Shopping while speaking Spanish

Checkmite

Skepticifimisticalationist
Joined
Jun 7, 2002
Messages
29,007
Location
Gulf Coast
This woman was at a grocery store in Montana when a Border Patrol overheard her speaking Spanish with a friend and detained her, demanding to know where she was born. She took out her phone and began to record the incident.

"He asked where I was born, so I looked at him and I said, 'Are you serious?' He's, like, 'Yes, I'm serious,' but, you know, with a very authoritative voice," Suda said.

Suda said she asked if she could pay for her items.

"He's, like, 'No, give me your I.D.' I said, 'I will give you my I.D. and I will go and pick up my cellular phone because I'm going to record you,'" Suda said.

Suda did just that. She recorded the incident and asked the agent why she was being detained.

"M'am, the reason I asked you for your I.D. is because I came and saw that you guys were speaking Spanish which is very unheard of up here," said the agent who identified himself as Agent O'Neal.

"I was shocked. I was like, 'Just because I speak Spanish?' I was waiting for something else," Suda said.
 
She's gonna sue? For what? Get over it.

She was born here but raised in Juarez, Mexico. Sounds like he was pretty perceptive to me ;)

Okay seriously, I have strong views on illegal immigration and I'm not 100% sure how far this should go. I don't want to be an outrage hypocrite about this just yet.

We have a problem with illegal immigration and I will entertain different possible solutions. Being asked for ID does not make this a communist nation but it is worth being concerned about.

I am trying to imagine how I would feel if a border patrol agent asked me for my ID. I'm pretty sure I'd be just fine with it. Where to draw the line on that? Not sure just yet.
 
Here in the United States, or at least the United States I grew up in, we do not have to carry our papers. We do not have to identify ourselves to anyone if we're minding our own business. Now if some authority asked to see my papers I might decide to comply as a matter of courtesy and convenience but that would be my own decision. I note too that the person in question DID provide documentation.

If you're driving on a public highway you need to show your license to a traffic cop. That's it.

Would you still be OK with this if the woman in question had, as is her absolute right, no documents on her, and was arrested and held on the mistaken and illegally unwarranted assumption that she's an alien? The ******** response from the Border Patrol makes it clear that they have the authority not only to accost and question citizens anywhere but to make arrests, anywhere. Do you think that if either of the women had omitted to take documentation with her, as any American is entitled to do, that unapologetically officious officer would have let them go about their business without at the very least a long detention, if not an arrest?

The fact that you can give a ready answer to a question does not mean that an inadmissible question is admissible.
 
For reference:

Here is the ACLU's page on how far into the US border officials have been given broad discretion to operate. If you reject them for some silly reason, you can find another source using that technowizardry known as Google, just as long as it isn't some garbage white supremacist site like Breitbart, Conservative Treehouse, or whatever. It includes any area within 100 miles of *any* US border, which includes the entirety of several states, including Hawaii and several smaller states on the east coast. Note that border officials sometimes act outside of this zone, without reasonable basis for suspicion, and this has been condoned by multipole circuit-level courts.

Is this sort of rude interference somewhat routine for border patrol and other agents? Well...yes. Does "Speaks Spanish near Canadian border" qualify as "reasonable suspicion"? In truth, I don't know. It'd be a good idea to look to the ACLU on this one - I hope the victim does so. Does this mean that Border Patrol's statement is correct? No, they're often laughable, like many other statements from various law enforcement organizations in the US.
 
LOL. 100 miles is "near" the border? In my country, any place is within 100 miles of a border.

If you reject them for some silly reason, you can find another source using that technowizardry known as Google, just as long as it isn't some garbage white supremacist site like Breitbart, Conservative Treehouse, or whatever. It includes any area within 100 miles of *any* US border, which includes the entirety of several states, including Hawaii and several smaller states on the east coast. Note that border officials sometimes act outside of this zone, without reasonable basis for suspicion, and this has been condoned by multipole circuit-level courts.

Is this sort of rude interference somewhat routine for border patrol and other agents? Well...yes. Does "Speaks Spanish near Canadian border" qualify as "reasonable suspicion"? In truth, I don't know. It'd be a good idea to look to the ACLU on this one - I hope the victim does so. Does this mean that Border Patrol's statement is correct? No, they're often laughable, like many other statements from various law enforcement organizations in the US.
Last I looked, Canada is not known for its large Spanish speaking population, nor is it known as an in-between for Mexican illegal immigrants. In my mind, that would be stretching the "reasonable" part of "reasonable suspicion". But given what we've seen in many threads about what is "reasonable" police behavior...

What's really suspicious, though, is the town. According to KRTV, this happened in Havre. That name is French for "port" - in a landlocked state? Border Patrol should look into how that town name illegally immigrated.
 
She's gonna sue? For what? Get over it.

She was born here but raised in Juarez, Mexico. Sounds like he was pretty perceptive to me ;)

Okay seriously, I have strong views on illegal immigration and I'm not 100% sure how far this should go. I don't want to be an outrage hypocrite about this just yet.

We have a problem with illegal immigration and I will entertain different possible solutions. Being asked for ID does not make this a communist nation but it is worth being concerned about.

I am trying to imagine how I would feel if a border patrol agent asked me for my ID. I'm pretty sure I'd be just fine with it. Where to draw the line on that? Not sure just yet.

As long as the border patrol and Ice concentrate on gang members (fully proven to be such ) and drug smugglers/sellers/producers (fully proven to be such ) I am fine with those being found much later as leathery dried out bodies in the deserts of the southwest. Otherwise they should leave people alone.
 
Being asked for ID does not make this a communist nation but it is worth being concerned about.

I am trying to imagine how I would feel if a border patrol agent asked me for my ID. I'm pretty sure I'd be just fine with it. Where to draw the line on that? Not sure just yet.

The being asked for ID part isn't the problem.
 
LOL. 100 miles is "near" the border? In my country, any place is within 100 miles of a border.

Oh and P.S.: for the purposes of this power, airports of international entry count as "border". So anywhere within 100 miles of an airport where international flights land also counts, regardless of the airport's distance from the geographical border. Lovely innit?
 
Tip for these dumbass Border Patrol officials:

Innocent until proven guilty.

Makes your job easier and there's less likelihood of ruining someone's day.
 
An updated version of the article clarifies it was a gas station, not a grocery store - unless I'd just missed that earlier.

It also includes this beautiful exchange:

Suda asks whether they are being racially profiled; the agent says no.

“It has nothing to do with that,” the agent tells her. “It’s the fact that it has to do with you guys speaking Spanish in the store, in a state where it’s predominantly English-speaking.”

Yes I'm sure if the agent had spotted a pale young European male speaking Dutch or something he would've demanded to see ID and asked where the speaker was born.
 
Last edited:
She's gonna sue? For what? Get over it.

She was born here but raised in Juarez, Mexico. Sounds like he was pretty perceptive to me ;)

Okay seriously, I have strong views on illegal immigration and I'm not 100% sure how far this should go. I don't want to be an outrage hypocrite about this just yet.

We have a problem with illegal immigration and I will entertain different possible solutions. Being asked for ID does not make this a communist nation but it is worth being concerned about.

I am trying to imagine how I would feel if a border patrol agent asked me for my ID. I'm pretty sure I'd be just fine with it. Where to draw the line on that? Not sure just yet.
So everyone should be ready to show their papers. Yessiree, no right winger ever bitched about such government intrusions.

Oh that's right, only if you are brown, they need to show their papers, and black people, they should be stopped and frisked if they look suspicious.

A US citizen raised in another country, should we apply that to the white John McCain? Of course not, only brown and black people are suspect.

Even if this woman was a Mexican citizen, what, are all tourists now suspect? OMG!
 
Last edited:
The underlying problem, of course, is that there have always been a lot of racist ******** in the immigration agencies and Trump has massively empowered them.
 
The underlying problem, of course, is that there have always been a lot of racist ******** in the immigration agencies and Trump has massively empowered them.

Exactly. I said this in a thread the other day. Trump's election didn't make these people racist. It's just that Obama's policies made it so they couldn't act on it as much. Trump took off the leash and now they can let their true colors fly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom