded.

The social scientists Jamie Bartlett and Carl Miller report their experiences with British conspiracy theorists and their actual motivations. "Messages" from 9/11 victims play an important role among conspirators [they probably mean CTers], too. The ghost expert and skeptiv Joe Nickel tackles this obvious nonsense [note: here, I think the story bleeds into non-9/11 issues].
...

The article is written in somewhat clumsy language. I would say a mediocre staff writer with no interest in the topic.
 
I didn't get it, so I had to read for myself :D
Human translator says:


The article is written in somewhat clumsy language. I would say a mediocre staff writer with no interest in the topic.

Thanks for the translation, Oystein! Ever so much better than the Google, this time.

I find it instructive to run web-based translators in recursive mode, translating back the result of each translation.

Google Translate did the following, for French to English and back:
  • Jesse is a nincompoop => Jesse est un nigaud
  • Jesse est un nigaud => Jesse is a fool
  • Jesse is a fool => Jesse est un imbécile
  • Jesse est un imbécile => Jesse is a fool
Of course, Jesse is an imbecile => Jesse est un imbécile also! :D
 
More from EBay

John Wade has finally gotten around to fulfilling his promise over on EBay Forums: "But in about a week I'll point out some of the errors and lies, one of which is so bad that even a 5 year old child can clearly see it's a lie."

In his new post, "I demolish the Skeptical Inquirer hate and lie piece about 911 Truth!" (July 8th), Wade writes:

"Skeptical Inquirer" is a national magazine that comes out monthly in bookstores, magazine shops, grocery stores. In January they did a hate and lie piece about the 911 Truth Movement. Now they are at it again with a report by someone named "Dave Thomas" in the July issue entitled "911 Truth Movement The Top Conspiracy Theory, A Decade later".

He attempts to put a dent in the giant locomotive called the 911 Truth Movement with a bunch of stupid lies and half truths. He identifies himself as a New Mexico scientist. The photo shows someone with a big, black, curly beard looking very much like a middle eastern man.

I'm going to focus on two of his more ridiculous and unsubtantiated claims.

1. He says that Building 7 of the World Trade complex, which was never hit by a plane, came down like a perfect controlled demolition because it was hit by large pieces of debris from the North Tower which produced multiple large fires.
...
2. He claims that the collapse of the two towers was due to fire softening the floor pans and girders so that they gave way resulting in the so called "pancaking" from top to bottom of the floors. But he makes a huge mistake in his diagram.

How does he dismantle my observations? A snippet:
The plane that hit the North Tower hit the side facing Building 7. The impact made debris fly AWAY from Building 7. If I throw a rock at a glass window, the fragments are going to move away from me and not towards me. Therefore, it's very unlikely that Building 7 got hit by any huge debris from the airplane impact into the North Tower when it was over 100 yards away from the base of the North Tower.
...
Since the North Tower came down like a perfect controlled demolition with not even 1 degree of tilt it's very doubtful that anything larger than dust, paper or pieces of drywall and possibly several steel girders hit Building 7. No photos exist of a huge chunk hitting Building 7.


Whoa - the Woo is strong with this one!
 
John Wade has finally gotten around to fulfilling his promise over on EBay Forums: "But in about a week I'll point out some of the errors and lies, one of which is so bad that even a 5 year old child can clearly see it's a lie."...
Since the North Tower came down like a perfect controlled demolition with not even 1 degree of tilt it's very doubtful that anything larger than dust, paper or pieces of drywall and possibly several steel girders hit Building 7. No photos exist of a huge chunk hitting Building 7.

Surfing around a bit, I found Boloboffin's excellent mashup, "But WTC 7 Wasn't Hit By A Plane!":



Looks a bit bigger than "dust and paper", eh?
 
Surfing around a bit, I found Boloboffin's excellent mashup, "But WTC 7 Wasn't Hit By A Plane!":



Looks a bit bigger than "dust and paper", eh?
here's a panel section off the north face of 1 WTC which appears to be heading towards building 7

collapse-01-2.jpg
 
Got my copy 2 days ago, well done Dave! I'm glad you addressed David Chandler's claims, as well as Richard Gage's.

I'd love to see this kind of rebuttal in a mag like Scientific American or something of that sort - SI is still a niche mag, doesn't reach enough regular folk IMO to make a big dent in public perception.

But kudos to you!
 
Delete massive post.....


Dude, you put all that in a post, and fail to note that the NWO is once again laughing at us by using the term "twin towers" in that article?




I didn't get it, so I had to read for myself :D
Human translator says:

For example, the physicist and mathematician Dave Thomas explains why building 7 of the WTC could collapse, even though it wasn't hit dircectly by a plan.

The article is written in somewhat clumsy language. I would say a mediocre staff writer with no interest in the topic.

Oh, it was hit by a "plan" alright! [/CTist] :D


And I'm Stundieing that guy who said no debris hit WTC7.....
 
As far as no photo of debris hitting Building 7, watch my YouTube video rebuttal of Gage part 13 here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uv06LjVGC6Q&feature=related
The NIST Report has a photo of hundreds of feet of debris flying towards Building 7 just as the second tower collapses. It's like a tsunami!

Dave, I noticed your article was called a "Hate Piece." You look Middle Eastern? Wow... as many of you know I have an article coming out in Skeptic.com (probably) in just over a month. Dave I can't wait to see the objective, dispassionate reviews of my article as well. Maybe I'll be treated more nicely because I don't have a beard???
 
Just snagged this issue today and couldn't put it down.* Very compelling breakdown, though I'm sure the truth movement won't see it that way.

I know some people who are generally curious, but don't know what to make of all the misinformation and disinformation surrounding 9/11. I'll be showing this to them.

(*I was at work, but thankfully not very busy and essentially being paid to do nothing. Good reading conditions.)
 
Dave,

Is there any way to get broader distribution of this S.I. issue? I had a hard time getting my own issue, it's good, as readable as any other popular lay science/mechanics type magazine out there, and I so wish the info could be more widely disseminated! Anyone good at publicity and how to followup good publicity with easy distribution...
 
Dave,

Is there any way to get broader distribution of this S.I. issue? I had a hard time getting my own issue, it's good, as readable as any other popular lay science/mechanics type magazine out there, and I so wish the info could be more widely disseminated! Anyone good at publicity and how to followup good publicity with easy distribution...

I'll inquire with the editor!

Thanks, Dave
 
Dave,

Is there any way to get broader distribution of this S.I. issue? I had a hard time getting my own issue, it's good, as readable as any other popular lay science/mechanics type magazine out there, and I so wish the info could be more widely disseminated! Anyone good at publicity and how to followup good publicity with easy distribution...

Online would be the way. Put it to the editor that he could put it free online for this one issue in recognition of 9/11. It might work wonders for his sales later on.
 
Last edited:
Hey, look what was tucked in with some of the birthday presents I received a couple of days ago.

Nice work, Dave!
 

Attachments

  • BD prezzies.jpg
    BD prezzies.jpg
    71.6 KB · Views: 12
Hey, look what was tucked in with some of the birthday presents I received a couple of days ago.

Nice work, Dave!

Cool! Happy belated birthday, btw! Hope you're not roasting too badly back East. No such problems here in Vancouver..:o
 
Hey, look what was tucked in with some of the birthday presents I received a couple of days ago.

Nice work, Dave!

Dude, she's got some creepy shrine thing going on with the stuff she got. What with what looks like a Heavens Gate purple death shroud laying there with her "Loot" on top of that you might be in trouble. Off to the right is what looks like an urn that one might keep the ashes of previous "Stalkee's" If one were so inclined (not that I'd know anything about that of course). I'd be careful if I were you...

:boxedin:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom