Should Registration for the the Military Draft in the USA be Abolished?

True enough - but potentially confusing. There need not be a crime in order to involuntarily eliminate a Soldier from service.

A Specialist (E4) that fails to make E5 (Sergeant) is eliminated upon reaching 8 years of service. This is true even if the Specialist was a Sergeant and gets reduced for inefficiency.

Sarge, I think Crossbow left the Navy after one hitch, in the years well before DOPMA and well before High Year Tenure separations, which was reinvigorated during the Clinton Era. It is a personnel policy I learned to love to hate as I lost some good sailors. :mad:
 
Sarge, I think Crossbow left the Navy after one hitch, in the years well before DOPMA and well before High Year Tenure separations, which was reinvigorated during the Clinton Era. It is a personnel policy I learned to love to hate as I lost some good sailors. :mad:

Maybe it's a service specific thing? The Army has had some form of retention control for as long as I've been aware of such things. The trigger points have changed often - two years ago an E6 could stay to 24 years, during the Clinton draw-downs, an E6 might be eliminated 2 years before retirement.

One of the five guys I was hired with when I became a DA Civilian was booted out after 15 years of service. He started in the Navy, got out after a single emnlistment, and joined the Army. He entered an MOS with very high promotion cut-off scores, and failed to make E6 before his 15th year of service. Good guy, excellent employee, and hard to imagine he was less than the same as a Soldier. Up or out has always seemed to be the least desirable way to meet end-strength goals to me.

In any event, Crossbow's information was perfectly accurate. I just wanted to make sure that the OP didn't get further confused about whether or not a service member could be involuntarily seperated without having committed a crime.
 
You say a lot of things that don't make any sense. You seem to believe in magic. If the country is attacked people will raise up and fight the enemy via magic.


There is no such thing as magic. The best decisions are not made by democratic process. Thinking that is so is akin to believe in magic. Magic is not real, man. (by the way, this is why we have the electorial college)


Democracy has its place in deciding things like "what movie are we all going out to see" or "what ice cream are we going to buy". But democracy does not work in real life-or-death scenarios like, "what antidote should we all inject into ourselves to save our lives". This is the same as believing a majority will decide when and if to go to war on its own.

But you seem to think that a people who need to raise up against an enemy will mostly do so when the need logically comes to pass. It won't. Human beings, in case you have not noticed, are not logical creatures. Your faith in them is a delusion.


What I am telling you is not just a matter of opnion. It is not contraversial. It is not even an argument. It is obvious. You are obviously wrong. It is obvious that our species is not intelligent enough to take care of itself and decide when and if to go to war. Want proof? We even KNOW that we are not an intelligent species. One simple proof is the fact that the word "medeocre" means both average and stupid at the same time. We are too stupid to go fight an enemy when we should. We need a draft.

The fact that we have been lucky with a volunteer military is a matter of just that: LUCK.

re the bolded. No it doesn't. Mediocre might.

And can I ask, are you a Spartan?
 
Last edited:
I am sorry. I thought we were talking about how things are in the real world instead of your fantasy Alice-In-Wonderland Liberal Fantasy world. I did not realize you were on a mission to make your fantasy world a reality by pretending it is plausible by assuming that it already exists.

Get out of the Matrix, Neo. Things are worse than you imagine and human nature on the international stage is not kind.
 
You say a lot of things that don't make any sense. You seem to believe in magic. If the country is attacked people will raise up and fight the enemy via magic.
Um, no, there's no such thing as magic. I think they will rise up via walking down to their local recruiting office. It's really not that difficult. It's even rather common at the outbreak of a war where the people genuinely care about it - for instance in World War I the British used the draft, but they really didn't need it to raise the required numbers; they always had a plentiful supply of volunteers, the main purpose of the draft was to turn the large glut of people who volunteered at the start of the war into a steady stream of manageable proportions.

The best decisions are not made by democratic process.
Perhaps. "Best" is a rather subjective term. Certainly democracy can lead to bad decisions, as indeed can any other system. But I've repeatedly said, if the people of the country aren't prepared to defend it, then the country deserves to perish.

But you seem to think that a people who need to raise up against an enemy will mostly do so when the need logically comes to pass. It won't.
You seem to have a reading comprehension problem, so I will say this again as simply as I can.

I accept that people might not volunteer for a war.

If that happens, the war should be lost.

If that means all the people are conquered or killed, that is what should happen.


Now you can blather and sputter all you want that people won't volunteer, but you seem not to grasp the fact that I AGREE WITH YOU. Yes, they might not volunteer. if they don't they should lose the war.

Here it is again : IF THEY DON'T VOLUNTEER THEY SHOULD LOSE THE WAR.

I really can't make it any simpler for you. I'm sure you will rant once more about how people won't volunteer, as if that is some sort of problem for my argument. It isn't. It has nothing to do with my argument.

There we go. I'm afraid I can't make it any simpler for you.
 
As an enlisted person In the military, you have a job that you cannot be fired for. You have free housing and meals. You have free dental care and healthcare. If you shop on base, you do not pay taxes. You work alongside people who you become to regard as your brothers. NOT being in the military can be regarded as being more like slavery, my misinformed friend.

Can you leave, if you want to?

No?

That's slavery.

I'm against slavery, and I am sorry that you are for it.
 
Can you leave, if you want to?

No?

That's slavery.

I'm against slavery, and I am sorry that you are for it.

Ignore for a moment the obvious factual errors in his posts. In fact, ignore his posts on this subject.

We have no draft. Almost all persons currently serving in the military volunteered for a specified term of service with full knowledge that they are contractually obligated to finish the term and that there might be penalties for failing to do so. In other words, an enlistee is similar to private contracted employees.

Do you consider this slavery as well?
 
Regarding the comment that a Draft is slavery: Life is slavery. Everyone has to answer to someone or something.

I mean, that is reality. Sorry you live in a fantasy world. I feel sorry for you.
 
Regarding the comment that a Draft is slavery: Life is slavery. Everyone has to answer to someone or something.
Being answerable to people isn't slavery. Being forced to be answerable to people against your will is slavery.

I mean, that is reality.
No, rather it's the little fantasy world you've concocted in which Somalian pirates are a major threat to civilization.

It's not so much that I mind you being wrong, but it's quite strange to see you being such a big baby about it.
 
Ignore for a moment the obvious factual errors in his posts. In fact, ignore his posts on this subject.
Okay, I can ignore his posts.

We have no draft. Almost all persons currently serving in the military volunteered for a specified term of service with full knowledge that they are contractually obligated to finish the term and that there might be penalties for failing to do so. In other words, an enlistee is similar to private contracted employees.

Do you consider this slavery as well?
I think it's about a halfway house. If it were up to me people would be able to resign from the military at any time, for the same reason - nobody should have to serve in the military who doesn't want to, IMO.

That said, a volunteer has agreed to give up that freedom in the first place, so whilst I oppose it, it's not nearly as bad a case as one where the government turns up on your doorstep and says "that's it mate, you're off to war."
 
Okay, I can ignore his posts.


I think it's about a halfway house. If it were up to me people would be able to resign from the military at any time, for the same reason - nobody should have to serve in the military who doesn't want to, IMO.

That said, a volunteer has agreed to give up that freedom in the first place, so whilst I oppose it, it's not nearly as bad a case as one where the government turns up on your doorstep and says "that's it mate, you're off to war."


If I fully understand your position, you oppose a person being obligated by something other than his own sense of obligation.

While I understand the appeal of this notion, I can't actually agree with it. People are self-serving, mostly. So long as that is true, and assuming you ascribe to the notion that "society" is desirable, it is going to be necessary to compel some people to do some things they otherwise would not do. All that remains to argue about is where to draw the line.
 
The idea that the abolishment of draft registration will somehow limit war and/or lead to a better world is like the idea that getting rid of ambulances will lead to less car accidents.
 
Ignore for a moment the obvious factual errors in his posts. In fact, ignore his posts on this subject.

Indeed, Bill Thompson had no idea that members of the military could be removed from service "fired" for non-criminal offences.
 
Last edited:
Maybe this thread is mistitled. Maybe I should have titled it "Could the Registration..." instead of "Should the Registration..."; many people believe in a fantasy that they think will come true if they insist it should come true.

The UN created a "Universal Human Rights" documents that had a lot of wonderful things on it such as the Universal Right to live in any country anyone wants and believe in any religion anyone wants. It is all candy and fantasy.

We are a horrible species. If it was not for the smallest part of one percent of us, we would all be living like wild dogs. I am sorry if this is not obvious to you. It should be.

It is a privledge, not a right, to live in a free country. If one day there is not a volunteer force to protect it, a military needs to be called upon a draft registry.

It is the same thing with any emergency. If all ambulance drivers were to be wiped out, people should and will be drafted to take their place. Too bad that is slavery, go cry in your Fruit Loops.
 
On Conscription, i feel that it is pointless for anything short of a full scale war. Professional soldiers are better motivated and trained because they want to be in the military, and thus have higher morale than people who were told "grab a gun, you're a meatshield!"

As well as that, training is more complex for soldiers today than 50 years ago. Not only in terms of getting used to more complicated equipment, but also the bar is raised for military standards with professional armies. Currently, training is expensive as it is, but try to conscript millions of troops, many of whom are unfit for military service for numerous reasons, and you will see those costs rise.

Another reason why conscription is mostly pointless - Drones. The modern military is transitioning to unmanned vehicles which are more effective in certain fields than humans (UAVs frex), and there's basically little point in putting ten or so lives at risk when a single drone would suffice for a mission.
 
Another reason why conscription is mostly pointless - Drones. The modern military is transitioning to unmanned vehicles which are more effective in certain fields than humans (UAVs frex), and there's basically little point in putting ten or so lives at risk when a single drone would suffice for a mission.

I agree with all your points, however in the event of a ground invasion of the homeland it would be useful for the public to act as a plain-clothes resistance force.. Though as long as we have all these guns I'm sure plenty of people would do just that with or without legal compulsion. Depends how well-mannered the Chinese troops are when they get here I suppose ;)
 
If I fully understand your position, you oppose a person being obligated by something other than his own sense of obligation.
No, not in a general sense. It's more the nature of the obligations. As I said before, I have no problem with taxes, nor with jury duty for instance. But conscription is far and away beyond any other legal obligation in terms of the demands it makes on a person. Conscription requires 24/7 service over an extended period - usually years - in an organization which removes many ordinary freedoms. Worse, it may require you to give up your life, or to take the life of others. Even surviving it physically without a scratch can and often does leave a person permanently damaged psychologically.

Now I have repeatedly said I am not opposed to war, but only a fool would fail to recognize the magnitude of the commitment required when compared to having to pay a percentage of your salary in tax, serve on a jury, obey a speed law, etc. To my mind, this is far into the realms where a government simply may not tread.

So long as that is true, and assuming you ascribe to the notion that "society" is desirable, it is going to be necessary to compel some people to do some things they otherwise would not do. All that remains to argue about is where to draw the line.
Absolutely agreed. But if the state has the right to force a significant percentage of its population into military service and require them to kill or die (or support such), then it seems to me like there would be precious little left on the other side of that line.
 
Maybe this thread is mistitled. Maybe I should have titled it "Could the Registration..." instead of "Should the Registration..."
Of course it could. Since the US hasn't actually drafted people for more than 35 years then it's perfectly obvious that the registration could be done away with. You'd barely notice the difference.

Hell, frankly the US could probably survive without a military altogether.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom