Shopping while speaking Spanish

The underlying problem, of course, is that there have always been a lot of racist ******** in the immigration agencies and Trump has massively empowered them.

If anyone else watched W Kamau Bell's episode of United Shades on this...

He points out, as one example, the many people who are working there, who sincerely see themselves as aiding the folks who try to enter illegally, because it *is* a dangerous undertaking. And to some extent, they are correct - better caught alive, then found dead with nothing but a few keepsakes and some forged documents.

He also shows that video of the border agents gleefully dumping out water that was left for people at the border crossing.

But yeah, immigration was one of those areas that was explicitly racial until a few decades ago - complete with Hispanic people who were born in the US being deported under "Operation Wetback". Immigration isn't really much different than the US in general in this regard (as usual, I won't discuss other countries since I've never so much as set foot in them aside from a handful of islands in the West Indies), both in history and in terms of the different people there.
 
An American cousin of mine firmly maintains that the immigrant situation in the US is a deliberate continuation of the capital owning classes policy of sourcing mass labour at the cheapest rate possible. According to him, first there was indentured servitude, then there was chattel slavery, then there was mass immigration from poor European countries, and then around the 1960s a serious tightening up of visas offered to Europeans as Europe became richer and they began to demand higher wages. Since then, the policy has been to turn a blind eye to as many immigrants from South America as possible crossing the border while officially disapproving and keeping their status illegal.

Illegal workers can't command much in the way of salaries and working conditions, so I suppose his theory makes sense.
 
Here in the United States, or at least the United States I grew up in, we do not have to carry our papers. We do not have to identify ourselves to anyone if we're minding our own business. Now if some authority asked to see my papers I might decide to comply as a matter of courtesy and convenience but that would be my own decision. I note too that the person in question DID provide documentation.

If you're driving on a public highway you need to show your license to a traffic cop. That's it.

Would you still be OK with this if the woman in question had, as is her absolute right, no documents on her, and was arrested and held on the mistaken and illegally unwarranted assumption that she's an alien? The ******** response from the Border Patrol makes it clear that they have the authority not only to accost and question citizens anywhere but to make arrests, anywhere. Do you think that if either of the women had omitted to take documentation with her, as any American is entitled to do, that unapologetically officious officer would have let them go about their business without at the very least a long detention, if not an arrest?

The fact that you can give a ready answer to a question does not mean that an inadmissible question is admissible.

But this is now blatantly untrue. Over 66% of the population lives in a border zone that the border patrol has expanded powers that are not limited by the constitution.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/latino/two-thirds-americans-live-border-zone-what-are-their-rights-n841141
 
Every Idiot Working for the Government...One by One

What idiocy? this is basic border patrol enforcement. This is entirely with in the powers granted to them. Really there is nothing to see here even less than the cops at starbucks.
 
An American cousin of mine firmly maintains that the immigrant situation in the US is a deliberate continuation of the capital owning classes policy of sourcing mass labour at the cheapest rate possible. According to him, first there was indentured servitude, then there was chattel slavery, then there was mass immigration from poor European countries, and then around the 1960s a serious tightening up of visas offered to Europeans as Europe became richer and they began to demand higher wages. Since then, the policy has been to turn a blind eye to as many immigrants from South America as possible crossing the border while officially disapproving and keeping their status illegal.

Illegal workers can't command much in the way of salaries and working conditions, so I suppose his theory makes sense.
There's some truth in this.
 
What idiocy? this is basic border patrol enforcement. This is entirely with in the powers granted to them. Really there is nothing to see here even less than the cops at starbucks.

Wrong, yet again. Speaking any language is not probable cause for anything. The guard was just being an ICEhat.
 
Wrong, yet again. Speaking any language is not probable cause for anything. The guard was just being an ICEhat.

But basic constitutional protections do no apply near the border and so the officer would have been well with in the expected behavior. Really she should just have given in and done what the cop was ordering legal or illegal. Because the officers orders were legal as the courts have consistently found.
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed previously moderated content and response to same
 
Last edited by a moderator:
But basic constitutional protections do no apply near the border and so the officer would have been well with in the expected behavior. Really she should just have given in and done what the cop was ordering legal or illegal. Because the officers orders were legal as the courts have consistently found.
I'm under the impression that she did do what he was ordering.
 
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...speaking-citizens-montana-havre-a8361051.html

....A woman said she plans to take legal action after a Border Patrol agent detained and questioned her and a friend - both US citizens - after overhearing them speak in Spanish at a petrol station.....

From the link:

“I just don't want this to happen anymore,” Ms Suda said. “I want people to know they have the right to speak whatever language they want.


News flash!

People still have the right to speak whatever language they want...
 
What are her legal grounds for suing?
I suppose you'd have to ask her for the details, but I think she contends that the action was improper, abusive, and constituted profiling. One presumes she and her friend obeyed the order in order to avoid even worse treatment (remember that the INS made it pretty clear that they can arrest anyone they damned well feel like anywhere they damned well please) but I think it would be too bad if the only way you could justify disputing an order would be to disobey it at untold expense.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom