Santorum really doesn't understand how the Supreme Court works

Someone help me out.

What exactly would it mean to have no judicial review in the USA? Who would it fall upon to interpret the meaning or constitutionality of laws exactly? If congress passed a law and someone believed violated their constitutional rights their only recourse would be to what, petition the same body that passed it??
 
Amazing the US has survived over 200 Years of this outrageous Judicial Review.
You can bitch all you want but Judicial Review is going no where.It has become a basic part of the American System..
As for the term unelected eggheads,I think the NO judge shoud be elected. There job is to give legal decisions without having to worry about the next election. As for eggheads, that is beneath contempt.
And I am ready to put you down as just another Right Winger who is angry that now Gays have the same rights as other citizens.

This is amazingly uncivil of you. You asked me what I thought was a good faith question, and I gave you a good faith answer. Instead of you offering me some thanks, you accuse me of "bitching" and of doing something "beneath contempt" and of being a Right Winger who is angry about Gays. Remind me never to do you a favor again.
 
Someone help me out.

What exactly would it mean to have no judicial review in the USA? Who would it fall upon to interpret the meaning or constitutionality of laws exactly? If congress passed a law and someone believed violated their constitutional rights their only recourse would be to what, petition the same body that passed it??

Who does it fall to if the Supreme Court approves a law that is clearly unconstitutional? It's the same problem, and it has happened many times in the past. Ultimately, power resides in the people, either to elect new people to Congress or the Presidency, or to take up arms against the government.
 
Amazing the US has survived over 200 Years of this outrageous Judicial Review.
You can bitch all you want but Judicial Review is going no where.It has become a basic part of the American System..
As for the term unelected eggheads,I think the NO judge shoud be elected. There job is to give legal decisions without having to worry about the next election. As for eggheads, that is beneath contempt.
And I am ready to put you down as just another Right Winger who is angry that now Gays have the same rights as other citizens.


If we got rid of the eggheads, they would just be replaced by some darned poindexter panel.
 
Term egghead just showed a sort of contempt for knowledge of the law that got me angry.
 
Who does it fall to if the Supreme Court approves a law that is clearly unconstitutional? It's the same problem, and it has happened many times in the past. Ultimately, power resides in the people, either to elect new people to Congress or the Presidency, or to take up arms against the government.

Well then you are no worse off than if there was no judicial review.

This is all very mixed up with interpreting the law. Someone has to be appointed to determine how a law applies in a situation and if that law is contrary to a higher level law (the highest in the USA being the constitution). I can barely see the point of having a constitution without judicial review, if the legislative branch can just ignore it at will.
 
First, because it has given too much power to a handful of unelected eggheads who have lifetime appointments. Second, because it has led to both Congress and the President to abdicate their sworn oaths to preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution. It's caused them to, effectively, throw crap against the wall and see what sticks. They have no inhibitions about passing legislation that they believe in their hearts to be unconstitutional because they think it's not their role to decide such things. Yet it is their role.

Yeah- we depend too much on the "experts" who understand the law in detail! We should give the decision making authority to people who know nothing, and so are not biased by the facts!

Or instead we could give the decision-making authority to someone who is truly unbiased and yet knowledgeable about the law, and who would therefore only make the correct decisions. Um.. can you take on a second job?

As to the second point: yes, we seem to be in a era of political theatre where legislators pass bills only for show, knowing that they are unconstitutional will later be overturned by the courts. From my location, this appears to be particularly prevalent among the Republicans. But more generally, I think it is touching that you believe that if there was no court restraint on the legislature and President, only well-thought out and clearly constitutional laws would be passed and signed. And, despite the lessons of history, your post strongly implies that the "will of the majority" will demonstrate a strong knowledge of the constitution and should ultimately prevail no matter its effects on the minority or on our society as a whole.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if the Supreme Court decisions in question are at odds with personal political bias.

ACA - check
Gay Marriage - check
Bush Gore - ok, that one was okay
Others?
 
Rick Santorum was on the Rachael Maddow show recently talking up how he would take down the Supreme Court ruling on gay marriage if he was president. That is somewhat astounding on its own. What was more interesting was how he clearly has no idea how our federal government works.

Santorum insisted that Congress could pass a law overturning the recent Supreme Court ruling on same sex marriage. Which is nonsense. Maddow tried to explain this to him.

“If there is a question as to the constitutionality of a law, it gets adjudicated. The second syllable in that word means it gets decided in the judiciary. The Supreme Court decides whether or not a law is constitutional. So you could not now pass a law that said, ‘We’re banning same-sex marriage.'”

But SCOTUS was not interpreting a law in Obergefell v. Hodges. They were addressing whether a state's action (not recognizing another states marriage licence) violated equal protection of the 14th amendment. SCOTUS interprets Federal law and the Constitution, and it's not rare for the legislature to rewrite/revise/clarify law, thus invalidating a decision. But the legislature can at most propose Constitutional amendments. So it's a debate absent grounds by both.

The 14th amendment, section 5 leaves enforcement up to legislature, so a Congress could choose to ignore any violation by a state, but that would be very sad. Just b/c SCOTUS is re-inventing the Constitution ad hoc isn't justification for the legislature to make a further joke of law.

To be clear - I don't care a bit about what any consenting adults do together, however that the important question is - what is the role of government in defining such relations. I think Roberts was right - the issue is the definition of marriage (and governments role in marriage).

In any case the President is neither a federal judge, not a legislator, so at most he can influence.


Santorum went to the "Nuh uh, can so" school of debate. “Congress can pass anything it wants to pass,” he countered.

I've heard the very same thing from both Dem & Rep legislators ! Often times SCOTUS re-interprets the Constitution favorably if the legislation is popular! No one can possibly imagine that Social Security, TSA, the Patriot Act or the the NDAA follow any rational reading of the constitution, yet there they are.

Frightening yes, uncommon no.

She pointed out that it would immediately be null. He said that it could be appealed back to the Supreme Court who might rule differently this time around after seeing how much some people hated their previous ruling.

Highly unlikely, but not false. FDR intimidated SCOTUS into concesssions for example.

“No, you could not pass a law that could contradict the constitutional ruling of the Supreme Court,"

Not true, it's been done before. Even recently. SCOTUS has repeatedly ruled that searches w/o warrants or probable cause are violations of the 4th amendment, yet they have supported TSA airport searches w/o warrants based on flimsy line of reasoning that has origins back in the zealous anti-drug war era. Yes SCOTUS is influenced by the topical frenzies too.

Maddow countered, “They decide what’s constitutional.”

Right, and they could revise that decision or pave over it with another in the future. Rather than directly overrule an old decisionm, they instead invoke some judicial gymnastics bring up a new principle that was not applied in the previous case, and come to a new conclusion. That's exactly how previous court decisions regarding prohibitions against inter-racial marriage were negated. The chance of that happening on this case, in the next few decades is far more remote than a Santorum presidency.

---


Well certainly Santorum's opinion deserves little very consideration, but I'd like to redirect your attention to the comments of Cass Sunstein. Sunstein is certainly bright, well respected, has been called an Obama mentor, and was the head the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs under Obama.

Sunstein said:
There is no reason to believe that in the face of statutory ambiguity, the meaning of federal law should be settled by the inclinations and predispositions of federal judges. The outcome should instead depend on the commitments and beliefs of the President and those who operate under him,
from Sunstein’s 2006 Yale Law School paper, “Beyond Marbury: The Executive’s Power to Say What the Law Is.”

Of course anyone half-intelligent can invent points of ambiguity to suite needs. Sunsteins thesis is primarily about regulatory & statutory interpretation, but it's pretty trivial to escalate that to impinge on rights & legislative acts. I think this has already shown itself in Obama revising ACA ad hoc and w/o legislation for example. Of course POdesta is part of that "go around the legislature" ideation that puts ends above means.

It's not just Reps who think the executive can & should games with the interpretation of law & the Constitution. I'm not suggesting a tu quoque argument - both sides are vile when they do or even suggest this.
 
Last edited:
It is actually pretty simple. Judicial review is a necessary aspect of the judicial power unless one wants claim the Constitution is not actually law.

Broken down:

1) The Constitution gives the judicial power to the Supreme Court.

2) Inherent to the judicial power is the power to adjudicate what law controls when laws conflict.

3) The Constitution is law, and holds a superior position over statutes, etc.

Ergo

The Supreme Court has the power to decide whether a lesser form of law conflicts with the Constitution. When they do, the Constitution wins. We call this judicial review.
 
RE: the hilited: which I take to mean he eats himself on waffles!!!! Kind of disgusting if you ask me!!!!!!!!:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp

waffle, as verb

North American
1. fail to make up one's mind.
"Joseph had been waffling over where to go"

2. British
speak or write, especially at great length, without saying anything important or useful.
"he waffled on about everything that didn't matter"
synonyms: waver, vacillate, equivocate, sit on the fence
"faced with this commitment, she waffled"

I'm glad I didn't inadvertently say "Santorum waffles".:jaw-dropp Talk about disgusting!

Interesting that, as a North American, my sense of waffle used as a verb is more that of the British than the North American definition.
 
After watching the video (or most of it - my screen crashed), I am coming around to your point of view.

Santorum is right that even if a law is struck down, Congress could pass that law again. It will go back to the courts and either be struck down again, or, as he points out, if enough time has passed it will not be struck down.

I was going to type an answer/response to the bolded.
Congress could tweak the law just a bit...

But, Steve typed it for me:

But SCOTUS was not interpreting a law in Obergefell v. Hodges. They were addressing whether a state's action (not recognizing another states marriage licence) violated equal protection of the 14th amendment. SCOTUS interprets Federal law and the Constitution, and it's not rare for the legislature to rewrite/revise/clarify law, thus invalidating a decision. But the legislature can at most propose Constitutional amendments. So it's a debate absent grounds by both.


So, was the frothy one correct?
A broken clock is right twice a day.
 
Someone help me out.

What exactly would it mean to have no judicial review in the USA? Who would it fall upon to interpret the meaning or constitutionality of laws exactly? If congress passed a law and someone believed violated their constitutional rights their only recourse would be to what, petition the same body that passed it??

Good question!

To be more specific, the discussion here is more along the lines of judicial supremecy and whether that exists.

The example below is what some believe is the actual situation now.

Suppose the supreme court ruled unconstitutional abuse of MeSeekes (some sort of macguffin for this discussion). Let's also assume the president and congress believe it is Constitutional. Congress can still fund MeSeekes abuse as they see fit. The courts have no or limited power on stopping the paychecks. The president can order the prosecutor's to not pursue any MeSeekes abuse. The courts can't compel that. However, those branches cannot compel rulings of the court. So, if a MeSeekes lawsuit makes it to court, and appealed to the supreme Court, they have all the power.

That is separation of powers. Someone above compared it to whoever has the guns. That is inaccurate. It recognizes no branch can compel the other.

Santorum would never be able to pull it off. Elections would be the final arbiter and I don't think he would win after pulling it. Maddow is an idiot. She may be on the right side of a strong argument, but she has no clue about where santorums position originates and thinks that means it has no basis.
 
So, was the frothy one correct?
A broken clock is right twice a day.


Let's say that the Supremes ruled the other way in that recent Obamacare case, which hinged on some poorly written language in the legislation that could have been interpreted as not authorizing subsidies for policies issued through the federal exchange. Then Congress could have easily (not that Republicans would have) passed a law fixing the problem. But, there's not constitutional issue in that example.

But if there were some ruling that struck a law due to a constitutional issue, like say the Supremes' recent ruling striking down some provisions of Voting Rights Act, then again Congress can make new law that passes constitutional muster (or attempts to) within the context of the majority opinion.

Does what Frothy was saying fit into those examples? I don't think so. He said that Congress gets to determine what's constitutional. He said Congress can and should stop gay marriage. I ask: On what basis? What law could they pass to achieve his ends that would also pass muster with the majority ruling of the court? He's frothing over with nonsense.
 
Does what Frothy was saying fit into those examples? I don't think so. He said that Congress gets to determine what's constitutional. He said Congress can and should stop gay marriage. I ask: On what basis? What law could they pass to achieve his ends that would also pass muster with the majority ruling of the court? He's frothing over with nonsense.

Even ignoring the Constitutional dimension, he's still dangerously wrong.

If he's expecting Congress to stop gay marriage, he also has a problem with how federalism works. It is highly doubtful that a federal law seeking to ban gay marriage in the states would survive a court challenge even ignoring the Court's recent decision. Congress just doesn't have that power, wildly expanded commerce clause or no.

Although it would be fun in a "new record for hypocrisy" sort of way to read a Scalia authored opinion joined by Thomas and Alito arguing that such a ban is valid under the commerce clause because marriage affects interstate commerce...
 
Even ignoring the Constitutional dimension, he's still dangerously wrong.

If he's expecting Congress to stop gay marriage, he also has a problem with how federalism works. It is highly doubtful that a federal law seeking to ban gay marriage in the states would survive a court challenge even ignoring the Court's recent decision. Congress just doesn't have that power, wildly expanded commerce clause or no.

Although it would be fun in a "new record for hypocrisy" sort of way to read a Scalia authored opinion joined by Thomas and Alito arguing that such a ban is valid under the commerce clause because marriage affects interstate commerce...

Plus, even if you believe in departmentalism, this is not the issue for it. Congress has.no power to fund or defund gay marriage. The president wouldn't have anybody to arrest or use prosecutorial discretion. Marriage is almost entirely handled.by judges and civil courts. They could mess up tax laws, but courts would simply let the person go without paying any taxes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom