Should Registration for the the Military Draft in the USA be Abolished?

Hell, frankly the US could probably survive without a military altogether.

The US could probably not survive in its present form and at its present size/influence without a military capable of projecting power at least regionally.

There are many countries that are able to forego having more than a token military because the US and a handful of other nations possess power projection platforms.
 
The US could probably not survive in its present form and at its present size/influence without a military capable of projecting power at least regionally.

There are many countries that are able to forgo having more than a token military because the US and a handful of other nations possess power projection platforms.
I've no doubt that it's in the interest of the US to maintain a large military, but that's the point - that military isn't really there to "protect America", America's base survival isn't threatened. It's there to protect America's overseas economic and political interests. And whatever enemies America has are generally enemies because of those interests; I don't think any of them really wants to send an army to invade America and hoist a flag over the White House. And I'm certain that none of them could do so.
 
I've no doubt that it's in the interest of the US to maintain a large military, but that's the point - that military isn't really there to "protect America", America's base survival isn't threatened. It's there to protect America's overseas economic and political interests. And whatever enemies America has are generally enemies because of those interests; I don't think any of them really wants to send an army to invade America and hoist a flag over the White House. And I'm certain that none of them could do so.

In the absence of the products and revenue of our overseas involvements, the United States ceases to exist in it's present form. In the absence of the ability to project power and influence, our overseas interests change substantially enough to dramatically change the nature of our country. So, in a very real sense, America does not exist without a military.

And yes, in the complete absence of a military, we would be at risk of invasion. Perhaps you really meant the "we have more military than we need" instead?
 
Indeed, Bill Thompson had no idea that members of the military could be removed from service "fired" for non-criminal offences.

Like what?

I think it is you who do not know what you are talking about.

And, by the way, I did not say "members of the military". I said enlisted persons.
 
Ignore for a moment the obvious factual errors in his posts. In fact, ignore his posts on this subject.

We have no draft. Almost all persons currently serving in the military volunteered for a specified term of service with full knowledge that they are contractually obligated to finish the term and that there might be penalties for failing to do so. In other words, an enlistee is similar to private contracted employees.

Do you consider this slavery as well?


You can get kicked out for going AWOL. But that seems like a criminal offense to me.

The military is not an accounting firm. Your life is required to help protect other lives when you are in the military.

One could say that that is like slavery. Is it a revelation to you that life is hard?
 
False. Only for crimes. You can sit around and screw up your job and be lazy etc. but you cannot be fired. If you freaking run off and kill someone on purpose, hell yeah you can get arrested. If you run off and do heroin and fail a drug test, hell yeah you can get arrested, but you cannot get fired. No enlisted man got kicked out of the military for poor job performance. That is what I mean by "fired". I don't mean dishonorable discharge, dude.

Disagree? Give a real example. Don't give vague generalizations. Don't give confused opinions showing you don't know specifics. I don't think you know what you are talking about. I do. I have first hand knowledge and experience.
Wiki disagrees with you.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_discharge
 
Like what?

I think it is you who do not know what you are talking about.

And, by the way, I did not say "members of the military". I said enlisted persons.

I provided a non-exhaustive list if several non-criminal activites/shortcomings that can result in enlisted persons being involuntarily eliminated from the military. I witnessed several hundred ofnthe eliminations during my career.

It is conclusive that you were wrong when you claimed that enlisted service members could not be "fired".
 
You can get kicked out for going AWOL. But that seems like a criminal offense to me.

The military is not an accounting firm. Your life is required to help protect other lives when you are in the military.

One could say that that is like slavery. Is it a revelation to you that life is hard?

Arguing past the point that you have been demonstrated to be wrong is silly - and I believe you are struggling to separate several different arguments younare involved in. I have made no "life should be easy" argument.
 
In the absence of the products and revenue of our overseas involvements, the United States ceases to exist in it's present form.
In its present form, sure. As I keep saying, I'm sure it would have an effect, a huge effect. What it wouldn't do is make America cease to exist.

And yes, in the complete absence of a military, we would be at risk of invasion.
From whom?
 
I've no doubt that it's in the interest of the US to maintain a large military, but that's the point - that military isn't really there to "protect America", America's base survival isn't threatened. It's there to protect America's overseas economic and political interests.
It also protects domestic economic and political interests. The military and all its accoutrements employ a lot of people and drive not insignificant portion of the economy... which is why the states where the military is a big employer or a driver of employment have representatives on the Armed Forces Committee.

From whom?
"Them"
 
In its present form, sure. As I keep saying, I'm sure it would have an effect, a huge effect. What it wouldn't do is make America cease to exist.[/qoute]

Your position seemed to be that America could exist without a military at all. I do not believe that the current America, or even a reasonable semblance of the current America, could.

The current America would soon cease lot exist without a military.


From whom?

If we had no military at all, Mexico would annex us in very short order.
 
You can get kicked out for going AWOL. But that seems like a criminal offense to me.

You can also be denied re-enlistment if you do not perform well, or fail PT tests for no apparent reason. You can also be discharged early for poor moral character and failure to meet certain standards of discipline. Spouse abusers can be discharged out of hand. It just requires a little more paperwork than it does at the local burger stand.
 
Your position seemed to be that America could exist without a military at all. I do not believe that the current America, or even a reasonable semblance of the current America, could.

The current America would soon cease lot exist without a military.
And once again, I'm not speaking of "the current" America in the sense of everything staying the same. Things would change, no doubt considerably. But America would still exist, with the same people living there, the same government, the same basic way of life.

If we had no military at all, Mexico would annex us in very short order.
Nonsense.
 
And once again, I'm not speaking of "the current" America in the sense of everything staying the same. Things would change, no doubt considerably. But America would still exist, with the same people living there, the same government, the same basic way of life.

In the complete absence of a military, the US would change so significantly that it would no longer be the same country - although it might still be called by the same name. The citizens would not enjoy the same basic way of life as they now do.

Not at all. If we had no means of preventing them, Mexico would absolutely move on America. We posses resources they lack, and they would possess the means to simply take the resources.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom