Santorum really doesn't understand how the Supreme Court works

sunmaster14: As for Maddow's claim that the word "adjudicate" is semantically meaningful, well, that's just garbage.

Garbage to you perhaps, since a lot of words seem to be no longer "semantically meaningful" in the GOP? :confused: The word derives from the Latin as she said.

ad·ju·di·cate
əˈjo͞odəˌkāt/
verb

make a formal judgment or decision about a problem or disputed matter.
"the committee adjudicates on all betting disputes"
act as a judge in a competition.
 
The way I see it, Santorum is able to ignore the equal protection clause of the fourteenth amendment, because he appears to genuinely not understand the nature of homosexuality. He waffles, but he really claims to "not know" if gays are born with a same sex preference. In any case, his religious beliefs prevent him from accepting any form of sexual behavior which is not destined to produce children. If this is his idea of a good marriage, and his wife buys into it, I suspect they both need some advice on sexual health. He told Rachel that he "doesn't think a lot about these things [sex]", which means, "he thinks a lot about these things."

I really wish some questioner would ask him if perhaps he may want to study the matter of human sexuality, and homosexuality in particular, and attempt to understand it before asking the country to elect him president.
 
Would this be just a home study course using visual aids or would you recommend a field work component?
 
The way I see it, Santorum is able to ignore the equal protection clause of the fourteenth amendment, because he appears to genuinely not understand the nature of homosexuality. He waffles, but he really claims to "not know" if gays are born with a same sex preference. In any case, his religious beliefs prevent him from accepting any form of sexual behavior which is not destined to produce children. If this is his idea of a good marriage, and his wife buys into it, I suspect they both need some advice on sexual health. He told Rachel that he "doesn't think a lot about these things [sex]", which means, "he thinks a lot about these things."

I really wish some questioner would ask him if perhaps he may want to study the matter of human sexuality, and homosexuality in particular, and attempt to understand it before asking the country to elect him president.

But, then, he is just santorum. Frothy.
 
The way I see it, Santorum is able to ignore the equal protection clause of the fourteenth amendment, because he appears to genuinely not understand the nature of homosexuality. He waffles, but he really claims to "not know" if gays are born with a same sex preference. In any case, his religious beliefs prevent him from accepting any form of sexual behavior which is not destined to produce children. If this is his idea of a good marriage, and his wife buys into it, I suspect they both need some advice on sexual health. He told Rachel that he "doesn't think a lot about these things [sex]", which means, "he thinks a lot about these things."

I really wish some questioner would ask him if perhaps he may want to study the matter of human sexuality, and homosexuality in particular, and attempt to understand it before asking the country to elect him president.


RE: the hilited: which I take to mean he eats himself on waffles!!!! Kind of disgusting if you ask me!!!!!!!!:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp
 
Santorum is right. There is nothing in the Constitution that gives the Supreme Court the final say on what is or is not Constitutional. All of the branches of government have a right, in fact a duty, to judge the constitutionality of a law or action for themselves. Operationally, I suppose the Congress could impeach and remove from office each of the justices who voted "incorrectly," so Congress really does have supremacy.

As for Maddow's claim that the word "adjudicate" is semantically meaningful, well, that's just garbage.

Wow!

Your ignorance of the Constitution of your own country is quite astounding.

From Article 3, Section 2 of the Constitution of the United States of America:

The judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution, the Laws of the United States, and Treaties made, or which shall be made, under their Authority;
—to all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls;
—to all Cases of admiralty and maritime Jurisdiction;
—to Controversies to which the United States will be a party;
—to Controversies between two or more States;
—between a State and Citizens of another State;
—between Citizens of different States,
—between Citizens of the same State claiming Lands under Grants of different States, and between a State, or the Citizens thereof, and foreign States, Citizens or Subjects.
 
Wow!

Your ignorance of the Constitution of your own country is quite astounding.

From Article 3, Section 2 of the Constitution of the United States of America:

The judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution, the Laws of the United States, and Treaties made, or which shall be made, under their Authority;
—to all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls;
—to all Cases of admiralty and maritime Jurisdiction;
—to Controversies to which the United States will be a party;
—to Controversies between two or more States;
—between a State and Citizens of another State;
—between Citizens of different States,
—between Citizens of the same State claiming Lands under Grants of different States, and between a State, or the Citizens thereof, and foreign States, Citizens or Subjects.

Nowhere in there does it say that the Supreme Court has the power of judicial review. The concept of judicial review was well-known to the founders, so it's not like they didn't know how to put it into the Constitution if they wanted to. They discussed it and contemplated it, and they looked to Britain's system, which did not, and still does not, have judicial review. In the end, they left explicit authorization of judicial review out of the Constitution. The Supreme Court was meant merely to be the country's highest appeals court, and the language you mention in the Constitution is actually limiting its power to actual cases (i.e. real, not moot or hypothetical, controversies) arising under federal laws or under the Constitutional. Rendering a federal law void due to a conflict with the Constitution is not necessarily (or even reasonably, in my opinion) a power granted to the judiciary by the Constitution. In theory, Congress should not have passed, and the President should not have signed, a law which is prohibited by the Constitution. They would be violating their oaths of office by doing so. So the situation shouldn't even arise. In theory.

All that being said, of course I understand that in Marbury v Madison, the Supreme Court arrogated to itself the power of judicial review, and that has mostly gone unchallenged for over 200 years. And perhaps the country is better off with the Supreme Court having this power (I'm conflicted about it). But Santorum wasn't just speaking out of ignorance. It is an idea which has been bandied about by conservative thinkers for many decades. Santorum is a lawyer, and he was actually a senator for 12 years. He's certainly thinking about it on a much deeper level.

For the record, I can't stand Santorum.
 
Garbage to you perhaps, since a lot of words seem to be no longer "semantically meaningful" in the GOP? :confused: The word derives from the Latin as she said.

It's garbage because it was a word she chose herself to describe the process of determining if a law passes Constitutional muster. I've never heard anybody describe that process as adjudication, and, regardless, the Constitution doesn't use that word to describe the process of judicial review because the concept doesn't even appear in the Constitution at all. She's doing semantic analysis on words she brought to the table.
 
Would this be just a home study course using visual aids or would you recommend a field work component?

He needs to sit down and interview a few eloquent gay spokesmen who can explain the LGBT experience or at least read some first person accounts which describe their feelings. The information base is huge and easily available. Short of religious obstinacy and right wing bigotry, there is simply no way that a fair-minded well-informed individual can claim LGBT issues are not civil rights matters in 2015.

Santorum appears to be obsessed with thoughts of sexual impropriety in others, is apparently willfully ignorant about human sexuality in general and probably just needs to have more access to sexual fulfillment. Somehow, he has gotten the idea that his religion informs him that sex is evil, except when used for procreation, and consequently we hear him loudly speaking against contraception and sexual relations as a means of pair bonding. Acting out this claimed religious belief in his own marriage could be a way of creating a cloak of legitimacy for psychological problems with sexual inadequacy or a cover for his own homosexuality.

Proudly aspiring to live the life approaching that of a Trappist monk within a marriage is more than a little odd.

When I hear him talk about sexual matters, I hear statements consistent with a man who has been able to function sufficiently with a woman to manage to create 7 kids who themselves very likely have been inculcated with unhealthy beliefs about normal sexual behavior.
 
Nowhere in there does it say that the Supreme Court has the power of judicial review. The concept of judicial review was well-known to the founders, so it's not like they didn't know how to put it into the Constitution if they wanted to. They discussed it and contemplated it, and they looked to Britain's system, which did not, and still does not, have judicial review. In the end, they left explicit authorization of judicial review out of the Constitution. The Supreme Court was meant merely to be the country's highest appeals court, and the language you mention in the Constitution is actually limiting its power to actual cases (i.e. real, not moot or hypothetical, controversies) arising under federal laws or under the Constitutional. Rendering a federal law void due to a conflict with the Constitution is not necessarily (or even reasonably, in my opinion) a power granted to the judiciary by the Constitution. In theory, Congress should not have passed, and the President should not have signed, a law which is prohibited by the Constitution. They would be violating their oaths of office by doing so. So the situation shouldn't even arise. In theory.

All that being said, of course I understand that in Marbury v Madison, the Supreme Court arrogated to itself the power of judicial review, and that has mostly gone unchallenged for over 200 years. And perhaps the country is better off with the Supreme Court having this power (I'm conflicted about it). But Santorum wasn't just speaking out of ignorance. It is an idea which has been bandied about by conservative thinkers for many decades. Santorum is a lawyer, and he was actually a senator for 12 years. He's certainly thinking about it on a much deeper level.

For the record, I can't stand Santorum.


After watching the video (or most of it - my screen crashed), I am coming around to your point of view.

Santorum is right that even if a law is struck down, Congress could pass that law again. It will go back to the courts and either be struck down again, or, as he points out, if enough time has passed it will not be struck down.
 
Nowhere in there does it say that the Supreme Court has the power of judicial review. The concept of judicial review was well-known to the founders, so it's not like they didn't know how to put it into the Constitution if they wanted to. They discussed it and contemplated it, and they looked to Britain's system, which did not, and still does not, have judicial review. ...snip...

You better let the courts and the governments of the UK know about this - they've been operating as if we did have it for quite some time!

https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/you-and-the-judiciary/judicial-review/
 
It's garbage because it was a word she chose herself to describe the process of determining if a law passes Constitutional muster. I've never heard anybody describe that process as adjudication, and, regardless, the Constitution doesn't use that word to describe the process of judicial review because the concept doesn't even appear in the Constitution at all. She's doing semantic analysis on words she brought to the table.

I misunderstood your use of "garbage" to refer to Maddow's claim that the word derives from the same source as judge.

Adjudicate is a broad term, not arcane, and to argue that somehow it is irrelevant or inappropriate to the discussion of Supreme Court decisions because you have "never heard anybody describe" them that way is mere whimsy.

"The legal process of resolving a dispute. The formal giving or pronouncing of a judgment or decree in a court proceeding; also the judgment or decision given. The entry of a decree by a court in respect to the parties in a case. It implies a hearing by a court, after notice, of legal evidence on the factual issue(s) involved. The equivalent of a determination. It indicates that the claims of all the parties thereto have been considered and set at rest."
 
You better let the courts and the governments of the UK know about this - they've been operating as if we did have it for quite some time!

https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/you-and-the-judiciary/judicial-review/

Well, I meant of Acts of Parliament, not how they're implemented or interpreted by regulatory authorities. I was relying on the wiki page (my emphasis added):

The English constitutional theory, as expounded by A.V. Dicey, does not recognise a separate system of administrative courts that would review the decisions of public bodies (as in France, Germany and many other European countries). Instead, it is considered that the government should be subject to the jurisdiction of ordinary Common Law courts.

At the same time, the doctrine of Parliamentary sovereignty does not allow for the judicial review of primary legislation (Acts of Parliament). This limits judicial review in English law to the decisions of public bodies and secondary (delegated) legislation, against which ordinary common law remedies as well as special "prerogative orders" are available in certain circumstances.

The constitutional theory of judicial review has long been dominated by the doctrine of ultra vires, under which a decision of a public authority can only be set aside if it exceeds the powers granted to it by Parliament. The role of the courts was seen as enforcing the "will of Parliament" in accordance with the doctrine of Parliamentary sovereignty. However, the doctrine has been widely interpreted to include errors of law[1] and of fact and the courts have also declared the decisions taken under the Royal Prerogative to be amenable to judicial review.[2] Therefore it seems that today the constitutional position of judicial review is dictated by the need to prevent the abuse of power by the executive as well as to protect individual rights.
 
Well, I meant of Acts of Parliament, not how they're implemented or interpreted by regulatory authorities. I was relying on the wiki page (my emphasis added):

That's fine - it was just that since we do have judicial review in the UK if you meant to say "do not have judicial review of primary legislation" it is rather important to include the italicized part otherwise what you were claiming is simply untrue.
 
I misunderstood your use of "garbage" to refer to Maddow's claim that the word derives from the same source as judge.

Adjudicate is a broad term, not arcane, and to argue that somehow it is irrelevant or inappropriate to the discussion of Supreme Court decisions because you have "never heard anybody describe" them that way is mere whimsy.
But the constitution doesn't use the word so it shouldn't be used.

Amazing, the dancing never stops.
 
Nowhere in there does it say that the Supreme Court has the power of judicial review. The concept of judicial review was well-known to the founders, so it's not like they didn't know how to put it into the Constitution if they wanted to. They discussed it and contemplated it, and they looked to Britain's system, which did not, and still does not, have judicial review. In the end, they left explicit authorization of judicial review out of the Constitution. The Supreme Court was meant merely to be the country's highest appeals court, and the language you mention in the Constitution is actually limiting its power to actual cases (i.e. real, not moot or hypothetical, controversies) arising under federal laws or under the Constitutional. Rendering a federal law void due to a conflict with the Constitution is not necessarily (or even reasonably, in my opinion) a power granted to the judiciary by the Constitution. In theory, Congress should not have passed, and the President should not have signed, a law which is prohibited by the Constitution. They would be violating their oaths of office by doing so. So the situation shouldn't even arise. In theory.

All that being said, of course I understand that in Marbury v Madison, the Supreme Court arrogated to itself the power of judicial review, and that has mostly gone unchallenged for over 200 years. And perhaps the country is better off with the Supreme Court having this power (I'm conflicted about it). But Santorum wasn't just speaking out of ignorance. It is an idea which has been bandied about by conservative thinkers for many decades. Santorum is a lawyer, and he was actually a senator for 12 years. He's certainly thinking about it on a much deeper level.

For the record, I can't stand Santorum.

WHy are you conflicted about it? It has worked well as a check on the other two branches of government. It has become a basic part of the American system.
 
WHy are you conflicted about it? It has worked well as a check on the other two branches of government. It has become a basic part of the American system.

First, because it has given too much power to a handful of unelected eggheads who have lifetime appointments. Second, because it has led to both Congress and the President to abdicate their sworn oaths to preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution. It's caused them to, effectively, throw crap against the wall and see what sticks. They have no inhibitions about passing legislation that they believe in their hearts to be unconstitutional because they think it's not their role to decide such things. Yet it is their role.
 
Nowhere in there does it say that the Supreme Court has the power of judicial review. The concept of judicial review was well-known to the founders, so it's not like they didn't know how to put it into the Constitution if they wanted to. They discussed it and contemplated it, and they looked to Britain's system, which did not, and still does not, have judicial review. In the end, they left explicit authorization of judicial review out of the Constitution. The Supreme Court was meant merely to be the country's highest appeals court, and the language you mention in the Constitution is actually limiting its power to actual cases (i.e. real, not moot or hypothetical, controversies) arising under federal laws or under the Constitutional. Rendering a federal law void due to a conflict with the Constitution is not necessarily (or even reasonably, in my opinion) a power granted to the judiciary by the Constitution. In theory, Congress should not have passed, and the President should not have signed, a law which is prohibited by the Constitution. They would be violating their oaths of office by doing so. So the situation shouldn't even arise. In theory.

All that being said, of course I understand that in Marbury v Madison, the Supreme Court arrogated to itself the power of judicial review, and that has mostly gone unchallenged for over 200 years. And perhaps the country is better off with the Supreme Court having this power (I'm conflicted about it). But Santorum wasn't just speaking out of ignorance. It is an idea which has been bandied about by conservative thinkers for many decades. Santorum is a lawyer, and he was actually a senator for 12 years. He's certainly thinking about it on a much deeper level.

For the record, I can't stand Santorum.
Wise - it is yucky stuff indeed!!!!
 
First, because it has given too much power to a handful of unelected eggheads who have lifetime appointments. Second, because it has led to both Congress and the President to abdicate their sworn oaths to preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution. It's caused them to, effectively, throw crap against the wall and see what sticks. They have no inhibitions about passing legislation that they believe in their hearts to be unconstitutional because they think it's not their role to decide such things. Yet it is their role.

I don't believe for a second that this relationship is causal. Without it, they'd still throw all the same crap to the wall and it would all stick.
 
First, because it has given too much power to a handful of unelected eggheads who have lifetime appointments. Second, because it has led to both Congress and the President to abdicate their sworn oaths to preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution. It's caused them to, effectively, throw crap against the wall and see what sticks. They have no inhibitions about passing legislation that they believe in their hearts to be unconstitutional because they think it's not their role to decide such things. Yet it is their role.

Amazing the US has survived over 200 Years of this outrageous Judicial Review.
You can bitch all you want but Judicial Review is going no where.It has become a basic part of the American System..
As for the term unelected eggheads,I think the NO judge shoud be elected. There job is to give legal decisions without having to worry about the next election. As for eggheads, that is beneath contempt.
And I am ready to put you down as just another Right Winger who is angry that now Gays have the same rights as other citizens.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom